I'll do it

Beatles

Best Album: Abbey Road

Worst Album: The Pre-Rubber Soul Albums

Most Overrated Album: The Pre-Rubber Soul Albums

Most Underrated Album: Let It Be

Top 5 Best Songs: Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds, I Am The Walrus, In My Life, Something, Elenor Rigby

Top 5 Worst Songs: Some Of The Songs Pre-Rubber Soul

Best Video: Hard Day's Night

Worst Video: I Am The Walrus

Depeche Mode

Best album: Violator
Worst album: Construction Time Again
Most overrated album: Playing the Angel
Most underrated album: A Broken Frame
Top 5 best songs: Enjoy The Silence, Little 15, Nothing's Impossible, Strangelove, Never Let Me Down Again

Top 5 worst songs: Pipeline, The Death of Night, Flexible, Boys Say Go, More Than a Party

Best video: Enjoy The Silence
Worst video: Barrel of a gun
Most creative 5 years: 1986-1991
Most lame 5 years: 1998-2003

great Post

Let me kick it off for me with

[Edited 12/26/12 11:09am]

Oh, I love A-ha, Morten Harket's voice simply magical.

Minor Earth Major Sky their best album for me.
I remember my obsession with the song Summer Moved On .. I listened to it again and again and again

LiLi1992 said:

Oh, I love A-ha, Morten Harket's voice simply magical.

Minor Earth Major Sky their best album for me.
I remember my obsession with the song Summer Moved On .. I listened to it again and again and again

My fsve band of all time, and people think im nuts for that, they say how is it not TheBeatles The Stones, and im like, "I love those bands, but i didnt grow up on them" to me a favorite band or aritst i really need to experience it from day one while they are active, the Beatles broke up before i was born.

Yes agree on a-ha, Morten one of the best vocalists ever, and Minor Earth is a HUGE album for me too, and to think that was their "comeback" record after being apart for four years and not releasing a record for 7, it was a HUGE statement for a "synth" 80's band to make, to me thats when they became "artists"

lastdecember said:

LiLi1992 said:

Oh, I love A-ha, Morten Harket's voice simply magical.

Minor Earth Major Sky their best album for me.
I remember my obsession with the song Summer Moved On .. I listened to it again and again and again

My fsve band of all time, and people think im nuts for that, they say how is it not TheBeatles The Stones, and im like, "I love those bands, but i didnt grow up on them" to me a favorite band or aritst i really need to experience it from day one while they are active, the Beatles broke up before i was born.

In my top 10 favorite bands of all time
I prefer them to The Stones or Led Zeppelin (not because I think they are greater, I just relate more to their songs)

The peak of the majority of my favorite artists was before I was born.

Curtis Mayfield

Best Album: Curtis

Worst Album: Take It To The Streets

Most Underrated: New World Order

Most Overrated: Superfly

Top 5 Best Songs: No Thing On Me(Coccaine Song), If There Is A Hell Below(We Are All Going To Go), New World Order, When Seasons Change, Never Say You Can't Survive

Top 5 Worst Songs: He's A Fly Guy, Just Want To Be With You, Hey Baby, Let's Do It Again, Toot an Toot an Toot

Best Videos: He just had live stuff mainly... so

Worst Videos: Same

Most Creative 5 Years: 1970-1975

Most Lame 5 Years: 1990-1995

Pet Shop Boys

Best Album: Behavior

Worst Album: Nightlife

Most Underrated: Billingual

Most Overrated: Actually

Top 5 Songs: Being Boring, Psychological, My October Symphony, Why Don't We Live Together, Kings Cross.

Worst 5 Songs: Boy Strange, Birthday Boy, Before, You Only Tell Me You Love Me When You're Drunk, New York City Boy

Best Videos: Being Boring, Suburbia, West End Girls

Worst Videos: New York City Boy, Can You Forgive Her

Most Creative 5 Years: 1990-1995

Most Lame- 1998-2002

[.]

[Edited 3/8/13 0:22am]

[.]

[Edited 3/8/13 0:22am]

CrabalockerFishwife said:

Yoko Ono

Most underrated album All of them
Most overrated album None of them

I dare someone to try New Edition (as a group and as individuals)!

CrabalockerFishwife said:

LiLi1992 said:

by 10 criteria

Best album
Worst album
Most underrated album
Most overrated album
Top 5 best songs
Top 5 worst songs
Best videos
Worst video
Most creative 5 years
Most lame 5 years

----------------------------------

I can't properly participate in this thread as I don't understand (or care to understand) the concept of 'overrated' and 'underrated'

overrated album - considered the best by critics or is the most successful in the career of artist, but, in your opinion, this artist has better albums that are in the shade
underrated - album, which was destroyed by critics or was not a commercial success (or had a weak commercial success compared to other albums of this artist), though you think it's good enough, or simply the best album but in the shadow of overrated.

Michael Jackson:

Best album-Bad/Dangerous
Worst album-don't have one, but least favourite can be Invincible though I still love it
Most underrated album-Blood on the Dancefloor
Most overrated album-Thriller
Top 5 best songs-Who Is It, Beat It , Smooth Criminal, Will You Be There, Scream
Top 5 worst songs-can't think of any
Best videos-Leave Me Alone, Scream, Bad, Smooth Criminal, Who Is It
Worst video-can't think of any, even if I have preferences
Most creative 5 years-86 to 91
Most lame 5 years- (2002-2007) loved the music in between, but hated his absence and what was happening to him

Janet Jackson:

Best album-Rhythm Nation/Velvet Rope
Worst album-20 YO
Most underrated album-Velvet Rope
Most overrated album-Janet (I love it but not like the others)
Top 5 best songs-Nasty, Love Will Never Do, Pleasure Principle, Again, If

Top 5 worst songs-Show Me, SloLove, Warmth, Let Me Know, Curtains

Best videos-Pleasure Principle, Nasty, Rhythm Nation, Love Will Never Do, If...honorable mention-You Want This
Worst video-Call On Me
Most creative 5 years-93'-98'
Most lame 5 years-2004-2009-she had some good songs here and there, but in comparison to the other eras, what a waste! Good singles went to waste, some could have had better videos, choreography and so on

Madonna:

Best album: Like a Virgin/Confessions
Worst album-MDNA
Most underrated album-American Life
Most overrated album-Like a Prayer
Top 5 best songs-Like a Prayer, Express Yourself, Spotlight, Where's the Party, Open Your Heart
Top 5 worst songs-Gang Bang, Mer Girl, Something to Remember, One More Chance, Spanish Lesson
Best videos-Like a Virgin, Like a Prayer, American Life long version, Bedtime Story, Human Nature
Worst video-Hollywood
Most creative 5 years-2003-2008
Most lame 5 years- 2009 to present, though I loved the MDNA tour a lot and really glad I still went.

Mariah:

Best album-Butterfly/Mimi
Worst album-Angels
Most underrated album-Charm Bracelet
Most overrated album-Music Box
Top 5 best songs-Can't Let Go, Fantasy, For the Record, Breakdown, Never Too Far
Top 5 worst songs-Loverboy, Obsessed, the song with Nikki Minaj, the Christmas song remake with bow wow, or was it beiber? I can't even remember...

Best videos-Breakdown, Honey, Can't Let Go, Heartbreaker, Heartbreaker remix, My All remix
Worst video-Loverboy, artrocious!
Most creative 5 years-1997-2002 plus 2005
Most lame 5 years-2008 to present, not really lame cause I do like a lot of songs, like singles and album cuts, it's just not consistent like before

Prince:

Best album-Around the World in a Day
Worst album-Chaos and Disorder
Most underrated album-Around the World in a Day
Most overrated album-Sign O The Times
Top 5 best songs-Bambi, Darlin Nikki, 1999, Alphabet Street, Gold, honorable mention: Soft & Wet
Top 5 worst songs-Adore, any track beside alphastreet on lovesexy, Cinnamon Girl, Pink Cashmere, Take Me With You
Best videos-Kiss, Alphabet Street, Get Off, Gold, Greatest Romance Ever Sold, When Doves Cry
Worst video-not sure
Most creative 5 years-1982-1987
Most lame 5 years-2000-2003

alphastreet said:

Michael Jackson:

Best album-Bad/Dangerous
Worst album-don't have one, but least favourite can be Invincible though I still love it
Most underrated album-Blood on the Dancefloor
Most overrated album-Thriller
Top 5 best songs-Who Is It, Beat It , Smooth Criminal, Will You Be There, Scream
Top 5 worst songs-can't think of any
Best videos-Leave Me Alone, Scream, Bad, Smooth Criminal, Who Is It
Worst video-can't think of any, even if I have preferences
Most creative 5 years-86 to 91
Most lame 5 years- (2002-2007) loved the music in between, but hated his absence and what was happening to him

Janet Jackson:

Best album-Rhythm Nation/Velvet Rope
Worst album-20 YO
Most underrated album-Velvet Rope
Most overrated album-Janet (I love it but not like the others)
Top 5 best songs-Nasty, Love Will Never Do, Pleasure Principle, Again, If

Top 5 worst songs-Show Me, SloLove, Warmth, Let Me Know, Curtains

Best videos-Pleasure Principle, Nasty, Rhythm Nation, Love Will Never Do, If...honorable mention-You Want This
Worst video-Call On Me
Most creative 5 years-93'-98'
Most lame 5 years-2004-2009-she had some good songs here and there, but in comparison to the other eras, what a waste! Good singles went to waste, some could have had better videos, choreography and so on

Madonna:

Best album: Like a Virgin/Confessions
Worst album-MDNA
Most underrated album-American Life
Most overrated album-Like a Prayer
Top 5 best songs-Like a Prayer, Express Yourself, Spotlight, Where's the Party, Open Your Heart
Top 5 worst songs-Gang Bang, Mer Girl, Something to Remember, One More Chance, Spanish Lesson
Best videos-Like a Virgin, Like a Prayer, American Life long version, Bedtime Story, Human Nature
Worst video-Hollywood
Most creative 5 years-2003-2008
Most lame 5 years- 2009 to present, though I loved the MDNA tour a lot and really glad I still went.

Mariah:

Best album-Butterfly/Mimi
Worst album-Angels
Most underrated album-Charm Bracelet
Most overrated album-Music Box
Top 5 best songs-Can't Let Go, Fantasy, For the Record, Breakdown, Never Too Far
Top 5 worst songs-Loverboy, Obsessed, the song with Nikki Minaj, the Christmas song remake with bow wow, or was it beiber? I can't even remember...

Best videos-Breakdown, Honey, Can't Let Go, Heartbreaker, Heartbreaker remix, My All remix
Worst video-Loverboy, artrocious!
Most creative 5 years-1997-2002 plus 2005
Most lame 5 years-2008 to present, not really lame cause I do like a lot of songs, like singles and album cuts, it's just not consistent like before

Prince:

Best album-Around the World in a Day
Worst album-Chaos and Disorder
Most underrated album-Around the World in a Day
Most overrated album-Sign O The Times
Top 5 best songs-Bambi, Darlin Nikki, 1999, Alphabet Street, Gold, honorable mention: Soft & Wet
Top 5 worst songs-Adore, any track beside alphastreet on lovesexy, Cinnamon Girl, Pink Cashmere, Take Me With You
Best videos-Kiss, Alphabet Street, Get Off, Gold, Greatest Romance Ever Sold, When Doves Cry
Worst video-not sure
Most creative 5 years-1982-1987
Most lame 5 years-2000-2003

How can those be ur 3 least favorite Prince songs lol.

Prefab Sprout:

Best album: Jordan: The Comeback

Worst album: Andromenda Heights

Most underrated album- Protest Songs
Most overrated album: Swoon
Top 5 best songs: "When Love Breaks Down", "Cars and Girls", "Appetite", "Goodbye Lucille #1", "Wild Horses"
Top 5 Worst Songs: "The Yearning Loins", "Moondog", "Machine Gun Ibiza",

"A Prisoner of the Past"

Best video:"If You Don't Love Me"
Worst video: "The Golden Calf"
Most creative 5 years: 1985-1990

Most lame 5 years: 1997-present

Whitney:

Best album: My Love Is Your Love

Worst album: Just Whitney

Most underrated: I'm Your Baby Tonight

Most overrated: Whitney Houston

Top 5 best songs: Fine, You Give Good Love, I Bow Out, I Look to You, Dear John Letter

Top 5 worst songs: Whatchulookinat, Like I Never Left, Someone for Me, Step by Step, In My Business

Best video: "My Love is Your Love"

Worst video: "How Will I Know" (I have my reasons )

Most creative 5 years: 1985-1990

Most lame 5 years: 2002-2007

Diana:

Best album: Surrender

Worst album: Ross

Most underrated: Everything is Everything

Most overrated: Diana

Top 5 best songs: All the Befores, This House, Telephone, If You're Not Gonna Love Me Right, Surrender

Top 5 worst songs: Force Behind the Power (one of Stevie's worst moments as a songwriter), Work That Body (that song makes me cringe for some reason), What You Gave Me (this Marvin classic should've been left alone, what was Motown thinking?), Pieces of Ice, Paradise

Best video: "Swept Away" (just for her kicking ass in it)

Worst video: "Not Over You Yet" (seems as if she just shot a fashion video in London lol)

Most creative 5 years: 1980-1985

Most lame 5 years: 1989-1994

Stevie:

Best album: Music of My Mind

Worst album: Conversation Peace

Most underrated: Where I'm Coming From

Most overrated: Songs in the Key of Life

Top 5 best songs: Never Dreamed You Leave in Summer, I Don't Know Why I Love You, Maybe Your Baby, Do I Do, Visions

Top 5 worst songs: I Just Called to Say I Love You, I'm Sorry, Cash in Your Face, Stay Gold, Fun Day

Best video: "Skeletons"

Worst video: "Do I Do" (too much going on)

Most creative 5 years: 1971-1976 (which is no question it was)

Most lame 5 years: 1982-1987

Aretha:

Best album: Lady Soul

Worst album: What You See Is What You Sweat

Most underrated: Hey Now Hey! The Other Side of the Sky

Most overrated: I Never Loved a Man The Way I Love You

Top 5 best songs: Mister Spain, That's the Way I Feel About You, Sparkle, Ain't No Way, Dr. Feelgood

Top 5 worst songs: Through the Storm, Everyday People, Watch My Back, The Only Thing Missing, Put You Up on Game

Best video: "Freeway of Love"

Worst video: "Rock a Lott"

Most creative 5 years: 1968-1973

Most lame 5 years: 1974-1979

aardvark15 said:

Bjork

Best Album: Vespertine

Worst Album: Drawing Restraint 9

Most Overrated Album: Homogenic

Most Underrated Album: Medulla

Top 5 Best Songs: Amphibian, Batabid, Venus As A Boy, Who Is It (Bell Mix), All Is Full Of Love (Single Version)

Top 5 Worst Songs: Most of the songs on Drawing Restraint 9

Best Video: All Is Full Of Love

Worst Video: n/a

Most Creative 5 Years: 2001-2006

Most Lame 5 Years: n/a

Luther Vandross

Best Album: Never Too Much

Worst Album: Dance With My Father

Most Overrated Album: Forever, For Always, For Love

Most Underrated Album: Power Of Love

Top 5 Best Songs: Heaven Knows, Power Of Love/Love Power, Never Too Much, A House Is Not A Home, The Night I Fell In Love

Top 5 Worst Songs: Some songs on Dance With My Father

Best Video: Heaven Knows

Worst Video: Never Too Much

Most Creative 5 Years: 1981-1986

Most Lame 5 Years: Last years

You know, I'm not fond of the Dance With My Father or Your Secret Love albums. I think people gave Dance such praise because it was Luther's last album.

Nine Inch Nails

Best album - The Fragile
Worst album - Ghosts I-IV
Most underrated album - With Teeth
Most overrated album - Year zero
Top 5 best songs - Wish, Echoplex, the day the world went away, Reptile, the fragile
Top 5 worst songs - the purest feeling, ring finger, my violent heart, the great destroyer
Best videos Closer, The perfect drug, Starfuckers Inc, the day the whole world went away
Worst video - into the void
Most creative 5 years - 1989 -1994
Most lame 5 years -1994-1999 when the band was on hiatus

Within Temptation

Best album: The Silent Force
Worst album: Mother Earth
Most overrated album: n/a
Most underrated album: Enter
Top 5 best songs: Stand My Ground, All I Need, Angels, The Howling, Sinead
Top 5 worst songs: Murder, Mother earth, Never-ending story, Forsaken, Caged
Best video: Memories
Worst video: n/a
Most creative 5 years: 2004-2009
Most lame 5 years: 1998-2003

Timmy84 said:

Whitney:

Best album: My Love Is Your Love

Worst album: Just Whitney

Most underrated: I'm Your Baby Tonight

Most overrated: Whitney Houston

Top 5 best songs: Fine, You Give Good Love, I Bow Out, I Look to You, Dear John Letter

Top 5 worst songs: Whatchulookinat, Like I Never Left, Someone for Me, Step by Step, In My Business

Best video: "My Love is Your Love"

Worst video: "How Will I Know" (I have my reasons )

Most creative 5 years: 1985-1990

Most lame 5 years: 2002-2007

Diana:

Best album: Surrender

Worst album: Ross

Most underrated: Everything is Everything

Most overrated: Diana

Top 5 best songs: All the Befores, This House, Telephone, If You're Not Gonna Love Me Right, Surrender

Top 5 worst songs: Force Behind the Power (one of Stevie's worst moments as a songwriter), Work That Body (that song makes me cringe for some reason), What You Gave Me (this Marvin classic should've been left alone, what was Motown thinking?), Pieces of Ice, Paradise

Best video: "Swept Away" (just for her kicking ass in it)

Worst video: "Not Over You Yet" (seems as if she just shot a fashion video in London lol)

Most creative 5 years: 1980-1985

Most lame 5 years: 1989-1994

Stevie:

Best album: Music of My Mind

Worst album: Conversation Peace

Most underrated: Where I'm Coming From

Most overrated: Songs in the Key of Life

Top 5 best songs: Never Dreamed You Leave in Summer, I Don't Know Why I Love You, Maybe Your Baby, Do I Do, Visions

Top 5 worst songs: I Just Called to Say I Love You, I'm Sorry, Cash in Your Face, Stay Gold, Fun Day

Best video: "Skeletons"

Worst video: "Do I Do" (too much going on)

Most creative 5 years: 1971-1976 (which is no question it was)

Most lame 5 years: 1982-1987

It took me awhile to come to it.

But My Love Is Your Love is Whitneys most mature album and for sure on may listens has the best writing.

This album is the album people wanted her to make sinc ethe 80's.

And my 2nd favorite is I'm Your Baby Tonight(Damn that got some shit tastic reviews when it came out )

Let's do Bob Dylan:

Best album: Blood On The Tracks
Worst album: Knocket Out Loaded
Most overrated album: Another Side of Bob Dylan
Most underrated album: Street Legal
Top 5 best songs: Simple Twist Of Fate, Workingman's Blues #2, If You See Her Say Hello, I Want You, The Lonesome Death Of Hattie Carrol,
Top 5 worst songs: Seeing The Real You At Last, Trust Yourself, Ugliest Girl In The World, Sally Sue Brown, Frankie & Albert
Best video: Subterranean Homesick Blues
Worst video: Duquesne Whistle
Most creative 5 years: 1963-1968
Most lame 5 years: 1983-1988

Identity said:

Prefab Sprout:

Best album: Jordan: The Comeback

Worst album: Andromenda Heights

Most underrated album- Protest Songs
Most overrated album: Swoon
Top 5 best songs: "When Love Breaks Down", "Cars and Girls", "Appetite", "Goodbye Lucille #1", "Wild Horses"
Top 5 Worst Songs: "The Yearning Loins", "Moondog", "Machine Gun Ibiza",

"A Prisoner of the Past"

Best video:"If You Don't Love Me"
Worst video: "The Golden Calf"
Most creative 5 years: 1985-1990

Most lame 5 years: 1997-present

I hate to be one of those people who go around saying 'how can you hate such-and-such?' but Prisoner of the Past is one of my very favourite Prefab songs.

Whitney Houston

Best Album: My Love Is Your Love

Worst Album: Just Whitney

Most Overrated: Whitney, I'm Your Baby Tonight (By Gunsnhalen)

Most Underrated: I Look To You

Top 5 Best Songs: You Give Good Love, Heartbreak Hotel, I Will Always Love You, My Love Is Your Love, I Have Nothing

Top 5 Worst Songs: Any 5 songs from Just Whitney

Best Video: My Love Is Your Love

Worst Video: Not really one I could say is worst than any other especially considering many of her videos are similar to each other

Most Creative 5 Years: 1990-1995

Most Lame 5 Years: 2002-2007

Madonna

Best Album: Ray Of Light

Worst Album: Hard Candy

Most Overrated: Like A Virgin

Most Underrated: Erotica, Music Or MDNA

Top 5 Best Songs: Drowned World/Subsitute For Love, Little Star, Vogue, Like A Prayer, Nobody's Perfect

Top 5 Worst Songs: Shoo-Bee-Doo, Turn Up The Radio, Spanish Lesson, Santa Baby, Gambler

Best Videos: Bad Girl, Nothing Really Matters, Bedtime Stories, Erotica, Justify My Love, Like A Prayer, Human Nature, Frozen, The Power Of Goodbye, Take A Bow, You'll See, Rain

Worst Video: Lucky Star

Most Creative 5 Years: 1992-1997

Most Lame 5 Years: 1982-1987

[Edited 12/29/12 16:59pm]

U2

Best Album: Achtung Baby

Worst Album: October

Most Overrated: How To Dismanted An Atomic Bomb

Most Underrated: Zooropa

Top 5 Best Songs: Miss Sarajevo, Mothers Of The Dissappeared, Like A Song, Until The End Of The World, Walk On

Worst 5 Songs: Mofo, Vertigo, With a Shout (Jerusalem), I Threw a Brick Through a Window, Breathe

Best Video: Stay(Faraway So Close!)

Worst Video: Vertio

Most Creative 5 Years 1990-1994

Most Lame: 1995-1999

Diamanda Galas

Best Album: The Litanies Of Satan

Worst Album: The Sporting Life

Most Overrated: Blood Reign Of America

Best Songs: I Woke Up And Saw The Face Of The devil, Wild Women and Steak Knives, Plague of Egypt, Down So Low, Do You Take This Man

Worst Songs: Sono Lantichrist, Another Day Of One, 2 Shots, Eat The Young, Hi hi

Best Video: Double Barrel Prayer

Worst Video: Errrrrrr

Most Creative 5 Years: 1986-1991

Most Lame 5 Years: 1994-1998

Oasis

Best Album: Definitely Maybe

Worst Album: Be Here Now

Most Overrated: (What's The Story) Morning Glory

Most Underrated: Heathen Chemistry

Top 5 Best Songs: "Supersonic", "Wonderwall", "The Masterplan", "Gas Panic", "Live Forever"

Worst 5 Songs: "Lyla", "Waiting for the Rapture", ''Stand By Me", ''Put Yer Money Where Yer Mouth Is", "Roll With it"

Best Video: "Who Feels Love"

Worst Video: "Go Let it Out"

Most Creative 5 Years 1994-1999

Most Lame: 2005 onward

Timmy84 said:

^ Funky, huh?

Here's my analysis on MJ:

Best album: Dangerous

Worst album: Michael

Most overrated album: Thriller

Most underrated album: Bad

Top 5 best songs: Human Nature, I Can't Help It, You Can't Win, Jam, Ain't No Sunshine

Top 5 worst songs: Doggin' Around, You've Really Got a Hold on Me (the 1984 version ), Farewell My Summer Love, Shoo-Be-Doo-Be-Do-Da-Day, Nite Line

Best video: Ghosts

Worst video: Liberian Girl

Most creative 5 years: 1978-1983

Most lame 5 years: 1996-2001 (because he hardly put anything out between those years)

Edit: I would've said 1971-1975 in the lame years category but that's four years, not five years...lol

[Edited 12/24/12 12:33pm]

For some reason I'd expect you to like Farewell My Summer Love. I like that song.

"Most lame 5 years:1996-2001" - That doesn't count. He was being a daddy.

My MJ analysis:

Best album: Dangerous

Worst album: Michael (I'd almost forgotten about it if Timmy didn't mention it)

Most overrated album: Thriller

Most underrated album: Dangerous

Top 5 best songs: (Impossible to choose actually, but I'll try) I Can't Help It, Who Is It, She Drives Me Wild, Earth Song, Someone Put Your Hand Out

Top 5 worst songs: YANA, Black or White, You Are My Life, Hold My Hand, Burn This Disco Out

Best video: Ghosts

Worst video: Liberian Girl or Cry

Most creative 5 years: 1987-1992

Most lame 5 years: Probably anytime after 2000, but it's hard to say cause he had other issues going on in his life.

My Prince analysis:

Best album: (Again impossible to choose), Come, Old Friends For Sale

Worst album: The Truth (listened to it only once or twice, couldn't be bothered to hear it again)

Most overrated album: Sign of the Times or Purple Rain (I like them, but they are not my favourites though, yet his most famous ones, I guess)

Most underrated album: Old Friends for Sale

Top 5 best songs: (again impossible) 5 women, Damn U, Courting Time, U want Me (from the Las Vegas DVD), I hate you, We can funk. (I mostly love his live stuff though like 21 Nights album. Most of his songs sound the best when played live)

Top 5 worst songs: Adore, Kiss, Black Sweat, Life of the Party, I Wish You Heaven

Best video: The One

Worst video: Kiss

Most creative 5 years: Hard to say, I like his 90's work.

Most lame 5 years: He's never stopped working, so also impossible to say, but my least favourite albums are from 2000 and on.

[Edited 12/30/12 6:52am]

[Edited 12/30/12 6:54am]

Timmy84 said:

LiLi1992 said:

by 10 criteria

Best album
Worst album
Most underrated album
Most overrated album
Top 5 best songs
Top 5 worst songs
Best videos
Worst video
Most creative 5 years
Most lame 5 years

----------------------------------

I invite everyone to participate

Marvin Gaye

Best album: Here, My Dear

Worst album: Hello Broadway

Most underrated album: In Our Lifetime

Most overrated album: What's Going On

Top 5 best songs (for now): I'm Gonna Give You Respect, Distant Lover, You're the Man (alternate version), Just to Keep You Satisfied, Heavy Love Affair

Top 5 worst songs: Down and Under When You're in Limbo, The Onion Song, Lucky Lucky Me (the alternate "pop" version), I Won't Cry Anymore (Romantically Yours version), Savage in the Sack

Most creative 5 years (roughly): 1971-1976

Most lame 5 years (roughly though he had some great moments): 1961-1966

What. The. Fuck.

An explanation is needed, sir!