I think the title track is enough from that album. Possibly Deeper And Deeper will make the cut too but I think it is a rather poor song especially when compared with its cousins: Express Yourself, Vogue and Rescue Me

There's alot to look forward to in the coming months If you have a Madonna fan on your Christmas list,you have alot of items to choose from.I'm gonna try to list everything.If anyone knows the release dates that I don't have,please add it to this list:


"Celebration" single release date:
"Celebration" maxi-single release date:
"Celebration" maxi-vinyl album release date:
"Celebration" 2-CD set release date: Sep.28
"Celebration" single disc release date: Sep.28
"Celebration:The Videos 2-DVD set release date: Sep.28
Sticky And Sweet Tour DVD release date: November 1st
"Revolver" single release date: September (I'm guessing it will be later in the fall....probably November/December).
"Sticky And Sweet Photography Book by Guy Oseary release date: December 1

"Gambler"

yeah, sorry, that's not gonna happen

i'll not comment on the quality of the song, but it's owned by Geffen and WB aren't going to bother licensing that when Crazy For You is mandatory.

if they're Madonna fans, they're going to snatch all that up LONG before Christmas, so don't bother

Was Gambler a hit? A single?

I haven't bought a Madonna single since "Nothing Fails"

I just got tired of all the remixes sounding the same and uninspired and with so few vocals or anything at all of interest.

I've got the Confessions ones, although the only one that's really worth it is "Jump" for the sake of the B-side.

Which was...?

Which was...?

"History"!

"History"!

To be honest, there really is no point of Madonna having another greatest hit compilation, except for her songs afer 2000.

Immaculate Collection and Something to Remember were really well made hit collections.


Immaculate Collection- really about the songs which made Madonna into a big superstar.

Something to Remember- the ballads which won her a lot of praise in her career.

Then there was the GHV2 which took into account some of her underrated songs.

To be honest, there really is no point of Madonna having another greatest hit compilation, except for her songs afer 2000.

Immaculate Collection and Something to Remember were really well made hit collections.


Immaculate Collection- really about the songs which made Madonna into a big superstar.

Something to Remember- the ballads which won her a lot of praise in her career.

Then there was the GHV2 which took into account some of her underrated songs.

I think the main point is to rectify the songs overlooked in those past packages, as well as serve up remastered versions of the "superstar" hits.

I personally thought the strongest tracklisting was the one on the "leaked" / faked CD back cover:

1. Holiday (Single version)
2. Like A Virgin (Edit)
3. Material Girl (Edit)
4. Into The Groove (Single Version)
5. Papa Dont Preach (Edit)
6. Who's That Girl (Single Version)
7. Like A Prayer (12" edit)
8. Express Yourself (Album Version)
9. Vogue (Immaculate Col Version)
10. Erotica (Edit)
11. Secret (Album Version)
12. Frozen (Edit)
13. Ray Of Light (Edit)
14. Music (Album Version)
15. Die Another Day (Album Version)
16. Hung Up (Radio edit)
17. 4 Minutes (Album Version)
18. Celebration

1. Everybody (Orinal 12" Single Edit)
2. Borderline (Edit)
3. Crazy For You (Single Version)
4. Dress You up (Album Version)
5. Live To Tell (Edit)
6. La Isla Bonita (Edit)
7. Cherish (Edit)
8. Justify My Love (Album Version)
9. This Used To be My Playground (Single Version)
10. Deeper & Deeper (Album Version)
11. Take A Bow (Edit)
12. Human Nature (Edit)
13. Don't Tell Me (Edit)
14. American Life (Edit w/o rap)
15. Sorry (Edit)
16. Give It 2 Me (Album Version)
17. Revolver

I think this is a logical tracklisting. CD1 features all her 1st release singles (Live To tell excluded), plus absolute classics like Material Girl & Express Yourself. CD2 features most of her ballads, and secondary single releases. This maintains a sense of chronology to it, and makes CD1 the sort of ultimate greatest hits disc, and CD2 more interesting and varied.

Id say the only songs you could add to it are "lucky Star" "Open Your Heart" "Rain" "You'll See" "Drowned World".
Of the ones included Id say Everybody and Human Nature should make way for Open Your Heart & Drowned World. That said Everybody was her first single.....its damn difficult.

Deeper and deeper is a handsdown forgotten classic as far as im concerned. Its got my favourite outro to any madonna song (bar the insane fly swatting synth at the end of music).....Madonna, Donna & Nicky belting out "deeper & deeper & Deeper, Sweet & Sweeter & Sweeter". Great stuff.

I Deeper & Deeper! Probably in my top 5 Madonna songs

Yet it looks like they are likely to once again overlook some Madonna classics.

I love it, too. It's my #15. The only other song from that album to make my top 50 is "Bad Girl" at #5.

Really? I'm also smitten over Erotica. Then I think my next favorite on that album is Words.

I love it, too. It's my #15. The only other song from that album to make my top 50 is "Bad Girl" at #5.