[Edited 11/2/06 8:50am]

Let's recap:

both were return to origin
both feature the worse that "hot" producers did
...
[Edited 11/2/06 8:54am]

If I had a gun to my head and had to pic one I'd go with Janet

Even though, I didn't love this album, her vocal ability is still superior
to J.No's.

Dag, they both had crap first singles too!
Jennifer had the song with the annoying ass party horn
and Janet had the bland, boring, 'ho hum', Call on Me

Still, I'd take 20 YO any day

thekidsgirl said:

Never heard Afterbirth. Don't want to. I never took JLO's singing career remotely seriously. I did, however, once take Janet seriously, so I'll have to go with 20 JOkes as the bigger turd in the bowl.

Shapeshifter said:

Honestly:
1. How many times have you heard the songs "Take Care," "With U" and "Do it 2 me"
2. Do you like "All For You?"

Janet over J. Ho!

badujunkie said:

I do. I think half of it is superb. Love Son of a Gun in particular.

thekidsgirl said:

I'd probably choose to get shot

strangely J.Ho's cover reminds me of another fabulous flop:




Needless to say that Kylie's BL is miles better than these 2 albums!
[Edited 11/3/06 5:28am]

BeatsPerMinute said:

Kylie's album is a straight-up classic, and I quite like 20 Y.O.. I haven't heard J-Lo, but I don't need to in order to know that I prefer Janet.

I play Body Language all the time. Rebirth had a few songs other songs by Rich Harrison besides Get Right that were tolerable.

Moonbeam said:

Body Language is the best album Kylie did after Impossible Princess!

(Whenever I mention Kylie...I bet that you'll appear moonbeam! )

BeatsPerMinute said:

I adore Impossible Princess too- another classic.

I stalk Kylie posts like none other!

Moonbeam said:

I have all her albums since Let's get to it!

But my love for Kylie is known by everybody here!

JackieBlue said:

I don't think there's a single duff track on Body Language Obviously some are stronger than others, but it's a lovely listen all the way through. Much better than stuff like Fever which is a bunch of singles mixed with fillers.
[Edited 11/3/06 6:00am]

Ellie said:

I agree with you...Fever was a rushed album!

BeatsPerMinute said:

I've got all of her albums. AND all of those remix ones.

BeatsPerMinute said:

I can't agree with that- Fever is my favorite Kylie album- it broke my Kylie cherry and nearly 100 CDs/vinyl/tapes later, the story continues.

Moonbeam said:

Let's get to it is the only PWL album that matters!

BeatsPerMinute said:

I have a different opinion, naturally! Rhythm of Love is the only PWL album that has merit in my book!

Ellie said:

Body Language has one of my favorite Kylie tracks of all time--After Dark. I don't know why I love it so much. There's just something about it. Sexy and smooth. Love it.

I didn't think much of 'After Dark' until she performed it live on TOTP. It somehow added lots of flavour to it.

Ellie said:

Yeah- the TOTP performance did it for me too. I still prefer "You Make Me Feel", but "After Dark" is AOK in my book.

i haven't heard J Lo's single, nor did i know she even had an album out...so thats says a lot.

I forgot that this thread was about Janet and J-Lo.

Moonbeam said:

who?

this thread was Kylie-jacked!

BeatsPerMinute said:

Are you on SayHey at all?

Moonbeam said:

I posted there as "lovesexy"

then I was hacked...and I migrated to togermano.com.

sayhey was a bit of a bitchfest for my taste

(I'm the orger formerly known as MikeMatronik actually! )
[Edited 11/3/06 6:31am]

BeatsPerMinute said:

I remember you! I also knew you were MM here.

Do you know the details behind the SayHey hijacking that led to the big changes?

Moonbeam said:

I was there when it happened...

Someone made all the members moderators...we had acess to the secret moderator forum...threads deleted...dirty secrets reveled...Elle came back...the usual sayhey drama!

BeatsPerMinute said:

I just knew it must have been big because of the long delay. What's Elle's deal anyway? She's some kind of celebrity over there.