independent and unofficial
Prince fan community
Welcome! Sign up or enter username and password to remember me
Forum jump
Forums > Prince: Music and More > Prince album ratings if u were a critic
« Previous topic  Next topic »
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
Author

Tweet     Share

Message
Thread started 07/14/10 9:44pm

dandeeland

Prince album ratings if u were a critic

If you were a critic and rated Prince's album out from 1-5 stars with 5 being the highest how would your grading come out? Just for fun.

For You - 3

Prince - 3

Dirty Mind - 3.5

Controversy - 3.5

1999 - 5

Purple Rain - 5

Around the World in a Day - 4

Parade - 2.5

Sign o' the Times 5

Lovesexy 3

Batman - 3.5

Graffiti Bridge - 3

Diamonds and Pearls - 4

0+> - 5

Come - 2

Black Album - 3

Gold - 5

Chaos and Disorder - 4.5

Emancipation - 3

New Power Soul - 1

Rave un2 the Joy Fantastic - 2.5

The Rainbow Children - 2

News - 1

Musicology - 3

3121 - 2.5

Planet Earth - 3

Lotusflower - 3

20ten - 2.5

My five star ratings came out to be

1999

Purple Rain

Sign o' the Times

0+>

Gold

4 Star

Around the World in a Day

Diamonds and Pearls

Chaos and Disorder

The rest of his albums to me were average or less. Curious to see your thoughts

[Edited 7/14/10 21:45pm]

[Edited 7/14/10 21:46pm]

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #1 posted 07/15/10 3:04am

Huggiebear

avatar

dandeeland said:

If you were a critic and rated Prince's album out from 1-5 stars with 5 being the highest how would your grading come out? Just for fun.

Scale

5 Classic

4 Excellent

3 Good

2 Mediocre

1 Tragic

0 It has to be the Rainbow children

For You - 3.5

Prince - 4

Dirty Mind - 5

Controversy - 4.5

1999 - 5

Purple Rain - 5

Around the World in a Day - 3

Parade - 5

Sign o' the Times 5

Lovesexy 5

Batman -4.5

Graffiti Bridge - 4

Diamonds and Pearls - 4

prince - 5

Goldnigga - 1

Come - 4.5

Black Album - 4

Exodus - 3

Gold - 5

Chaos and Disorder - 2

Emancipation - 4

Crystal Ball - 4.5

The Truth - 2

Kamasutra - 1

New Power Soul - 2

Rave un2 the Joy Fantastic - 3

The Rainbow Children - 0

ONA - 2

ONA LIVE -1.5

News - 1

Musicology - 2.5

3121 - 4

Planet Earth - 3

Indigo Nights 2.5

Lotusflower - 4

20ten - 4

Complimations

Hits/Bsides 5

Very Best of 4

The Ultimate 5

The rest of his albums to me were average or less. Curious to see your thoughts

[Edited 7/14/10 21:45pm]

[Edited 7/14/10 21:46pm]

[Edited 7/15/10 3:04am]

[Edited 7/15/10 3:06am]

So what are u going 2 do? R u just gonna sit there and watch? I'm not gonna stop until the war is over. Its gonna take a long time
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #2 posted 07/15/10 3:24am

JoHANSOLO

For You - 3

Prince - 3

Dirty Mind - 4

Controversy - 4

1999 - 3,5

Purple Rain - 4

Around the World in a Day - 3

Parade - 4

Sign o' the Times - 4,5

Lovesexy - 5

Batman - 3

Graffiti Bridge - 3

Diamonds and Pearls - 4

prince - 4

Goldnigga - 3
Come - 3,5

Black Album - 4

Exodus - 2

Gold - 3,5

Chaos and Disorder - 2,5

Emancipation - 2,5

Crystal Ball - 3

The Truth - 2,5

Kamasutra - 2

New Power Soul - 2,5

Rave un2 the Joy Fantastic - 2,5

The Rainbow Children - 5

ONA - 3

ONA LIVE - 2,5

News - 1,5

Musicology - 3

3121 - 3

Planet Earth - 2,5
Indigo Nights - 2

Lotusflower - 3,5
MPLSound - 3

20ten - 4

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #3 posted 07/15/10 6:01am

Tame

avatar

"For You," is my favorite album of all time....Thank U Prince....this record is....

"Simply....Rose Throwing." cool

"The Lion Sleeps Tonight...
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #4 posted 07/15/10 6:07am

3chainsofgold

For You - 3

Prince - 4

Dirty Mind - 5

Controversy - 4

1999 - 5

Purple Rain - 5

Around the World in a Day - 5

Parade - 5

Sign o' the Times 5

Lovesexy 5

Batman -4

Graffiti Bridge - 3

Diamonds and Pearls - 5

Symbol- 3

Goldnigga - 1

Come - 4

Black Album - 4

Exodus - 2

Gold - 4

Chaos and Disorder - 1

Emancipation - 4

Crystal Ball - 2

The Truth - 2

Kamasutra - 1

New Power Soul - 2

Rave un2 the Joy Fantastic - 2

The Rainbow Children - 4

ONA - 2

ONA LIVE -1

News - 1

Musicology - 2

3121 - 2

Planet Earth - 1

Indigo Nights 1

Lotusflower - 2

20ten - 0

[Edited 7/15/10 6:08am]

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #5 posted 07/15/10 6:42am

govinda

avatar

"Goodness will guide us if Love is inside us"
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #6 posted 07/15/10 6:54am

Romeoblu

For You - 3

Prince - 4

Dirty Mind - 4

Controversy -4

1999 - 5

Purple Rain -5

ATWIAD - 5

Parade - 5

SOTT - 5

The Black Album - 5

Lovesexy - 5

Batman - 4

Graffiti Bridge - 3.5

Diamonds And Paerls - 4

Symbol - 3.5

Come - 3.5

TGE - 4

Chaos - 3

Emancipation - 3.5

The Truth - 2.5

Cystal Ball - 3.5

Rave - 3

The Rainbow Children - 3.5

Xpectation - 2.5

ONA - 2

NEWS - 2

Choc Invasion - 2.5

Slaughter House - 2

Musicology - 3.5

3121 - 4

Planet Earth - 3.5

Lotusflow3r - 4

Mplsound - 4

20ten - 4

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #7 posted 07/15/10 7:04am

TheSkinMechani
c

For You - 0

Prince - 1

Dirty Mind - 2

Controversy -2

1999 - 3

Purple Rain -5

ATWIAD - 5

Parade - 5

SOTT - 5

The Black Album - 2

Lovesexy - 4

Batman - 2

Graffiti Bridge - 2

Diamonds And Pearls - 2

Symbol - 2

Come - 2

Gold Exp. - 2

Chaos Disorder - 2

Emancipation - 1

The Truth - 1

Rave - 2

The Rainbow Children - 2

Xpectation - 0

ONA - 0

NEWS - 0

Chocolate Invasion - 0

Slaughter House - 0

Musicology - 0

3121 - 0

Planet Earth - 0

Lotusflow3r/Mplsound - 1

20ten - 0


[Edited 7/15/10 7:11am]

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #8 posted 07/15/10 7:21am

irreverence

avatar

For You - 3

Prince - 3

Dirty Mind - 3.5

Controversy - 4

1999 - 5

Purple Rain - 5

Around the World in a Day - 4

Parade - 5

Sign o' the Times 5

Lovesexy 5

Batman - 3

Graffiti Bridge - 3

Diamonds and Pearls - 3

0 > - 3

Come - 3

Black Album - 3

Gold - 3

Chaos and Disorder - 4

Emancipation - 3

New Power Soul - 2

Rave un2 the Joy Fantastic - 3

The Rainbow Children - 5

News - 4

Musicology - 4

3121 - 4

Planet Earth - 3

Lotusflower - 5

MPLSound - 4

20ten - ?

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #9 posted 07/15/10 7:45am

oscar73

avatar

dandeeland said:

If you were a critic and rated Prince's album out from 1-5 stars with 5 being the highest how would your grading come out? Just for fun.

For You - 3

Prince - 3

Dirty Mind - 3

Controversy - 3.5

1999 - 10

Purple Rain - 5

Around the World in a Day - 4

Parade - 2.5

Sign o' the Times 5

Lovesexy 4

Batman - 3.5

Graffiti Bridge - 3

Diamonds and Pearls - 4

0+> - 3

Come - 2

Black Album - 10!!

Gold - 5

Chaos and Disorder - 3

Emancipation - 3

New Power Soul - 2.5

Rave un2 the Joy Fantastic - 2.5

The Rainbow Children - 10

News - 5

Musicology - 3

3121 - 2.5

Planet Earth - 3

Lotusflower - 3

20ten - 3

thanks, Prince......
prince prince prince prince
flag flag flag flag flag flag flag flag
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #10 posted 07/15/10 9:36am

Empress

For You - 3

Prince - 3

Dirty Mind - 3.5

Controversy - 3.5

1999 - 4

Purple Rain - 4

Around the World in a Day - 3.5

Parade - 3

Sign o' the Times 5

Lovesexy 3

Batman - 3

Graffiti Bridge - 3

Diamonds and Pearls - 3.5

0+> - 4

Come - 3

Black Album - 4

Gold - 4

Chaos and Disorder - 3

Emancipation - 3

New Power Soul - 2.5

Rave un2 the Joy Fantastic - 2.5

The Rainbow Children - 5

News - 2

Musicology - 3.5

3121 - 3

Planet Earth - 3

Lotusflower - 3.5

20ten - can't say as I don't have it yet.

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #11 posted 07/15/10 1:38pm

Alguy

For You - 1

Prince - 2

Dirty Mind - 5

Controversy - 3.5

1999 - 3

Purple Rain -5

ATWIAD - 3

Parade - 5

Sign O the Times - 4.5

The Black Album - 4.5

Lovesexy - 3.5

Batman - 4

Graffiti Bridge - 1

Diamonds And Pearls - 3.5

prince - 5

Come - 1

The Gold Experience - 5

Chaos and Disorder - 3

Emancipation - 3.5

The Truth - 2.5

Cystal Ball - 2

Rave Un2 the Joy Fantastic- 1

The Rainbow Children - 1

Xpectation - 3.5

One Nite Alone - 3

N.E.W.S - 0

The Chocolate Invasion - 0

The Slaughterhouse - 0

Musicology - 3.5

3121 - 4

Planet Earth - 3.5

Lotusflow3r - 4

Mplsound - 4

20ten - 4

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #12 posted 07/15/10 3:49pm

JoeTyler

For You : ** out of *****

Prince: *** out of *****

Dirty Mind: ***** out of *****

Controversy: *** out of *****

1999: ***** out of *****

Purple Rain: ***** out of *****

Around the World in a Day: *** out of *****

Parade: ***** out of *****

Dream Factory: ***** out of *****

Sign 'O' the Times: ***** out of *****

Black Album: **** out of *****

Lovesexy: *** out of *****

Batman: **** out of *****

Graffiti Bridge: *** out of *****

Diamonds and Pearls: **** out of *****

Love Symbol: ***** out of *****

Come: *** out of *****

Gold Experience: **** out of *****

Chaos & Disorder: ** out of *****

Emancipation: ** out of *****

New Power Soul: ** out of *****

The Truth: *** out of *****

Rave Into the Joy Fantastic: ** out of *****

The Rainbow Children: *** out of *****

NEWS: ** out of *****

One Nite Alone: ** out of *****

Chocolate Invasion / Slaughterhouse: **out of *****

Musicology: *** out of *****

3121: **** out of *****

Planet Earth: ** out of *****

Lotus Flower: *** out of *****

MPLSound: ** out of *****

20Ten: ** out of *****

tinkerbell
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #13 posted 07/15/10 10:19pm

StonedImmacula
te

avatar

blunt music She has robes and she has monkeys, lazy diamond studded flunkies.... music blunt
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #14 posted 07/15/10 10:26pm

kimrachell

For You - 2

Prince - 2

Dirty Mind - 3

Controversy - 4

1999 - 5

Purple Rain - 5

Around the World in a Day - 4

Parade - 3

Sign o' the Times 5

Lovesexy 4

Batman - 3

Graffiti Bridge - 4

Diamonds and Pearls - 5

0+> - 5

Come - 4

Black Album - 2

Gold - 5

Chaos and Disorder - 4

Emancipation - 5

New Power Soul - 3

Rave un2 the Joy Fantastic - 3

The Rainbow Children - 2

News - 1

Musicology - 3

3121 - 3

Planet Earth - 3

Lotusflower - 3

20ten - 3

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #15 posted 07/15/10 10:31pm

violetblues

For You - 3

Prince - 3

Dirty Mind - 5

Controversy - 5

1999 - 5

Purple Rain - 5

Around the World in a Day - 4

Parade - 5

Sign o' the Times 5

Lovesexy 3

Batman - 3

Graffiti Bridge - 2

Diamonds and Pearls - 2

0+> - 2

Come - 4

Black Album - 5

Gold - 2

Chaos and Disorder - 3

Emancipation - 2

New Power Soul - 2

Rave un2 the Joy Fantastic - 2

The Rainbow Children - 2

News - 2

Musicology - 2

3121 - 3

Planet Earth - 2

Lotusflower - 3

20ten - 2

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #16 posted 07/15/10 10:38pm

stillwaiting

I always change my mind with these type of lists, but I could not resist:

For You - 3.7

Prince - 4

Dirty Mind - 3.5

Controversy -4.9

1999 - 5

Purple Rain - 5

Around the World in a Day - 5

Parade - 5

Sign o' the Times 599,488,211,200,222,111...ok a little more than 5, but how I feel.

Lovesexy 5

Batman - 4

Graffiti Bridge - 4

Diamonds and Pearls - 3

0+> - 3.5

Come - 3.5

Black Album - 4.5

Gold - 4

Chaos and Disorder - 4.5

Emancipation - 3

New Power Soul - 2.8

Rave un2 the Joy Fantastic -3

The Rainbow Children - 4.5

ONA 3.4

ONA Live 3.1

News - 2.2

Musicology - 3.5

3121 - 4

Planet Earth - 3.9

Lotusflower - 5

MPLS Sound 2.9

20ten - 3.2

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #17 posted 07/16/10 4:18am

Huggiebear

avatar

stillwaiting said:

I always change my mind with these type of lists, but I could not resist:

For You - 3.7

Prince - 4

Dirty Mind - 3.5

Controversy -4.9

1999 - 5

Purple Rain - 5

Around the World in a Day - 5

Parade - 5

Sign o' the Times 599,488,211,200,222,111...ok a little more than 5, but how I feel.

Lovesexy 5

Batman - 4

Graffiti Bridge - 4

Diamonds and Pearls - 3

0+> - 3.5

Come - 3.5

Black Album - 4.5

Gold - 4

Chaos and Disorder - 4.5

Emancipation - 3

New Power Soul - 2.8

Rave un2 the Joy Fantastic -3

The Rainbow Children - 4.5

ONA 3.4

ONA Live 3.1

News - 2.2

Musicology - 3.5

3121 - 4

Planet Earth - 3.9

Lotusflower - 5

MPLS Sound 2.9

20ten - 3.2

Nothing wrong with that, let it out brother8-)

So what are u going 2 do? R u just gonna sit there and watch? I'm not gonna stop until the war is over. Its gonna take a long time
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #18 posted 07/16/10 4:29am

leonciolm

avatar

For You - 2

Prince - 3

Dirty Mind - 3.5

Controversy - 3

1999 - 5

Purple Rain -5

ATWIAD - 4

Parade - 4

SOTT - 5

The Black Album - 4

Lovesexy - 3.5

Batman - 3

Graffiti Bridge - 3.5

Diamonds And Paerls - 3.5

Symbol - 3.5

Come - 4

TGE - 4

Chaos - 3

Emancipation - 3.5

The Truth - 2

Cystal Ball - 3.5

Rave - 3

The Rainbow Children - 5

Xpectation - 2

ONA - 2

NEWS - 2

Choc Invasion - 3.5

Slaughter House - 2

Musicology - 3.5

3121 - 4

Planet Earth - 2

Lotusflow3r - 2

Mplsound - 2.5

20ten - 3.5

cool

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
« Previous topic  Next topic »
Forums > Prince: Music and More > Prince album ratings if u were a critic