independent and unofficial
Prince fan community
Welcome! Sign up or enter username and password to remember me
Forum jump
Forums > Prince: Music and More > Revolution Question
« Previous topic  Next topic »
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
Author

Tweet     Share

Message
Thread started 07/31/05 8:36am

southpark88

avatar

Revolution Question

This may sound like a dumb question, but in The Revolution, was it Wendy or Lisa that played keyboards? I am asking becaus my guitar teacher told me he used to date the keyboardist in 1985. I don't know if that is actually true or not.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #1 posted 07/31/05 8:41am

BorisFishpaw

avatar

Lisa played keyboards

and I think it's highly, highly unlikely that your guitar teacher would've
dated her (unless it was all in his head!)
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #2 posted 07/31/05 8:47am

Dewrede

avatar

Thought she's a lesbian confuse
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #3 posted 07/31/05 10:44am

squirrelgrease

avatar

Maybe the guitar teacher dated Matt Fink... wink
If prince.org were to be made idiot proof, someone would just invent a better idiot.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #4 posted 07/31/05 1:48pm

tookielv

squirrelgrease said:

Maybe the guitar teacher dated Matt Fink... wink


she said in the interviews that she used to go out with guys and also her and prince had a thing going on when she join the band. although no one knows for sure the nature of her personal life since she always been tight-lipped of it i think that she is a bi.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #5 posted 07/31/05 1:49pm

tookielv

tookielv said:

squirrelgrease said:

Maybe the guitar teacher dated Matt Fink... wink


she said in the interviews that she used to go out with guys and also her and prince had a thing going on when she join the band. although no one knows for sure the nature of her personal life since she always been tight-lipped of it i think that she is a bi.

also wanted to added wendy is the one is a full-fledge lesbian and i dont think that wendy has ever dated guys before.
[Edited 7/31/05 13:50pm]
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #6 posted 07/31/05 1:50pm

NouveauDance

avatar

squirrelgrease said:

Maybe the guitar teacher dated Matt Fink... wink


falloff
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #7 posted 07/31/05 7:30pm

southpark88

avatar

squirrelgrease said:

Maybe the guitar teacher dated Matt Fink... wink


My guitar teacher is a guy and I don't think he's gay.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #8 posted 07/31/05 7:37pm

sosgemini

avatar

tookielv said:

squirrelgrease said:

Maybe the guitar teacher dated Matt Fink... wink


she said in the interviews that she used to go out with guys and also her and prince had a thing going on when she join the band. although no one knows for sure the nature of her personal life since she always been tight-lipped of it i think that she is a bi.



news to me.....my understanding is that wendy and lisa were always an item...up until recently...about a year after their break-up lisa started dating someone else...she is currently in a long-term relationship with that same person...its good to see her happy again....

so, cant see when lisa would have the time to "date" anyone...those interview responces could have just been lisa's funny sense of humor....she tends to fuck around without letting people in on it..
Space for sale...
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #9 posted 07/31/05 9:49pm

tookielv

sosgemini said:

tookielv said:



she said in the interviews that she used to go out with guys and also her and prince had a thing going on when she join the band. although no one knows for sure the nature of her personal life since she always been tight-lipped of it i think that she is a bi.



news to me.....my understanding is that wendy and lisa were always an item...up until recently...about a year after their break-up lisa started dating someone else...she is currently in a long-term relationship with that same person...its good to see her happy again....

so, cant see when lisa would have the time to "date" anyone...those interview responces could have just been lisa's funny sense of humor....she tends to fuck around without letting people in on it..


yeah i agree sos lisa has the sense of humor while wendy has the motormouth lol

i always wondered is lisa a bi ( like if her current partner a guy or a girl?) since rumors of her and prince were involved sexually. i always think of her as annie heche to wendy's ellen wink

i always curious how long wendy and lisa have dated was it before or after they was fired from prince. i asking that because the original poster said that her guitarist dated lisa around 1985 and also that w&l might became lovers afterwards.

i think that w&l has a unique relationship because not only that they are still friends and also still music partners so i got the impression that the breakup was in amicable. i couldn't imagine the same with my ex-boyfriend.

i wondered is lisa's partner is famous as wendy's partner lisa chodenko sp?

i read somewhere that wendy and lisa still lives together and i wondered how their partners feel biggrin
[Edited 7/31/05 22:02pm]
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #10 posted 07/31/05 10:58pm

neronava

avatar

southpark88 said:

This may sound like a dumb question, but in The Revolution, was it Wendy or Lisa that played keyboards? I am asking becaus my guitar teacher told me he used to date the keyboardist in 1985. I don't know if that is actually true or not.


wow...just in case anyone asks you-Prince is his real name, and blah blah blah blah. How do these people get on this board (?)
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #11 posted 08/01/05 1:32am

sosgemini

avatar

neronava said:

southpark88 said:

This may sound like a dumb question, but in The Revolution, was it Wendy or Lisa that played keyboards? I am asking becaus my guitar teacher told me he used to date the keyboardist in 1985. I don't know if that is actually true or not.


wow...just in case anyone asks you-Prince is his real name, and blah blah blah blah. How do these people get on this board (?)


its a public access site...lets not judge others on their knowledge..we were all prince newborns at one time or another.....

lets celebrate that our family is growing instead of knocking em for trying...

k?
Space for sale...
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #12 posted 08/01/05 7:00am

tookielv

sosgemini said:

neronava said:



wow...just in case anyone asks you-Prince is his real name, and blah blah blah blah. How do these people get on this board (?)


its a public access site...lets not judge others on their knowledge..we were all prince newborns at one time or another.....

lets celebrate that our family is growing instead of knocking em for trying...

k?


I agreed. not everyone going to know wendy and lisa's names but still likes prince music and also people don't give a shit who played in his band either because they want to see prince. and often get them mixed up since they look so similar back then; their similar hair color etc etc. but a lot of people do noticed them more than other band member. hell even my family who likes the time more because they are pro-funk referred to them as being white girls played in prince band but in my family wendy always get more knowledge because she was a front woman and i still have to tell them her name and what have she done since she was fired from prince!
[Edited 8/1/05 7:05am]
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #13 posted 08/01/05 7:27am

JediMaster

avatar

First off, Lisa is not bisexual. She is a lesbian, and never dated Prince (this rumour may have started because of the outtake "Lisa"). W&L were an item before Wendy even joined the Revolution in 1984, and didn't break up until failry recently.

Perhaps this guitar teacher dated Gayle Chapman? She was Prince's keyboardist before Lisa. By 1985 she was long gone from Prince's band, but did she tell him she was his current keyboardist at the time? She might have told him she used to be in Prince's band at that point.
jedi

Do not hurry yourself in your spirit to become offended, for the taking of offense is what rests in the bosom of the stupid ones. (Ecclesiastes 7:9)
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #14 posted 08/01/05 8:20am

tookielv

JediMaster said:

First off, Lisa is not bisexual. She is a lesbian, and never dated Prince (this rumour may have started because of the outtake "Lisa"). W&L were an item before Wendy even joined the Revolution in 1984, and didn't break up until failry recently.

Perhaps this guitar teacher dated Gayle Chapman? She was Prince's keyboardist before Lisa. By 1985 she was long gone from Prince's band, but did she tell him she was his current keyboardist at the time? She might have told him she used to be in Prince's band at that point.


it said in possessed book that prince and lisa have a sexual thing going and people do sexual things without dating. why would alex hahn made that up especially if he got half of his sources from DMSR author Per Nielson? apparently lisa's parents must have knew about it because i read somewhere they disapproved prince or something and not because he is black because i guess they considered him to be a freak. I never said that prince and lisa dated i said that i believed they had something sexual and i don't care if you guys believed it or not. she said in the older interviews that she dated guys and it sounds to me like a straightfoward answer too and she wasn't joking. i still continued to believe that lisa is bi and wendy is a lesbian.


wendy joined the revolution in 1983, not 1984.

with all these sources i don't know whom to believe! damn i want a W&L autobiography!
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #15 posted 08/01/05 8:23am

tookielv

tookielv said:

JediMaster said:

First off, Lisa is not bisexual. She is a lesbian, and never dated Prince (this rumour may have started because of the outtake "Lisa"). W&L were an item before Wendy even joined the Revolution in 1984, and didn't break up until failry recently.

Perhaps this guitar teacher dated Gayle Chapman? She was Prince's keyboardist before Lisa. By 1985 she was long gone from Prince's band, but did she tell him she was his current keyboardist at the time? She might have told him she used to be in Prince's band at that point.


!

it said in possessed book that prince and lisa have a sexual thing going and people do sexual things without dating and hell they both liberals (at least prince more at the time). why would alex hahn made that up especially if he got half of his sources from DMSR author Per Nielson? apparently lisa's parents must have knew about it because i read somewhere they disapproved prince or something and not because he is black because i guess they considered him to be a freak. I never said that prince and lisa dated i said that i believed they had something sexual and i don't care if you guys believed it or not. she said in the older interviews that she dated guys and it sounds to me like a straightfoward answer too and she wasn't joking. i still continued to believe that lisa is bi and wendy is a lesbian.


wendy joined the revolution in 1983, not 1984.

with all these sources i don't know whom to believe! damn i want a W&L autobiography![/
[Edited 8/1/05 8:24am]
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #16 posted 08/01/05 5:53pm

squirrelgrease

avatar

southpark88 said:

squirrelgrease said:

Maybe the guitar teacher dated Matt Fink... wink


My guitar teacher is a guy and I don't think he's gay.


Fink's not gay either.
If prince.org were to be made idiot proof, someone would just invent a better idiot.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #17 posted 08/01/05 6:58pm

sosgemini

avatar

JediMaster said:

First off, Lisa is not bisexual. She is a lesbian, and never dated Prince (this rumour may have started because of the outtake "Lisa"). W&L were an item before Wendy even joined the Revolution in 1984, and didn't break up until failry recently.

Perhaps this guitar teacher dated Gayle Chapman? She was Prince's keyboardist before Lisa. By 1985 she was long gone from Prince's band, but did she tell him she was his current keyboardist at the time? She might have told him she used to be in Prince's band at that point.



for the record, lisa has never publically stated this...wendy has.....well, she didnt but her new lisa did...

lisa coleman keeps her sh*t private....in a world full of britney's, bobby's and madonnas...its a breath of fresh air ... wink
Space for sale...
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #18 posted 08/01/05 8:57pm

tookielv

sosgemini said:

JediMaster said:

First off, Lisa is not bisexual. She is a lesbian, and never dated Prince (this rumour may have started because of the outtake "Lisa"). W&L were an item before Wendy even joined the Revolution in 1984, and didn't break up until failry recently.

Perhaps this guitar teacher dated Gayle Chapman? She was Prince's keyboardist before Lisa. By 1985 she was long gone from Prince's band, but did she tell him she was his current keyboardist at the time? She might have told him she used to be in Prince's band at that point.



for the record, lisa has never publically stated this...wendy has.....well, she didnt but her new lisa did...

lisa coleman keeps her sh*t private....in a world full of britney's, bobby's and madonnas...its a breath of fresh air ... wink


exactly sos and they both have kept private of their personal life. who could blame them? those journalists already still clueless as what wendy and lisa been doing after 1986 and i guarantee they will want to know more info about their lesbian rather than them being good musicians and unless you know lisa or wendy personally don't assumed anything.

sos i think wendy has stated that she is homosexual remember when she mention that Prince want to denounced her sexuality and also want her to convert to jw? good thing that wendy wasn't going to cede or else i would thought she must have lost it. lol
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #19 posted 08/01/05 9:09pm

sosgemini

avatar

tookielv said:

sosgemini said:




for the record, lisa has never publically stated this...wendy has.....well, she didnt but her new lisa did...

lisa coleman keeps her sh*t private....in a world full of britney's, bobby's and madonnas...its a breath of fresh air ... wink


exactly sos and they both have kept private of their personal life. who could blame them? those journalists already still clueless as what wendy and lisa been doing after 1986 and i guarantee they will want to know more info about their lesbian rather than them being good musicians and unless you know lisa or wendy personally don't assumed anything.

sos i think wendy has stated that she is homosexual remember when she mention that Prince want to denounced her sexuality and also want her to convert to jw? good thing that wendy wasn't going to cede or else i would thought she must have lost it. lol



yes...wendy did out them...but in an ambigious kinda way....one or another could could be bi, queer.....a-sexual now...who knows... wink
Space for sale...
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #20 posted 08/01/05 11:09pm

JudasLChrist

avatar

sosgemini said:

tookielv said:



exactly sos and they both have kept private of their personal life. who could blame them? those journalists already still clueless as what wendy and lisa been doing after 1986 and i guarantee they will want to know more info about their lesbian rather than them being good musicians and unless you know lisa or wendy personally don't assumed anything.

sos i think wendy has stated that she is homosexual remember when she mention that Prince want to denounced her sexuality and also want her to convert to jw? good thing that wendy wasn't going to cede or else i would thought she must have lost it. lol



yes...wendy did out them...but in an ambigious kinda way....one or another could could be bi, queer.....a-sexual now...who knows... wink



You guys...I think it's awesome that the girls are Lesbian or bi or WHATEVER, but stop arguing about it, LABELS SHMABELS!
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #21 posted 08/02/05 3:59am

sosgemini

avatar

JudasLChrist said:

sosgemini said:




yes...wendy did out them...but in an ambigious kinda way....one or another could could be bi, queer.....a-sexual now...who knows... wink



You guys...I think it's awesome that the girls are Lesbian or bi or WHATEVER, but stop arguing about it, LABELS SHMABELS!



im not arguing or trying to label anyone...the point i am trying to make is that lisa coleman is a private person and has never publically admitted to being anything other than lisa coleman..and while wendy melvoin has discussed her queer factor, she too has never publically admitted anything.

big difference there... wink
Space for sale...
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #22 posted 08/02/05 6:06am

JediMaster

avatar

tookielv said:

tookielv said:



!

it said in possessed book that prince and lisa have a sexual thing going and people do sexual things without dating and hell they both liberals (at least prince more at the time). why would alex hahn made that up especially if he got half of his sources from DMSR author Per Nielson? apparently lisa's parents must have knew about it because i read somewhere they disapproved prince or something and not because he is black because i guess they considered him to be a freak. I never said that prince and lisa dated i said that i believed they had something sexual and i don't care if you guys believed it or not. she said in the older interviews that she dated guys and it sounds to me like a straightfoward answer too and she wasn't joking. i still continued to believe that lisa is bi and wendy is a lesbian.


wendy joined the revolution in 1983, not 1984.

with all these sources i don't know whom to believe! damn i want a W&L autobiography![/
[Edited 8/1/05 8:24am]


You're right about Wendy joining in 1983, but that still backs up my statement. As for whether Lisa is gay, bi, whatever, it really doesn't matter. I've always heard she was gay, but whatever.

As for the rumoured relationship between her & Prince, I don't buy it. Alex Hahn's book is full of rumours, half-truths and out-of-context statements (quite a few of his sources have come forward to say they were mis-quoted). The MAIN reason I don't believe it is the whole "her parents didn't approve because he was black" thing. Lisa's dad is an old liberal, California musician from the hippie days. Doesn't strike me as the racist type.

It really doesn't matter in the long run. I think it's safe to say that the person this guitar teacher was dating was not Lisa
jedi

Do not hurry yourself in your spirit to become offended, for the taking of offense is what rests in the bosom of the stupid ones. (Ecclesiastes 7:9)
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #23 posted 08/02/05 2:02pm

tookielv

JediMaster said:

tookielv said:


it said in possessed book that prince and lisa have a sexual thing going and people do sexual things without dating and hell they both liberals (at least prince more at the time). why would alex hahn made that up especially if he got half of his sources from DMSR author Per Nielson? apparently lisa's parents must have knew about it because i read somewhere they disapproved prince or something and not because he is black because i guess they considered him to be a freak. I never said that prince and lisa dated i said that i believed they had something sexual and i don't care if you guys believed it or not. she said in the older interviews that she dated guys and it sounds to me like a straightfoward answer too and she wasn't joking. i still continued to believe that lisa is bi and wendy is a lesbian.


wendy joined the revolution in 1983, not 1984.

with all these sources i don't know whom to believe! damn i want a W&L autobiography![/
[Edited 8/1/05 8:24am]


You're right about Wendy joining in 1983, but that still backs up my statement. As for whether Lisa is gay, bi, whatever, it really doesn't matter. I've always heard she was gay, but whatever.

As for the rumoured relationship between her & Prince, I don't buy it. Alex Hahn's book is full of rumours, half-truths and out-of-context statements (quite a few of his sources have come forward to say they were mis-quoted). The MAIN reason I don't believe it is the whole "her parents didn't approve because he was black" thing. Lisa's dad is an old liberal, California musician from the hippie days. Doesn't strike me as the racist type.

It really doesn't matter in the long run. I think it's safe to say that the person this guitar teacher was dating was not Lisa


are my messages are in french or something?
where did i said that lisa's parents didnt approved because he is black? i never said! reread my posts more carefully because i don't have time to repeat myself. yes i aware that lisa's dad is a liberal and so is wendy's dad too. as a matter of fact wendy's father said he still adored prince and his music despite how prince treated his daughter susannah back in the day but that is another topic. W&L even said themselves that their parents were into the beatnik culture and that influence was why Lisa (unlike Gayle) had no problem or wasn't shock of performing Head and homegirl was just nineteen.

i still standing by that there something went on between her and prince sexually and stopped sounding so certain nothing happen because you wasn't there and also unless you know lisa's personal life better than the rest of us you also can't assumed that the guitarist teacher didn't dated her.
[Edited 8/2/05 14:25pm]
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #24 posted 08/02/05 2:17pm

tookielv

sosgemini said:[quote]

JudasLChrist said:




You guys...I think it's awesome that the girls are Lesbian or bi or WHATEVER, but stop arguing about it, LABELS SHMABELS![/
quote]


im not arguing or trying to label anyone...the [b]point i am trying to make is that lisa coleman is a private person and has never publically admitted to being anything other than lisa coleman..and while wendy melvoin has discussed her queer factor, she too has never publically admitted anything[/b].

big difference there... wink


co-sign sos. also no one isn't arguing judaslchrist and it doesn't matter yes true . it just that i am informing that u shouldn't denied something that didn't happen in that other person's life especially if you don't ACTUALLY knows them personally or imitately or you wasn't there either. usually it backfires!
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #25 posted 08/02/05 2:28pm

sosgemini

avatar

tookielv said:[quote]

sosgemini said:

JudasLChrist said:




You guys...I think it's awesome that the girls are Lesbian or bi or WHATEVER, but stop arguing about it, LABELS SHMABELS![/
quote]


im not arguing or trying to label anyone...the [b]point i am trying to make is that lisa coleman is a private person and has never publically admitted to being anything other than lisa coleman..and while wendy melvoin has discussed her queer factor, she too has never publically admitted anything[/b].

big difference there... wink


co-sign sos. also no one isn't arguing judaslchrist and it doesn't matter yes true . it just that i am informing that u shouldn't denied something that didn't happen in that other person's life especially if you don't ACTUALLY knows them personally or imitately or you wasn't there either. usually it backfires!



i didnt know you lived in broklyn..i just spent a week in NY.. falloff next time we are going to have to do tea or something..
Space for sale...
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #26 posted 08/02/05 3:01pm

tookielv

sosgemini said:

tookielv said:



co-sign sos. also no one isn't arguing judaslchrist and it doesn't matter yes true . it just that i am informing that u shouldn't denied something that didn't happen in that other person's life especially if you don't ACTUALLY knows them personally or imitately or you wasn't there either. usually it backfires!



i didnt know you lived in broklyn..i just spent a week in NY.. falloff next time we are going to have to do tea or something..


yeah u mention that u was up there so how did it went? well actually i no longer lives in brooklyn i better change my location then and i moved back home to indiana the midwest recently. i got homesick. i lived there for a few months with a friend and i moved back home recently. nyc was too fast for a lifetime midwest gal and not to mention the cost of living was hell. i added my jon seda picture on my avatar yet fail to change my location. hehehe.

i will go back to nyc to visit relatives but never to live again.

maybe have a tea out in bay area is that where u from right? i have a friend lives down south in LA and perhaps when i planned to go out there next year i give a W&L a hollar if they going to perform anywhere.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #27 posted 08/03/05 9:38am

JediMaster

avatar

tookielv said:

JediMaster said:



You're right about Wendy joining in 1983, but that still backs up my statement. As for whether Lisa is gay, bi, whatever, it really doesn't matter. I've always heard she was gay, but whatever.

As for the rumoured relationship between her & Prince, I don't buy it. Alex Hahn's book is full of rumours, half-truths and out-of-context statements (quite a few of his sources have come forward to say they were mis-quoted). The MAIN reason I don't believe it is the whole "her parents didn't approve because he was black" thing. Lisa's dad is an old liberal, California musician from the hippie days. Doesn't strike me as the racist type.

It really doesn't matter in the long run. I think it's safe to say that the person this guitar teacher was dating was not Lisa


are my messages are in french or something?
where did i said that lisa's parents didnt approved because he is black? i never said! reread my posts more carefully because i don't have time to repeat myself. yes i aware that lisa's dad is a liberal and so is wendy's dad too. as a matter of fact wendy's father said he still adored prince and his music despite how prince treated his daughter susannah back in the day but that is another topic. W&L even said themselves that their parents were into the beatnik culture and that influence was why Lisa (unlike Gayle) had no problem or wasn't shock of performing Head and homegirl was just nineteen.

i still standing by that there something went on between her and prince sexually and stopped sounding so certain nothing happen because you wasn't there and also unless you know lisa's personal life better than the rest of us you also can't assumed that the guitarist teacher didn't dated her.
[Edited 8/2/05 14:25pm]


No need to get nasty. I did mis-read your post, and I'm sorry for that.

No, I wasn't around P during that time period, so I don't know if anything happened between him & Lisa, and I also don't know for certain if she dated this guitar teacher. All I was stating was MY OPINION that it was unlikely based on what I DO know. The only source for P & Lisa having a sexual relationship is Hahn's book, which is filled with errors, misquotes and outright falsehoods, so I find it highly unlikely. It is conjecture on my part, but no more so that yours. No, I can't prove that Lisa and Prince didn't hook up, but neither can you prove that they did, so its a moot point.
jedi

Do not hurry yourself in your spirit to become offended, for the taking of offense is what rests in the bosom of the stupid ones. (Ecclesiastes 7:9)
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #28 posted 08/03/05 1:39pm

tookielv

JediMaster said:

tookielv said:



are my messages are in french or something?
where did i said that lisa's parents didnt approved because he is black? i never said! reread my posts more carefully because i don't have time to repeat myself. yes i aware that lisa's dad is a liberal and so is wendy's dad too. as a matter of fact wendy's father said he still adored prince and his music despite how prince treated his daughter susannah back in the day but that is another topic. W&L even said themselves that their parents were into the beatnik culture and that influence was why Lisa (unlike Gayle) had no problem or wasn't shock of performing Head and homegirl was just nineteen.

i still standing by that there something went on between her and prince sexually and stopped sounding so certain nothing happen because you wasn't there and also unless you know lisa's personal life better than the rest of us you also can't assumed that the guitarist teacher didn't dated her.
[Edited 8/2/05 14:25pm]


No need to get nasty. I did mis-read your post, and I'm sorry for that.

No, I wasn't around P during that time period, so I don't know if anything happened between him & Lisa, and I also don't know for certain if she dated this guitar teacher. All I was stating was MY OPINION that it was unlikely based on what I DO know. The only source for P & Lisa having a sexual relationship is Hahn's book, which is filled with errors, misquotes and outright falsehoods, so I find it highly unlikely. It is conjecture on my part, but no more so that yours. No, I can't prove that Lisa and Prince didn't hook up, but neither can you prove that they did, so its a moot point.


Exactly right and you can't prove that since you don't personally know them. Also I stated my opinion as well but at least my tone I didn't sound certain of my opinion because I don't know them! Yes I went with the Hahn book to backup my claim but again since I wasn't there or do I know them then yes my opinion is just that. Also Prince and Lisa are more alike in many ways too. Not only that they are both private but when they met and they took a ride to Prince's house they both hardly said a word and when they later jammed togehter at his house they communcated through music and also like prince Lisa said in interview she spend many hours in her room alone writing songs it tells you right there of their personality and also I wouldn't be suprised by Hahn's claim.

Speaking of that Hahn book if his info been misquote and lies of the people he was writing about I always wondered then how come none of the people sueing him for libel or slander? Make u wonder that some of the gossip info in that book did happen and some of those people just disliking him airing out their dirty laundry. Now I am not saying his book is error-free but these people bitched about the things that he said was untrue then how come not one of them bonded taking legal action against him? And also isn't hahn a lawyer and journalist too and I don't think that he is that dumb enough of making up stuff and risking a lawsuit too especially from a famous celeb and his former associates? That don't make sense.

and i am also being adult here that is apologize that i being nasty to u but i just don't like my words being twisted and also people think that they are certain of something without any evidence so again I sorry too. I hope we cool and I dont want this to cause us to have some amosity here and we all here for the common goal is liking prince's music not trying to knock each other here.
[Edited 8/3/05 13:56pm]
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #29 posted 08/04/05 6:54am

JediMaster

avatar

tookielv said:

JediMaster said:



No need to get nasty. I did mis-read your post, and I'm sorry for that.

No, I wasn't around P during that time period, so I don't know if anything happened between him & Lisa, and I also don't know for certain if she dated this guitar teacher. All I was stating was MY OPINION that it was unlikely based on what I DO know. The only source for P & Lisa having a sexual relationship is Hahn's book, which is filled with errors, misquotes and outright falsehoods, so I find it highly unlikely. It is conjecture on my part, but no more so that yours. No, I can't prove that Lisa and Prince didn't hook up, but neither can you prove that they did, so its a moot point.


Exactly right and you can't prove that since you don't personally know them. Also I stated my opinion as well but at least my tone I didn't sound certain of my opinion because I don't know them! Yes I went with the Hahn book to backup my claim but again since I wasn't there or do I know them then yes my opinion is just that. Also Prince and Lisa are more alike in many ways too. Not only that they are both private but when they met and they took a ride to Prince's house they both hardly said a word and when they later jammed togehter at his house they communcated through music and also like prince Lisa said in interview she spend many hours in her room alone writing songs it tells you right there of their personality and also I wouldn't be suprised by Hahn's claim.

Speaking of that Hahn book if his info been misquote and lies of the people he was writing about I always wondered then how come none of the people sueing him for libel or slander? Make u wonder that some of the gossip info in that book did happen and some of those people just disliking him airing out their dirty laundry. Now I am not saying his book is error-free but these people bitched about the things that he said was untrue then how come not one of them bonded taking legal action against him? And also isn't hahn a lawyer and journalist too and I don't think that he is that dumb enough of making up stuff and risking a lawsuit too especially from a famous celeb and his former associates? That don't make sense.

and i am also being adult here that is apologize that i being nasty to u but i just don't like my words being twisted and also people think that they are certain of something without any evidence so again I sorry too. I hope we cool and I dont want this to cause us to have some amosity here and we all here for the common goal is liking prince's music not trying to knock each other here.
[Edited 8/3/05 13:56pm]


Agreed. I didn't mean to twist your words, and I have no animosity towards you.
jedi

Do not hurry yourself in your spirit to become offended, for the taking of offense is what rests in the bosom of the stupid ones. (Ecclesiastes 7:9)
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
« Previous topic  Next topic »
Forums > Prince: Music and More > Revolution Question