One of the greatest albums ever!!!!! Every song is great... Which makes it a great survivor thread...and my first



1. Queen Is Dead
2. Frankly, Mr. Shankly
3. I Know It's Over
4. Never Had No One
5. Cemetry Gates
6. Bigmouth Strikes Again
7. Boy With the Thorn in His Side
8. Vicar in a Tutu
9. There Is a Light That Never Goes Out
10. Some Girls Are Bigger Than Others


Round One closes May 20th, 9:45 EST
[Edited 5/15/05 19:12pm]
[Edited 5/20/05 20:16pm]

Cemetry Gates

Frankly Mr. Shankly

All I know is that "There is a Light that Never Goes Out" better win.

Frankly Mr Shankly, all others are genius, this ones gonna hurt.

GangstaFam said:

If any other song wins, it would qualify as one of the biggest upsets since truman beat dewey.

aww, shit...I can't vote for any of 'em...this is the best survivor thread yet...

Frankly, Mr. Shankly to go.

I'm actually pulling for I Know It's Over.

This one is harder than the Prince survivor rounds.
I love all Smiths songs, but I'll play...

Vote,

Vicar In A Tutu.

Cool this one ill play
its probably the best albume the smiths did
and everything is a classic except
vicar in a tutu
great idea but it really doesnt go anywhere

Vicar In A Tutu.


Obviously. I mean, it's a country mile behind the rest of the album.

that's so cruel!

TheFrog said:

What is...?

Slash said:

i don't know. i'm losing it. just the thought of voting any of these tunes off.

TheFrog said:

Much as I adore the Smiths, every album has it's duff track(s).


(Exhibit A: Death At One's Elbow.)


SO, damnit, put in your vote for Vicar In A Bleedin' Tutu.


Please
[Edited 5/16/05 3:29am]

Slash said:

i like that tune.

i guess you're right though.

so yeah - reluctantly, Vicar in a Tutu.

TheFrog said:

Any song could only ever be "reluctantly" voted off TQID, of course.


Although I am still pissed off that Vicar..made it onto the live album Rank, at the expense of much better Queen Is Dead tracks.. (There is A Light..for example) Stoopid Manc twats..

Frankly Mr. Shankly must go

Nightcrawler said:

...through to the next round. Agreed

seriously, I don't know how I'm gonna be able to keep voting. Every song on this CD is SO DAMN GOOD!

but, here goes....

Vicar In A Tutu

Slash said:

Vicar in a Tutu

I know some haven't voted yet.



Rock the vote

Vicar in a Tutu

WAIT UP!!



Can't we just cut to the chase and crown There Is A Light That Never Goes Out as the overall winner of this game right now?


I mean, it is SO gonna win.



...it is gonna win, right? I mean, you Org people wouldn't let something else win, would you? You wouldn't do that to me, surely...?

Slash said:

"on the shop floor, there's a calendar, as obvious as snow....as if you didn't know...."

I haven't heard this album in, like 2 years, but I do hope that "The Boy With The Thorn in His Side" wins.


That's all I'm gonna post on this thread.

Round 1 Voting ends tonight.

lilgish said:

Cheerio, Vicar In A Tutu! nice knowin' ya!