Don't get it, all three don't write their own songs, all three are really bad dancers, Pink has a better voice than Madonna or Britney live from what i've seen?, all non are musicians, all have fake blonde hair?

So what is it what makes Britney Bigger than Pink ? Did Madonna get a head start, or is she the reason why Britneys so big?

UK Top 100 Position Last week Artist Title
4*** BRITNEY SPEARS CIRCUS
10 8 PINK FUNHOUSE
Madonna HARD CANDY not even in the top 100 cd's ?

US Top 200 Position Last week Artist Title
1*** BRITNEY SPEARS CIRCUS
198 BRITNEY SPEARS BLACKOUT
21 20 PINK FUNHOUSE
MADONNA HARD CANDY not even in the top 200 cd's ?

* HARD CANDY RELEASE DATE 25TH APRIL 2008 wtf?

looks

pink is the shit i love her cds funhouse is fun and full of emotion i digs her voice big time over both of them losers watching britney dance is like watching a talent competition she the white chic that wanna dance but really cant hyped 2 say she have talent that she really dont have go sit down brit u r lame and madonna she just old and ugly tired of seeing her let pink take over america is lame true talent get pushed aside 4 sex sluts these day

I do not understand why a lot of singers are not as loved as Madonna and Britney (or Janet even)!

I do not dislike Madonna, Britney or Janet, but I just think people like Pink and Christina Aguilera are so talented, too, but they never really have the same type of success. I guess they probably do not care--maybe?

Probably cause she does not kiss anybody's ass and is not looking to be everybody's sweetheart.

CONTROVERSEY

Despite "Womaniser" being complete turd (even by Spears' standards) her album has had big openings mainly due to the Michael Jackson style programme she did.

Looks, she is very harsh-looking, and controversial, not as mainstream-friendly, more rebel than teen idol, plus her songs (generally speaking) are not as good.

She's a one-trick pony.People are getting tired of her "angry rock chick" routine.

SoulAlive said:

Exactly. Frankly, I'm sick of this "I'm angry" vibe that she seems to have every freakin' album. Get over it b-atch!

Bishop31 said:

Bingo! How many times can she play this role? lol

SoulAlive said:

About as many times as Madonna can "reinvent" herself"

SoulAlive said:

SoulAlive said:

at this point i'm like, grow a dick or get over it pink, please

IstenSzek said:

Didn't Pink perform on the Grammy nomination show?

I saw her perform on some show where she was wearing a pretty dress.. Oh. yes. she was singing a duet with Sarah Mc...I can't spell her name!

I love Sarah Mc...., too!

She can sing much better, but most singers can sing better than M or Brit. That's not the point. It's the music and the quality of music. Pink! does generic rock/pop music. She doesn't even write her own songs. Her videos are always the same (she plays different roles).
Also she's not a tragic person as Britney or Madonna. Gays don't adore Pink. She doesn't change her style as M does.

To be honest, her music just doesn't have enough quality to stand the test of time.

SoulAlive said:

Right on!

Also, her music is so immature too. I liked her one song a few years ago - I think it was called "stupid girls" or something like that, but as for the rest....

it'd be a skank overloard. america can only handle one at a time. pink is actually the most talented of the three to me vocally, dance-wise. i actually THINK about buying a Pink album.

Well even though Madonna continues to make albums and would like to think she is a lot younger than she is, Pink and Madonna are not contempoeraries.

Now Britney and Pink...I think just at the begining Britney had a better team behind her and everything had been well mapped out. The sound, the image, etc. People caught on and even as Britney changed her sound slightly, those that were fans continued to be hooked and stuck around. Granted, she didn't keep all her fans, but a sizable amount. Pink changes her sound (her first album was a label creation but she did a 180 on it and really never went back to safe R&B dance pop), although again she is pretty pop (much like Madonna)...yeah, I don't know!

I also agree with others. The angry girl shtick of Pink wears thin. And I know a lot of people look at Britney and think what a complete drug addict loser but you can tell she is human and hellvu a lot more relatable than superwoman Pink. Not that this matters, it should be about the music. Britney's is a little more accessible. There is your answer!
[Edited 12/12/08 10:13am]

Pink makes good music. It's not all angry rock chick things.
But she doesn't have that much outside of her music to hold my interest. She doesn't have an interesting personality or an exciting look.
Her songs are good, but some of them are too similiar in their sound. Her music is good, but a little predictable.

Pink looks like a DUDE.

Because of what people have said.
She's annoying as fuck OFFA

kenlacam said:

Too masculine.

Bad lyrics.

Too many singles where anger was the emotion. "Get This Party Started" was her biggest song because it was the most fun, and even that one had some attitude in it ("I'll be burnin' rubber, you'll be kissin' my ass") but at least people could party to it.

Props to her for staying in her lane or doing what she wants, but, that answers your question.

angel345 said:

'I'm Not Dead' is way better than anything Madogga or Britney have pulled in recent years.I love that album. Pink isn't a one trick pony, i bought her her second album whatever that was called (i listened once), horrible generic RnB-type shite, never listened again, But IND is smoking, not bought the new one, she doesn't have my full trust yet.

lascantas said:

It's called marketing. Madonna is execellent at marketing herself. So is Britney. They are products to the music biz.

Because Pink is f*cking annoying and pretentious as hell! She's a contender for my least favorite female act of all time. I'm not a fan of Britney's music, but at least she knows what she is- a pop starlet. Pink seems to think she's a serious artist who has the clout to make fun of other pop tarts when that's exactly what she is.

Moonbeam said:

it's only pop music, nothing major. like you said, 'fun'. I honestly think Pink knows where she stands.

Moonbeam said:

TAWK!!!