independent and unofficial
Prince fan community
Welcome! Sign up or enter username and password to remember me
Forum jump
Forums > Prince: Music and More > Flashback: Reappraissal of "Under the Cherry Moon"
« Previous topic  Next topic »
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
Author

Tweet     Share

Message
Thread started 03/30/03 9:42pm

NuPwrSoul

Flashback: Reappraissal of "Under the Cherry Moon"

Posted here and elsewhere in the past but deserves a repost.

http://archive.salon.com/...9tayl.html

A.F.R.O.-.Deco
Prince's unfairly maligned second film mixes
swank screwball comedy with uptown sass.
by Charles Taylor



The luxurious settings of 1930s movies were less the province of the characters who could afford them than the ones who knew how to have the most fun. For all their art-deco elegance, the comedies and musicals of the era were populated by the sort of earthy performers you wouldn't expect to find on the social register. Cruising through the plush, satiny settings with an air of cheerful disrespect, Mae West, Jean Harlow, Ginger Rogers and others kept all the wealth on display from seeming like just cold cash. In contrast to stiff swells determined to be tastefully discreet about their bucks, the wisecracking stars most popular with Depression audiences acted out an unabashed fantasy of finding yourself in the chips.

A gloss on '30s movies that combines lowdown comedy with high-fashion style, Prince's "Under the Cherry Moon" (1986) was not what anybody expected as a follow-up to the hit "Purple Rain," although it's a much more enjoyable movie. "Under the Cherry Moon" isn't in the same class as "Top Hat," "She Done Him Wrong" or "Dinner at Eight," but Prince captures the essence of '30s comedies better than any of the directors (from Peter Bogdanovich to Woody Allen) who have slavishly imitated them. The movie has a casual, tossed-off approach and an air of impudent swank. If Becky Johnston's script proceeds more by flourishes than plot development, she still includes plenty of snappy repartee. And Prince was lucky enough to have the benefit of Richard Sylbert's production design and Michael Ballhaus' cinematography, which bring the lush, silvery look of '30s movies into the age of Versace and rock 'n' roll.

When Prince appeared in the early '80s, the essence of his appeal lay in the way his outrageously sexual image flouted the new conservatism of American society (it was a Prince song that prompted a shocked Tipper Gore to found the Parents Music Resource Center). Every enjoyable movie fantasy is rooted in some emotional or cultural reality, and here that reality is the Reagan era, with its agenda of relegating wealth and privilege to a chosen few. But, in place of speechifying, the movie's cultural nose-thumbing expresses itself as a dedication to the principle of fun.

"Under the Cherry Moon" is a fantasia of what might have happened if blacks in classic Hollywood comedy hadn't been relegated to playing maids and bellhops. Prince and the gifted and debonair Jerome Benton (he was Morris Day's sidekick in "Purple Rain") play a pair of gigolos loose on the French Riviera and insinuating themselves into the playground of rich whites. The sassiness of Mae West and Jean Harlow here translates into the jivey put-ons of a pair of slick black hustlers. As Christopher and his partner Tricky, Prince and Benton are something like Bob Hope and Bing Crosby doing Amos and Andy. (And if you know Amos and Andy only in disrepute, you probably don't know about the program's clever, punning verbal humor, like the great line "I not only denies the allegation, but I resents the allegator!") The difference is, Prince and Benton are nobody's patsies. Everyone who deals with them winds up feeling three steps behind, just as the poor straights who tried to have a conversation with Groucho or Chico did. When their landlady (the comely Emannuelle Sallet) tells them that Tricky's charms will no longer suffice to pay the rent, the two of them sink to their knees and become a pair of po' little orphan boys, begging not to get thrown out in the cold, mean streets.

Prince and Benton's antics are a form of subversive blackface. In the '20s and '30s, rich New York whites headed to Harlem for what they regarded as chic slumming. In "Under the Cherry Moon," the slums make house calls on the Vanity Fair set. Throughout the movie, whenever Prince wants to bait stuffy white people (or just have a little fun), he abandons his natural sexy speaking voice for a high-pitched black dialect. In one scene Christopher and Tricky, dining in a fancy restaurant with a tycoon's daughter (Kristin Scott Thomas, in her movie debut) they've set their sights on, make her read a phrase they've written out: "Wrecka Stow." To the pair's whooping delight, Thomas (who, with her tart comic delivery is as game as she is beautiful) pronounces it in her flawless English accent, and when she demands to know what it means, they tell her, "If you wanted to buy a Sam Cooke album, where would you go?"

Maybe because his sexuality had been the subject of speculation, Prince makes a grand joke out of his doe-eyed swanning. Wittily costumed in a series of ensembles that includes high-heeled boots, cut-to-the-waist jackets, beaded bandannas and skin-tight sequined pants, he asks the camera to drink in every primped and pomaded inch. At one point he sits in the bathtub wearing a bolero hat while Benton showers rose petals on him. The two of them conduct their partnership as an endless round of flirtations and flare-ups (too good-spirited to be homophobic), even falling into a couple of eye-flashing clinches. (The real drama queen here is Steven Berkoff, in one of his reliably disgraceful performances, as Scott Thomas' father. He makes his entrance in a white suit leading a big trophy dog on a leash and greets his daughter with a mincing, "Hello Kitten, how's the prettiest girl on the Côte d'Azur?" Oh, Mary!) But when he wants to be, Prince is an ace seducer. The movie's sexiest scene comes when he and Scott Thomas are talking on the phone, lying on their respective beds, not doing much more than listening to each other's breathing. And when he takes her to his seaside grotto, there's a lovely superimposed shot where the two of them appear to be making love inside her outstretched hand.

The bad buzz about "Under the Cherry Moon" began a week into the shoot when Prince fired director Mary Lambert (who had made a name directing videos for Madonna) and took over. His direction is a little all over the place. At times he seems to have gotten swept up in the movie's party escapades and the parade of scenemakers floating by the camera. The big set piece, Scott Thomas' birthday garden party, captures the slightly tipsy feel that pervades the film. But sometimes it's as important for a director to provide the right spirit as it is to be precise, and the most important thing to Prince here seems to be to keep us entertained. The stylish, slightly unsteady whirl of "Under the Cherry Moon" is like watching a '30s movie while slipping into an afternoon nap and having it become part of your dreams. It doesn't even wreck the fun when Prince moves from comedy to romantic melodrama in the last half-hour: His dreams just seem to have led him into another movie. And the comic tone is restored in the number ("Mountains") that ends the picture: Prince and the Revolution performing the song direct from heaven. Life is a parade, Christopher says. So's the movie. Prince wants to ride atop the float, receiving the crowd's adulation, but he's also larking about down in the street, happy to be one of the clowns.

SALON | Sept. 29, 1998

EDIT THE CREDIT.
[This message was edited Sun Mar 30 21:52:02 PST 2003 by NuPwrSoul]
"That...magic, the start of something revolutionary-the Minneapolis Sound, we should cherish it and not punish prince for not being able to replicate it."-Dreamshaman32
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #1 posted 03/30/03 9:46pm

rdhull

avatar

Thanks for this redeux Nu!

.
[This message was edited Sun Mar 30 21:47:30 PST 2003 by rdhull]
"Climb in my fur."
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #2 posted 03/30/03 9:58pm

CalhounSq

avatar

Thank you NPS!! I'd never read this. In fact I didn't know a positive review of this film existed lol

... but Prince captures the essence of '30s comedies better than any of the directors (from Peter Bogdanovich to Woody Allen) who have slavishly imitated them.


He better have this quote framed & on a wall somewhere biggrin

Prince and the gifted and debonair Jerome Benton


I had no idea 'Rome was gifted, y'all!! lol

...he asks the camera to drink in every primped and pomaded inch.


This is GREAT... biggrin
heart prince I never met you, but I LOVE you & I will forever!! Thank you for being YOU - my little Princey, the best to EVER do it prince heart
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #3 posted 03/30/03 10:16pm

NuPwrSoul

CalhounSq said:

Thank you NPS!! I'd never read this. In fact I didn't know a positive review of this film existed lol

... but Prince captures the essence of '30s comedies better than any of the directors (from Peter Bogdanovich to Woody Allen) who have slavishly imitated them.


He better have this quote framed & on a wall somewhere biggrin

Prince and the gifted and debonair Jerome Benton


I had no idea 'Rome was gifted, y'all!! lol


Yeah it's a bit over the top, but there are some interesting points in there that are often overlooked in Prince's work, especially his engaging the role of the Trickster character in black folk culture:

...The sassiness of Mae West and Jean Harlow here translates into the jivey put-ons of a pair of slick black hustlers. As Christopher and his partner Tricky, Prince and Benton are something like Bob Hope and Bing Crosby doing Amos and Andy...

...Prince and Benton's antics are a form of subversive blackface...


And of course this is no where better illustrated than in the "wrecka stow" scene, which goes right along the whole "white people clap on the four" (DMSR), "white folk you're much too uptight" (The Bird), etc.:

...Throughout the movie, whenever Prince wants to bait stuffy white people (or just have a little fun), he abandons his natural sexy speaking voice for a high-pitched black dialect. In one scene Christopher and Tricky, dining in a fancy restaurant with a tycoon's daughter (Kristin Scott Thomas, in her movie debut) they've set their sights on, make her read a phrase they've written out: "Wrecka Stow." To the pair's whooping delight, Thomas (who, with her tart comic delivery is as game as she is beautiful) pronounces it in her flawless English accent, and when she demands to know what it means, they tell her, "If you wanted to buy a Sam Cooke album, where would you go?"...

Watching "Under the Cherry Moon" as the story of two black hustler/trickster figures making mockery of the stuffiness of upper class white culture, by flouting all the conservative notions of race, gender, and sexuality, opens the film up to a different viewing. Especially considering this came out at the height of Reagan's America.
"That...magic, the start of something revolutionary-the Minneapolis Sound, we should cherish it and not punish prince for not being able to replicate it."-Dreamshaman32
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #4 posted 03/31/03 12:56am

CalhounSq

avatar

NuPwrSoul said:

...Prince and Benton's antics are a form of subversive blackface...

...

Watching "Under the Cherry Moon" as the story of two black hustler/trickster figures making mockery of the stuffiness of upper class white culture, by flouting all the conservative notions of race, gender, and sexuality, opens the film up to a different viewing. Especially considering this came out at the height of Reagan's America.


Yea, the "subversive blackface" comment made me wanna watch it again w/ that on my mind. Very interesting, NPS, thanks for bringing it up!! biggrin

Another confession: I purchased UTCM for the first time along w/ SOTT... boxed I'm really on punishment now!!
heart prince I never met you, but I LOVE you & I will forever!! Thank you for being YOU - my little Princey, the best to EVER do it prince heart
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #5 posted 03/31/03 1:02am

mistermaxxx

the Story&Idea wasn't bad but the Whole Acting Cast just were Wack IMHO.Prince tried that Morris Day Bag on Himself&Folks didn't buy it from him&also for the First time anywhere Prince the Mystique Cat let His Guard down&was Seen as Corny with that Film.Nobody can't Sell that Film with Him as a Actor&that Scary Camera Work that still makes My Head Hurt from just remembering the Swings at the Movie House back in the day.
mistermaxxx
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #6 posted 03/31/03 7:10am

NuPwrSoul

It's just campy. In that vein, I actually find UTCM to be much less pretentious than the parts of Purple Rain where we are supposed to be serious about certain scenes.
"That...magic, the start of something revolutionary-the Minneapolis Sound, we should cherish it and not punish prince for not being able to replicate it."-Dreamshaman32
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #7 posted 03/31/03 7:18am

Handclapsfinga
snapz

woot! yay, props 4 utcm!!! i don't see why folks diss this movie so much. it's pure camp and just fun as hell!!!

...and that sez what? horns
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #8 posted 03/31/03 7:18am

Handclapsfinga
snapz

mistermaxxx said:

the Story&Idea wasn't bad but the Whole Acting Cast just were Wack IMHO.Prince tried that Morris Day Bag on Himself&Folks didn't buy it from him&also for the First time anywhere Prince the Mystique Cat let His Guard down&was Seen as Corny with that Film.Nobody can't Sell that Film with Him as a Actor&that Scary Camera Work that still makes My Head Hurt from just remembering the Swings at the Movie House back in the day.

(tank girl voice)...well, that's a bore...
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #9 posted 03/31/03 7:20am

Handclapsfinga
snapz

NuPwrSoul said:

In that vein, I actually find UTCM to be much less pretentious than the parts of Purple Rain where we are supposed to be serious about certain scenes.

exactly. i find myself actually laughin at the "serious" points of the film, anyway...
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #10 posted 03/31/03 12:11pm

thechronic

avatar

the acting sucked man yall try to make prince out to be a God...it sucked admit it!
" could I be... the most beautiful man in the world! plain to see, i"m the reason that God made a man!"UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN GRADUATE! VERY PRESTIGIOUS!
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #11 posted 03/31/03 12:53pm

Handclapsfinga
snapz

thechronic said:

the acting sucked man yall try to make prince out to be a God...it sucked admit it!



wave
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #12 posted 03/31/03 12:55pm

Supernova

avatar

lol!!! @ Dansa!
This post not for the wimp contingent. All whiny wusses avert your eyes.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #13 posted 03/31/03 1:07pm

gypsyfire

avatar

NuPwrSoul said:

Posted here and elsewhere in the past but deserves a repost.

http://archive.salon.com/...9tayl.html

A.F.R.O.-.Deco
Prince's unfairly maligned second film mixes
swank screwball comedy with uptown sass.
by Charles Taylor



The luxurious settings of 1930s movies were less the province of the characters who could afford them than the ones who knew how to have the most fun. For all their art-deco elegance, the comedies and musicals of the era were populated by the sort of earthy performers you wouldn't expect to find on the social register. Cruising through the plush, satiny settings with an air of cheerful disrespect, Mae West, Jean Harlow, Ginger Rogers and others kept all the wealth on display from seeming like just cold cash. In contrast to stiff swells determined to be tastefully discreet about their bucks, the wisecracking stars most popular with Depression audiences acted out an unabashed fantasy of finding yourself in the chips.

A gloss on '30s movies that combines lowdown comedy with high-fashion style, Prince's "Under the Cherry Moon" (1986) was not what anybody expected as a follow-up to the hit "Purple Rain," although it's a much more enjoyable movie. "Under the Cherry Moon" isn't in the same class as "Top Hat," "She Done Him Wrong" or "Dinner at Eight," but Prince captures the essence of '30s comedies better than any of the directors (from Peter Bogdanovich to Woody Allen) who have slavishly imitated them. The movie has a casual, tossed-off approach and an air of impudent swank. If Becky Johnston's script proceeds more by flourishes than plot development, she still includes plenty of snappy repartee. And Prince was lucky enough to have the benefit of Richard Sylbert's production design and Michael Ballhaus' cinematography, which bring the lush, silvery look of '30s movies into the age of Versace and rock 'n' roll.

When Prince appeared in the early '80s, the essence of his appeal lay in the way his outrageously sexual image flouted the new conservatism of American society (it was a Prince song that prompted a shocked Tipper Gore to found the Parents Music Resource Center). Every enjoyable movie fantasy is rooted in some emotional or cultural reality, and here that reality is the Reagan era, with its agenda of relegating wealth and privilege to a chosen few. But, in place of speechifying, the movie's cultural nose-thumbing expresses itself as a dedication to the principle of fun.

"Under the Cherry Moon" is a fantasia of what might have happened if blacks in classic Hollywood comedy hadn't been relegated to playing maids and bellhops. Prince and the gifted and debonair Jerome Benton (he was Morris Day's sidekick in "Purple Rain") play a pair of gigolos loose on the French Riviera and insinuating themselves into the playground of rich whites. The sassiness of Mae West and Jean Harlow here translates into the jivey put-ons of a pair of slick black hustlers. As Christopher and his partner Tricky, Prince and Benton are something like Bob Hope and Bing Crosby doing Amos and Andy. (And if you know Amos and Andy only in disrepute, you probably don't know about the program's clever, punning verbal humor, like the great line "I not only denies the allegation, but I resents the allegator!") The difference is, Prince and Benton are nobody's patsies. Everyone who deals with them winds up feeling three steps behind, just as the poor straights who tried to have a conversation with Groucho or Chico did. When their landlady (the comely Emannuelle Sallet) tells them that Tricky's charms will no longer suffice to pay the rent, the two of them sink to their knees and become a pair of po' little orphan boys, begging not to get thrown out in the cold, mean streets.

Prince and Benton's antics are a form of subversive blackface. In the '20s and '30s, rich New York whites headed to Harlem for what they regarded as chic slumming. In "Under the Cherry Moon," the slums make house calls on the Vanity Fair set. Throughout the movie, whenever Prince wants to bait stuffy white people (or just have a little fun), he abandons his natural sexy speaking voice for a high-pitched black dialect. In one scene Christopher and Tricky, dining in a fancy restaurant with a tycoon's daughter (Kristin Scott Thomas, in her movie debut) they've set their sights on, make her read a phrase they've written out: "Wrecka Stow." To the pair's whooping delight, Thomas (who, with her tart comic delivery is as game as she is beautiful) pronounces it in her flawless English accent, and when she demands to know what it means, they tell her, "If you wanted to buy a Sam Cooke album, where would you go?"

Maybe because his sexuality had been the subject of speculation, Prince makes a grand joke out of his doe-eyed swanning. Wittily costumed in a series of ensembles that includes high-heeled boots, cut-to-the-waist jackets, beaded bandannas and skin-tight sequined pants, he asks the camera to drink in every primped and pomaded inch. At one point he sits in the bathtub wearing a bolero hat while Benton showers rose petals on him. The two of them conduct their partnership as an endless round of flirtations and flare-ups (too good-spirited to be homophobic), even falling into a couple of eye-flashing clinches. (The real drama queen here is Steven Berkoff, in one of his reliably disgraceful performances, as Scott Thomas' father. He makes his entrance in a white suit leading a big trophy dog on a leash and greets his daughter with a mincing, "Hello Kitten, how's the prettiest girl on the Côte d'Azur?" Oh, Mary!) But when he wants to be, Prince is an ace seducer. The movie's sexiest scene comes when he and Scott Thomas are talking on the phone, lying on their respective beds, not doing much more than listening to each other's breathing. And when he takes her to his seaside grotto, there's a lovely superimposed shot where the two of them appear to be making love inside her outstretched hand.

The bad buzz about "Under the Cherry Moon" began a week into the shoot when Prince fired director Mary Lambert (who had made a name directing videos for Madonna) and took over. His direction is a little all over the place. At times he seems to have gotten swept up in the movie's party escapades and the parade of scenemakers floating by the camera. The big set piece, Scott Thomas' birthday garden party, captures the slightly tipsy feel that pervades the film. But sometimes it's as important for a director to provide the right spirit as it is to be precise, and the most important thing to Prince here seems to be to keep us entertained. The stylish, slightly unsteady whirl of "Under the Cherry Moon" is like watching a '30s movie while slipping into an afternoon nap and having it become part of your dreams. It doesn't even wreck the fun when Prince moves from comedy to romantic melodrama in the last half-hour: His dreams just seem to have led him into another movie. And the comic tone is restored in the number ("Mountains") that ends the picture: Prince and the Revolution performing the song direct from heaven. Life is a parade, Christopher says. So's the movie. Prince wants to ride atop the float, receiving the crowd's adulation, but he's also larking about down in the street, happy to be one of the clowns.

SALON | Sept. 29, 1998

EDIT THE CREDIT.
[This message was edited Sun Mar 30 21:52:02 PST 2003 by NuPwrSoul]


nod
I DON'T WANT TO BE NORMAL,because normal is part of the status quo,which I don't want to be a part of- Tori Amos
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #14 posted 03/31/03 1:56pm

NuPwrSoul

Handclapsfingasnapz said:

thechronic said:

the acting sucked man yall try to make prince out to be a God...it sucked admit it!



wave


LMAO lol
"That...magic, the start of something revolutionary-the Minneapolis Sound, we should cherish it and not punish prince for not being able to replicate it."-Dreamshaman32
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #15 posted 03/31/03 2:07pm

mltijchr

avatar

Good thread, NPS..


Maybe 1 of the bigger reasons "Cherry Moon" got dissed so much was that as it came "so soon" after Purple Rain, a lot of people thought it would/should be like his 1st movie. There seemed to be this "Purple Rain sequel" expectation from many, even though- clearly- the movie had virtually no connections with its predesessor. So, it seems a lot of people had.. misplaced expectations about what they thought this film should be.

It seems like all those "casual/new fans" who jumped on the "Purple Rain" bandwagon, expected "Purple Rain II" but got "ATWIAD" instead. Many of those casual fans who were "straddling the fence" probably "fell away" from Prince when Parade came out because they saw it as an "extension" of ATWIAD, with the exception of the VERY poplular "Kiss"..
the 1 Prince song I think gets played THE MOST (which is the reason now I can hardly stand to hear this song, as danceable as it is). These "disgruntled", casual, temporary fans also probably contributed to the overall dissing of Cherry Moon.. not to mention most of the critics' reviews, who often said something to the effect that in Cherry Moon, Prince was just "mugging for the camera"..


I too would say that in some ways, Cherry Moon was "over the top" or "overdone"..
but really, it's the kind of movie you can enjoy more when you "suspend your belief" & enjoy the movie for the "escapism" that it is..

I give Prince credit for doing this movie the way
HE
wanted to; whether anyone else shared in or appreciated his "vision" of Cherry Moon.
Instead of being another "serious dramatic character" like he was in Purple Rain, Prince decided to play a character who was more often trippin' & buggin' out than not. Even though he was technically "playing a character".. it was cool to see Prince laugh & act stupid, something most people hadn't seen before then.


On a more personal note, I appreciate Cherry Moon because it was the 1st (& only?) movie that made me change my perception, my "fear" of death.. because before then, I
HAD
been.. afraid to die..

Cherry Moon gave me the opportunity to re-examine this.. "fear" I had.. & not too long after I'd seen that movie, I was.. much less afraid to die.


Finally, whatever anyone thinks of the movie, most agree that the music from the film- the album itself- is very good, whether you associate the album to the film, or not (& really, who could separate 1 from the other?) I've said many times that Parade is my 2nd favorite album-
right after Dirty Mind-
& the music, to me, adds more "depth" to this already..
"unconventional" movie..


(memo to self: rent Under The Cherry Moon.. SOON.)
I'll see you tonight..
in ALL MY DREAMS..
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #16 posted 04/01/03 2:34am

CalhounSq

avatar

Handclapsfingasnapz said:

thechronic said:

the acting sucked man yall try to make prince out to be a God...it sucked admit it!



wave


evillol evillol evillol
heart prince I never met you, but I LOVE you & I will forever!! Thank you for being YOU - my little Princey, the best to EVER do it prince heart
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
« Previous topic  Next topic »
Forums > Prince: Music and More > Flashback: Reappraissal of "Under the Cherry Moon"