I know their music isn't exactly the same, with Lady Gaga being more electro/dance pop and Katy Perry being more pop/rock but they both seems to be doing quite well for themselves on their debut albums. I am actually quite shocked they are still releasing singles and videos for Katy Pery. I really thought she'd be a one hit wonder. Who do you see having more longevity in their careers? I think i'm gonna say Lady Gaga because I do think she has talent although she isn't very originally. She's basically Madonna, Grace Jones and Dale Bozzio all rolled into one!

- I'm not going to say Lady Gaga is a bit of ___, ___, & ____ but in this battle she wins

Katy Perry sux

Lady Gaga by far

InsatiableCream said:

i agree. i just think it will be interesting to see how well her 2nd album does. if she doesn't have another solid hit i could see her career taking a turn for the worst. lady gaga i think will be around for a while and i can see her evolving with her sound and style.

GaGa

she'll be around in a few years still whereas Shitty Perry will be forgotten

dancerella said:

yeah, since her first album is sooo succesful, for her the second album is really very important. Not only does she need equal or bigger hits... she has to beat The Fame in terms of quality as well.

Surely she's working on something new right now, I read she worked with quite a few new producers, but can't remember which ones.

I don't get either of them's success

Oh definitely Gaga--she writes her own stuff, right? But that said, I'll take "Hot N Cold" and "Kissed a Girl" over "Just Dance" and "Poker Face" any day.

KP....reminds me of a cuter Anne H.

Judging Gaga's piano performance of Poker Face that someone posted in another thread vs. Perry's performance of I Kissed A Girl on some random awards show (Grammys, maybe?).

The clearcut winner is Gaga.

K.P. Lady Caca is full of copy cat shit.

Some is better than none, so Gaga takes it.

In reality they are both cashing in on something already done, i find them both to be "fads" that will burn out, and the thing will be who burns out faster, i would say Katy Perry will burn out quick since her hit was nothing more than a "catch phrase" and as we all know "catch phrases" as your first hit are the ticket to the end.

I think Lady Gaga will probably go the Madonna way in terms of reinventing her image whenever she gets bored with her look. She has a good voice though.

As for Katy Perry, her voice is actually quite good, but it all depends how what stuff she brings to table later on. I didn't really like I kissed a Girl, but her voice is good.

Lady Gaga- by far.

Katy Perry is just a disaster.

suga10 said:

Katy Perry's voice is absolutely terrible. Have you seen any of her live performances? Atrocious.

VoicesCarry said:

No I haven't seen Katy live, I was basing it off her studio recordings.

VoicesCarry said:

Exactly. Her studio voice is absolutely atrocious to me too. The way she turns the word "it" into 3 absolutely cringe-worthy syllables was enough for me.

They are equally untalented.

PANDURITO said:

Ya got that right!

Gaga

PANDURITO said:

I do..due to the serious lack of white females right now in pop music...

who cares? I would fuck them both; that's what counts.

None of them is a conventional beuty but GaGa's got more style.

You can't see what Ga Ga [ I refrain from using the word Lady] looks like because she is hiding under that bloody awful wig. She looks so fake. Remove the wig girl! I like Katy she makes good videos and I like her voice, it's unique. She is stunning, naturally beautiful. Hot n Cold , Thinking of you and Waking up in Vegas are good songs.

lipstick said:

Well, you do GaGa a favor in calling her so, because that's what everyone calls her.
As far as I know she only has extensions, no wig.

And yes, her eyes are covered either by make-up or glasses, most of the time.

But on the current RS-Cover you can see her, and she looks funny. Not pretty I think.

Neither!

gwen stefani+nina hagen+madonna+ aladdin sane's bowie= lady gaga..

baroque said:

you did not get good grades in maths, did you?