independent and unofficial
Prince fan community
Welcome! Sign up or enter username and password to remember me
Forum jump
Forums > Prince: Music and More > were the vault tracks on Purple Rain Deluxe remastered?
« Previous topic  Next topic »
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
Author

Tweet     Share

Message
Thread started 01/14/21 6:17am

FasterThan67

were the vault tracks on Purple Rain Deluxe remastered?

only questioning this because i rarely (only if i wanna hear the segue into Darling Nikki) listen to the album cut of Computer Blue but noticed how much different (better) that track sounds than the Hallway Speech version. maybe this is because Prince never got to remaster the vault tracks, but it makes me wonder if they were just thrown onto a disc without any remastering? would they really take 24 year old tracks and just assume they were perfectly mastered?

i mean, We Can Fuck is arguably the best vault track we’ve ever gotten and there is barely any low end in that song...

hope there’s not other threads on this (haven’t checked) even though i’m nearly four years too late asking this haha.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #1 posted 01/14/21 8:04am

BartVanHemelen

avatar

FasterThan67 said:

Prince never got to remaster the vault tracks

.

Learn what mastering is first.

.

Also, this has been debated to death.

© Bart Van Hemelen
This posting is provided AS IS with no warranties, and confers no rights.
It is not authorized by Prince or the NPG Music Club. You assume all risk for
your use. All rights reserved.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #2 posted 01/14/21 8:15am

LoveGalore

FasterThan67 said:

only questioning this because i rarely (only if i wanna hear the segue into Darling Nikki) listen to the album cut of Computer Blue but noticed how much different (better) that track sounds than the Hallway Speech version. maybe this is because Prince never got to remaster the vault tracks, but it makes me wonder if they were just thrown onto a disc without any remastering? would they really take 24 year old tracks and just assume they were perfectly mastered?

i mean, We Can Fuck is arguably the best vault track we’ve ever gotten and there is barely any low end in that song...

hope there’s not other threads on this (haven’t checked) even though i’m nearly four years too late asking this haha.


The likelihood that the tracks were sourced from tapes he sent the label is high. So, not a true remaster, no, because that isn't possible.

The songs were given a fidelity facelift though. We can tell this from our pristine copies of some of these songs. How much that helped the song is up to you. To me, everything is pretty clear and clean despite not having the dynamics of the album tracks.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #3 posted 01/14/21 12:26pm

JoeyCococo

I thought it all sounded pretty muddy when it came out, especially the Comp Blue long version. It wasn't until I heard the 1999 Vault tracks did I confirm this in my mind. I think they used poorly sourced vault material for the PR Deluxe. Love and Sex sounds murky....but when you listen to older songs from 1999 and even older on the SOTT (I Could Never '79 version) you can't help but conclude, the PR vault stuff is poorly done.I think the estate acknowledges this by calling it a Deluxe and the 1999 and SOTT sets, Super Deluxe.

The good thing is, we'll very likely see a Super Deluxe of PR.

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #4 posted 01/14/21 12:36pm

RODSERLING

No, and I think the old CD versions of any SDE original albums sound better.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #5 posted 01/14/21 1:45pm

databank

avatar

BartVanHemelen said:

FasterThan67 said:


.

Learn what mastering is first.

.

Also, this has been debated to death.

I have to agree.

How can something that's never been mastered in the first place be remastered?

A COMPREHENSIVE PRINCE DISCOGRAPHY (work in progress ^^): https://sites.google.com/...scography/
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #6 posted 01/14/21 6:35pm

FasterThan67

i worded myself terribly.

my main question about Purple Rain deluxe is: why does the album sound so much better than the vault tracks AND single edits?

for example, Computer Blue (2015 Paisley Park Remaster) sounds much better (to me) than Computer Blue (Hallway Speech Version). since these are the same song being released on the same set, i was confused as to why one version of the song sounds so much better than the other (even though they are different lengths, they are still virtually the same song, so something still doesn’t make sense to me.)

this also is true for the single edits. for example, When Doves Cry (2015 Paisley Park Remaster) is MUCH louder and fuller sounding than When Doves Cry (7” single edit) and yet they’re on the same set.

what i have gathered is that i incorrectly used the term remaster (i meant to say “why is the album Purple Rain album so much better sounding than the vault tracks EVEN THOUGH they are released on the same set”) and that the source material for the vault tracks of Purple Rain Deluxe may not have been in the best condition, which means bad sound on the album.

again, i’m sorry if there’s already been threads on this. i just recently joined the org and found myself wondering this while re-listening to the album.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #7 posted 01/14/21 6:45pm

FasterThan67

also, i guess i was confused on using the term remaster because every track on Sign ☮️ the Times Super Deluxe is labeled (2020 Remaster), so i guess i just figured all the Purple Rain tracks would have been mastered at some point, too.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #8 posted 01/14/21 7:05pm

databank

avatar

FasterThan67 said:

i worded myself terribly. my main question about Purple Rain deluxe is: why does the album sound so much better than the vault tracks AND single edits? for example, Computer Blue (2015 Paisley Park Remaster) sounds much better (to me) than Computer Blue (Hallway Speech Version). since these are the same song being released on the same set, i was confused as to why one version of the song sounds so much better than the other (even though they are different lengths, they are still virtually the same song, so something still doesn’t make sense to me.) this also is true for the single edits. for example, When Doves Cry (2015 Paisley Park Remaster) is MUCH louder and fuller sounding than When Doves Cry (7” single edit) and yet they’re on the same set. what i have gathered is that i incorrectly used the term remaster (i meant to say “why is the album Purple Rain album so much better sounding than the vault tracks EVEN THOUGH they are released on the same set”) and that the source material for the vault tracks of Purple Rain Deluxe may not have been in the best condition, which means bad sound on the album. again, i’m sorry if there’s already been threads on this. i just recently joined the org and found myself wondering this while re-listening to the album.

OK. So as stated before and as far as we know, the vault hadn't even begun to being sorted out at that time (2017), so WB could either postpone the project or use what they had for the outtakes CD. What they had were cassette mixdowns (regular cassettes, the same kind bootleggers use) and they decided to go with that. Same with Moonbeam Levels on 4ever BTW.

.

Later on, they did it again with P&AM83 and Bold Generation on 1999 SDE, but in in these cases it's because they couldn't find any better source or usable multitrack in the vault (they had, by then, begun to inventory its content).

.

This explains the sound quality as well as the fact that TDE isn't the final mix that was sent to André and that we have on bootlegs, but an earlier, work in progress version.

.

The good news there, though, is that we got to hear original mixes, as made by Prince's engineers at the time. Later on, when mixdowns couldn't be found on any other formats than cassettes, WB had Niko Bolas recreate the mix from the multitracks, which led to certain creative liberties being taken with the material, particularly on Originals.

.

Also, it appears that the RG/OD crossfade on PR SDE was made by WB from 2 separate cassettes in order to try and recreate the original intent but, if I'm to believe collectors who've heard said original intent, WB got it wrong.

A COMPREHENSIVE PRINCE DISCOGRAPHY (work in progress ^^): https://sites.google.com/...scography/
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #9 posted 01/14/21 7:10pm

databank

avatar

^ I forgot to reply about the difference between the proper album and the singles' sound.

.

Prince had Josh Welton remaster PR before he died. WB chose to respect P's wishes and use this. The edits, mixes and b-sides, however, were remastered posthumously by Bernie Grundman, who considered one of the best mastering engineers in the world. Predictably, young Welton went for loudness wars and old Grundman went for a little more subtelty.

A COMPREHENSIVE PRINCE DISCOGRAPHY (work in progress ^^): https://sites.google.com/...scography/
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #10 posted 01/14/21 7:17pm

FasterThan67

databank said:

^ I forgot to reply about the difference between the proper album and the singles' sound.


.


Prince had Josh Welton remaster PR before he died. WB chose to respect P's wishes and use this. The edits, mixes and b-sides, however, were remastered posthumously by Bernie Grundman, who considered one of the best mastering engineers in the world. Predictably, young Welton went for loudness wars and old Grundman went for a little more subtelty.



ahhh, i see. thank you so much for all the information!
[Edited 1/14/21 19:20pm]
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #11 posted 01/14/21 7:37pm

databank

avatar

FasterThan67 said:

databank said:

^ I forgot to reply about the difference between the proper album and the singles' sound.

.

Prince had Josh Welton remaster PR before he died. WB chose to respect P's wishes and use this. The edits, mixes and b-sides, however, were remastered posthumously by Bernie Grundman, who considered one of the best mastering engineers in the world. Predictably, young Welton went for loudness wars and old Grundman went for a little more subtelty.

ahhh, i see. thank you so much for all the information! [Edited 1/14/21 19:20pm]

Anytime. Welcome 2 the Org wink

A COMPREHENSIVE PRINCE DISCOGRAPHY (work in progress ^^): https://sites.google.com/...scography/
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #12 posted 01/14/21 11:57pm

ForceofNature

Remastering just means a new tape transfer and processes like EQ and compression (ideally not too much compression lol) to tweak the overall sound of the already-mixed recording. The Hallway Speech version was mastered, however the source of the tape was clearly not first gen, or anywhere near close to that, resulting in a murkier sound overall than the original album version


Not even the best remastering processes can fix a bad mix, or a tape transfer taken from a high gen source, even though it can certainly help lesson their faults to at least a little extent

The album version remaster was taken from a high-resolution digital transfer of the original analog master tapes, the Hallway Speech version was transferred via God knows where lol it clearly doesn't sound like a first gen source to me. More like a tape of a tape of a tape

[Edited 1/15/21 0:04am]

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #13 posted 01/15/21 6:50am

JoeyCococo

databank said:

^ I forgot to reply about the difference between the proper album and the singles' sound.

.

Prince had Josh Welton remaster PR before he died. WB chose to respect P's wishes and use this. The edits, mixes and b-sides, however, were remastered posthumously by Bernie Grundman, who considered one of the best mastering engineers in the world. Predictably, young Welton went for loudness wars and old Grundman went for a little more subtelty.

Databank, I agree with all you have said. After hearing how great a job they did with the SOTT album, I really hope they can do something for the Purple Rain album. SOTT sounds new to me. Leading up to the Super Deluxe set, I was sure I would spend most of my time on the vault material. I am surprised how often I've returned to the remastered original album. Truly amazing. I feel they can do a great remaster of Purple Rain.

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #14 posted 01/19/21 4:03pm

ForceofNature

Thankfully Purple Rain had a decent hi-res transfer done via HD Tracks a while back, however I am definitely down for a bit of modernization in the form of a bass-frequency laden, properly EQ'd mastering in the same vein as the 1999 remaster

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #15 posted 01/22/21 2:08am

ForceofNature

RODSERLING said:

No, and I think the old CD versions of any SDE original albums sound better.

Even SOTT?

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #16 posted 01/22/21 2:59am

JorisE73

RODSERLING said:

No, and I think the old CD versions of any SDE original albums sound better.


lol Wait until you hear the original vinyl of SOTT then compared to the horrible original SOTT CD.
The original vinyl still sounds great but the SDE CD's sound better and you can hear even more than on the original vinyl and especially than on the original CD.

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
« Previous topic  Next topic »
Forums > Prince: Music and More > were the vault tracks on Purple Rain Deluxe remastered?