independent and unofficial
Prince fan community
Welcome! Sign up or enter username and password to remember me
Forum jump
Forums > Music: Non-Prince > Robin Thicke - 2013 VMAs Prove He Can't Sing
« Previous topic  Next topic »
Page 1 of 2 12>
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
Author

Tweet     Share

Message
Thread started 08/26/13 10:00am

Giovanni777

avatar

Robin Thicke - 2013 VMAs Prove He Can't Sing

Okay, so I just caught up to that ridiculous Robin Thicke/Miley Cyrus "duet", and I learned two things.

A) Miley Cyrus must have a thing for ecstacsy.

B) Robin Thicke can't sing live... He was so far off key it was confusing to hear.

That's all for now.

"He's a musician's musician..."
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #1 posted 08/26/13 10:09am

Graycap23

Giovanni777 said:

Okay, so I just caught up to that ridiculous Robin Thicke/Miley Cyrus "duet", and I learned two things.

A) Miley Cyrus must have a thing for ecstacsy.

B) Robin Thicke can't sing live... He was so far off key it was confusing to hear.

That's all for now.

G..........u just now figured that out?

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #2 posted 08/26/13 10:16am

Giovanni777

avatar

Graycap23 said:

Giovanni777 said:

Okay, so I just caught up to that ridiculous Robin Thicke/Miley Cyrus "duet", and I learned two things.

A) Miley Cyrus must have a thing for ecstacsy.

B) Robin Thicke can't sing live... He was so far off key it was confusing to hear.

That's all for now.

G..........u just now figured that out?

Well honestly, I haven't listened to him at all until I heard about Marvin Gaye's family lawsuit against him. Then I heard what I believe to be a solid case against Robin Thicke.

Even with whatever pitch correction was used on his recordings, I still wasn't impressed. Eric Benet is a far better singer in that style.

Then I watched that mess from the VMAs... couldn't even tell what the key was.

This guy is so far overrated... but then again, most all singers and MCs have been overrated since like 1998, so... U know what I'm sayin'.

"He's a musician's musician..."
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #3 posted 08/26/13 10:28am

Graycap23

Giovanni777 said:

Graycap23 said:

G..........u just now figured that out?

Well honestly, I haven't listened to him at all until I heard about Marvin Gaye's family lawsuit against him. Then I heard what I believe to be a solid case against Robin Thicke.

Even with whatever pitch correction was used on his recordings, I still wasn't impressed. Eric Benet is a far better singer in that style.

Then I watched that mess from the VMAs... couldn't even tell what the key was.

This guy is so far overrated... but then again, most all singers and MCs have been overrated since like 1998, so... U know what I'm sayin'.

I certainly do.

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #4 posted 08/26/13 10:28am

Stymie

When he was doing something positive no one paid attention. Now that he is perceived to be dishonest(negative), people come out of the woodwork like roaches when the lights are off.

I've been to many of his shows and his singing was fine. I can't speak to last night because I didn't watch him sing but perhaps he had an off night.

He's a pop singer. I don't expect him to be George Michael or Luther Vandross. If we are talking about famous people who can't sing, we may be here a while.

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #5 posted 08/26/13 10:39pm

SamSamba

avatar

Yeah I was surprised everybody's talking about Cyrus' "twerking" but nobody's is talking about how badly off-key this boy was. Actually, not even off-key, in a completely different key. Or two.

Usually when that happens, it's a technical/sound issue - the singer can't hear him/herself, or the backing track. I'm guessing it was pretty loud out there, so it might be that (they usually wear ear monitors). That said, I've never been that impressed with him either.

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #6 posted 08/26/13 11:01pm

ADC

I don't think he sounded that bad live. It wasn't too much unlike the record.

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #7 posted 08/27/13 3:52am

vikfunk

avatar

Giovanni777 said:

Graycap23 said:

G..........u just now figured that out?

Well honestly, I haven't listened to him at all until I heard about Marvin Gaye's family lawsuit against him. Then I heard what I believe to be a solid case against Robin Thicke.

Even with whatever pitch correction was used on his recordings, I still wasn't impressed. Eric Benet is a far better singer in that style.

Then I watched that mess from the VMAs... couldn't even tell what the key was.

This guy is so far overrated... but then again, most all singers and MCs have been overrated since like 1998, so... U know what I'm sayin'.

It's not like I'm a fan of both, but in all fairness, yes Eric is a stronger vocalist than Robin, but Robin is a better songwriter and musician (Evolution and Something Else are nice, enjoyable albums, although they do sound like an audition tape for the late Marvin). Time will tell whether this whole Blurred Lines episode is a brilliant career move or career suicide for Robin.

Is everybody wet?
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #8 posted 08/27/13 4:19am

VenusBlingBlin
g

avatar

SamSamba said:

Yeah I was surprised everybody's talking about Cyrus' "twerking" but nobody's is talking about how badly off-key this boy was. Actually, not even off-key, in a completely different key. Or two.

Usually when that happens, it's a technical/sound issue - the singer can't hear him/herself, or the backing track. I'm guessing it was pretty loud out there, so it might be that (they usually wear ear monitors). That said, I've never been that impressed with him either.

nod I'm pretty sure it was something like that. Plus he could have had a cold or something. Considering he usually sounds anything but bad and I have seen him live in a small venue, I would definitely not say he can't sing.

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #9 posted 08/27/13 6:48am

Ottensen

I've been to his shows before. He's not a bad singer and I've always enjoyed his concerts. But

Him being off key the entireperformance was likely him not being able to hear himself or the music properly from his ear monitor. It happens.

What's more cumbersome than this particular performance though, was his choice of MONOPOLY Jailbird ensemble that was supposed to pass as a suit...that, and the fact that he's one good meal at the Ivy away from developing Child Bearing Hips attempting to wear aforementioned attire.

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #10 posted 08/27/13 7:37am

VenusBlingBlin
g

avatar

Ottensen said:

I've been to his shows before. He's not a bad singer and I've always enjoyed his concerts. But

Him being off key the entireperformance was likely him not being able to hear himself or the music properly from his ear monitor. It happens.

What's more cumbersome than this particular performance though, was his choice of MONOPOLY Jailbird ensemble that was supposed to pass as a suit...that, and the fact that he's one good meal at the Ivy away from developing Child Bearing Hips attempting to wear aforementioned attire.

falloff falloff

Not the best looking attire in the world, no... He should have stayed in the black suit he wore before the show!

I had to look at the trainwreck again and now I'm definitely convinced the man couldn't hear himself! He didn't sound bad, just totally off key/too loud.

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #11 posted 08/27/13 8:05am

robertlove

Giovanni777 said:

Graycap23 said:

G..........u just now figured that out?

Well honestly, I haven't listened to him at all until I heard about Marvin Gaye's family lawsuit against him. Then I heard what I believe to be a solid case against Robin Thicke.

Even with whatever pitch correction was used on his recordings, I still wasn't impressed. Eric Benet is a far better singer in that style.

Then I watched that mess from the VMAs... couldn't even tell what the key was.

This guy is so far overrated... but then again, most all singers and MCs have been overrated since like 1998, so... U know what I'm sayin'.

How is he overrated? He has been releasing stuff for years and now he finally has a hit, let him enjoy the moment. I don't think he sounds bad live actually.

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #12 posted 08/27/13 9:56am

VenusBlingBlin
g

avatar

robertlove said:

Giovanni777 said:

Well honestly, I haven't listened to him at all until I heard about Marvin Gaye's family lawsuit against him. Then I heard what I believe to be a solid case against Robin Thicke.

Even with whatever pitch correction was used on his recordings, I still wasn't impressed. Eric Benet is a far better singer in that style.

Then I watched that mess from the VMAs... couldn't even tell what the key was.

This guy is so far overrated... but then again, most all singers and MCs have been overrated since like 1998, so... U know what I'm sayin'.

How is he overrated? He has been releasing stuff for years and now he finally has a hit, let him enjoy the moment. I don't think he sounds bad live actually.

Right, the guy has been releasing stuff for over a decade yet never had a major hit like now. Hardly any of my friends know/knew about him so it's not like his been that big of a name.

[Edited 8/27/13 9:56am]

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #13 posted 08/27/13 10:23am

DysregulatedTo
xicity

avatar

robertlove said:

Giovanni777 said:

Well honestly, I haven't listened to him at all until I heard about Marvin Gaye's family lawsuit against him. Then I heard what I believe to be a solid case against Robin Thicke.

Even with whatever pitch correction was used on his recordings, I still wasn't impressed. Eric Benet is a far better singer in that style.

Then I watched that mess from the VMAs... couldn't even tell what the key was.

This guy is so far overrated... but then again, most all singers and MCs have been overrated since like 1998, so... U know what I'm sayin'.

How is he overrated? He has been releasing stuff for years and now he finally has a hit, let him enjoy the moment. I don't think he sounds bad live actually.

thumbs up!

“The right to be heard does not automatically include the right to be taken seriously.”
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #14 posted 08/27/13 10:23am

Stymie

DysregulatedToxicity said:

robertlove said:

How is he overrated? He has been releasing stuff for years and now he finally has a hit, let him enjoy the moment. I don't think he sounds bad live actually.

thumbs up!

nod

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #15 posted 08/27/13 10:25am

DysregulatedTo
xicity

avatar

Stymie said:

When he was doing something positive no one paid attention. Now that he is perceived to be dishonest(negative), people come out of the woodwork like roaches when the lights are off.

I've been to many of his shows and his singing was fine. I can't speak to last night because I didn't watch him sing but perhaps he had an off night.

He's a pop singer. I don't expect him to be George Michael or Luther Vandross. If we are talking about famous people who can't sing, we may be here a while.

I agree; he always sounds fine during his live performances. There were tons of sound issues during the VMAs, he wasn't the only one who sounded "bad." JT sounded like crap and he's a douch whose always on key.

“The right to be heard does not automatically include the right to be taken seriously.”
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #16 posted 08/27/13 10:27am

DysregulatedTo
xicity

avatar

VenusBlingBling said:

Ottensen said:

I've been to his shows before. He's not a bad singer and I've always enjoyed his concerts. But

Him being off key the entireperformance was likely him not being able to hear himself or the music properly from his ear monitor. It happens.

What's more cumbersome than this particular performance though, was his choice of MONOPOLY Jailbird ensemble that was supposed to pass as a suit...that, and the fact that he's one good meal at the Ivy away from developing Child Bearing Hips attempting to wear aforementioned attire.

falloff falloff

Not the best looking attire in the world, no... He should have stayed in the black suit he wore before the show!

I had to look at the trainwreck again and now I'm definitely convinced the man couldn't hear himself! He didn't sound bad, just totally off key/too loud.

He's fine as hell so for all I care he can wear his house curtains as a cape and still look super fuckable.

“The right to be heard does not automatically include the right to be taken seriously.”
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #17 posted 08/27/13 1:12pm

Zannaloaf

I've heard him sing live perfectly fine before. the mashup sucked and so did the overall sound. it;s easy to find him singing well...if you want to. Is he the best singer ever...um. No. But way better than that performance.

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #18 posted 08/27/13 5:46pm

kitbradley

avatar

robertlove said:

Giovanni777 said:

Well honestly, I haven't listened to him at all until I heard about Marvin Gaye's family lawsuit against him. Then I heard what I believe to be a solid case against Robin Thicke.

Even with whatever pitch correction was used on his recordings, I still wasn't impressed. Eric Benet is a far better singer in that style.

Then I watched that mess from the VMAs... couldn't even tell what the key was.

This guy is so far overrated... but then again, most all singers and MCs have been overrated since like 1998, so... U know what I'm sayin'.

How is he overrated? He has been releasing stuff for years and now he finally has a hit, let him enjoy the moment. I don't think he sounds bad live actually.

He's had big hits (Three #1's on the R&B Chart). I know because its the R&B chart, some people may tend to dismiss those accomplishments and say his first big hit was "Blurred Lines" because it's his first #1 Pop song. It's like saying the only "hit" Teena Marie had was "Lovergirl" because it was her only song to reach the Top 10 on the Pop charts. But, we all know Lady T had big hits before and after that song. But, again, some people may dismiss those successes because they were on the R&B side of the charts.

"It's not nice to fuck with K.B.! All you haters will see!" - Kitbradley
"The only true wisdom is knowing you know nothing." - Socrates
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #19 posted 08/27/13 8:11pm

woogiebear

His Daddy's a BETTER songwriter!!!!!

cool

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #20 posted 08/27/13 9:19pm

phunkdaddy

avatar

kitbradley said:

robertlove said:

How is he overrated? He has been releasing stuff for years and now he finally has a hit, let him enjoy the moment. I don't think he sounds bad live actually.

He's had big hits (Three #1's on the R&B Chart). I know because its the R&B chart, some people may tend to dismiss those accomplishments and say his first big hit was "Blurred Lines" because it's his first #1 Pop song. It's like saying the only "hit" Teena Marie had was "Lovergirl" because it was her only song to reach the Top 10 on the Pop charts. But, we all know Lady T had big hits before and after that song. But, again, some people may dismiss those successes because they were on the R&B side of the charts.

That's what I was thinking. Blurred Lines is his first hit like Word Up was Cameo's first

hit. lol

Don't laugh at my funk
This funk is a serious joint
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #21 posted 08/28/13 8:19am

kitbradley

avatar

phunkdaddy said:

kitbradley said:

He's had big hits (Three #1's on the R&B Chart). I know because its the R&B chart, some people may tend to dismiss those accomplishments and say his first big hit was "Blurred Lines" because it's his first #1 Pop song. It's like saying the only "hit" Teena Marie had was "Lovergirl" because it was her only song to reach the Top 10 on the Pop charts. But, we all know Lady T had big hits before and after that song. But, again, some people may dismiss those successes because they were on the R&B side of the charts.

That's what I was thinking. Blurred Lines is his first hit like Word Up was Cameo's first

hit. lol

lol Yep! I was never really a Robin Thicke fan. I still say his best song is "Magic". But, after doing a little research recently regarding his Billboard chart rankings, I was quite surprised to see most of his songs doing so well on the R&B side but not so much on the Pop charts. "Sex Therapy" was #1 on the R&B charts but couldn't even manage to crack the Top 40 on the Pop side? Wow! He really is the male version of Teena Marie. It's going to be interesting to see if he will be successful where Teena wasn't by following-up "Blurred Lines" with another huge single that does well on the Pop charts.

"It's not nice to fuck with K.B.! All you haters will see!" - Kitbradley
"The only true wisdom is knowing you know nothing." - Socrates
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #22 posted 08/28/13 9:02am

robertlove

phunkdaddy said:

kitbradley said:

He's had big hits (Three #1's on the R&B Chart). I know because its the R&B chart, some people may tend to dismiss those accomplishments and say his first big hit was "Blurred Lines" because it's his first #1 Pop song. It's like saying the only "hit" Teena Marie had was "Lovergirl" because it was her only song to reach the Top 10 on the Pop charts. But, we all know Lady T had big hits before and after that song. But, again, some people may dismiss those successes because they were on the R&B side of the charts.

That's what I was thinking. Blurred Lines is his first hit like Word Up was Cameo's first

hit. lol

Maybe for people who like a certain type of music like R&B he had some hits, for the big public he really didn´t. Most people don´t even care about a R&B chart or a rock chart or whatever.

I think most people didn't even know him before Blurred Lines.

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #23 posted 08/28/13 9:07am

Giovanni777

avatar

SamSamba said:

Yeah I was surprised everybody's talking about Cyrus' "twerking" but nobody's is talking about how badly off-key this boy was. Actually, not even off-key, in a completely different key. Or two.

Usually when that happens, it's a technical/sound issue - the singer can't hear him/herself, or the backing track. I'm guessing it was pretty loud out there, so it might be that (they usually wear ear monitors). That said, I've never been that impressed with him either.

Yeah, I noticed that it seemed to be in a different key, and not one that worked. I agree that it could have been a monitor issue.

"He's a musician's musician..."
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #24 posted 08/28/13 11:10am

VenusBlingBlin
g

avatar

robertlove said:



phunkdaddy said:




kitbradley said:



He's had big hits (Three #1's on the R&B Chart). I know because its the R&B chart, some people may tend to dismiss those accomplishments and say his first big hit was "Blurred Lines" because it's his first #1 Pop song. It's like saying the only "hit" Teena Marie had was "Lovergirl" because it was her only song to reach the Top 10 on the Pop charts. But, we all know Lady T had big hits before and after that song. But, again, some people may dismiss those successes because they were on the R&B side of the charts.





That's what I was thinking. Blurred Lines is his first hit like Word Up was Cameo's first


hit. lol



Maybe for people who like a certain type of music like R&B he had some hits, for the big public he really didn´t. Most people don´t even care about a R&B chart or a rock chart or whatever.



I think most people didn't even know him before Blurred Lines.





Agree. He def wasn't a household name like Timberlake has become one. None of the ppl around me (who weren't in the biz) had a clue who he was before BL. Funny thing is, my friends actually thought BL was Prince lol
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #25 posted 08/28/13 11:14am

Graycap23

Giovanni777 said:

SamSamba said:

Yeah I was surprised everybody's talking about Cyrus' "twerking" but nobody's is talking about how badly off-key this boy was. Actually, not even off-key, in a completely different key. Or two.

Usually when that happens, it's a technical/sound issue - the singer can't hear him/herself, or the backing track. I'm guessing it was pretty loud out there, so it might be that (they usually wear ear monitors). That said, I've never been that impressed with him either.

Yeah, I noticed that it seemed to be in a different key, and not one that worked. I agree that it could have been a monitor issue.

Excuses. I've seen this guy live from the front row.

He just isn't good live.

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #26 posted 08/28/13 11:22am

Giovanni777

avatar

Graycap23 said:

Giovanni777 said:

Yeah, I noticed that it seemed to be in a different key, and not one that worked. I agree that it could have been a monitor issue.

Excuses. I've seen this guy live from the front row.

He just isn't good live.

...and back in the mid to late '90s, I saw Eric Benet in the tiny State Of The Union club on U St in D.C., and he nailed it live. That was back when his "debut" album, 'True To Myself' had just come out... his best album by far.

"He's a musician's musician..."
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #27 posted 08/28/13 11:40am

Frederick96

avatar

I am surpised by everyone's reaction to Miley.... she didn't have anything to shake anyway. But no one said anything about Ga Ga being half naked. I'm not complaining either way but JT was the best of the night. I also enjoyed Katie Perry.

And HECK YEAH Eric Benet is a better singer.

The lawsuit with Robin Thicke....to me just the intro part of the song reminds me of Marvin Gaye. As a whole it doesn't. But there are others that sound similar that Gaye's estate needs to jump on for money.

Love God and I shall 4ever Love u
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #28 posted 08/28/13 11:43am

Graycap23

Giovanni777 said:

Graycap23 said:

Excuses. I've seen this guy live from the front row.

He just isn't good live.

...and back in the mid to late '90s, I saw Eric Benet in the tiny State Of The Union club on U St in D.C., and he nailed it live. That was back when his "debut" album, 'True To Myself' had just come out... his best album by far.

Eric is the real deal.

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #29 posted 08/28/13 1:40pm

Timmy84

robertlove said:

phunkdaddy said:

That's what I was thinking. Blurred Lines is his first hit like Word Up was Cameo's first

hit. lol

Maybe for people who like a certain type of music like R&B he had some hits, for the big public he really didn´t. Most people don´t even care about a R&B chart or a rock chart or whatever.

I think most people didn't even know him before Blurred Lines.

Yep. And even being big on R&B myself, he only really hit it big with three songs and one of them was number-one but most of his other songs were quite forgettable. BL joins Lost Without You and When I Get You Alone as his most memorable.

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Page 1 of 2 12>
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
« Previous topic  Next topic »
Forums > Music: Non-Prince > Robin Thicke - 2013 VMAs Prove He Can't Sing