My money is on Grace.

Grace!~ that woman is an animal. She would probably fight durty to, nails, biting.

Where as i see Aretha using a lot of pots and pans

I imagine Aretha would also use her weapons of mass destruction-her breasts.

Ninja Simone.

Aretha could just sit on them

True, but ReRe doesn't move quickly, so sitting on people wouldn't really work.

Joan Jett

She's not one of the choices

Nina Simone

MickyDolenz said:

Joan Jett

@ her abs... God I'm in LOVE LUST with this woman.

I pick Grace by the way.

Timmy84 said:

MickyDolenz said:

Joan Jett

@ her abs... God I'm in LOVE LUST with this woman.

She looks like Lady Gaga's male alter-ego

aardvark15 said:

Timmy84 said:

@ her abs... God I'm in LOVE LUST with this woman.

She looks like Lady Gaga's male alter-ego

Please. Mr. Calderone wishes he looked that good.

scriptgirl said:

She's not one of the choices

I don't see Aretha as a fighter. Bessie Smith beat up men, so she would have been a better choice.

MickyDolenz said:

scriptgirl said:

She's not one of the choices

I don't see Aretha as a fighter. Bessie Smith beat up men, so she would have been a better choice.

In the Franklin family, Carolyn was the real fighter in that family. I think Erma Franklin was "too classy" for that and Aretha probably used Carolyn as her protection. Aretha's more of a talker/slapper than anything else. She once slapped a cop (I think, don't quote me) while in Paris in 1971 during a tour. So nah I can't see her winning a three-way fight between Nina and Grace. Besides Grace got the karate/wrestling moves and Nina is a straight boxer. She'd lose with either one.

Timmy84 said:

MickyDolenz said:

I don't see Aretha as a fighter. Bessie Smith beat up men, so she would have been a better choice.

In the Franklin family, Carolyn was the real fighter in that family. I think Erma Franklin was "too classy" for that and Aretha probably used Carolyn as her protection. Aretha's more of a talker/slapper than anything else. She once slapped a cop (I think, don't quote me) while in Paris in 1971 during a tour. So nah I can't see her winning a three-way fight between Nina and Grace. Besides Grace got the karate/wrestling moves and Nina is a straight boxer. She'd lose with either one.

I don't know if it's true or not, but I read once that Patti LaBelle gave Cindy Birdsong a beatdown when she left her group for the Supremes.

who's erma?

scriptgirl said:

who's erma?

Carolyn & Erma are Aretha's sisters.

MickyDolenz said:

Timmy84 said:

In the Franklin family, Carolyn was the real fighter in that family. I think Erma Franklin was "too classy" for that and Aretha probably used Carolyn as her protection. Aretha's more of a talker/slapper than anything else. She once slapped a cop (I think, don't quote me) while in Paris in 1971 during a tour. So nah I can't see her winning a three-way fight between Nina and Grace. Besides Grace got the karate/wrestling moves and Nina is a straight boxer. She'd lose with either one.

I don't know if it's true or not, but I read once that Patti LaBelle gave Cindy Birdsong a beatdown when she left her group for the Supremes.

I knew they had a fallout and there was probably a nasty argument but you know, I wouldn't be surprised if that was actually accurate.

Timmy84 said:

MickyDolenz said:

I don't know if it's true or not, but I read once that Patti LaBelle gave Cindy Birdsong a beatdown when she left her group for the Supremes.

I knew they had a fallout and there was probably a nasty argument but you know, I wouldn't be surprised if that was actually accurate.

Remember what happened a few months ago involving Patti?

aardvark15 said:

Timmy84 said:

I knew they had a fallout and there was probably a nasty argument but you know, I wouldn't be surprised if that was actually accurate.

Remember what happened a few months ago involving Patti?

Yup. Patti gangsta.

What's Cindy Birdsong doing these days?

Im ROUGH AND TOUGH AND READY GIRL!

So dont you even try it!!

_aretha "Every girl wants my guy"

My vote goes to Grace Jones because she fights like a man.

TonyVanDam said:

My vote goes to Grace Jones because she fights like a man.

TonyVanDam said:

My vote goes to Grace Jones because she fights like a man.

And looks like one too

Why was Grace Jones never on Xena? i seriously want to know this

Grace, and she could take out that Gaga impostor too

Grace is the obvious favourite, because in a combat situation her thighs will act like a vice designed trap even the wiliest opponent.

Aretha's not so nimble, but she has one killer trick up her sleeve: should the opportunity arise, she can let loose 'the dogs' and suffocate her foe.

But my money's on Nina, because she'd likely turn up packing a gun.