Planet Earth assessment: Rank the songs and rate them

As a compliment to the Planet Earth survivor threads, which reward the songs that are the least offensive to people, I thought I would run a poll to see which ones incite the most love. There are some songs on there that are likely to divide the fanbase and thus suffer in a survivor where they may thrive in a poll of this type. So, without further ado, rank the songs on Planet Earth and assign each a rating from 0 to 10. I'll keep tabs.

Here is my list.

1. Lion of Judah- 10
2. Planet Earth- 10
3. The 1 U Wanna C- 10
4. Somewhere Here on Earth- 10
5. Resolution- 8
6. All the Midnights in the World- 7
7. Chelsea Rodgers- 7
8. Mr. Goodnight- 4
9. Guitar- 4
10. Future Baby Mama- 2

"I'm a lover, not a haitcher"- Pandurito

What a vile recycled album. I've been a fan since Purple Rain, but it's getting tough to hang on now.

1. Mr. Goodnight- 8
2. Chelsea Rodgers- 6
3. The 1 U Wanna C- 5
4. Somewhere Here on Earth- 3
5. Planet Earth- 3
6. All the Midnights in the World- 3
7. Future Baby Mama- 2
8. Resolution- 1
9. Guitar- 1
10. Lion of Judah- 1

1. Somewhere Here On Earth - 10
2. Future Baby Mama - 9
3. Mr Goodnight - 8
4. Chelsea Rodgers - 8
5. Planet Earth - 7
6. The One U Wanna C - 7
7. Lion Of Judah - 7
8. Guitar - 5
9. All The Midnights In The World - 2
10. Resolution - 0

01. The 1 U Wanna C - 8
02. Somewhere Here on Earth - 7
03. Resolution - 7
04. Future Baby Mama - 7 (love the music, too bad about the lyrics)
05. Chelsea Rodgers - 6
06. Guitar - 5
07. Planet Earth - 3 (we've heard this many times before, yawn)
08. All the Midnights in the World - 3
09. Lion of Judah - 1 (i can't get with this, vocals & lyrics mainly)
10. Mr. Goodnight - 1

Here's how it looks so far:

By average rank:

1. Somewhere Here on Earth- 2.75
2. The 1 U Wanna C- 3.25
3. Chelsea Rodgers- 4.5
4. Planet Earth- 4.75
5. Mr. Goodnight- 5.5
6. Future Baby Mama- 5.75
7. Resolution- 6.5
8. Lion of Judah- 6.75
9. All the Midnights in the World- 7.25
10. Guitar- 8.0

By average rating:

1. Somewhere Here on Earth- 7.5
1. The 1 U Wanna C- 7.5
3. Chelsea Rodgers- 6.75
4. Planet Earth- 5.75
5. Mr. Goodnight- 5.25
6. Future Baby Mama- 5.0
7. Lion of Judah- 4.75
8. Resolution- 4.0
9. All the Midnights in the World- 3.75
9. Guitar- 3.75

"I'm a lover, not a haitcher"- Pandurito

1. Future Baby Mama - 8,5
2. Chelsea Rodgers - 8
3. Somewhere here on Earth - 7,5
4. Mr. Goodnight - 6,5
5. Guitar - 6,5
6. Planet Earth - 6
7. All the midnights in the world - 5,5
8. Lion on Judah - 4
9. The one U wanna C - 2
10. Resolution - 1,5

Vote, vote, vote!

"I'm a lover, not a haitcher"- Pandurito

1 Lion of Judah 10
2 Chelsea Rodgers 10
3 Resolution 10
4 Somewhere here on Earth 10
5 The 1 U wanna C 9
6 Planet Earth 9
7 Guitar 9
8 Future Baby Mama 7
9 All the Midnights 7
10 Mr Goodnight 5

1.The one U Wanna C-10
2.Chelsea Rodgers-10
3.Future Baby Mama-10
4.Resolution-9
5.Lion Of Judah-9
6 Somewhere Here On Earth-9
7.All The Midnights In The World-8
8.Mr. Goodnight-7
9.Planet Earth-7
10.Guitar-6

"Guitar" is being unfairly slammed! It's actually quite a crunchy groovy melodic song. And listening to it with the previous download version is cool.

__________________________
Ze belong ere in Mozambique...

http://www.crashthesuperb...video/4955
http://www.vimeo.com/ufoclub1977/videos
http://www.myspace.com/ufoclub1977

Here is my list.

1. Planet Earth- 9
2. Guitar - 9
3. Somewhere Here on Earth- 10
4. The 1 U Wanna C- 10
5. Future Baby Mama - 10
6. Mr. Goodnight- 8
7. All the Midnights in the World - 8
8. Chelsea Rodgers - 7
9. Lion of Judah - 7
10.Revelation -10

1. Planet Earth- 8
2. Guitar - 5
3. Somewhere Here on Earth- 7
4. The 1 U Wanna C- 7
5. Future Baby Mama - 7
6. Mr. Goodnight- 4
7. All the Midnights in the World - 8
8. Chelsea Rodgers - 7
9. Lion of Judah - 7
10.Revelation -7

Average rating after post 11:

1. Somewhere Here on Earth- 8.17
2. Chelsea Rodgers- 7.67
3. The 1 U Wanna C- 7.56
4. Future Baby Mama- 6.94
5. Planet Earth- 6.89
6. Lion of Judah- 6.22
7. Resolution- 5.94
8. Mr. Goodnight- 5.72
8. All the Midnights in the World- 5.72
10. Guitar- 5.61

"I'm a lover, not a haitcher"- Pandurito

PE=6
GUITAR=6
SOME WHERE=5
1 I WANNA C=7
FBM=10
MR G=8
ALL THE MIDNIGHTS=5
CR=9
LION O J=9
RESOLUTION=2

1) Chelsea Rogers: 9
2) The 1 U Wanna C: 8
3) All The Midnights in the World: 7
4) Guitar: 7
5) Lion of Judah: 5
6) Mr. Goodnight: 4
7) Somewhere Here on Earth: 4
8) Resolution: 3
9) Planet Earth: 3
10) Future Baby Mama: 1

1. Planet Earth - 7
2. Guitar - 10
3. Somewhere Here on Earth - 6
4. The 1 U Wanna C- 9
5. Future Baby Mama - 5
6. Mr. Goodnight- 2
7. All the Midnights in the World - 8
8. Chelsea Rodgers - 6
9. Lion of Judah - 5
10.Resolution - 9

1. Guitar - 10
2. The One U Wanna C - 9
3. Lion of Judah - 8
4. Planet Earth - 8
5. Resolution - 7
6. All The Midnights In The World - 7
7. Chelsea Rodgers - 7
8. Somewhere Here On Earth - 4
9. Mr. Goodnight - 4
10. Future Baby Mama - 4

I can't figure out the dislike for Guitar... I think it's a catchy song, and while it still bothers me that the song fades when Prince is starting to crank the guitar up, I still enjoy the guitar work throughout.
[Edited 8/1/07 20:33pm]
[Edited 8/1/07 20:33pm]

Listen to "I Will Follow" by U2 and you will see why it is hard to appreciate Guitar. The original was better and I can't figure out why he decided to change it. Was it a sneaky way to get us to pay for it twice?

Future Baby Mama 3
Planet Earth 1
Chelsea Rodgers 2
Guitar 1

Everything else 0

hmm. gimme a minute to think about this.

can't believe how many folks hate it.

GangstaFam said:

hmm. gimme a minute to think about this.

can't believe how many folks hate it.

"I'm a lover, not a haitcher"- Pandurito

with 10= excellent!!!
and 1 =



1. Planet Earth = 9
2. The One U Wanna C= 8
3. Somewhere Here on Earth = 7
4. Guitar = 6.5
5. Chelsea Rodgers = 6.5
6. Future Baby Mama = 6
7. Mr. Goodnight = 5
8. Resolution = 5
9. All the Midnights and Lion of Judah = both 3s
(couldn't decide which I disliked more)

1. Planet Earth- 8
2. Guitar - 9
3. Somewhere Here on Earth- 9
4. The 1 U Wanna C- 10
5. Future Baby Mama - 8
6. Mr. Goodnight- 8
7. All the Midnights in the World - 7
8. Chelsea Rodgers - 8
9. Lion of Judah - 2
10.Resolution - 7

Somewhere Here on Earth- 10(reminds of parade era a bit. my fav of the bunch)
The 1 U Wanna C- 8(it grew on me lol)
Chelsea Rodgers-7( i do like the groove on this one)
Future baby mama-7(the so bad its good category?)
Planet Earth-7
Resolution-5
All the Midnights in the World-4
Lion of Judah-4
Mr. Goodnight-1(lawd i just...lawd!)
Guitar-0

I've changed my mind cuz I love this album better with every listen!


[Edited 8/2/07 11:16am]

After Post 23:

1. The 1 U Wanna C- 7.50
2. Chelsea Rodgers- 7.19
3. Somewhere Here on Earth- 7.03
4. Planet Earth- 6.56
5. Future Baby Mama- 6.47
6. Guitar- 5.72
7. Lion of Judah- 5.67
8. All the Midnights in the World- 5.58
8. Resolution- 5.58
10. Mr. Goodnight- 4.86

"I'm a lover, not a haitcher"- Pandurito

Planet Earth 10
Guitar 10
Somewhere Here On Earth 10
The One U Wanna C 10
Future Baby Mama 10
Mr Goodnight 10
All The Midnights In The World 10
Chelsea Rodgers 10
Lion of Judah 10
Resolution 10
Perfect album 4 me!

Somewhere Here On Earth 10
Planet Earth 9.5
Future Baby Mama 9.5
The One U Wanna C 9
Chelsea Rodgers 8.5
Resolution 8.5
Guitar 8
Mr Goodnight 7
All The Midnights In The World 7
Lion of Judah 7

Overall I love this CD and have listened to it non-stop (no other CD in my player) for two weeks which I have not done with a Prince CD for a long while!

1 The 1 U Wanna C 10
2 Chelsea Rodgers 9
3 Lion Of Judah 9
4 Resolution 9
5 Guitar 8
6 Somewhere Here on Earth 8
7 All The Midnights 8
8 Mr Goodnight 8
9 Future Baby Mama 8
10 Planet Earth 8

Great album.

Future Baby Mama- 10
Mr. Goodnight- 10
All The Midnights In The World- 10
Somewhere Here On Earth- 8.5
Planet Earth- 8.5
Resolution- 8
Lion Of Judah- 8
The 1 U Wanna C- 7
Guitar- 7
Chelsea Rodgers- 6.5

1. Planet Earth 8
2. Guitar 8
3. Somewhere Here on Earth 9
4. The 1 U Wanna C 10
5. Future Baby Mama 8
6. Mr. Goodnight 7
7. All the Midnights.... 7
8. Chelsea Rodgers 8
9. Lion of Judah 8
10.Resolution 8