sleepyq said:

Why are you questioning Janet's writing credibility? Was she ever sued for plagiarizing? Do you question Prince, MJ and Madonna, etc as well.

She wrote TA at a hotel when she was on tour in Europe.

sleepyq said:

Idk you're the one in here hating on Miss Jackson for no apparent reason while your fav have stated to be inspired by none other than - Janet. Yet you claim she's not talented. Sounds pressed to me.

trueiopian said:

I don' question Madonna because she wrote most of the songs on her debut album by herself.
I don't question MJ because he wrote almost all but 2 of the songs on the Bad album by himself
I don't question Prince because he wrote virtually all his music by himself. for himself, and other artists as well.


Janet may very well have written all, or most of her hits on her own. But we can't say that for sure. Its all heresay. I'd rather stick with official stuff, ie the writers registry, liner notes, etc.

midiscover said:

Maybe I'm not pressed at all?

All my faves (according to u) have been shitting all over Janet for YEARS. All of them.

I have NO REASON to be mad at Janet. Maybe i'm just giving my opinions, hm?

sleepyq said:

No, you're pressed. If you were unmoved by Janet you wouldn't be on here wasting bandwidth, dear.

Janet has you shook. Its ok It happens to the best of them.

Yet your favs will be the first to get on their knees and worship her. Janet ruled the charts for 3 decades. She had to step down and let these little girls have their time to shine.

midiscover said:

I'm not unmoved by her.

I like her as a person and am a fan of the majority of her music.

I just don't think she's particularly talented, simple as that. I'm not gonna let u bully me out of this thread because u dont agree with my opinion, THATS whats up with me.

sleepyq said:

Yet you find Usher and Beyonce talented

You're pressed.

sleepyq said:

But how do you know if they really wrote their music ? Remember there's no way of proving it.

the bitchiness in this thread.....

bboy87 said:

bboy87 said:

midiscover said:

Usher? Talented? at emulating Michael Jackson?

trueiopian said:

I agree.

But as i said, i just like to stick with official stuff. Unless we have situations like Beyonce where songwriters CONSTANTLY accuse her pof not writing anything. Otherwise, i just ignore all the heresay and stuffstick with credits.

Thats just my personal take, but i see where u comin from.

midiscover said:

Talented? Yes.

Great catalogues of mussic? No.

More talented than Michael Jackson? No.

Dont put words in my mouth, mmkay?

trueiopian said:

ahahhahahhahah!!!!!

Yes, Mz. flabbyq thinks Usher is talented and that Beyonce is too.

sleepyq said:

Um right.

and Janet is credited as the performer, writer and producer. You know - I'm just going by official credits. See how it works.

- I predict that your argument (the same one you've kept pushing a few pages back) will be that Janet's not a REAL songwriter because Jam & Lewis are credited as well -

So predictable.

Yet you find Beyonce - someone who doesn't write their music is talented?
[Edited 4/18/10 15:53pm]

trueiopian said:

Umm of course u do, we already had this argument on the last page, and where i already stated ur "prediction."

Ur psychic abilities are STUNNING. Do u have a hotline?

trueiopian said:

Songwriter? Nope. Telented? Yes.

Shes a great singer with great stage presence, connects with her audience, does her choreography well.

And she sings LIVE. Its always nice to have ppl sing LIVE, u know?

midiscover said:

Oh wow aha!

He loses all credibility right there.

How can you say someone who's whole career is based off another artist is talented yet someone who's been performing since 7 and making music since 9 isn't talented at all.



Anways..... Some people say the darnest things.

trueiopian said:

I've been singing and performing since I was 5 years old. So has my cousin. And my step sister. And my brother's baby mamma.

I guess i can assume we're ALL more talented than Usher and Beyonce, correct?

sleepyq said:

An argument you failed to follow through.

sleepyq said:

Irrelevant

sleepyq said:

No, you're just a non-talented, flabby boy.

trueiopian said:

Yes, chile he's hopeless

Janet is the most talented artist ever.

KI!

He thinks Beyonce sings live. So delusional.

trueiopian said:

What argument?

I've given my opinion and explained it. U provided some hersay to prove me wrong, and I said i dont consider hersay factual.

What else is there to say? I've sia dmy piece and u said urs. U wanna bring forth more he-said she-said?

midiscover said:

Always? No.

More often than Janet? Most certainly.

sleepyq said:

No, no, no sweetie. You're confusing your little fantasies of performing in front of your mirror in that 1 bedroom apartment to actual talent. Janet was performing in front of millions and millions at just 7 years old.

So that does make her more talented than those other two. She has more natural ability in the performance and music category.

midiscover said:

And THAT is where u loose YOUR credibility.

I was waiting for u to say that. Always gives me a good laugh. U should be a comedian. Or a clown.

sleepyq said:

You keep thinking that.