3121 vs Planet Earth (track by track)

Forums > Prince: Music and More > 3121 vs Planet Earth (track by track)

« Previous topic

Next topic »

Create new topic

Printable version (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)

Author

Message

Thread started 07/23/07 12:05am

Marco81

3121 vs Planet Earth (track by track)

(excluding Te Amo Corazon and Incense & Candles from 3121...)

3121 vs Planet Earth
Lolita vs The One U Wanna C
Black Sweat vs Mr. Goodnight
Love vs Chelsea Rodgers
Satisfied vs All The Midnights In The World
Fury vs Guitar
The Word vs Lion of Judah
Beautiful Loved & Blessed vs Future Baby Mama
The Dance vs Somewhere Here on Earth
Get On The Boat v Resolution

tell me the 10 winners!

- E-mail - orgNote -

Report post to moderator

Reply #1 posted 07/23/07 12:09am

JoVoCoP

3121 vs Planet Earth - pretty close to call, i think planet earth

Lolita vs The One U Wanna C - the one u wanna c

Black Sweat vs Mr. Goodnight - black sweat isnt great, but i like it more.

Love vs Chelsea Rodgers - chelsea rodgers hands down

Satisfied vs All The Midnights In The World - satisfied

Fury vs Guitar - i like both but ill go with fury

The Word vs Lion of Judah - i like the word

Beautiful Loved & Blessed vs Future Baby Mama - I LOVE beautiful, loved, and blessed

The Dance vs Somewhere Here on Earth - somewhere here on earth for me

Get On The Boat v Resolution - get on the boat

theres my 10 winners. kool thread

- E-mail - orgNote -

Report post to moderator

Reply #2 posted 07/23/07 12:46am

Raze

avatar

Marco81 said:

mmmm... but when you get rid of the most boring song and the most annoying song, you give 3121 an unfair advantage. it's still not as good as Planet Earth. but, it's still an unfair advantage.

"Half of what I say is meaningless; but I say it so that the other half may reach you." - Kahlil Gibran

- E-mail - orgNote -

Report post to moderator

Reply #3 posted 07/23/07 1:16am

IstenSzek

avatar

3121 vs Planet Earth
Lolita vs The One U Wanna C
Black Sweat vs Mr. Goodnight
Love vs Chelsea Rodgers
Satisfied vs All The Midnights In The World
Fury vs Guitar
The Word vs Lion of Judah
Beautiful Loved & Blessed vs Future Baby Mama
The Dance vs Somewhere Here on Earth
Get On The Boat v Resolution

i was born with the wrong sign, in the wrong house, with the wrong ascendancy

- E-mail - orgNote -

Report post to moderator

Reply #4 posted 07/23/07 2:59am

Snap	3121 vs Planet Earth Lolita vs The One U Wanna C Black Sweat vs Mr. Goodnight Love vs Chelsea Rodgers Satisfied vs All The Midnights In The World Fury vs Guitar The Word vs Lion of Judah Beautiful Loved & Blessed vs Future Baby Mama The Dance vs Somewhere Here on Earth Get On The Boat v Resolution Te Amo Corazon vs Resolution
	- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator

Reply #5 posted 07/23/07 4:01am

Moonbeam

avatar

Hmmm....

wink

"I'm a lover, not a haitcher"- Pandurito

clapping

- E-mail - orgNote -

Report post to moderator

Reply #6 posted 07/23/07 4:55am

Moonbeam

avatar

3121 vs Planet Earth

This is really hard. I adore both tracks and both are my favorites from their respective albums. I'll give a slight edge to "3121".

Lolita vs The One U Wanna C

I like "Lolita", but I adore "The 1 U Wanna C".

Black Sweat vs Mr. Goodnight

"Black Sweat" wins this easily.

Love vs Chelsea Rodgers

"Love" is very superior.

Satisfied vs All The Midnights In The World

"All the Midnights in the World", easily.

Fury vs Guitar

Perhaps the most lopsided yet. "Fury" is a million times better.

The Word vs Lion of Judah

Good pairing. I like both, but "Lion of Judah" resonates much more with me.

Beautiful Loved & Blessed vs Future Baby Mama

I hate "Future Baby Mama", so BLB wins.

The Dance vs Somewhere Here on Earth

"Somewhere Here on Earth" is lovely. love

Get On The Boat v Resolution

"Resolution" wins this rather easily.

The result is a 5-5 tie. It's still early, but I think I prefer 3121 as an album.

"I'm a lover, not a haitcher"- Pandurito

clapping

- E-mail - orgNote -

Report post to moderator

Reply #7 posted 07/23/07 5:09am

MendesCity

avatar

Marco81 said:

Shouldn't this be in order of the track list?

- E-mail - orgNote -

Report post to moderator

Reply #8 posted 07/23/07 5:10am

emilio319

Both of these albums are really GREAT !!!

As much as I'm digging Planet Earth, right now I would have to say that I love 3121 more as an entire album, but that's not a fair comparison cuz I've already heard 3121 so many times that it has really grown on me and I haven't listened to Planet Earth anywhere nearly as much since it's brand new.

But just for the fun of it I'll go ahead and play cuz this thread is a good one!
razz

3121 vs Planet Earth (PE is an awesome song but 3121 is that cold, dirty funk that reminds me of the 1999 album)
Lolita vs The One U Wanna C
Black Sweat vs Mr. Goodnight
Love vs Chelsea Rodgers
Satisfied vs All The Midnights In The World
Fury vs Guitar
The Word vs Lion of Judah (Both of these songs are fantastic though)
Beautiful Loved & Blessed vs Future Baby Mama (I love FBM...it's got that "Do Me, Baby" vibe)
The Dance vs Somewhere Here on Earth (The DANCE is INCREDIBLE...this is some tough competition here though with S.H.O.E.)
Get On The Boat v Resolution (Resolution is a cool song but Get On The Boat is SMOKING, an INCREDIBLE song by P.)

HA ! I'm not surprised that my votes resulted in a tie. Regarding the 3121 tracks left off the vote..."Te Amo Corazon" is a fantastic song..."Incense & Candles" is not really my type of vibe but I can understand why some people like it.
[Edited 7/23/07 5:11am]

- E-mail - orgNote -

Report post to moderator

Reply #9 posted 07/23/07 7:49am

Marco81

MendesCity said:

Marco81 said:

Shouldn't this be in order of the track list?

I preferred pairing songs which have something in common (i.e. style / initial track / final track / etc.)

- E-mail - orgNote -

Report post to moderator

Reply #10 posted 07/23/07 8:35am

MendesCity

avatar

Marco81 said:

MendesCity said:

Shouldn't this be in order of the track list?

I preferred pairing songs which have something in common (i.e. style / initial track / final track / etc.)

ok, i'll play

3121 vs Planet Earth: PE, by a hair
Lolita vs The One U Wanna C: 1 U Wanna See, No Contest
Black Sweat vs Mr. Goodnight: Black Sweat, big time
Love vs Chelsea Rodgers: Chelsea Rodgers, just barely
Satisfied vs All The Midnights In The World: Satisfied, although these are so different
Fury vs Guitar: Guitar, but not by much.
The Word vs Lion of Judah: Lion of Judah
Beautiful Loved & Blessed vs Future Baby Mama: FBM, BL&B was so drippy.
The Dance vs Somewhere Here on Earth: SHOE, the best song he's written in ages
Get On The Boat v Resolution: Get on the Boat

- E-mail - orgNote -

Report post to moderator

Reply #11 posted 07/23/07 8:59am

BeneHaze

avatar

3121 vs Planet Earth *3121*
Lolita vs The One U Wanna C *The 1 U Wanna C *
Black Sweat vs Mr. Goodnight *Black Sweat*
Love vs Chelsea Rodgers *Chelsea Rodgers*
Satisfied vs All The Midnights In The World *Satisfied*
Fury vs Guitar *Guitar*
The Word vs Lion of Judah *The Word*
Beautiful Loved & Blessed vs Future Baby Mama *Future Baby Mama*
The Dance vs Somewhere Here on Earth *The Dance
Get On The Boat v Resolution * Neither*

- E-mail - orgNote -

Report post to moderator

Reply #12 posted 07/23/07 9:12am

lastdecember

avatar

Its really impossible to compare, two totally different albums in VIBE. As soon as 3121 kicks in U know its gonna be a party vibe so to speak and as Soon as Planet Earth starts you know you are in for some thought and deeper meaning. With that said i could never compare the two records as a whole.

a-ha "foot of the mountain TOUR 2009"
a-ha "Ending on a High Note Final TOUR 2010" going everywhere!

- E-mail - orgNote -

Report post to moderator

Reply #13 posted 07/23/07 9:17am

MIR1

avatar

3121 vs Planet Earth
Lolita vs The One U Wanna C
Black Sweat vs Mr. Goodnight
Love vs Chelsea Rodgers
Satisfied vs All The Midnights In The World
Fury vs Guitar
The Word vs Lion of Judah
Beautiful Loved & Blessed vs Future Baby Mama
The Dance vs Somewhere Here on Earth
Get On The Boat v Resolution

cool

http://www.myspace.com/vmn1

- E-mail - orgNote -

Report post to moderator

Reply #14 posted 07/23/07 4:48pm

GangstaFam
	- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator

Reply #15 posted 07/24/07 1:57am

Thibaut	3121 vs Planet Earth Lolita vs The One U Wanna C Black Sweat vs Mr. Goodnight Love vs Chelsea Rodgers Satisfied vs All The Midnights In The World Fury vs Guitar The Word vs Lion of Judah Beautiful Loved & Blessed vs Future Baby Mama The Dance vs Somewhere Here on Earth Get On The Boat v Resolution WICKED NEW TRACK: http://www.youtube.com/wa...annel_page
	- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator

Reply #16 posted 07/24/07 9:30pm

zcofnnu	3121 vs Planet Earth Lolita vs The One U Wanna C Black Sweat vs Mr. Goodnight Love vs Chelsea Rodgers Satisfied vs All The Midnights In The World Fury vs Guitar The Word vs Lion of Judah Beautiful Loved & Blessed vs Future Baby Mama The Dance vs Somewhere Here on Earth Get On The Boat v Resolution
	- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator

Reply #17 posted 07/24/07 10:30pm

jacknapier

avatar

3121 vs Planet Earth
Lolita vs The One U Wanna C
Black Sweat vs Mr. Goodnight
Love vs Chelsea Rodgers
Satisfied vs All The Midnights In The World
Fury vs Guitar
The Word vs Lion of Judah
Beautiful Loved & Blessed vs Future Baby Mama
The Dance vs Somewhere Here on Earth
Get On The Boat v Resolution

A tie 5/5, though PE is a much more cohesive record than 3121. Also the 5 tracks on 3121 that I though were better were marginally, while the PE tracks were much superior...
[Edited 7/24/07 22:34pm]

- E-mail - orgNote -

Report post to moderator

Create new topic

Printable version (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)

« Previous topic

Next topic »

Forums > Prince: Music and More > 3121 vs Planet Earth (track by track)