moderator |
LOL, no worries man. |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
the funny thing is, i don't. i don't even remember seeing this performance... even though i KNOW i watched motown 25 when it came on. i actually remember the supremes performance more, oddly enough. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Let me start out my response to you by stating that I find the tone of your comment childish. Perhaps you don't speak English too well, but the way you express yourself doesn't really make want to take your comment too seriously. You seem to have some insight on the issue, but that's not the way to lend it any credibility.
This was a musicologist trained in ethnomusicology and his research on the field has been well established. He is from South America himself and he has very little interest in Western pop music. He expressed personal disdain for what he had witnessed and and used it as an example of how Western culture has invaded everywhere and transformed indigenous habits. His comments certainly weren't meant to flatter Michael Jackson and it was clear that he wasn't a fan of his music to any degree. I'd take it that the individuals he stayed with had heard other type of pop music as well, but had taken a specific liking to Michael Jackson's songs. If I recall correctly, the shaman he was talking about in this case had acquired a tape player or a radio of some sort and was running it on batteries. My memory of the details of the story is getting even hazier here, but I think he sometimes made trips to towns to acquire whatever he needed for his rituals. Melodies from pop music being incorporated into indigenous music is nothing new on its own right though. It has happened everywhere.
Unless you are a musicologist yourself and have done similar research I'd strongly advise you to refrain making such comments. You can't have extensive knowledge on the issue by simply working on a Medical Care program. I don't know the exact geographical location this researcher was staying, so it's of course possible that these tribes weren't living as far removed from the more populated areas than some others. The expression I used myself, "the deepest of amazon", might have been an exaggeration in that respect. I didn't think the actual "depth" would matter that much when commenting on this very thread. It's just the absurdity of the anecdote that has made me bring it up on some occasions. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |