Se7en said:

He might be the best of his generation, but if you're talking about all time, then he pales by comparison to most of his predecessors.

His claim to fame has always been his musicianship, not his lyrics.

I agree completely. But remember that songwriting includes lyrics and music - I think Prince is great at composing music; just not one of the best lyricists.

CrabalockerFishwife said:

Se7en said:

He might be the best of his generation, but if you're talking about all time, then he pales by comparison to most of his predecessors.

His claim to fame has always been his musicianship, not his lyrics.

I agree completely. But remember that songwriting includes lyrics and music - I think Prince is great at composing music; just not one of the best lyricists.

I agree. His musical compositions were genius. His lyrics left a lot to the imagination though. I guess his stubbornness wouldn't let anyone help his lyrics shine more than it did. He can write a good song or two lyrically though.

I love Prince but when it comes to songwriting i would choose Lennon/McCartney every other day over him ...

This subject is really subjective. Haha

jk

Well in a way...

I wouldn't say 'OF ALL TIME'

John Lennon

Stevie Wonder

Joni Mitchel

David Bowie

Bob Dylan

Kate Bush

Marvin Gaye

Smokey Robinson

(To Name a few of my favorites...)

SO many great lyricists!

Prince manages the double meaning of words pretty well. He has a theory to many of his songs that can often be taken many ways. I think he's definitely one of the best of THIS GENERATION. Definitely better than many from the era of the '80's' who were 'NEW COMERS'.

Yet, they are many great song writers, and many have been in the game longer and have greater skill.

I just appreciate good lyrics, and so many are able to accomplish that over the years!