independent and unofficial
Prince fan community
Welcome! Sign up or enter username and password to remember me
Forum jump
Forums > Prince: Music and More > was prince the only black new romantic on the music scene?
« Previous topic  Next topic »
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
Author

Tweet     Share

Message
Thread started 03/28/10 12:15am

PurpleJane

avatar

was prince the only black new romantic on the music scene?

when prince came onto the uk pop scene with doves and purple rain, he was all glammed up in keeping with the new romantics look.
cor! he was the frilly vision in purple heart
but i dont remember any other black performers at the time that used this style, it did seem to be a white cultral thing and and the same goes for punk genre but princey embraced both
was there anyone else or was he unique?
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #1 posted 03/28/10 1:50am

MrGravyLumps

PurpleJane said:

when prince came onto the uk pop scene with doves and purple rain, he was all glammed up in keeping with the new romantics look.
cor! he was the frilly vision in purple heart
but i dont remember any other black performers at the time that used this style, it did seem to be a white cultral thing and and the same goes for punk genre but princey embraced both
was there anyone else or was he unique?


Oh, surely we can think of plenty more. What about these?

- Michael Jackson
- Smokey Robinson
- Regina Belle
- Whitney Houston
- George Benson

Each have their own style, not so similar to Prince of course. Remember Lionel Richie's "Say you, say me" from 1985-1986?
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #2 posted 03/28/10 4:18am

TheVoid

In my opinion there were quite a few of them.

Black artists are often defined as 'black artists' by the media. I doubt the members of Living Colour (despite their name having obvious racial overtones) wanted to be thought of as the 'black rock band', but rather a good rock band, period. But, the media defines them as such.

I would think Alan Thicke doesn't want to be thought of the white guy with 'soul' either though. lol
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #3 posted 03/28/10 5:11am

novabrkr

MrGravyLumps said:



Oh, surely we can think of plenty more. What about these?

- Michael Jackson
- Smokey Robinson
- Regina Belle
- Whitney Houston
- George Benson

Each have their own style, not so similar to Prince of course. Remember Lionel Richie's "Say you, say me" from 1985-1986?


Not "romantic". "New Romantics" was a stylistic and a musical movement in the mid-80s.
[Edited 3/28/10 5:12am]
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #4 posted 03/28/10 6:32am

lotusflw3r

in the UK bands of the New Romantic scene usually had a mix of white, black, male & female - so in many respects Prince & the Revolution fit this mold fairly well - he wasn't truly a New Romantic though - Funk Rock would be a better catch all term for his early to mid 80's work. Prince has always been to chameleon-like to be pigeon-holed to any one music style.

to animals in one sentence!
[Edited 3/28/10 6:33am]
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #5 posted 03/28/10 7:25am

NouveauDance

avatar

novabrkr said:


Not "romantic". "New Romantics" was a stylistic and a musical movement in the mid-80s.

lol

Anita Baker!
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #6 posted 03/28/10 3:06pm

violetskye

PurpleJane said:

when prince came onto the uk pop scene with doves and purple rain, he was all glammed up in keeping with the new romantics look.
cor! he was the frilly vision in purple heart
but i dont remember any other black performers at the time that used this style, it did seem to be a white cultral thing and and the same goes for punk genre but princey embraced both
was there anyone else or was he unique?


Don't forget Jessie Johnson, Playin that pink guitar!! I like it!! I like it!
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #7 posted 03/28/10 4:07pm

1725topp

The "New Romantic" style/movement, like any other style/movement, was merely a new interpretation of Punk or something else. With that said, one could say that the Black version or Black artists who were engaging or influenced by the "New Romantic" style were simply acting in the legacy of Little Richard, who may have been the first glam artist. And later you would have someone like Screamin' Jay Hawkins who added his own twist to what Little Richard was doing, and so on. Even Michael Jackson was wearing "make up" and shiny or more feminine attire. And let's not forget that Rick James was doing his own twist a few years before Prince. And even before that Parliament/Funkadelic was amalgamating soul/rock/glam styles.

Thus, I don't know if it would be accurate to call Prince a "New Romantic" because he was equally soul/R&B, equally Funk, equally "traditional" RnR, so to call him a "New Romantic" puts him into a singular category that he never was. Thus, the genius of Prince is that he was a dandy--one who used clothing and accessories as a way to make himself this hybrid but indefinable thing, which, then, kept him from being pigeonholed or limited in the type of music that he would produce/release.

Finally, to go socio-political, Prince was merely continuing in the line of Little Richard, making himself as feminine and as different/weird as possible so that he could get radio play on white stations while having just enough bass/bottom in his work to stay connected to black radio. So, to call Prince a "New Romantic" only is to gloss over or minimize all that he was doing. However, I will say that your premise is correct in that Prince was one of the few black artists of his time who was willing to go to battle with record companies, radio, magazines, and even fans as to what constitutes a “black” artist. Even Michael Jackson who became “the” pop icon, for the most part, crafted music that was more identifiable as soul/R&B, whereas Prince seems to have been more concerned with artistic freedom than with making songs or hits that could be easily promoted in a basic genre or category.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #8 posted 03/28/10 5:00pm

2elijah

TheVoid said:

In my opinion there were quite a few of them.

Black artists are often defined as 'black artists' by the media. I doubt the members of Living Colour (despite their name having obvious racial overtones) wanted to be thought of as the 'black rock band', but rather a good rock band, period. But, the media defines them as such.

I would think Alan Thicke doesn't want to be thought of the white guy with 'soul' either though. lol



That's baloney, because Black artists are defined by African-Americans as black artists as well, nothing wrong with that, and yes there's black guys that play rock, and have been defined as black rock groups by the black community and those outside the media. Thing is, rock was born from blues and gospel, so quite frankly, rock is rock. Not owned by anyone in particular, just a form of music passed down from artists to artists, and changed in many different forms along the way, over the years.
[Edited 3/28/10 17:01pm]
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #9 posted 03/29/10 7:09am

TheVoid

2elijah said:

TheVoid said:

In my opinion there were quite a few of them.

Black artists are often defined as 'black artists' by the media. I doubt the members of Living Colour (despite their name having obvious racial overtones) wanted to be thought of as the 'black rock band', but rather a good rock band, period. But, the media defines them as such.

I would think Alan Thicke doesn't want to be thought of the white guy with 'soul' either though. lol



That's baloney, because Black artists are defined by African-Americans as black artists as well, nothing wrong with that, and yes there's black guys that play rock, and have been defined as black rock groups by the black community and those outside the media. Thing is, rock was born from blues and gospel, so quite frankly, rock is rock. Not owned by anyone in particular, just a form of music passed down from artists to artists, and changed in many different forms along the way, over the years.
[Edited 3/28/10 17:01pm]


I just don't think Prince would have defined himself as a 'black' new wave anything. That's not to say he wasn't well aware of the tags placed on him--indeed his selection of a less than stellar drummer based on the guy's skin color (white) so that he'd have a multi-ethnic band shows he was quite aware of what he was doing. I'm just saying that if he were interviewed, he'd say , "I'm an artist" and not involve race in it at all. I think at Prince's level it would be as silly as Mozart saying "I'm a German artist", etc. etc.

At least early in Prince's career I think this was the case.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #10 posted 03/29/10 8:18am

erik319

avatar

lotusflw3r said:

in the UK bands of the New Romantic scene usually had a mix of white, black, male & female - so in many respects Prince & the Revolution fit this mold fairly well - he wasn't truly a New Romantic though - Funk Rock would be a better catch all term for his early to mid 80's work. Prince has always been to chameleon-like to be pigeon-holed to any one music style.

to animals in one sentence!
[Edited 3/28/10 6:33am]


lol
Tell you what though. I never understand that 'Chamelion' thing. They say it about Bowie. 'He's the chamelion of pop'. Eh? Chamelions are fantastic at blending in and disappearing into the background. Bowie & Prince certainly never did that...
blah blah blah
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #11 posted 03/29/10 12:54pm

lotusflw3r

"We Don't Like new wave! Bwa-hahaaa"

says it all really.

.....
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #12 posted 03/29/10 1:13pm

Marrk

avatar

Fuck me.rolleyes

New Romantics were all late 70's early 80's Brit bands and their fans. The Human League, Adam & The Ants, Duran Duran (When Stephen Duffy was a member), Spandau Ballet. All that stuff.

Just cause Prince wore a ruffled shirt and was a bit girly three years after the event doesn't make him part of that movement at all.

At all.
[Edited 3/29/10 13:16pm]
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #13 posted 03/29/10 6:49pm

aarontj

MrGravyLumps said:

PurpleJane said:

when prince came onto the uk pop scene with doves and purple rain, he was all glammed up in keeping with the new romantics look.
cor! he was the frilly vision in purple heart
but i dont remember any other black performers at the time that used this style, it did seem to be a white cultral thing and and the same goes for punk genre but princey embraced both
was there anyone else or was he unique?


Oh, surely we can think of plenty more. What about these?

- Michael Jackson
- Smokey Robinson
- Regina Belle
- Whitney Houston
- George Benson

Each have their own style, not so similar to Prince of course. Remember Lionel Richie's "Say you, say me" from 1985-1986?


MrGravyLumps Do you know what are the New Romantics (New Wave in America)? seems like: NO.
"I have so much love for Prince. But why don't they look at me that way"- MJ
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #14 posted 03/29/10 7:11pm

johnny2000

Not really a 'New Romantic' ... Phil Lynott

http://needlebeamcassette...lynott.jpg
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #15 posted 03/31/10 10:36pm

MrGravyLumps

aarontj said:

MrGravyLumps said:



Oh, surely we can think of plenty more. What about these?

- Michael Jackson
- Smokey Robinson
- Regina Belle
- Whitney Houston
- George Benson

Each have their own style, not so similar to Prince of course. Remember Lionel Richie's "Say you, say me" from 1985-1986?


MrGravyLumps Do you know what are the New Romantics (New Wave in America)? seems like: NO.



Yes, I'm familiar with the genre. I just got confused with the term, my silly mistake.

Not too many blacks come to mind when thinking about it. The only one I can think of is that dude with Boy George's Culture Club.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #16 posted 04/01/10 4:41am

Brofie

avatar

Almost everyone that responded needs an education on the new romantic movement at the 80s
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #17 posted 04/01/10 6:17am

errant

avatar

Brofie said:

Almost everyone that responded needs an education on the new romantic movement at the 80s



well go on, then....
"does my cock look fat in these jeans?"
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #18 posted 04/01/10 7:29am

vivid

MrGravyLumps said:

PurpleJane said:

when prince came onto the uk pop scene with doves and purple rain, he was all glammed up in keeping with the new romantics look.
cor! he was the frilly vision in purple heart
but i dont remember any other black performers at the time that used this style, it did seem to be a white cultral thing and and the same goes for punk genre but princey embraced both
was there anyone else or was he unique?


Oh, surely we can think of plenty more. What about these?

- Michael Jackson
- Smokey Robinson
- Regina Belle
- Whitney Houston
- George Benson

Each have their own style, not so similar to Prince of course. Remember Lionel Richie's "Say you, say me" from 1985-1986?



None of them were 'new romantics' lol
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #19 posted 04/01/10 7:32am

vivid

Marrk said:

Fuck me.rolleyes

New Romantics were all late 70's early 80's Brit bands and their fans. The Human League, Adam & The Ants, Duran Duran (When Stephen Duffy was a member), Spandau Ballet. All that stuff.

Just cause Prince wore a ruffled shirt and was a bit girly three years after the event doesn't make him part of that movement at all.

At all.
[Edited 3/29/10 13:16pm]


I was here in London at the time and it went on a little longer than that. Prince was of course not whollly new romantic, but he was part of it.

A ruffled shirt, lots of make-up and a bunch of synthesizers does kind of qualify you.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
« Previous topic  Next topic »
Forums > Prince: Music and More > was prince the only black new romantic on the music scene?