Yes. An instrumental exists that was considered for use in the movie. I have seen/heard no evidence that an extended version of WDC exists, but it wouldn't shock me if one existed. His vault is huge and there are a lot of items that were never cataloged. The argument against it existing is that if there was a longer version, it would have likely been released. WDC was his first #1, so WB would have wanted to take advantage of the momentum like they did with his other singles from PR, so that argues against a long version existing. The instrumental is the only variation of this track that I've found, and I don't know if it had the bass on it or not. I've only seen the documents about it, and haven't heard the actual song. The expanded version of my book PRINCE and The Purple Rain Era Studio Sessions 1983-1984 was released in November 2018. (www.amazon.com/gp/product/1538114623/ref=dbs_a_def_rwt_bibl_vppi_i0) or www.facebook.com/groups/1...104195943/ | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
madhouseman said:
Yes. An instrumental exists that was considered for use in the movie. I have seen/heard no evidence that an extended version of WDC exists, but it wouldn't shock me if one existed. His vault is huge and there are a lot of items that were never cataloged. The argument against it existing is that if there was a longer version, it would have likely been released. WDC was his first #1, so WB would have wanted to take advantage of the momentum like they did with his other singles from PR, so that argues against a long version existing. The instrumental is the only variation of this track that I've found, and I don't know if it had the bass on it or not. I've only seen the documents about it, and haven't heard the actual song. Thank 1 more Duane! Ps) Question about Father's song = the one included in PR Deluxe...if this song at ur knowledge was always intended as a full instrumental song with no vocals ? [Edited 5/12/17 15:13pm] | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Yes. Without going into too many details, it was recorded as an instrumental on October 29, 1983. It was done just as a piano version as well as a piano/synth version. Both of these versions exist. As far as I know, there wasn't a version with lyrics, but again... that is just from what I know so far.
Hope that helps. The expanded version of my book PRINCE and The Purple Rain Era Studio Sessions 1983-1984 was released in November 2018. (www.amazon.com/gp/product/1538114623/ref=dbs_a_def_rwt_bibl_vppi_i0) or www.facebook.com/groups/1...104195943/ | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
bam "Climb in my fur." | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Great to read some interesting insights into the timing of the recording of these 2 songs. . My first thought on hearing they were to be on the PR deluxe release was that it's a shame there won't be a Roadhouse Garden album release. But then hearing them like this, I wonder if there ever really was an album!? There was just tracks that could have been an album, but never were. You can obviously hear from these they share more with ATWIAD than PR... So these really are just out takes from that era... And they sound like demos. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
. Respectfully going to have to disagree strongly here. RHG uses CMI Fairlight, which he hadn't been acquainted with prior to April 1985. OD featured a Katayama/Coleman/etc string arrangement, but Clare Fischer's work is one of the most prominent features of the version featured here (and one of the identifiable signatures of P's Parade and post-Parade era work). That he referred these embellishments to the personnel he used on the Purple Rain album should be a strong indication that no substantial working relationship with Fischer had yet been formed (he referred 'Screams of Passion' in the Fall of '84 or Winter/Spring of '85, more likely the latter, as a test case). . Both songs, naturally, follow the same skeletal structure and length of the June 7 1984 First Avenue show, and retain most of Linn/Bobby Z drum track from that mobile studio-recorded performance, as well as most of Matt Fink's DX7 work (train whistle, etc), and a small amount of P's original lead vocals for RHG (in the background, or as pretend 'ad libs'). . From the sound of the original live performance, which forms an absolute 'de minimus' basis of these studio reworked versions, taken from the standpoint of 1984-era Prince, one would expect something more along the lines of what was done with 'I Would Die 4 U' as the intended result. It is difficult to imagine that P would have envisioned or preordained these fortuitous and peculiar '85-'86-era sound changes so far ahead of time, and yet not significantly reflect those changes in other released work recorded around this time (much of what would become ATWIAD, 'The Dance of Electric', 100 MPH, etc), nor approximated (within the limits of the technology) in the unpolished live performance itself. If one wanted to say that he was already anticipating these very specific changes, it would require an unusually charitable, literary-critic-esque argument of his evolving artistry. I'm interested in the reality here, not a Village Voice pop cultural study. (This is a general statement, and not directed at madhouseman, whose work we should all appreciate) . It also concerns me that an 'instrumental version of WDC' may reflect confusion by the interviewees with 'Traffic Jam'; WDC most likely was conceived as an elaboration of and improvement on the same ideas (and follows a similar structure and production technique) to 'Traffic Jam', recorded only days earlier, for prospective use during the train chase/outtake montage sequence (which scene/montage happens to begin with a traffic pileup), at the request of the director. . The talk about different versions on this forum is rather silly (when it doesn't refer to an outtake known to exist), as a virtually infinite number of lengths and mixes could be assembled from the basic tracks of such complex studio efforts as WDC, incorporating many tapes' and channels' worth of different/alternate or unused vocal takes or instrumental parts. This would be true of a large portion of his 1980s studio work. Probably everything but his simplest and most down-to-earth (or most heavily programmed/sequenced) songs could be extended or cut 1,000 different ways, using nothing but what was recorded during the original session(s). . [Edited 5/12/17 16:57pm] | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Don't hate your neighbors. Hate the media that tells you to hate your neighbors. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Don't hate your neighbors. Hate the media that tells you to hate your neighbors. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
RD is cracking me up as usual. :lol: Listening to it more closely, I can hear that this isn't perfect sound quality, but I agree with those who find it a big win that we can actually BUY these songs. "Roadhouse Garden" for SALE? Are you kidding me? Feel free to join in the Prince Album Poll 2018! Let'a celebrate his legacy by counting down the most beloved Prince albums, as decided by you! | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Guys--let's not try to talk the man into giving everything away for free on the .org. Buy the book!
(Mine's free now, right?) | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Don't hate your neighbors. Hate the media that tells you to hate your neighbors. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
[Edited 5/12/17 16:43pm] Don't hate your neighbors. Hate the media that tells you to hate your neighbors. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Don't hate your neighbors. Hate the media that tells you to hate your neighbors. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
glam slam thank you ma'am Bitch this ain't the movies | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Always interesting to hear another viewpoint and thank you for being so specific, but where is Clare Fischer's work on this? I'm sorry if I'm missing it. The expanded version of my book PRINCE and The Purple Rain Era Studio Sessions 1983-1984 was released in November 2018. (www.amazon.com/gp/product/1538114623/ref=dbs_a_def_rwt_bibl_vppi_i0) or www.facebook.com/groups/1...104195943/ | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
. It's dotted throughout much of the versions of 'Our Destiny' on BFTP3.0 and PR Deluxe. Consider, for instance, the portions of around 0:48 - 0:52, with the horns arrangement. The Coleman/Katayma/etc orchestration is also present (although I believe excerpts of it have been moved around from their originally conceived/recorded placement from September 1984). . In my perspective, this is an unfinished track that likely went through many reimaginings over its relatively short lifespan, and we happen now to have one of those versions from near the end of that lifespan. Or, more correctly, a derivative of that late-stage version. I believe some of the warbles and other sound irregularities others here have mentioned are the product, among other reasons (lossy bootleg-sourced, perhaps), of being a mixdown of a much more elaborate and (on that grander scale) even more incomplete track. . I am dubious that Lisa was intended to be the sole lead vocalist, or even a lead vocalist if on the finished version. That may be an experiment that, as a product of the inattention the song received before the Revolution were dissolved, is now fossilized here for all eternity. . [Edited 5/12/17 17:21pm] | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
. EXACTLY!!!!!! .
| |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Ok, now I think I know where the confusion comes from. That isn’t Clare Fischer’s work. That is a group of musicians that were conducted by Lisa Coleman. According to the studio documents (as well documents from the local musician’s union), the session occurred on September 28, 1984 at Sunset Sound, Studio 2 from 11 a.m. - 9:30 p.m. and included Suzie Katayama (violin), Sid Page (violin), Marcy Dicterow (violin), Denyse Buffum (viola), David Coleman (cello), Tim Barr (double bass), Annette Atkinson (double bass) and Lauryie Woods (viola). Prince was not in attendance at that session as he was in Minneapolis working on Tambourine.
Clare started recording for Prince in October when he was given a tape of songs for The Family, so this pre-dates his work with Prince.
Lisa's orchestral parts are often accidentally credited to Clare. I’ve even heard members of The Revolution say the same thing!
Again, it is always great to hear another person's perspective on this. That is what makes putting Prince's studio sessions together so tricky. It is a gigantic puzzle and people can have honest disagreements about their theories. Thank you for voicing yours.
I hope that helps explain it a little bit.
The expanded version of my book PRINCE and The Purple Rain Era Studio Sessions 1983-1984 was released in November 2018. (www.amazon.com/gp/product/1538114623/ref=dbs_a_def_rwt_bibl_vppi_i0) or www.facebook.com/groups/1...104195943/ | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
But who are the horns section players? Fischer usually orchestrated both strings and horns, and the latter can be heard in this version of 'Our Destiny'. There are also a number of tracks that were never assumed or known to have CF work done on them, that studio documentation or actual outtakes later demonstrated to be the case. . For me, it's also problematic as W&L told me many years ago that both OD/RHG were sent in for input to CF, and Questlove apparently has a string-orchestral-overdubbed version of RHG. . Although I fear we're obsessing over mediocre songs here. . [Edited 5/12/17 17:32pm] | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Where are the horn players on the track? I'm sorry I'm not able to listen carefully at the moment, but according to the Union session notes, the horn players who were brought in including John James Liotine (trumpet) who was the leader, Brad Warnaar (french horn), Steven Madaio (trumpet) and Dick Mitchell (alto sax or tenor sax or flute) who would record from 7 p.m. until the end of the shift.
The expanded version of my book PRINCE and The Purple Rain Era Studio Sessions 1983-1984 was released in November 2018. (www.amazon.com/gp/product/1538114623/ref=dbs_a_def_rwt_bibl_vppi_i0) or www.facebook.com/groups/1...104195943/ | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
. These moments stand out: . [00:46 - 00:51], particularly at 00:50 . [1:06-1:17], particularly [01:09-01:10] (sounds synthetic, though) . [01:21 - 01:30] . [01:49-01:58] .
| |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
I can't always tell if those are synth or actual horns while listening to this on my computer, but those almost certainly are the ones covered by the horn section hired for that date.
Great talking to you about this. The expanded version of my book PRINCE and The Purple Rain Era Studio Sessions 1983-1984 was released in November 2018. (www.amazon.com/gp/product/1538114623/ref=dbs_a_def_rwt_bibl_vppi_i0) or www.facebook.com/groups/1...104195943/ | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Thanks Madhouseman! | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
| |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
madhouseman said: Our Destiny and Roadhouse Garden are basically the way they were recorded in May and June of 1984, with Lisa's vocals recorded on September 27, 1984 (the following day, Jill Jones also recorded her vocals for the track). As far as I can tell in the quick listen I've given to them, they are pretty much identical to what was done in 1984, with the exception of the edit, which came at a later date.
The were recorded as two seperate tracks, although they were performed together for their live premiere on June 7, 1984.
The difference in quality may stem from them being recorded at different times on different systems. Both were started at the warehouse which was not always the best place to record (Roadhouse Garden being among the first in the new warehouse), but Our Destiny was overdubbed at Sunset Sound, which could have altered the sound of the recording. I also don't know the sources of these originals that were used, but they were not meant to be blended, as you can tell from the change in quality.
Regarding some who have a problem with these being issued on the PR re-release, these were started 2 months after When Doves Cry and only days after Possessed was being edited for use in the movie, so it is still well within the range of the Purple Rain era. In fact, other tracks that are part of this CD reissue were recorded much later in 1984 (after the album and film had been released). Dance Electric was recorded on August 17, 1984, God (vocal) on August 19, 1984, and the extended version of I Would Die 4 U was recorded on October 25, 1984.
It could be argued that Our Destiny/Roadhouse Garden should be placed on a deluxe version of ATWIAD, but by May/June 1984, only 2 tracks for that album had been recorded: Pop Life (February ’84) and ‘Raspberry Beret’ (April ’84). ‘Paisley Park’ (March ’84) was the title of an instrumental which had nothing in common with the song that would eventually share the name, so at this stage.
Personally, I would have saved these for a release of the Roadhouse Garden album that Prince had mentioned multiple times, but historically, they are arguably in the proper place chronologically.
I hope that helps explain this a little bit. Very interesting. Thank you for the information. I think this would have fit nicely on ATWIAD. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Murph it lots like it's back to normal for the Org. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
djThunderfunk said:
It worked on me. I ordered from ITunes and was gonna cancel and wait to see if I would get the auto ripp from Amazon with the set I ordered from there, but now that they released these songs to me, no way I'm canceling now, lol. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
I dont know you, have no ill will towards you, kindof like you...but... given all that ... yall are balls deep into this TDK Dolby shit lol
that blip in the middle of Lovesexy must have drove all of you mad
.
[Edited 5/12/17 19:37pm] "Climb in my fur." | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Listened to it at spotify and think its the most exciting track of the three "vault" tracks released. Lisa's voice always gets me, its beautiful and not beautiful at the same time. Roadhouse garden is funky as i like my prince sound. Love it! | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
djThunderfunk said:
After hearing these I'm SOOOOO glad he did ATWIAD instead. That whole album is miles ahead of these. They are ok...but not near the quality of anything on that album. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |