MUSICIAN (1997) APRIL 1997 * MUSICIAN The Sound of Emancipation
For me, excellence comes from the fact that God loves me. But what is excellence? You've heard about these people who will bomb a building and kill all these people in God's name. You could say that they did an excellent job at what they were trying to do, right? Now, when I look at my band, Dyson is a different kind of guitar player than Mike. She looks cool, she has that kind of punk attitude. But that's her; that's not Mike. Lisa was never an explosive keyboard player, but she was a master of color in her harmonies; I could sing off of what she had with straight soul. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
I agree about everything,Lisa is amazing,always was. Whole The Revolution was amazing and Wendy was the weakest link but still she was a good musician and a good influence and inspiration on Prince.she just was not a gifted soloist and she never become one,so yes all the rhythm work she did was ok.but as soon as she needed to solo,she was lost. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
I think I get why he broke them up...likely many reasons. I think he definitely out grew them in terms of talent, capability...you can see how he blew up with better musicians after. His shows were so much more musical. Besides this, we all know he had that itch to change all the time. He proved that he never stayed with the same band for very long although the NPG lasted a long while and some players, Rhonda, Morris stayed longer then most.
However, I believe 'Management' had something to do with dropped the Rev. I am just guessing that Wendy and Lisa (prob the former more) became too much of a hassle to bother with and he decided..f it, i'm starting over. Sure, their threat of leaving prob also got him going...but I really believe...he was not the kind to put up with BS. As is with human nature, the ladies prob felt like 'partners' and not employees and Prince did not like it.
| |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Let me add, I recall Levi saying on a Michael Dean podcat that Prince had become wary of women in the band. It seemed to imply that BOnnie was trouble...talking back to Prince, etc. Despite that, he took on Rosie but my point is...he surely was tuned to women and prob didn't like W&L getting so damn close when he didn't want it.
The Sussanah break up msut have hae also influenced. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Prince basically stated in the 1990 interview that is was more of an emotional friend/employer-employee thing
which connects to him dedicating In This Bed I Scream to them in 1997
But the emotional friend/employer-employee thing was connected to Vanity, the Time as well . But after 1986 the colorful innovation of Purple Music dried up. It tappered out through the 87-88/89 period, of course because it's all fresh out of there. But after that 1981-1986/7 period it was not the same | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Basically the revolution were better at songwriting than later prince bands Sure, the later bands were better in many ways But his 80s bands in some ways, maybe cos they weren't virtuoso, lent to tighter songs | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
I've heard her live and she sounded fine to me. I take your point that she was far from the best guitarist back available to him in 1983 and he had flashier guitarists both before and after her - and better straight up funk rhythm guitarists as well. Miko is great, I ain't complaining about Miko. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Prince made the right decision with all of his bands when he was ready to move on I don't understand these kinds of conversations. It's crystal clear, especially now, that he did what was right for himself and where he wanted to go musically. I appreciate it all.
Welcome to "the org", Mumio…they can have you, but I'll have your love in the end | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Andys guitar was always unplugged so i don't count her just because she had guitar in her hands but you are right Wendy is Jimi Hendrix compared to Andy | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
This idea that prince didnt always pick the technically best players, sometimes personality trumps technique. The way you are all arguing it, everyone should sing like Christina Aguilera. And prince also picked some musicians/collaborators just cos he wanted to have them or was having them in bed. Or cos they were school friends. Or they had the right look. Etc etc etc As Billy said, this is a business and you guys ain't too far gone to see that yet! | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Did you wintess her solo on Purple Rain on the Grammy Tribute show? It was the highlight of the show! I've seen her live a few times now and she can solo her ass off. You're not a fan of Wendy I get it, but stop disrespecting her talent that she clearly has.
| |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Neither wendy or lisa were great virtuoso musicians But being a good musician or artist is also about WHAT and HOW you Express as much as the facility with which you can do it | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Listen what you say is not true.I like her influence on Prince but i'm just objective about her playing. The best guitar solo she ever did was on a studio version of her own song Waterfalls. Her solo on that version of Purple Rain is just ok. I highly doubt that you heard Wendy "solo her ass off" . if you said i heard Wendy play mean rhythm guitar lick that i could believe. I don't know why people get upset when i say that Wendy is an ok funk rhythm guitar player but a lousy soloist. Like some of you said Wendy was there to add some other elements , and she did it well, but she just can't solo. She can learn to play a certain solo,but you can see when she bends,use vibrato,or try to play some faster licks she can't do it. Did you notice she always skipps the outro solo on Lets Go Crazy. What do you think why? Also what she played on When Doves Cry live is a simplified version of the guitar parts for that song. Intro was simplified and solo as well and she still couldn't play it. I am sorry because some of you are starry eyed when it comes to her. You know i wish it was the opposite,cause she had a much bigger stage presence than Levi Seacer for example,but Lev would smoke her on anything guitar related. And i do agree being better at instrument don't mean you are a better musician,but it helps in the execution of what you need to bring to in a live setting.Wendys take on Prince solos was like it was played by those 90s pop punk bands like Blink 1982 or something like that. And i'm not saying all this just to attack Wendy,i want to say that the weakest link in The Revolution was not Bobby,it was Wendy. And all these years on the org i keep seeing posts how Wendy was great but Bobby was messing up and thats not true at all. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Well u are right but i place Lisa a few classes above Wendy as a musican . | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Wow! Now my ears aren't good enough? I know solos and YES she did. [Edited 11/4/20 9:37am] | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
ok,can you please give me examples of Wendy playing a good guitar solo | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Ultimately he did what he did, we'll never know if it actually would have been better (or worse!) another way because it never happened. I don't get these conversations either. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
It was indeed time for them to go for multiple reasons. Between, him needing a new direction to go in musically and his palette was expanding in ways that band simply couldn't execute. Just listen to stuff like Housequake, Beautiful Night, Dorothy Parker, etc. The Revolution couldn't do anything with that material. It's not in their wheelhouse. Them long, boring extended "jams" for lack of a better phrase was ok at best but as Prince himself said, that was due to them being super rehearsed and repetitive instead of spontaneous and versatile. Sheila E. is miles ahead a better drummer than Bobby Z. Miko vs. Wendy Melvoin on rhythm guitar? Forget it.
Him changing bands became commonplace and i welcome it. It's also how you get other/new ideas. Keeps you from being stagnant. Folks harp on him getting rid of them but it's like damn, you want him to stay the same forever? Wanna hear the Revolution? listen to some bootlegs haha. I would say albums but they're barely playing as a whole unit on the albums that bore their names
Also if folks can sit here and critique him going JW later on or adding rap into his music, then we can certainly critique his decision for disbanding this group. Yall love to pick and choose what to cry about when it don't serve you | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Yall have got to kill this bullshit narrative. They edited/added to/remixed a lot of stuff during that time (majority of which went right into the vault) but they have nothing to do with 14/16 songs on the album. Outside of strange relationship and beautiful night, they're nowhere to be found. My God yall and this constant diminishing his talent to needing/requiring help from them 2 is ridiculous and tiresome. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Nostalgia and familiarity are the primary reasons folks love this group. i get it. It most certainly ain't skill. They had the advantage of being his backing band during his commercial peak and they were in the movie..... | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Cat and Sheila didn't get along but Prince and Cat's chemistry was FAR from forced. I know you have this Revolution preference but come on now. That's a reach. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
It was definitely stiff. Especially the PR Tour. He hated it cause they were pretty much the same every night; especially as far as the setlist and no aftershows. Too many gimmicks as well. The best part of that tour is the soundchecks. The rest is boring. What friendship did you feel? lol i'm curious | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
On the nude tour, there was a drum machine. It was malfunctioning during a nude tour rehearsal causing Prince to stop rehearsal. Also, he didn't need to rely on them cause he had a Powerful drummer in the form of Michael Bland | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Also a weak excuse cause, even when prince started to incorporate popular musical styles of the time (rap/hip-hop, etc) it still didn't sound like anything on the radio. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
THIS...ALL OF THIS | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Derek880 said:
Nah...and it's time that people who have been a part of Prince's musical journey from the beginning, start to debunk this myth. They didn't help him be his "best self" artistically. That's always been either the most insulting comment made about his legacy, or the most uninsightful. Prince was a phenom before they ever played with him, and many years after. The biggest part of the problem is that for some odd reason, the Revolution voices are the only ones that are allowed to speak. They weren't even around as long as most of the people he played with. Wendy was only around 3-4 years. Lisa - 6 years. Now look at some of his other band members...Rhonda Smith was around even longer than Wendy and Lisa, about 6 years or so, give or take. Sheila E.- spans about a 10 year period off and on. Miko - 7 years, Levi - about 6 years or so. Morris Hayes - off and on for about 20 years (!). Tommy Barbarella was even around about 6-8 years. Prince connected and grew from LOTS of people artistically. In the span of his career, The Revolution years really aren't as big a time span as people think. That 1999 period, BEFORE all the Revolution hype, was the turning point in my opinion, and it didn't require either Wendy or Lisa. Just Prince, in a room, letting his creativity loose. Let's give the man his due and stop acting as if he didn't begin to know music until he put these two women in his band. It's insulting... no lies or inaccuracies were detected in this comment | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
tab32792 said:
On the nude tour, there was a drum machine. It was malfunctioning during a nude tour rehearsal causing Prince to stop rehearsal. Also, he didn't need to rely on them cause he had a Powerful drummer in the form of Michael Bland | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
RJOrion said: Derek880 said:
Nah...and it's time that people who have been a part of Prince's musical journey from the beginning, start to debunk this myth. They didn't help him be his "best self" artistically. That's always been either the most insulting comment made about his legacy, or the most uninsightful. Prince was a phenom before they ever played with him, and many years after. The biggest part of the problem is that for some odd reason, the Revolution voices are the only ones that are allowed to speak. They weren't even around as long as most of the people he played with. Wendy was only around 3-4 years. Lisa - 6 years. Now look at some of his other band members...Rhonda Smith was around even longer than Wendy and Lisa, about 6 years or so, give or take. Sheila E.- spans about a 10 year period off and on. Miko - 7 years, Levi - about 6 years or so. Morris Hayes - off and on for about 20 years (!). Tommy Barbarella was even around about 6-8 years. Prince connected and grew from LOTS of people artistically. In the span of his career, The Revolution years really aren't as big a time span as people think. That 1999 period, BEFORE all the Revolution hype, was the turning point in my opinion, and it didn't require either Wendy or Lisa. Just Prince, in a room, letting his creativity loose. Let's give the man his due and stop acting as if he didn't begin to know music until he put these two women in his band. It's insulting... no lies or inaccuracies were detected in this comment There's at least one. Rhonda was around a lot longer than 6 years. She started in 1996. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
LoveGalore said: RJOrion said: no lies or inaccuracies were detected in this comment There's at least one. Rhonda was around a lot longer than 6 years. She started in 1996. I just think this is an overresponse Prince and W&L had a collaboration. They had direct effect on the sound de of his output at the time. Saying that isn’t making a statement either way about his singular talent. It’s just the truth. I don’t think everytime someone says something truthful and positive about the Revolution era that the naysayers need to run in and correct the record. Ya’ll have a an agenda that is extracurricular to these conversations. Don’t care about. These are things that happened, there’s nothing you can say that can change it. No one needs to apologize for enjoying The Revolution era, and having an understanding that there was a lot of collaboration involved. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
- I'm giving up on you, you know. Do you play the guitar yourself ? I don't like to judge someone for something I'm not capable of doing myself. Isn't it clear that it is not always about the skills you need to have, but about the whole package you need to deliver (as an artist)? At least that's what I believe in. Michael jackson for instance couldn't play one instrument, but was a songwriter nevertheless. Anyway, I'm giving up on the Wendy this Wendy that badness. Peace though. -
"The whole problem with the world is that fools and fanatics are always so certain of themselves. And wiser people so full of doubts" (Bertrand Russell 1872-1972) | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |