independent and unofficial
Prince fan community
Welcome! Sign up or enter username and password to remember me
Forum jump
Forums > Music: Non-Prince > Most underrated album of all time
« Previous topic  Next topic »
Page 3 of 4 <1234>
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
Reply #60 posted 09/10/09 9:10pm

Moonbeam

avatar

xlr8r said:

Imago said:

Scary Monsters - David Bowie.



The last classic David Bowie album, Scary Monsters is also his best. Throughout the 70s, Bowie was a pioneer of unthinkable talent and foresight. Each of his 70s albums was an adventure that greatly influenced the music that followed. 1980's Scary Monsters offers a capstone to Bowie's epic achievements of the 70s.

Following the Berlin trilogy (Low, Heroes and Lodger), David Bowie seemed to be able to do no wrong, but it was hard to think he could top himself. Scary Monsters takes the experiments of that period and extends them to a more human, palatable aesthetic. From the roaring title track to the quirky genius of "Ashes to Ashes," from the paranoid, ultra-hip funk workout of "Fashion" to the truly gut-wrenching "Teenage Wildlife" and "Because You're Young," Scary Monsters is both instantly catchy and memorable.

This is Bowie searching the depths of his soul to exorcise his demons. The angry opener "It's No Game" with its comical confrontation with a Japanese woman sets the stage for an emotionally charged listen. The dejected acceptance of "Up the Hill Backwards" reveals a lot of Bowie's thoughts on the world circa 1980: "A series of shocks - sneakers fall apart, Earth keeps on rolling - witnesses falling." "Ashes to Ashes" reflects on decades of drug use and its effects with a new take on "Space Oddity"'s Major Tom. 33 must have been an awkward age for Bowie, as he fiercely demands respect in the guttural "Teenage Wildlife" while dejectedly accepting his loss of youth and its ability to heal on "Because You're Young."

This is Bowie's most personal album. He invents no fictitious characters here to deter the attention from himself. This is perhaps the most pure glimpse into the turbulence of a man stretched to the limits of his imagination, ability and health for over a decade. No wonder he took a 3-year sabbatical from the music industry afterward. This album sounds like the final words of a man dying before his time. In a sense, he did die after this album, languishing in his own legend and status for over a decade. Scary Monsters is David Bowie's parting message, a chronicle of his own crucifixion.


This was his Lovesexy (the last of his classic era) imo. Or was Lovesexy Prince's Scary Momnsters I mean lol...I see them both in the same light


Maybe that's why Imago thinks both are overrated. Check the other thread and give him a smackdown. lol
Feel free to join in the Prince Album Poll 2018! Let'a celebrate his legacy by counting down the most beloved Prince albums, as decided by you!
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #61 posted 09/10/09 9:11pm

Moonbeam

avatar

INSATIABLE said:

Moonbeam said:



I've been trying to find this for a few months now. sad

CD or LP?

smile


CD. I need a new turntable. sad
Feel free to join in the Prince Album Poll 2018! Let'a celebrate his legacy by counting down the most beloved Prince albums, as decided by you!
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #62 posted 09/10/09 9:23pm

Imago

Moonbeam said:

xlr8r said:



This was his Lovesexy (the last of his classic era) imo. Or was Lovesexy Prince's Scary Momnsters I mean lol...I see them both in the same light


Maybe that's why Imago thinks both are overrated. Check the other thread and give him a smackdown. lol

falloff

brick
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #63 posted 09/10/09 9:51pm

whatsgoingon

avatar

All those Jackson albums from the late 70s to the early 80s:
The Jacksons, Going Places, Destiny and Triumph. There is too much emphasise on Michael's solo work and not enough attention paid to albums like Destiny and Triumph. Give me those albums any day over Bad, Dangerous or History.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #64 posted 09/11/09 3:18am

mancabdriver

How the hell is 'off the wall' underrated?

It sold nearly 20 million copies and has made appearances on numerous 'best albums' lists.

????
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #65 posted 09/11/09 3:47am

NONSENSE

Al Green -- Get's Next to You, Let's Stay Together, & Call Me

anything by Ohio Players, Cameo, Rick James, & Parliament/Funkadelic... I say this because these individuals never got the respect due, never.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #66 posted 09/11/09 5:25am

motownlover

here my dear : marvin gaye
on the corner : miles davis
bitches brew : miles davis
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #67 posted 09/11/09 6:11am

WetDream

avatar

ThirdandFinal said:

The Rainbow Children

Some of the best music ever made. Unheard of by the general public, and rejected by fans who either wouldn't get past "that voice", or wouldn't spend a minute to understand the depth of the lyrics


Dig up
This Post is produced, arranged, composed and performed by WetDream
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #68 posted 09/11/09 6:17am

WetDream

avatar

mancabdriver said:

How the hell is 'off the wall' underrated?

It sold nearly 20 million copies and has made appearances on numerous 'best albums' lists.

????


Good point.

I think its underrated compared to his other work and that's whats being said i think. Still, not suited for "most underrated" for the reasons you stated.
This Post is produced, arranged, composed and performed by WetDream
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #69 posted 09/11/09 6:43am

unique

avatar



anyone who knows this album will know what i mean. it had the worlds first full video album to accompany it, with videos for all the tracks on the album



the first album by mick jones from the clash's (who later produced pete docherty in the libtertines) new band big audio dynamite. a mash of hip hop and rock and reggae and movie samples before anyone else mixed these things together. samples that complimented the music instead of creating the music. mariah carey released an album in tribute to one of the singles. the later albums weren't half as great, but they were much better live than in the studio



adam ants second album, and the first with the new ants as the original band were persuaded by malcolm mclaren to form bow wow wow with annabella lwin. it was a hit album in the uk at the time, but quickly forgotten about in later years, particularly after the huge success of the follow up album, prince charming, which was written about a short dude from minneapolis
[Edited 9/11/09 6:44am]
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #70 posted 09/11/09 7:14am

pricy503

unique said:



anyone who knows this album will know what i mean. it had the worlds first full video album to accompany it, with videos for all the tracks on the album



the first album by mick jones from the clash's (who later produced pete docherty in the libtertines) new band big audio dynamite. a mash of hip hop and rock and reggae and movie samples before anyone else mixed these things together. samples that complimented the music instead of creating the music. mariah carey released an album in tribute to one of the singles. the later albums weren't half as great, but they were much better live than in the studio



adam ants second album, and the first with the new ants as the original band were persuaded by malcolm mclaren to form bow wow wow with annabella lwin. it was a hit album in the uk at the time, but quickly forgotten about in later years, particularly after the huge success of the follow up album, prince charming, which was written about a short dude from minneapolis
[Edited 9/11/09 6:44am]
B.A.D. is my shit. I thought i was the only one!
nice guy.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #71 posted 09/11/09 7:51am

unique

avatar

pricy503 said:

unique said:



anyone who knows this album will know what i mean. it had the worlds first full video album to accompany it, with videos for all the tracks on the album



the first album by mick jones from the clash's (who later produced pete docherty in the libtertines) new band big audio dynamite. a mash of hip hop and rock and reggae and movie samples before anyone else mixed these things together. samples that complimented the music instead of creating the music. mariah carey released an album in tribute to one of the singles. the later albums weren't half as great, but they were much better live than in the studio

adam ants second album, and the first with the new ants as the original band were persuaded by malcolm mclaren to form bow wow wow with annabella lwin. it was a hit album in the uk at the time, but quickly forgotten about in later years, particularly after the huge success of the follow up album, prince charming, which was written about a short dude from minneapolis
[Edited 9/11/09 6:44am]
B.A.D. is my shit. I thought i was the only one!


BAD were the first live band i ever saw during the first tour. schoolly d was the opening act, and world party were the second support. brilliant gig. i later saw them a few other times each time they came to my town. one gig had adamski as support and i thought he would do well if he had a vocalist, and a few months later he had a huge hit with killer when seal joined him on vocals. another time they had goodbye mr mackenzie support, with shirley manson on keyboards before she left to form garbage. BAD used to do a great live cover of 1999 at the gigs. the later albums got worse and worse as mick tried to get too many different styles of music on board, and try a bit of rock/rave. it worked well live, but on record it just sounded lame compared to what other people were doing. he had the right idea, he just didn't pull it off very well. malcolm mclaren copied the idea to some extent with buffalo gals and his later albums mixing house music and operah or waltz (i met malcolm the other week actually, saw him talk for nearly 90 mins and then he was hanging at the bar afterwards, right next to me and my mate)

i have a ton of live BAD bootlegs, bunch of outtakes and unreleased stuff too. the outtakes are pretty awful though. if you think about the crap they did release, imagine the stuff that wasn't good enough. i couldn't believe that rush was a hit single either, and levi used it as an advert. it was utter shite. apparently the bottom line was used as a theme tune to american football (maybe only in the uk where it was on at about 2am before cable tv was here, and no-one watched it)

mick has a new group called carbon silicon, with one of the guys from generation x (billy idols old band)/sigue sigue sputnik(frankie goes to hollywood labelmates on ZTT)/etc

BAD had a promo only 12" called lovesensi that had the bass player on the front mimicking the lovesexy cover. it was just 2 instrumental acid house type tracks they made when mick was really ill in hospital. obviously they were prince fans

hard fi were influenced by BAD and cover e=mc2 at gigs. mick jones guested with them once or twice to play that and should i stay or should i go

and dan donovan was patsy kensits first husband (before she married jim kerr from simple minds, then liam gallacher from oasis, then dj jeremy healey). his dad was terance donovan, the famous photographer who did the classic 60s shots as parodied by austin powers (copying scenes from the movie blow up)
[Edited 9/11/09 7:56am]
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #72 posted 09/11/09 10:29am

mancabdriver

WetDream said:

mancabdriver said:

How the hell is 'off the wall' underrated?

It sold nearly 20 million copies and has made appearances on numerous 'best albums' lists.

????


Good point.

I think its underrated compared to his other work and that's whats being said i think. Still, not suited for "most underrated" for the reasons you stated.



I simply just don't agree - people always put OTW ahead of all MJ's releases (apart from Thriller) when they rank his albums. DSTYGE and Rock with you are played constantly on radio, music channels and clubs after all these years.

It's a joke that ANY of his records are in a 'most underrated album thread'!
[Edited 9/11/09 10:31am]
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #73 posted 09/11/09 10:46am

unique

avatar

mancabdriver said:

WetDream said:



Good point.

I think its underrated compared to his other work and that's whats being said i think. Still, not suited for "most underrated" for the reasons you stated.



I simply just don't agree - people always put OTW ahead of all MJ's releases (apart from Thriller) when they rank his albums. DSTYGE and Rock with you are played constantly on radio, music channels and clubs after all these years.

It's a joke that ANY of his records are in a 'most underrated album thread'!
[Edited 9/11/09 10:31am]


exactly. MOST of them should be in a most overrated thread

in saying that, i don't think most of the people who have posted on this thread have quite understood the concept of underrated. in keeping with the spirit of the other responses i listed three albums with critical acclaim, thus aren't underrated. again, sales has no bearing on whether an album is overrated or underrated, it's the way that critics and consumers rate the album that relates to the nature of being underrated or overrated. a truly underrated album is one with minor critical or consumer acclaim, thus mediocre reviews and poor sales on a record that's later regarded a classic

so in keeping with the true spirit of the thread, perhaps this is THE most underrated album of all time. it had shit reviews, as reviewers and fans alike didn't understand the album which was completely different to the album it preceeded, and initial sales were awful, particularly compared to it's predecessor. it wasn't until years later that critics and fans realised it was years ahead of it's time, and it was regarded as a particularly fine example of it's genre, with a relatively recent deluxe anniversary edition being released

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #74 posted 09/11/09 11:39am

xlr8r

avatar

unique said:

mancabdriver said:




I simply just don't agree - people always put OTW ahead of all MJ's releases (apart from Thriller) when they rank his albums. DSTYGE and Rock with you are played constantly on radio, music channels and clubs after all these years.

It's a joke that ANY of his records are in a 'most underrated album thread'!
[Edited 9/11/09 10:31am]


exactly. MOST of them should be in a most overrated thread

in saying that, i don't think most of the people who have posted on this thread have quite understood the concept of underrated. in keeping with the spirit of the other responses i listed three albums with critical acclaim, thus aren't underrated. again, sales has no bearing on whether an album is overrated or underrated, it's the way that critics and consumers rate the album that relates to the nature of being underrated or overrated. a truly underrated album is one with minor critical or consumer acclaim, thus mediocre reviews and poor sales on a record that's later regarded a classic

so in keeping with the true spirit of the thread, perhaps this is THE most underrated album of all time. it had shit reviews, as reviewers and fans alike didn't understand the album which was completely different to the album it preceeded, and initial sales were awful, particularly compared to it's predecessor. it wasn't until years later that critics and fans realised it was years ahead of it's time, and it was regarded as a particularly fine example of it's genre, with a relatively recent deluxe anniversary edition being released



.


Wrong

Pauls Bouitique has been heralded as one of their best releases and is considered a sampling masterpeice. It even has a deluxe version in honor of it.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #75 posted 09/11/09 11:54am

Graycap23

Individuality (Can I Be Me?)
Rachelle Ferrell
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #76 posted 09/11/09 12:16pm

unique

avatar

xlr8r said:

unique said:



exactly. MOST of them should be in a most overrated thread

in saying that, i don't think most of the people who have posted on this thread have quite understood the concept of underrated. in keeping with the spirit of the other responses i listed three albums with critical acclaim, thus aren't underrated. again, sales has no bearing on whether an album is overrated or underrated, it's the way that critics and consumers rate the album that relates to the nature of being underrated or overrated. a truly underrated album is one with minor critical or consumer acclaim, thus mediocre reviews and poor sales on a record that's later regarded a classic

so in keeping with the true spirit of the thread, perhaps this is THE most underrated album of all time. it had shit reviews, as reviewers and fans alike didn't understand the album which was completely different to the album it preceeded, and initial sales were awful, particularly compared to it's predecessor. it wasn't until years later that critics and fans realised it was years ahead of it's time, and it was regarded as a particularly fine example of it's genre, with a relatively recent deluxe anniversary edition being released


.


Wrong

Pauls Bouitique has been heralded as one of their best releases and is considered a sampling masterpeice. It even has a deluxe version in honor of it.


wtf do you mean wrong? did you bother to read wtf i said?
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #77 posted 09/11/09 12:40pm

xlr8r

avatar

unique said:

xlr8r said:



Wrong

Pauls Bouitique has been heralded as one of their best releases and is considered a sampling masterpeice. It even has a deluxe version in honor of it.


wtf do you mean wrong? did you bother to read wtf i said?


Thats why its not underrated
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #78 posted 09/11/09 1:12pm

unique

avatar

xlr8r said:

unique said:



wtf do you mean wrong? did you bother to read wtf i said?


Thats why its not underrated


what is why it's not underrated?
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #79 posted 09/11/09 1:36pm

XNY

avatar

Too many to mention, but my favorite groups who still get little or no attention here in the states are The Smiths(even though they're obviously not a band anymore) and Terence Trent D'Arby. They both had their moment in the sun, but still deserve a lot more respect and airplay than they are given.
"Great dancers are not great because of their technique, they are great because of their passion" -- Martha Graham
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #80 posted 09/11/09 2:13pm

unique

avatar

XNY said:

Too many to mention, but my favorite groups who still get little or no attention here in the states are The Smiths(even though they're obviously not a band anymore) and Terence Trent D'Arby. They both had their moment in the sun, but still deserve a lot more respect and airplay than they are given.


the smiths had shitloads of critical acclaim, to the point that they could be discussed as one of the most over rated bands of all time

TTD also had a ton of acclaim and sales for his first album, he just couldn't keep up with the success afterwards. i don't know his more recent stuff enough, but he generally gets a fair amount of critical acclaim for it, even though he doesn't sell much
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #81 posted 09/11/09 4:11pm

violetblues

I think every album by "Big Audio Dynamite" have been criminally underrated.




[Edited 9/11/09 16:12pm]
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #82 posted 09/11/09 4:20pm

nurseV

John Legend's Get Lifted especially So High And Refuge-just a terrific album.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #83 posted 09/11/09 4:24pm

Farfunknugin

avatar

John legend? What a bore fest. Now there's a guy that brings nothing fresh to the table.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #84 posted 09/11/09 4:24pm

PPKING

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #85 posted 09/11/09 4:31pm

nurseV

Farfunknugin said:

John legend? What a bore fest. Now there's a guy that brings nothing fresh to the table.



eek You for real? lol That man has talent and So High is a lyrically beautiful song eek
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #86 posted 09/11/09 4:58pm

Riverpoet31



World Party - Goodbye Jumbo



Grant McLennan - Horsebreaker Star



Urban Dance Squad - Life and Perspectives of a genuine crossover
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #87 posted 09/11/09 5:51pm

mynameisnotsus
an















flipped off flipped off flipped off flipped off flipped off flipped off flipped off flipped off flipped off flipped off flipped off flipped off flipped off flipped off flipped off
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #88 posted 09/11/09 6:23pm

PurpleDiamond2
009






[Edited 9/11/09 18:28pm]
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #89 posted 09/11/09 6:46pm

TonyVanDam

avatar



biggrin
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Page 3 of 4 <1234>
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
« Previous topic  Next topic »
Forums > Music: Non-Prince > Most underrated album of all time