independent and unofficial
Prince fan community
Welcome! Sign up or enter username and password to remember me
Forum jump
Forums > Prince: Music and More > TARGET/PRINCE: A Critical Thinker's Discussion Thread on Ethical Business
« Previous topic  Next topic »
Page 6 of 6 <123456
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
Reply #150 posted 03/05/09 12:25pm

GNS

paisley4me said:

Cheap Prince CD sold on a little cardboard display next to 10-packs of Strawberry-Banana Bubalicious and X-treme Spice Dorritos?! Welcome 2 the Dawn?

WTF, Prince? Aren't we past all this? Aren't you comfortable enough in your own reputation and legend to just be able to release a CD in the few record stores left. Or maybe as a download on your cool new site? What's with jumping into the Made in China fray. Let us find you, don't come looking for us.

what happened to Prince between Rainbow Children and Musicology? It's as if he had a panic attack that no one would ever love him again. Free CD's at concerts, in newspapers, etc. Relax, dude...if it's good it'll be found.

Oh wait! Maybe that's the problem...

Poetry.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #151 posted 03/05/09 12:32pm

GNS

lemoncrush said:

This thread is so misinformed and sad.
The pro-union jibberish isn't relevant, and certainly doesn't make Target a bad corporation.
If you did do your homework, you would see what kind of Philathrophic company Target is. If you spoke to people who worked for Target, you would see what an incredibly diverse and happy workforce they have.
They give somewhere around 2-3 million back to the community each WEEK, through different programs.
And if you've ever heard of Target House, which provides a comfortable place for seriously ill children and their family to stay during treatments free of charge, then maybe you would stop spewing this nonsense about unethical business practices.

Aren't you gonna be late for work? You Targeteer you.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #152 posted 03/05/09 1:03pm

themusicthatco
unts

Completely agree with your point of view Trickology. Its a toughie... how do you reach a wider audience without exploiting/using captialist organisations? I always thought the band Manic Street Preachers were hypocrites for being signed to Sony listening to what they sing... but they get a bigger platform on the bigger record label... I guess we all use things in life that have come from a poss dodgy source where no doubt we wouldn't like the ethics going on there... but although it doesn't make it right when I say that... how do we realistically escape it these days???

smile
[Edited 3/5/09 13:04pm]
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #153 posted 03/05/09 2:08pm

Serena

GNS said:

I'm fairly certain this thread is in the running for best EVER.

I mean, for reals.

Good job trickology.

Prince has officially sold out.



falloff Damn, there's some funny ass people around here, good job!
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #154 posted 03/05/09 2:10pm

GNS

Serena said:

GNS said:

I'm fairly certain this thread is in the running for best EVER.

I mean, for reals.

Good job trickology.

Prince has officially sold out.



falloff Damn, there's some funny ass people around here, good job!

Thanks.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #155 posted 03/05/09 2:26pm

jackblack

Prince should take a break after this. Live his life! A couple of years away from the public eye, away from other peoples music (a virus to originality) and the internet fan sites LOL and come back with the most inspired introspective genious album of his life! You dont know what you got until its gone.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #156 posted 03/05/09 3:19pm

CarrieMpls

Ex-Moderator

avatar

We could all become freegans and live off the grid.

http://freegan.info/


peace
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #157 posted 03/05/09 3:38pm

Anxiety

CarrieMpls said:

We could all become freegans and live off the grid.

http://freegan.info/


peace





groovy, let's all like build a teepee and love each other, right.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #158 posted 03/05/09 3:43pm

gubbins4ever

avatar

lezama said:

gubbins4ever said:


3. "The kind of practices in which Target engages are prevalent across the industry."
This point is weak. The prevalence is a practice is unrelated to whether or not such a practice is moral.


My point isn't reducible to some issue of the prevalence of any given practice. My question to you is whether those who live in glass houses can throw stones. If you can say without laughing that your livelihood and consumption intersects with no immoral business then go ahead and call someone a heathen. But pointing a finger at someone else when you most certainly dont research every entity you do business with is in my book just a tiny bit hipocritical.
[Edited 3/4/09 18:30pm]


Whether or not I'm a hypocrite still has no bearing on this argument. My point stands or falls on its own merits.

Furthermore, your argument rests on the strange idea that unless one is perfect, one cannot comment upon another's actions. If this logic prevailed then it would stifle all critical dialogue.

Nobody here is arguing that they are perfect. But comparing Prince's distribution practices with our daily lives is a flawed approach. Few of us have been in the position of considering distribution of a major album, so you are not comparing like with like. Were I in Prince's position, I would certainly not go through Target.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #159 posted 03/05/09 6:31pm

PurpleLove7

avatar

moderator

Sowhat said:

I have a few questions for Trickology....

1) Do you own the computer you are online with? If so, where did you buy it from and what kind of business practices do the store/place you bought it from have?

2) What kind of computer is it? Can you guarantee that no slave labor was used in making the computer or any of it's components? Was the Computer and ALL of it's components made with union labor?

3) What about the server we are using right now? Same questions.

4) What about the online service you are using? Same questions.


How far do you want to go with this? If you dig deep enough, pretty much any business or product is going to have the same problems.

So IMHO unless Target has separate bathrooms for blacks and whites, or breaks labor laws, or pays workers less than minimum wage, etc....something blatant like that, I think $11.99 for 3 CD's is a great deal and a wise decision on Prince's part.


Great questions ... What's the term? The ball is in your court Trick ...
Peace ... & Stay Funky ...

~* The only love there is, is the love "we" make *~

www.facebook.com/purplefunklover
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #160 posted 03/06/09 2:16am

BoySimon

"So IMHO unless Target has separate bathrooms for blacks and whites, or breaks labor laws, or pays workers less than minimum wage, etc....something blatant like that, I think $11.99 for 3 CD's is a great deal and a wise decision on Prince's part."

1. Seperate bathrooms: don't be so naive as to think that the place where you shit, or how you shit, or how often you shit is a 'point' here.

2. IF Target doesn't pay more than the minimum wage and/or is an employer who chooses not to pay above the 'living wage' then we are in conflict here BECAUSE Prince has vocalised a distrust of companies like this through the Money Don't Matter Tonight song/video... and his involvement in the Girl 6 project.

You see, it's a bit like the 'back-door draft' Anerica has for it's military. There are plenty of people who will sign up for and work for and will appear happy to represent... but it doesn't mean anything. Target pay lower than a living wage, aggresively discourage unions and appaer to have a less than ethical sourcing policy for its goods. This could be a bad move for the, 'slave', Prince.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #161 posted 03/06/09 6:13am

wonder505

BoySimon said:

"So IMHO unless Target has separate bathrooms for blacks and whites, or breaks labor laws, or pays workers less than minimum wage, etc....something blatant like that, I think $11.99 for 3 CD's is a great deal and a wise decision on Prince's part."

1. Seperate bathrooms: don't be so naive as to think that the place where you shit, or how you shit, or how often you shit is a 'point' here.

2. IF Target doesn't pay more than the minimum wage and/or is an employer who chooses not to pay above the 'living wage' then we are in conflict here BECAUSE Prince has vocalised a distrust of companies like this through the Money Don't Matter Tonight song/video... and his involvement in the Girl 6 project.

You see, it's a bit like the 'back-door draft' Anerica has for it's military. There are plenty of people who will sign up for and work for and will appear happy to represent... but it doesn't mean anything. Target pay lower than a living wage, aggresively discourage unions and appaer to have a less than ethical sourcing policy for its goods. This could be a bad move for the, 'slave', Prince.


it will not be a bad move for Prince because nobody cares. if you want to talk about what retailers pay their employees that's a whole other issue, but you really think people are going to see a Prince CD and automatically think about labor ethics and wages and employees. give me a break!
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #162 posted 03/06/09 7:06am

Sowhat

avatar

BoySimon said:

"So IMHO unless Target has separate bathrooms for blacks and whites, or breaks labor laws, or pays workers less than minimum wage, etc....something blatant like that, I think $11.99 for 3 CD's is a great deal and a wise decision on Prince's part."

1. Seperate bathrooms: don't be so naive as to think that the place where you shit, or how you shit, or how often you shit is a 'point' here.



It's an analogy.....let me state it another way, unless Target is blatantly or obviously racist.....
"Always blessings, never losses......"

Ya te dije....no manches guey!!!!!

mad I'm a guy!!!!

"....i can open my-eyes "underwater"..there4 i will NOT drown...." - mzkqueen03 eek lol
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #163 posted 03/06/09 7:44am

Sowhat

avatar

BoySimon said:

You see, it's a bit like the 'back-door draft' Anerica has for it's military. There are plenty of people who will sign up for and work for and will appear happy to represent... but it doesn't mean anything. Target pay lower than a living wage, aggresively discourage unions and appaer to have a less than ethical sourcing policy for its goods. This could be a bad move for the, 'slave', Prince.


OK so how should Prince distribute his music? Wal Mart? Best Buy? Traditional Record Stores? Amazon.com? ITunes? Exclusively from his website?

Because I can guarantee no matter what, no matter how he could distribute his music, that somehere along the line in the process there is someone not making a so called "living wage" or who is not a union member, etc...







.
[Edited 3/6/09 7:44am]
"Always blessings, never losses......"

Ya te dije....no manches guey!!!!!

mad I'm a guy!!!!

"....i can open my-eyes "underwater"..there4 i will NOT drown...." - mzkqueen03 eek lol
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #164 posted 03/06/09 11:46am

Darwintheorgan
grinder

CarrieMpls said:

From http://sites.target.com/s...P04-031696

Corporate Recognition Awards

Ethisphere Magazine ranks Target among the World’s Most Ethical Companies – 6/24/2008

BusinessWeek named Target among “Most Innovative Companies” – 4/22/2008

Black Collegian Magazine ranked Target 6th among Top 100 Employers – 3/12/2008

Fortune Magazine ranked Target one of “America’s Most Admired Companies” – 3/3/2008

BusinessWeek ranks Target 20th among top 50 Best Internships – 2008

BusinessWeek lists Target 24th in World’s Most Innovative Companies – 2008

Ethisphere Council names Target one of the World's Most Ethical Companies – 2008

Fortune ranks Target 31st in 500 Largest U.S. Corporations – 2008

Fortune places Target 11th in “America’s Most Admired Companies” – 2008

Fortune magazine names the Target Bullseye the champion in “Company Logo Smackdown,” beating out Apple, Nike, Google, McDonald’s and CBS – 2008

International Association of Chiefs of Police (IACP) recognized Target for Continued Support and Contributions – 9/1/2007

National Black MBA Association (NBMBAA) Twin Cities Chapter named Target Corporate Partner of the Year – 8/26/2007

Universum Communications listed Target in the Top-10 List of “Ideal Employers” – 8/9/2007

INROADS Corporate Plus Award – 7/19/2007

Chief Executive Magazine named Robert J. Ulrich “CEO of the Year” – 6/7/2007
Federal Bureau of Investigation recognized Target for Community Contributions with “Directors Community Leadership Award” – 6/7/2007

United Way “Operations United Way” earned the “Employee Engagement Award” – 5/17/2007

The Dave Thomas Foundation for Adoption ranked Target among Best Adoption-Friendly Companies – 5/3/2007

DiversityBusiness.com recognized Target – 5/1/2007

Ethisphere Council names Target one of the World's Most Ethical Companies – 2007

INROADS 25 Year Commitment Recognition – 2007

International Association of Chiefs of Police (IACP) recognized Target for Continued Support and Contributions to IACP – 2007

Metropolitan Economic Development Association Corporation of the Year 2007

National Black MBA Association (NBMBAA) The Silver Torch Award – 2007

Corporate Citizenship Survey ranks Target second – 2006

DiversityBusiness.com "Top 50" Corporations for Supplier Diversity – 2006

Federal Bureau of Investigation “Director’s Community Leadership Award” – 2006

Fortune “Top 100 Employers for Women” list – 2006

INROADS Strategic Growth Award – 2006

International Association of Chiefs of Police (IACP) recognizes Target for continued support and contributions to the IACP – 2006

Metropolitan Economic Development Association Corporation of the Year – 2006

National Association of Minority Contractors Corporate Partner of the Year – 2006

National Business Group on Health “Best Employer for Healthy Lifestyle” – 2006

National White Collar Crime Center (NW3C) recognizes Target for continued dedication in support of state and local law enforcement and NW3C – 2006

Newsweek names Target the corporate recipient of the “Giving Back Awards” – 2006

U.S. Secret Service “Certificate of Appreciation” from Director W. Ralph Basham for efforts and superior contributions to the law enforcement responsibilities of the Secret Service – 2006

Women Business Development Center Minnesota (A chapter of Women Business Enterprise National Council), Corporate Partner of the Year – 2006

American Red Cross Good Neighbor Award – 2005

Americans for the Arts Corporate Citizenship in the Arts Award – 2005

Barron's magazine survey ranks Target 6th "Most Respected Company" – 2005

DiversityBusiness.com "Top 50" Corporations for Supplier Diversity – 2005

Forbes names Target "Most Charitable Company" – 2005

Keep America Beautiful awards 1st place National Award for Waste Reduction – 2005

National Association for Female Executives (NAFE) "Top 30 Companies for Executive Women" – 2005

“Literacy Campaign Award” for Reach Out and Read, presented by First Lady Laura Bush – 2004

American Red Cross Circle of Humanitarians Award – 2004

King Center "Salute to Greatness" Award, recognizing civic engagement and consistent commitment to community” – 2004

National Committee for Employer Support of the Guard and Reserve Washington State Chapter "Outstanding Employer" award – 2004

Working Mother "100 Best Companies for Working Mothers" – 2004

Forbes names Target "One of the Most Philanthropic Companies" – 2003


Unfortunately, you failed to qualify your statement by mentioning that you are an employee (and not one of the sales floor lackeys) of Target. That hurts the credibility. I bet you could find a number of awards given to Wal-Mart. I wouldn't even be surprised in Enron received a laundry list of awards before their demise. It should also be mentioned that most of those awards were given for things having nothing to do with treatment of low-level employees, which is what this is all about.

You can throw all of these awards around, but it does not change the fact that most floor employees of Target don't make much money. I worked at a Target for a short period of time. It was not a horrible experience, but I didn't get paid squat. When it came time for my raise, I was awarded an extra 18 cents per hour. I
t is very possible that I worked with the person who wrote the report on which this thread is based. There was a college professor (who specializes in ethics) at my Target who was in between gigs. He told me he was planning on writing a book about target.
I abdicated the throne in Ithaca, but now I am...
Albany's Number 1 Prince Fan
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #165 posted 03/06/09 12:15pm

CarrieMpls

Ex-Moderator

avatar

Darwintheorgangrinder said:


Unfortunately, you failed to qualify your statement by mentioning that you are an employee (and not one of the sales floor lackeys) of Target. That hurts the credibility. I bet you could find a number of awards given to Wal-Mart. I wouldn't even be surprised in Enron received a laundry list of awards before their demise. It should also be mentioned that most of those awards were given for things having nothing to do with treatment of low-level employees, which is what this is all about.

You can throw all of these awards around, but it does not change the fact that most floor employees of Target don't make much money. I worked at a Target for a short period of time. It was not a horrible experience, but I didn't get paid squat. When it came time for my raise, I was awarded an extra 18 cents per hour. I
t is very possible that I worked with the person who wrote the report on which this thread is based. There was a college professor (who specializes in ethics) at my Target who was in between gigs. He told me he was planning on writing a book about target.


Actually, I listed them as they are awards given to Target by independent entities, so it’s not someone from within the company just saying “wow, we’re great!” That adds to the credibility, not takes away from it. Not to mention these are awards that come from well-known organizations like the United Way, the American Red Cross, Forbes and Newsweek as well as organizations like The National Black MBA Association and the National Association of Minority contractors.

I was simply pointing out that Target has been recognized by numerous organizations for business ethics, not to mention it is widely recognized for philanthropy. That is not to say that there isn’t room for improvement. I have not explored whether or not store employees make a livable wage. Only to say that if you’re going to attack a corporation for unethical practices, Target is an odd target.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #166 posted 03/07/09 12:26am

bluefish

avatar

Sowhat said:

I have a few questions for Trickology....

1) Do you own the computer you are online with? If so, where did you buy it from and what kind of business practices do the store/place you bought it from have?

2) What kind of computer is it? Can you guarantee that no slave labor was used in making the computer or any of it's components? Was the Computer and ALL of it's components made with union labor?

3) What about the server we are using right now? Same questions.

4) What about the online service you are using? Same questions.


How far do you want to go with this? If you dig deep enough, pretty much any business or product is going to have the same problems.

So IMHO unless Target has separate bathrooms for blacks and whites, or breaks labor laws, or pays workers less than minimum wage, etc....something blatant like that, I think $11.99 for 3 CD's is a great deal and a wise decision on Prince's part.


clapping Brilliant post! Sowhat 4, Trickology 0.
‎https://www.youtube.com/@PurpleKnightsPodcast
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Page 6 of 6 <123456
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
« Previous topic  Next topic »
Forums > Prince: Music and More > TARGET/PRINCE: A Critical Thinker's Discussion Thread on Ethical Business