independent and unofficial
Prince fan community
Welcome! Sign up or enter username and password to remember me
Forum jump
Forums > Prince: Music and More > Complaints About New Releases
« Previous topic  Next topic »
Page 2 of 9 <123456789>
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
Reply #30 posted 12/23/21 4:57pm

BartVanHemelen

avatar

Vannormal said:

RODSERLING said:

Mostly complaints about the LACK of new releases these days. Almost a year between SOTT deluxe and Welcome 2 America. And still nothing scheduled before at least April of 2022. And according to some insiders, not coming before September/October,

What do you know from your ''insiders'' ?

Not one of us here knows shit in my opinion to be honest.

It just could be that in januari there might be an announcement,

.

Nope. Not gonna happen. That would step on the Sony/Legacy reissues in Feb. So no announcement until those are in stores. And then certainly not one immediately after.

.

Earliest announcement is IMHO around mid-april. Considering that between annoucnement and release these days there's 3/4 months: release in mid-/late-July. Which means very little chance of a major release in second half of 2022.

.

Alternative: lightweight release around Prince's birthday à la Originals, with announcement in mid-April or perhaps mid-March, and major SDE announcement shortly after 7 June for release in Oct/Nov.

.

And if the Netflix series drops in 2023, I'd expect a proper SDE for PR that year to ride on that wave.

© Bart Van Hemelen
This posting is provided AS IS with no warranties, and confers no rights.
It is not authorized by Prince or the NPG Music Club. You assume all risk for
your use. All rights reserved.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #31 posted 12/23/21 5:02pm

BartVanHemelen

avatar

RODSERLING said:


Keaton's Batman is coming back in a couple of movies in 2022/2023. So as I already said last year, a Batman SDE would make sense then.

.

Completely different things.

.

Plus what's gonna be on a Batman SDE? Barely any outtakes from that era, but if they're smart they'd keep the Rave stuff etc. for a GB SDE.

.

At most we'd get an Expanded Batman: everything remastered, plus singles and remixes etc. Perhaps a couple of outtakes from those sessions as bonus tracks. At most a 2CD set. Perhaps throw in a DVD with the videos.

© Bart Van Hemelen
This posting is provided AS IS with no warranties, and confers no rights.
It is not authorized by Prince or the NPG Music Club. You assume all risk for
your use. All rights reserved.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #32 posted 12/23/21 5:31pm

sulls

avatar

RODSERLING said:

sulls said:

I have a family of 5 and it’s not an easy sell to the other 4 that daddy needs to spend a decent chunk of the family kitty on something just for him.


Just sell one of your kid.


That’s been considered. lol
"I like to watch."
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #33 posted 12/23/21 5:51pm

Phase3

BartVanHemelen said:



RODSERLING said:



Keaton's Batman is coming back in a couple of movies in 2022/2023. So as I already said last year, a Batman SDE would make sense then.

.


Completely different things.


.


Plus what's gonna be on a Batman SDE? Barely any outtakes from that era, but if they're smart they'd keep the Rave stuff etc. for a GB SDE.


.


At most we'd get an Expanded Batman: everything remastered, plus singles and remixes etc. Perhaps a couple of outtakes from those sessions as bonus tracks. At most a 2CD set. Perhaps throw in a DVD with the videos.




The Vicki Vale mix
Batmix
And the extended video for partyman have yet to get a official release on physical media

Also Ithis is prince we are talking about,there are probably 50 or more outtakes from Batman
American in Paris
Anna waiting
The original version of the future
Voice inside
Your love is so hard
Extended version of electric chair
The alternate versions of trust
Dance with the devil

I'm sure there are more
[Edited 12/23/21 17:52pm]
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #34 posted 12/23/21 7:03pm

TrevorAyer

the grand progression

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #35 posted 12/23/21 7:47pm

sulls

avatar

coldcoffeeandcocacola said:

sulls said:

I have a family of 5 and it’s not an easy sell to the other 4 that daddy needs to spend a decent chunk of the family kitty on something just for him.


Sulls, youre clearly a good dad, many don't prioritize their kids needs above their own. You are the winner as the music will still be there when they grow up, they won't be little long. prince can take a back seat, he wont mind. cool
[Edited 12/23/21 12:03pm]


It’s an easier sell if it’s close to a bd, Xmas or Fathers Day cool
"I like to watch."
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #36 posted 12/23/21 9:33pm

udo

avatar

[Off topic snip - luv4u]

Pills and thrills and daffodils will kill... If you don't believe me or don't get it, I don't have time to try to convince you, sorry.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #37 posted 12/23/21 9:53pm

Phase3

For those saying that they have no space on their shelves.All they should do is buy a new shelf and make it a purple one while your at it
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #38 posted 12/23/21 11:48pm

bozojones

8up said:

bozojones said:
Are you the same guy who was hitting every thread last night to brag about how much more disposable income you have? What a clown.
Yes,I did reply to two posts and I knew they would not come off well. I apologize and did not mean to offend anyone. I just get bored reading about how people don't like the costs of new releases. I mowed lawns as a kid just to buy Prince records.

Kudos for owning up to it instead of getting defensive, I respect that. I think people are justified in being annoyed by obvious cash-grabs when there's so much material that could be released instead, but I don't have anything against people who spend money on these variants and get some genuine joy out of it. Just remember that having more spending money doesn't make you a better person or bigger fan than anyone else wink

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #39 posted 12/24/21 1:53am

RODSERLING

BartVanHemelen said:



RODSERLING said:



Keaton's Batman is coming back in a couple of movies in 2022/2023. So as I already said last year, a Batman SDE would make sense then.

.


Completely different things.


.


Plus what's gonna be on a Batman SDE? Barely any outtakes from that era, but if they're smart they'd keep the Rave stuff etc. for a GB SDE.


.


At most we'd get an Expanded Batman: everything remastered, plus singles and remixes etc. Perhaps a couple of outtakes from those sessions as bonus tracks. At most a 2CD set. Perhaps throw in a DVD with the videos.



Unless WB will sit on it forever, I don't know what's the problem with a Batman SDE released around the new bramd of movie.

For the new Ghostbusters movies, the original actors just do cameos, but they released toys around them and the ecto-1, and other merchandising.
People are listening to the original soundtrack again, buying the old movies, etc.

What would prevent WB to do the same thing?


There are tons of b-sides, remixes, The Scandalous Sexsuite, etc. From that era that would make for 3 discs.
.
You could easily fit a 2 disc of unreleased or alternate takes, if not more.

That's already more than the 1999 SDE.

We don't need a 8/10 discs boxset everytime.

I m all for lighter SDE such as Dirty Mind, For You, etc. More affordable for eveyone. It would allow for more releases a year.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #40 posted 12/24/21 1:58am

RODSERLING

herb4 said:

Maybe, but I don't see a Batman Prince reissue making much noise.

Perhaps MAYBE if they worked with the film makers and timed some weird re-release of Batdance (or better, use that song in the movie somewhere) but...eh. Keaton's role is a cameo in The Flash movie too if I'm reading the news right, so it's just minor fan service I think.

The success of that album had everything to do with the film and next to nothing to do with the quality of the music. It was a collection of rehashed songs that our man had lying around with some lyrics switched around that Prince cobbled together and WB slapped a Batman logo on since, in 1989, that was a license to print money and you could market a cat turd by simply changing one letter and calling it a Bat Turd. I doubt there's a treasure trove of outtakes here, nor a ton of fan interest.

Prince got to cash a nice check and put out an OK-ish album but, by and large, no one considers it anywhere close to a classic - despite its sales - and even fans of the movie sort of slot the album as more of a novelty than anything else. Aside from "Partyman", which aint that great, and "Trust" (also not great), Prince's music was totally BURIED in the actual film and, over time, has played second fiddle to Danny Elfman's legendary score.

If Prince had put out that same record and that same single minus that logo, neither go to #1 and fly off the shelves absent the strength of those bat wings folded up out of hundred dollar bills.




Because the 1999 amd SOTT did much noise?
No.
They were bought only by Prince fans.
With Batman you have at least the chance it will be bought buy hardcore-sucker Batman fans, old and new, just like Ghostbusters.

The Keaton's Batman logo, which is the cover of Prince album, is still the most popular. I often see kids wearing t-shirts, casket, bag, etc. With that logo on it.
[Edited 12/24/21 1:59am]
[Edited 12/24/21 2:00am]
[Edited 12/24/21 2:07am]
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #41 posted 12/24/21 7:32am

lastdecember

avatar

Well people dont realize what goes into manufacturing these releases, especially vinyl at this point, if you are looking for vinyl sets to drop in price, you are going to be waiting a LONG LONG TIME. Now with supply chain issues, printing and shipping vinyl is having major issues, if U want something you better jump on it quick especially if its one of these larger sets because demand and quantity are not matching up. But also the thing is like I heard a KISS fan say recently about spending 200 on their Destroyer 4cd set, yes 200 thats basically what it goes for. He said they arent forcing you to buy it, 200 is crazy even with all the other stuff in the box but the band is not forcing you to buy it, and you could get it in smaller packages too. I know we all want it all and think prices should drop on these things but they arent coming down, sometimes you get a deal or the $$ seems worth it, or you have the $$ at the time or you dont its that simple. As for the complaint on Prince things when there are reissues, the ones that just come out on Vinyl and CD like Chaos and disorder and all those things are part of the Legacy deal, you arent going to get something new from that, with the exception of getting something on vinyl that never was on it. ALSO Im not sure if anyone has noticed or realized this but with the exception of PR and the Very Best of and the package of hits that came out in 2016, and these new pressings, all of his catalog is out of print, meaning YES you can still order it on amazon or whatever, but the labels are not making any of the older pressings anymore. And for the complaint of "we have it already" when we get outtakes that we have on bootlegs, the estate is not in the bootleg business, as much as PRINCE knew this stuff was out there and probably the people doing these deluxes are, its not there problem we spent hundreds and hundreds on illegal stuff, I mean do you really think the person in charge is saying lets not reissue these outtakes because it was on a bootleg that im sure people bought? really?


"We went where our music was appreciated, and that was everywhere but the USA, we knew we had fans, but there is only so much of the world you can play at once" Magne F
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #42 posted 12/24/21 9:00am

udo

avatar

Well, to help out the heirs and thus the Estate, i'd gladly pay $200 (or equivalent in euro or BTC) for a 4CD set, if only these releases came quicker....!

Much quicker.

Pills and thrills and daffodils will kill... If you don't believe me or don't get it, I don't have time to try to convince you, sorry.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #43 posted 12/24/21 9:18am

herb4

RODSERLING said:

herb4 said:

Maybe, but I don't see a Batman Prince reissue making much noise.

Perhaps MAYBE if they worked with the film makers and timed some weird re-release of Batdance (or better, use that song in the movie somewhere) but...eh. Keaton's role is a cameo in The Flash movie too if I'm reading the news right, so it's just minor fan service I think.

The success of that album had everything to do with the film and next to nothing to do with the quality of the music. It was a collection of rehashed songs that our man had lying around with some lyrics switched around that Prince cobbled together and WB slapped a Batman logo on since, in 1989, that was a license to print money and you could market a cat turd by simply changing one letter and calling it a Bat Turd. I doubt there's a treasure trove of outtakes here, nor a ton of fan interest.

Prince got to cash a nice check and put out an OK-ish album but, by and large, no one considers it anywhere close to a classic - despite its sales - and even fans of the movie sort of slot the album as more of a novelty than anything else. Aside from "Partyman", which aint that great, and "Trust" (also not great), Prince's music was totally BURIED in the actual film and, over time, has played second fiddle to Danny Elfman's legendary score.

If Prince had put out that same record and that same single minus that logo, neither go to #1 and fly off the shelves absent the strength of those bat wings folded up out of hundred dollar bills.


Because the 1999 amd SOTT did much noise? No. They were bought only by Prince fans. With Batman you have at least the chance it will be bought buy hardcore-sucker Batman fans, old and new, just like Ghostbusters. The Keaton's Batman logo, which is the cover of Prince album, is still the most popular. I often see kids wearing t-shirts, casket, bag, etc. With that logo on it. [Edited 12/24/21 1:59am] [Edited 12/24/21 2:00am] [Edited 12/24/21 2:07am]


From what I read, I think they kind of did, especially for a deceased artist that would be what, 63 years old right now? Not as much as PR but they sold OK.

And, sure, "they were bought by Prince fans" because...well, duh. Except that by "Prince fans", that encompasses people who say "yeah, I love Prince" who mainly remember him from the 80's and probably bought them out of nostalgia. Not people like us who still post on this board that will buy anything.

And, unlike the SDE releases we've gotten so far, I don't see a lot of potential crossover audience for something like Batman. The hardcore fans aren't nuts about it or clamouring for it and I doubt that the more casual fans have a ton of nostalgia for it either. Hardly anyone (casual or hardcore) considered it a grand artistic acheivement.

I could be wrong, of course, and maybe there's actually a way to market and sell the thing (Batman). Also, if you're right, then the estate may as well cue up Lovesexy, Parade, CB2, the live box set, etc. especially if, like you said, it's only the "fans" buying the stuff. I just think there's a difference between people who love Prince, People Who L.O.V.E. Prince and what they'll spend money on.


  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #44 posted 12/24/21 9:49am

dualboot

avatar

I can imagine that the Batman license can come into play when throwing a spanner in the works.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #45 posted 12/24/21 12:22pm

RODSERLING

herb4 said:



RODSERLING said:


herb4 said:

Maybe, but I don't see a Batman Prince reissue making much noise.

Perhaps MAYBE if they worked with the film makers and timed some weird re-release of Batdance (or better, use that song in the movie somewhere) but...eh. Keaton's role is a cameo in The Flash movie too if I'm reading the news right, so it's just minor fan service I think.

The success of that album had everything to do with the film and next to nothing to do with the quality of the music. It was a collection of rehashed songs that our man had lying around with some lyrics switched around that Prince cobbled together and WB slapped a Batman logo on since, in 1989, that was a license to print money and you could market a cat turd by simply changing one letter and calling it a Bat Turd. I doubt there's a treasure trove of outtakes here, nor a ton of fan interest.

Prince got to cash a nice check and put out an OK-ish album but, by and large, no one considers it anywhere close to a classic - despite its sales - and even fans of the movie sort of slot the album as more of a novelty than anything else. Aside from "Partyman", which aint that great, and "Trust" (also not great), Prince's music was totally BURIED in the actual film and, over time, has played second fiddle to Danny Elfman's legendary score.

If Prince had put out that same record and that same single minus that logo, neither go to #1 and fly off the shelves absent the strength of those bat wings folded up out of hundred dollar bills.




Because the 1999 amd SOTT did much noise? No. They were bought only by Prince fans. With Batman you have at least the chance it will be bought buy hardcore-sucker Batman fans, old and new, just like Ghostbusters. The Keaton's Batman logo, which is the cover of Prince album, is still the most popular. I often see kids wearing t-shirts, casket, bag, etc. With that logo on it. [Edited 12/24/21 1:59am] [Edited 12/24/21 2:00am] [Edited 12/24/21 2:07am]


From what I read, I think they kind of did, especially for a deceased artist that would be what, 63 years old right now? Not as much as PR but they sold OK.

And, sure, "they were bought by Prince fans" because...well, duh. Except that by "Prince fans", that encompasses people who say "yeah, I love Prince" who mainly remember him from the 80's and probably bought them out of nostalgia. Not people like us who still post on this board that will buy anything.

And, unlike the SDE releases we've gotten so far, I don't see a lot of potential crossover audience for something like Batman. The hardcore fans aren't nuts about it or clamouring for it and I doubt that the more casual fans have a ton of nostalgia for it either. Hardly anyone (casual or hardcore) considered it a grand artistic acheivement.

I could be wrong, of course, and maybe there's actually a way to market and sell the thing (Batman). Also, if you're right, then the estate may as well cue up Lovesexy, Parade, CB2, the live box set, etc. especially if, like you said, it's only the "fans" buying the stuff. I just think there's a difference between people who love Prince, People Who L.O.V.E. Prince and what they'll spend money on.




I have news for you : they could sell Parade, Lovesexy, 1999, or Batman or whatever : it would sell more or less the same amount, at an equal price.
So I don't understand the reasonning behind your assumption than a Batman SDE wouldn't sell.

Because a Parade or a D&P would sell more? No.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #46 posted 12/24/21 1:16pm

herb4

RODSERLING said:

herb4 said:


From what I read, I think they kind of did, especially for a deceased artist that would be what, 63 years old right now? Not as much as PR but they sold OK.

And, sure, "they were bought by Prince fans" because...well, duh. Except that by "Prince fans", that encompasses people who say "yeah, I love Prince" who mainly remember him from the 80's and probably bought them out of nostalgia. Not people like us who still post on this board that will buy anything.

And, unlike the SDE releases we've gotten so far, I don't see a lot of potential crossover audience for something like Batman. The hardcore fans aren't nuts about it or clamouring for it and I doubt that the more casual fans have a ton of nostalgia for it either. Hardly anyone (casual or hardcore) considered it a grand artistic acheivement.

I could be wrong, of course, and maybe there's actually a way to market and sell the thing (Batman). Also, if you're right, then the estate may as well cue up Lovesexy, Parade, CB2, the live box set, etc. especially if, like you said, it's only the "fans" buying the stuff. I just think there's a difference between people who love Prince, People Who L.O.V.E. Prince and what they'll spend money on.


I have news for you : they could sell Parade, Lovesexy, 1999, or Batman or whatever : it would sell more or less the same amount, at an equal price. So I don't understand the reasonning behind your assumption than a Batman SDE wouldn't sell. Because a Parade or a D&P would sell more? No.


I have no idea. Sounds like you have strong opinions about it though.

I tried to make my reasoning rather clear and thought I explained my thoughts about it pretty well.

I think D&P is the last big commercial cash grab and that, after that, we're looking at vault material and live stuff to mine what's left of the gold. I think that 1999, PR and SoTT would/will/did rake in MORE extraneous buyers beyond the hardcore fan base than Lovesexy, Parade, GB and cetainly Batman will/would. I'm not sure why that might be a controversial opinion.

Again, I could be wrong. I'm not in control of the estate. I know what I would do, I know what I want to have and I'm not a marketing executive nor a record producer so I'm just speculating about supply and demand moving forward and just don't see it with fucking Batman is all. If I'm rading you right (and maybe I'm not), you seem to be implying that ONLY people like us are buying this stuff and I don't think that's true. Could be.

Anything they release will SELL. The question is how much and what's worth doing? I ponied up for 1999, PR and SoTT primarily for the outtakes/vault stuff. I'm not talking primarlily about fans like US so much as fans in general. It's like the difference with fans of an NFL team that will pay for tickets, a cable package and jerseys vs people who will catch a game on TV now and again.

I thought I worded my opinions rather succinctly but feel free to ask me any specific follow up questions if you found something I wrote to be vague or unclear.

Thanks.

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #47 posted 12/24/21 4:06pm

Dandroppedadim
e

It's very frustrating when we know how much there is to be released! All I can do is spend my money elsewhere and the estate lose out. More money for my Star Wars figure addiction! biggrin
There is a waiting audience (although dwindling) that will happily spend money every month on new Prince music - I'm not into the merch and re-issues, so seems a wasted income stream for the Estate. On the flip side I guess it's hard to monetise digital music these days and the physical stuff takes a lot of time to get out.

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #48 posted 12/24/21 4:13pm

herb4

Dandroppedadime said:

It's very frustrating when we know how much there is to be released! All I can do is spend my money elsewhere and the estate lose out. More money for my Star Wars figure addiction! biggrin
There is a waiting audience (although dwindling) that will happily spend money every month on new Prince music - I'm not into the merch and re-issues, so seems a wasted income stream for the Estate. On the flip side I guess it's hard to monetise digital music these days and the physical stuff takes a lot of time to get out.


It'll come out, believe me. Remember also, that not all of that shit stored in that vault is golden.

Prince probably shelved a lot of it for good reason. As much as I like the vault CD's we got on the SDE's so far, not all of it is what I'd consider to be killer. But as a fan, I was still happy to hear most of it.


  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #49 posted 12/24/21 4:19pm

lastdecember

avatar

I have a feeling regardless of what happens in 2022 or 2023 we can pretty much on some giant deluxe PR for the 40th anniversary, yes they already had a re do deluxe but that was a quick get it out now job, and there are artists that have redone remasters multiple times and added more and made them deluxes, Black Sabbath is infamous for this some fan of there's told me one of their albums has been remastered boxed deluxes four times, including two versions only three or four years apart


"We went where our music was appreciated, and that was everywhere but the USA, we knew we had fans, but there is only so much of the world you can play at once" Magne F
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #50 posted 12/24/21 4:44pm

herb4

God I hope not.

I'm Purple Rained out and have been for some time.

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #51 posted 12/24/21 5:09pm

LoveGalore

Purple Rain and it's outtakes never get old to me. Bring it on.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #52 posted 12/24/21 6:42pm

Phase3

LoveGalore said:

Purple Rain and it's outtakes never get old to me. Bring it on.

Same plus you know it will sell really good being that Purple Rain is prince's best seller
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #53 posted 12/24/21 7:45pm

bozojones

lastdecember said:

I have a feeling regardless of what happens in 2022 or 2023 we can pretty much on some giant deluxe PR for the 40th anniversary, yes they already had a re do deluxe but that was a quick get it out now job, and there are artists that have redone remasters multiple times and added more and made them deluxes, Black Sabbath is infamous for this some fan of there's told me one of their albums has been remastered boxed deluxes four times, including two versions only three or four years apart

Purple Rain is a double-dip that I honestly won't mind as long as they actually do it right next time. We're long overdue for a high quality release of the original "G-Spot"

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #54 posted 12/25/21 4:29am

eyewishuheaven

avatar

bozojones said:

lastdecember said:

I have a feeling regardless of what happens in 2022 or 2023 we can pretty much on some giant deluxe PR for the 40th anniversary, yes they already had a re do deluxe but that was a quick get it out now job, and there are artists that have redone remasters multiple times and added more and made them deluxes, Black Sabbath is infamous for this some fan of there's told me one of their albums has been remastered boxed deluxes four times, including two versions only three or four years apart

Purple Rain is a double-dip that I honestly won't mind as long as they actually do it right next time. We're long overdue for a high quality release of the original "G-Spot"


Same here. I'd prefer they go into uncharted territory, but I'm always up for another Purple Rain release, provided they get it right this time.

PRINCE: the only man who could wear high heels and makeup and STILL steal your woman!
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #55 posted 12/25/21 5:44am

SantanaMaitrey
a

RODSERLING said:

herb4 said:

Maybe, but I don't see a Batman Prince reissue making much noise.

Perhaps MAYBE if they worked with the film makers and timed some weird re-release of Batdance (or better, use that song in the movie somewhere) but...eh. Keaton's role is a cameo in The Flash movie too if I'm reading the news right, so it's just minor fan service I think.

The success of that album had everything to do with the film and next to nothing to do with the quality of the music. It was a collection of rehashed songs that our man had lying around with some lyrics switched around that Prince cobbled together and WB slapped a Batman logo on since, in 1989, that was a license to print money and you could market a cat turd by simply changing one letter and calling it a Bat Turd. I doubt there's a treasure trove of outtakes here, nor a ton of fan interest.

Prince got to cash a nice check and put out an OK-ish album but, by and large, no one considers it anywhere close to a classic - despite its sales - and even fans of the movie sort of slot the album as more of a novelty than anything else. Aside from "Partyman", which aint that great, and "Trust" (also not great), Prince's music was totally BURIED in the actual film and, over time, has played second fiddle to Danny Elfman's legendary score.

If Prince had put out that same record and that same single minus that logo, neither go to #1 and fly off the shelves absent the strength of those bat wings folded up out of hundred dollar bills.




Because the 1999 amd SOTT did much noise?
No.
They were bought only by Prince fans.
With Batman you have at least the chance it will be bought buy hardcore-sucker Batman fans, old and new, just like Ghostbusters.

The Keaton's Batman logo, which is the cover of Prince album, is still the most popular. I often see kids wearing t-shirts, casket, bag, etc. With that logo on it.
[Edited 12/24/21 1:59am]
[Edited 12/24/21 2:00am]
[Edited 12/24/21 2:07am]

Of course those sets are only bought by fans! That's the whole idea. And fans of the Batman movie(s) are not going to be interested in unknown Prince songs. And the logo, that says nothing. Teenagers are walking around in Guns N Roses t shirts, that doesn't mean they are fans of the band, in fact they might hardly even know that it is a band.
[Edited 12/25/21 5:50am]
If you take any of this seriously, you're a bigger fool than I am.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #56 posted 12/25/21 5:46am

SantanaMaitrey
a

herb4 said:

God I hope not.

I'm Purple Rained out and have been for some time.


Same here. I only bought the deluxe for the outtakes.
If you take any of this seriously, you're a bigger fool than I am.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #57 posted 12/25/21 6:33am

RODSERLING

herb4 said:



RODSERLING said:


herb4 said:



From what I read, I think they kind of did, especially for a deceased artist that would be what, 63 years old right now? Not as much as PR but they sold OK.

And, sure, "they were bought by Prince fans" because...well, duh. Except that by "Prince fans", that encompasses people who say "yeah, I love Prince" who mainly remember him from the 80's and probably bought them out of nostalgia. Not people like us who still post on this board that will buy anything.

And, unlike the SDE releases we've gotten so far, I don't see a lot of potential crossover audience for something like Batman. The hardcore fans aren't nuts about it or clamouring for it and I doubt that the more casual fans have a ton of nostalgia for it either. Hardly anyone (casual or hardcore) considered it a grand artistic acheivement.

I could be wrong, of course, and maybe there's actually a way to market and sell the thing (Batman). Also, if you're right, then the estate may as well cue up Lovesexy, Parade, CB2, the live box set, etc. especially if, like you said, it's only the "fans" buying the stuff. I just think there's a difference between people who love Prince, People Who L.O.V.E. Prince and what they'll spend money on.




I have news for you : they could sell Parade, Lovesexy, 1999, or Batman or whatever : it would sell more or less the same amount, at an equal price. So I don't understand the reasonning behind your assumption than a Batman SDE wouldn't sell. Because a Parade or a D&P would sell more? No.


I have no idea. Sounds like you have strong opinions about it though.

I tried to make my reasoning rather clear and thought I explained my thoughts about it pretty well.

I think D&P is the last big commercial cash grab and that, after that, we're looking at vault material and live stuff to mine what's left of the gold. I think that 1999, PR and SoTT would/will/did rake in MORE extraneous buyers beyond the hardcore fan base than Lovesexy, Parade, GB and cetainly Batman will/would. I'm not sure why that might be a controversial opinion.

Again, I could be wrong. I'm not in control of the estate. I know what I would do, I know what I want to have and I'm not a marketing executive nor a record producer so I'm just speculating about supply and demand moving forward and just don't see it with fucking Batman is all. If I'm rading you right (and maybe I'm not), you seem to be implying that ONLY people like us are buying this stuff and I don't think that's true. Could be.

Anything they release will SELL. The question is how much and what's worth doing? I ponied up for 1999, PR and SoTT primarily for the outtakes/vault stuff. I'm not talking primarlily about fans like US so much as fans in general. It's like the difference with fans of an NFL team that will pay for tickets, a cable package and jerseys vs people who will catch a game on TV now and again.

I thought I worded my opinions rather succinctly but feel free to ask me any specific follow up questions if you found something I wrote to be vague or unclear.

Thanks.



I don't know where you got that D&P was " The last commercial cash-grab"?

It's the Prince album, with Batman and Lovesexy that has the lowest catalogue sales.

Between 2006-2016 ( week after Prince death), here was the best selling Prince albums in the US, which should be a marketing study for the estate :


1. Purple Rain ( 1000 k)
2. 1999 (200k)
3. Prince (76k)
4. SOTT (74k)
5. ATWIAD (60k)
6. Parade (58k)
7. Controversy (56k)
8. Dirty Mind (53k)
9. D&P (22k)

In the UK, D&P sold only 25k between 2001 and 2017.
In France it sold 25k between 2003 and 2017.

So, if I were the estate, it's rather a Prince SDE that I would release, than a D&P or Parade 😂.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #58 posted 12/25/21 10:36am

herb4

RODSERLING said:

herb4 said:


I have no idea. Sounds like you have strong opinions about it though.

I tried to make my reasoning rather clear and thought I explained my thoughts about it pretty well.

I think D&P is the last big commercial cash grab and that, after that, we're looking at vault material and live stuff to mine what's left of the gold. I think that 1999, PR and SoTT would/will/did rake in MORE extraneous buyers beyond the hardcore fan base than Lovesexy, Parade, GB and cetainly Batman will/would. I'm not sure why that might be a controversial opinion.

Again, I could be wrong. I'm not in control of the estate. I know what I would do, I know what I want to have and I'm not a marketing executive nor a record producer so I'm just speculating about supply and demand moving forward and just don't see it with fucking Batman is all. If I'm rading you right (and maybe I'm not), you seem to be implying that ONLY people like us are buying this stuff and I don't think that's true. Could be.

Anything they release will SELL. The question is how much and what's worth doing? I ponied up for 1999, PR and SoTT primarily for the outtakes/vault stuff. I'm not talking primarlily about fans like US so much as fans in general. It's like the difference with fans of an NFL team that will pay for tickets, a cable package and jerseys vs people who will catch a game on TV now and again.

I thought I worded my opinions rather succinctly but feel free to ask me any specific follow up questions if you found something I wrote to be vague or unclear.

Thanks.

I don't know where you got that D&P was " The last commercial cash-grab"?


From the Billboard 100 sales figures and the top 10 single releases, minus what the estate has already put out (1999, PR, SoTT). Meaning, the next biggest seller (aside from Batman)

You seem to be just kind of shouting into the wind and saying I'm wrong about Batman without really engaging with much at all that I wrote about it. Fuck it, then. Bring on Batman SDE and we'll see I guess. I don't care but would prefer CB2 or a love box set with aftershows.

I have no dog in this fight nor is it some hill I want to die on. I'm just talkin and speculating.

[Edited 12/25/21 11:34am]

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #59 posted 12/25/21 12:42pm

RODSERLING

herb4 said:



RODSERLING said:


herb4 said:



I have no idea. Sounds like you have strong opinions about it though.

I tried to make my reasoning rather clear and thought I explained my thoughts about it pretty well.

I think D&P is the last big commercial cash grab and that, after that, we're looking at vault material and live stuff to mine what's left of the gold. I think that 1999, PR and SoTT would/will/did rake in MORE extraneous buyers beyond the hardcore fan base than Lovesexy, Parade, GB and cetainly Batman will/would. I'm not sure why that might be a controversial opinion.

Again, I could be wrong. I'm not in control of the estate. I know what I would do, I know what I want to have and I'm not a marketing executive nor a record producer so I'm just speculating about supply and demand moving forward and just don't see it with fucking Batman is all. If I'm rading you right (and maybe I'm not), you seem to be implying that ONLY people like us are buying this stuff and I don't think that's true. Could be.

Anything they release will SELL. The question is how much and what's worth doing? I ponied up for 1999, PR and SoTT primarily for the outtakes/vault stuff. I'm not talking primarlily about fans like US so much as fans in general. It's like the difference with fans of an NFL team that will pay for tickets, a cable package and jerseys vs people who will catch a game on TV now and again.

I thought I worded my opinions rather succinctly but feel free to ask me any specific follow up questions if you found something I wrote to be vague or unclear.

Thanks.



I don't know where you got that D&P was " The last commercial cash-grab"?


From the Billboard 100 sales figures and the top 10 single releases, minus what the estate has already put out (1999, PR, SoTT). Meaning, the next biggest seller (aside from Batman)

You seem to be just kind of shouting into the wind and saying I'm wrong about Batman without really engaging with much at all that I wrote about it. Fuck it, then. Bring on Batman SDE and we'll see I guess. I don't care but would prefer CB2 or a love box set with aftershows.

I have no dog in this fight nor is it some hill I want to die on. I'm just talkin and speculating.


[Edited 12/25/21 11:34am]



If I were them, I would have, from the start, released the SDE chronologically, with a tv/netflix documentary about each album/era.

I would have started with FOR YOU, and would have coincided it with the release of the autobiography, and a 2 part documentary about his childhood until signing with WB, and then the making of For You and its release, how it was perceived at the time, etc.


Something to hook a bigger audience from the start with the SDE, with an affordable price and at a faster pace ( two SDE a year), until at least the 1999 SDE. Something to make a new audience sympathise with the character.

I think their strategy of releasing the SDE in complete disorder is a mistake.
[Edited 12/25/21 12:43pm]
[Edited 12/25/21 12:44pm]
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Page 2 of 9 <123456789>
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
« Previous topic  Next topic »
Forums > Prince: Music and More > Complaints About New Releases