New topic
Printablemusicjunky318 said: Kelly Clarkson - Deserved it 100%
Ruben Studdard - Undeserved. Clay Aiken should have won Fantasia Barrino - Undeserved. Jennifer Hudson should have won Carrie Underwood - Deserved it 100% Taylor Hicks - AN UTTER TRAVESTY. Daughtry should have won Jordin Sparks - Cop out. Melinda should have won David Cook - Acceptable. Could be argued however. Kris Allen - Acceptable. Could be argued however. Agreed 100! The only thing is, though, had the people who should have won actually won, their career would be lacking in creative control and they may not have been as successful as they are now, so it is a good thing that they DIDN'T win. But I agree, talent-wise, they should have won. | |
- E-mail - orgNote -  Report post to moderator |
|
InsatiableCream said: Kelly Clarkson - like her.
Ruben Studdard - i honestly can't remember a thing about him Fantasia Barrino - i think her voice is gross Carrie Underwood - my favorite. love her! Taylor Hicks - wtf is this shit 
Jordan Sparks - i have no idea who she is David Cook - i like David A. better but whatever Kris Allen- he's hot.  I know right  |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Alej said: InsatiableCream said: Kelly Clarkson - like her.
Ruben Studdard - i honestly can't remember a thing about him Fantasia Barrino - i think her voice is gross Carrie Underwood - my favorite. love her! Taylor Hicks - wtf is this shit
Jordan Sparks - i have no idea who she is David Cook - i like David A. better but whatever Kris Allen- he's hot. I know right I guess, if you're into country...geeky looking guys with wide faces.  **--••--**--••**--••--**--••**--••--**--••**--••-
U 'gon make me shake my doo loose! http://www.twitter.com/nivlekbrad | |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
daPrettyman said: Alej said: I know right I guess, if you're into country...geeky looking guys with wide faces. That can't sing..... | |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Graycap23 said: daPrettyman said: I guess, if you're into country...geeky looking guys with wide faces. That can't sing.....  **--••--**--••**--••--**--••**--••--**--••**--••-
U 'gon make me shake my doo loose! http://www.twitter.com/nivlekbrad | |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
RipHer2Shreds said: U don't understand the deserved/didn't deserve talk, so I'll just say who I did/didn't like:
Kelly Clarkson - awful dresser boring Ruben Studdard - you ain't Luther boring Fantasia Barrino - too much gums boring Carrie Underwood - pretty, blonde and boring (Jesus, take the wheel and crash that mofo) Taylor Hicks - gray and boring Jordin Sparks - young, gigantic head and boring David Cook - five o'clock shadow boring Kris Allen - Starbucks CD coffee shop boring  I can't stand Taylor Hicks, he was too corny for me.  RIP, mom. I will forever miss and love you. | |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
musicjunky318 said: Kelly Clarkson - Deserved it 100%
Ruben Studdard - Undeserved. Clay Aiken should have won Fantasia Barrino - Undeserved. Jennifer Hudson should have won Carrie Underwood - Deserved it 100% Taylor Hicks - AN UTTER TRAVESTY. Daughtry should have won Jordin Sparks - Cop out. Melinda should have won David Cook - Acceptable. Could be argued however. Kris Allen - Acceptable. Could be argued however. I agree, Daughtry definitely should have won over Taylor. Daughtry's first CD has some great music on it. There's a new Daughtry CD that is coming out in July. I can't wait to hear it.  RIP, mom. I will forever miss and love you. | |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Tamyra Gray is clearly the best talent I've seen on the show. I should've given up on it when she didn't win the 1st season. Thankfully, I gave up a couple of seasons later. "Whitney was purely and simply one of a kind." ~ Clive Davis | |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
I wonder if the "it's all crap" posters have even listened to any songs by the artists outside the show. Kelly and Carrie are true artists, write their own songs and go out of the box for the genres. Who now can claim to be a power country singer other than Carrie Underwood? Even Reba was quoted as saying she had to "rock" it up abit after playing with Carrie. She's a real deal. When Kelly won, the show was still honest.
But look at the list of winners. Only Carrie and David Cook look remotely like pop stars in our supposedly looks-obsessed country. A guyliner-wearing, obviously not straight guy ALMOST took it all. Jordin is no skinny-mini. Rueben was well fed, Clay needed to be fed. The show just needs to quit pimpin' certain contestants and ban anyone who even sniffed a record studio. THEN it will seem more honest. | |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
pbrite said: I wonder if the "it's all crap" posters have even listened to any songs by the artists outside the show. Kelly and Carrie are true artists, write their own songs and go out of the box for the genres. Who now can claim to be a power country singer other than Carrie Underwood? Even Reba was quoted as saying she had to "rock" it up abit after playing with Carrie. She's a real deal. When Kelly won, the show was still honest.
But look at the list of winners. Only Carrie and David Cook look remotely like pop stars in our supposedly looks-obsessed country. A guyliner-wearing, obviously not straight guy ALMOST took it all. Jordin is no skinny-mini. Rueben was well fed, Clay needed to be fed. The show just needs to quit pimpin' certain contestants and ban anyone who even sniffed a record studio. THEN it will seem more honest. I've heard enough to know that it really is all crap, to these ears anyway. I know "Since U Been Gone" got a lot of acclaim, but I didn't like it. It may only be a symptom of the real problem, but American Idol is emblematic of everything that's wrong with the music industry. Feel free to join in the Prince Album Poll 2018! Let'a celebrate his legacy by counting down the most beloved Prince albums, as decided by you! | |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
|
daPrettyman said: Alej said: I know right I guess, if you're into country...geeky looking guys with wide faces. I guess I'm into that, then. |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Moonbeam said: pbrite said: I wonder if the "it's all crap" posters have even listened to any songs by the artists outside the show. Kelly and Carrie are true artists, write their own songs and go out of the box for the genres. Who now can claim to be a power country singer other than Carrie Underwood? Even Reba was quoted as saying she had to "rock" it up abit after playing with Carrie. She's a real deal. When Kelly won, the show was still honest.
But look at the list of winners. Only Carrie and David Cook look remotely like pop stars in our supposedly looks-obsessed country. A guyliner-wearing, obviously not straight guy ALMOST took it all. Jordin is no skinny-mini. Rueben was well fed, Clay needed to be fed. The show just needs to quit pimpin' certain contestants and ban anyone who even sniffed a record studio. THEN it will seem more honest. I've heard enough to know that it really is all crap, to these ears anyway. I know "Since U Been Gone" got a lot of acclaim, but I didn't like it. It may only be a symptom of the real problem, but American Idol is emblematic of everything that's wrong with the music industry. I'd have agree. | |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Alej said: daPrettyman said: I guess, if you're into country...geeky looking guys with wide faces. I guess I'm into that, then. I still love you, Alej 
Just teasing you. **--••--**--••**--••--**--••**--••--**--••**--••-
U 'gon make me shake my doo loose! http://www.twitter.com/nivlekbrad | |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
|
daPrettyman said: Alej said: I guess I'm into that, then. I still love you, Alej
Just teasing you.  |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Moonbeam said: pbrite said: I wonder if the "it's all crap" posters have even listened to any songs by the artists outside the show. Kelly and Carrie are true artists, write their own songs and go out of the box for the genres. Who now can claim to be a power country singer other than Carrie Underwood? Even Reba was quoted as saying she had to "rock" it up abit after playing with Carrie. She's a real deal. When Kelly won, the show was still honest.
But look at the list of winners. Only Carrie and David Cook look remotely like pop stars in our supposedly looks-obsessed country. A guyliner-wearing, obviously not straight guy ALMOST took it all. Jordin is no skinny-mini. Rueben was well fed, Clay needed to be fed. The show just needs to quit pimpin' certain contestants and ban anyone who even sniffed a record studio. THEN it will seem more honest. I've heard enough to know that it really is all crap, to these ears anyway. I know "Since U Been Gone" got a lot of acclaim, but I didn't like it. It may only be a symptom of the real problem, but American Idol is emblematic of everything that's wrong with the music industry. Kelly Clarkson's 2nd album was strictly a female empowerment record. People love that kind of stuff. **--••--**--••**--••--**--••**--••--**--••**--••-
U 'gon make me shake my doo loose! http://www.twitter.com/nivlekbrad | |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Dull,boring,middle of the road crap.I don't believe in capital punishment but l'd make an exception for Simon Cowell. | |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Gzilla said: Dull,boring,middle of the road crap.I don't believe in capital punishment but l'd make an exception for Simon Cowell.
You might want to say Simon Fuller. He's the big dog. **--••--**--••**--••--**--••**--••--**--••**--••-
U 'gon make me shake my doo loose! http://www.twitter.com/nivlekbrad | |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Out of all the past winners, the only one I've listened to is Fantasia, and that was only her first album. Didn't care for the second one at all. To me, she's a Soul singer and Arista tried to surpress that, like the did with Jennifer.
Rueben was supposed to be the next Luther Vandross. It didn't happen, though. [Edited 5/29/09 3:29am] "It's not nice to fuck with K.B.! All you haters will see!" - Kitbradley
"The only true wisdom is knowing you know nothing." - Socrates | |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
daPrettyman said: Gzilla said: Dull,boring,middle of the road crap.I don't believe in capital punishment but l'd make an exception for Simon Cowell.
You might want to say Simon Fuller. He's the big dog. Imagine what Fuller must be pulling down a year. Cowell makes $36 million a year just 4 A.I. | |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Graycap23 said: daPrettyman said: You might want to say Simon Fuller. He's the big dog. Imagine what Fuller must be pulling down a year. Cowell makes $36 million a year just 4 A.I. I know. Cowell must pull in over a half-billion between Idol (US and UK) and the Got Talent shows (Britain and America). That doesn't include his other reality shows. **--••--**--••**--••--**--••**--••--**--••**--••-
U 'gon make me shake my doo loose! http://www.twitter.com/nivlekbrad | |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
daPrettyman said: Graycap23 said: Imagine what Fuller must be pulling down a year. Cowell makes $36 million a year just 4 A.I. I know. Cowell must pull in over a half-billion between Idol (US and UK) and the Got Talent shows (Britain and America). That doesn't include his other reality shows. I need his gig. At least 1 of them. | |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |