What are your thoughts/opinions on tonight's show? I liked the first singer, but everyone (so far) who has been on American Idol has not sounded good at all. They've been either singing off key, growling, etc., etc., not sounding the way they should. I'm not feeling most of the contestants this year, and it will be interesting to see what happens.

I know what you mean, Psycho. There has not been a musical "moment" yet tonight.

rubymoon53 said:

Agreed! I hate to say it, but this seems to be the WORST seaon of American Idol so far. I'm hoping that some of the contestants on the show are able to change my mind.

I liked the boi with the head band and the blind guy but something seems off with AI as of late...

ABeautifulOne said:

Agreed.

On a positive note, I do like Lil Rounds. I think she was the best contestant on the show tonight: was able to sing in pitch and not hit any bad notes, etc. etc. She's my favorite on the show so far.

i only watch the auditions,the only whole full season i watched is when fantasia was on,i think she was the best ever on american idol...so soulful like patti labelle.

I really liked the first guy. For some reason, he reminded me of a young George Michael. Maybe it was his vocal delivery.

As for the others, I wasn't wild about any of them. The guy with the head band has a great voice, but singing Meatloaf will not help you in this type of competition. The blind guy was ok. He has a great voice, but I wasn't crazy about his song choice either.

I liked the last girl. They kept saying she was the real deal and she was. My only complaint was that she needs to work on her diction. I think she would make an excellent gospel artist.

bambi777 said:

I liked Fantasia a lot too. Her first CD was pretty good.

daPrettyman said:

I liked the first and last singers too. They seemed to have the best vocal ability (so far) out of all of the contestants.

ABeautifulOne said:

that headband/hair was too hideous for any voice to salvage!

NDRU said:

I was sooo glad when they got rid of Tatiana. That girl gets on my last nerve. She is the biggest drama queen in American Idol history. When they voted her back on the show last night, I hollered out loud, "Nooooo, not that bitch!" I was cheering very loudly tonight when she got booted off. At least now I won't have to watch her stupid crying all the damn time. That gets old fast.

psychodelicide said:

I said the same thing. I was hoping they would give the big bald guy another chance (that sang the Hinder song). He has a really good voice.

psychodelicide said:

Honestly, Tatiana was the only reason why I was watching. Yes, she's annoying but there is something I find very attractive about her. She has a nice voice and she's unpredictable. She's an idiot for choosing the same song that got her booted off in the first place so it's her fault that she didn't get picked to be in the final 13. If she had of chosen a different song, chances are she would have made it through.

daPrettyman said:

I'm trying to think of who the bald guy was. I can never keep the names straight in the beginning.

kitbradley said:

Tatiana was so annoying to me that I guess I just didn't see any talent that she may have had. Love your signature, by the way.

I wasn't gonna watch the show this season if Tatiana made it in2 the Top 13.

sexxydancer said:

I don't blame you one bit!