independent and unofficial
Prince fan community
Welcome! Sign up or enter username and password to remember me
Forum jump
Forums > Music: Non-Prince > Madonna's Superbowl Performance?!
« Previous topic  Next topic »
Page 14 of 28 « First<101112131415161718>Last »
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
Reply #390 posted 02/06/12 8:09am

KCOOLMUZIQ

glamstar01 said:

what a joke performance - ceeloogreen as the only 1 who did not lyp- sinch

and the most ridiculous comment was from sheila e., love the girl but to say that was the best & madonna outdid everyone... & the 2comment "The only thing is she lip-sync...that is too bad...The visual was dope."

one question for SHEILA E. " wasn' you over the years singing with prince & band " REAL MUSIC 4 REAL MUSIC LOVERS "

ok you have a beef with prince but come on yr comment is bs - sorry sheila e.

nod

Exactly! Sheila E gets a major #fail for that remark. This proves she is no longer a part of the purple kingdom anymore.Whatever happen with her and Prince this put a final nail in the coffin with them.

How dare she say "Madonna outdid everyone"....Prince has his ways at getting back at people.Even though she is a talent in her own right PRINCE IS THE ONE THAT MADE HER A SUPERSTAR.Very ungrateful of her..

eye will ALWAYS think of prince like a "ACT OF GOD"! N another realm. eye mean of all people who might of been aliens or angels.if found out that prince wasn't of this earth, eye would not have been that surprised. R.I.P. prince
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #391 posted 02/06/12 8:16am

JoeTyler

KCOOLMUZIQ said:

glamstar01 said:

what a joke performance - ceeloogreen as the only 1 who did not lyp- sinch

and the most ridiculous comment was from sheila e., love the girl but to say that was the best & madonna outdid everyone... & the 2comment "The only thing is she lip-sync...that is too bad...The visual was dope."

one question for SHEILA E. " wasn' you over the years singing with prince & band " REAL MUSIC 4 REAL MUSIC LOVERS "

ok you have a beef with prince but come on yr comment is bs - sorry sheila e.

nod

Exactly! Sheila E gets a major #fail for that remark. This proves she is no longer a part of the purple kingdom anymore.

man, the purple kingdom is empty; yes the "king" is still there but he's an old, bitter king who betrayed ALL his friends of the 80s, now the kingdom is full of uncharismatic (or should I say unknown) "yes men/women"...

tinkerbell
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #392 posted 02/06/12 8:18am

kimrachell

she seemed really nervous to me, i didn't care for the performance at all. shrug

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #393 posted 02/06/12 8:22am

KCOOLMUZIQ

JoeTyler said:

KCOOLMUZIQ said:

nod

Exactly! Sheila E gets a major #fail for that remark. This proves she is no longer a part of the purple kingdom anymore.

man, the purple kingdom is empty; yes the "king" is still there but he's an old, bitter king who betrayed ALL his friends of the 80s, now the kingdom is full of uncharismatic (or should I say unknown) "yes men/women"...

A rich still revelant "King" that slayed all artist Madonna included as the best non lip Sync per4mance of the superbowl. Prince is still number 1 and the "King" of the stage. He doesn't need all the theatrics to get noticed. All the people in his purple kingdom in the 80's served there purpose. Poof! they are gone. But Prince can replace anyone in a heartbeat. He is the master muscian not them..Dont hate!

eye will ALWAYS think of prince like a "ACT OF GOD"! N another realm. eye mean of all people who might of been aliens or angels.if found out that prince wasn't of this earth, eye would not have been that surprised. R.I.P. prince
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #394 posted 02/06/12 8:25am

JoeTyler

KCOOLMUZIQ said:

JoeTyler said:

man, the purple kingdom is empty; yes the "king" is still there but he's an old, bitter king who betrayed ALL his friends of the 80s, now the kingdom is full of uncharismatic (or should I say unknown) "yes men/women"...

A rich still revelant "King" that slayed all artist Madonna included as the best non lip Sync per4mance of the superbowl. Prince is still number 1 and the "King" of the stage. He doesn't need all the theatrics to get noticed. All the people in his purple kingdom in the 80's served there purpose. Poof! they are gone. But Prince can replace anyone in a heartbeat. He is the master muscian not them..Dont hate!

I only meant that Prince is no saint, so if an old 80s collaborator talks shit about him, she/he's probably (partially) right

Prince sucks as a "King", h's kingdom is all ego, terror and bullshit, hell he's the Henry VIII of music!

lol

tinkerbell
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #395 posted 02/06/12 8:26am

deadmansbones

W

[Edited 2/6/12 9:20am]

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #396 posted 02/06/12 8:32am

Milty

avatar

rdhull said:

Milty said:

The Madonna discussion thread is locked.

Ok so....I watched it on YouTube, someone filming it on their phone from the tv.

I won't disparage it yet but I'll say that as a piece of theatre, it was brilliant. The dancing, the music, visuals, the costumes, the stage, all that stuff. Brilliant. I really liked the screen floor thingy. Wicked. I think Madge should have a Broadway show or a Vegas show and bring exactly what she did tonight (and more) to that kind of show. No one can bring it like her when it comes to that stuff.

Now the cons.....it's a crying shame that she had to bring all that stuff in the first place to make up for the fact that she probably can't carry a show like that by herself. And bringing the younger artists on feels like she is searching for relevance again. And as for the lip-synching.....terrible.

My two cents.

no credit for those badass boots she had on? it must have taken an hour to put them on

i think the left one was riding down. it looked wonky.

And what happened with Prince and Sheila E? there's beef?

[Edited 2/6/12 8:34am]

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #397 posted 02/06/12 8:38am

SoulAlive

Super Bowl 2012: Madonna Does A Higher Rating Than The Game
by Matt Verderame

Madonna is apparently still quite popular. The past sensation out-rated the Super Bowl, as her halftime performance generated a 48.3 rating compared to a 47.8 for the game according to reports from John Ourand.

Despite two very large market teams being involved in the affair, Super Bowl couldn't break its own ratings record which was set just last year by Green Bay and Pittsburgh.

Part of that is undoubtedly the very nice weather that the East has seen this year. With a normally bitter time of year upon us, people are much more likely to stay inside and look forward to the game.

It's truly amazing that Madonna is still as popular as she is. Many people were annoyed that the NFL was bringing in another older superstar to perform the halftime show, but clearly they made the right decision.

This Super Bowl did outdraw the previous match-up between these two teams as the 2007 game did a 43.1 rating.


http://newyork.sbnat...-madonna-rating

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #398 posted 02/06/12 8:40am

SoulAlive

The halftime performance by Madonna (8-8:30), earned a 48.1/72 overnight, one percent ahead of last year’s 8-8:30 time period featuring the Black Eyed Peas (47.4/70) and 20 percent higher than NBC’s last Super Bowl with Bruce Springsteen (40.2/62).The post-game (10-10:15) registered a 35.3/54, 17 percent higher than last year’s 30.3 for Super Bowl XLV in Fox.

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #399 posted 02/06/12 8:41am

KCOOLMUZIQ

Milty said:

rdhull said:

no credit for those badass boots she had on? it must have taken an hour to put them on

i think the left one was riding down. it looked wonky.

And what happened with Prince and Sheila E? there's beef?

[Edited 2/6/12 8:34am]

Yes! Sheila tweeted last year that "she will no longer per4rm with Prince again"....Now her making these praise remarks 4 Madonna's superbowl show. Puts the nail in the Coffin.

[Edited 2/6/12 12:26pm]

eye will ALWAYS think of prince like a "ACT OF GOD"! N another realm. eye mean of all people who might of been aliens or angels.if found out that prince wasn't of this earth, eye would not have been that surprised. R.I.P. prince
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #400 posted 02/06/12 8:42am

SoulAlive

http://www.bbc.co.uk...t-arts-16904511
Super Bowl: Madonna gives 'shot of brass'

Madonna gave "a shot of female brass" to the Super Bowl with her 12-minute half-time show, reviewers have said.

Entertainment Weekly said the pop star was "a bright delight", "plugging her product with such gleeful abandon".

The Los Angeles Times said her show was "arguably more outrageous than the notorious Jackson nipple shot" of 2004.

But the New York Times argued she had taken "a downright benign stance" compared with more shocking Madonna performances of years gone by.
Posted Image
The 53-year-old's half-time performance at the Lucas Oil Stadium, in Indianapolis, included hits Vogue, Music, Open Your Heart, Express Yourself and Like a Prayer as well as new song Give Me all Your Luvin', from new album MDNA, due out next month.

She entered the stadium on a chariot, led by dozens of Roman gladiators, wearing a black and gold costume topped with an elaborate crown.

Marching bands, tightrope acrobats, gladiators and choirs - as well as guest stars M.I.A, Nicki Minaj, Cee Lo Green and LMFAO - were among the cast in the spectacular show, watched by more than 100 million TV viewers in the US.

Censors have paid special attention to the half-time entertainment ever since the 2004 Super Bowl performance in Houston, Texas, when Justin Timberlake famously exposed Janet Jackson's breast during a duet.

The only controversial moment this year came when British singer M.I.A. was seen gesturing with her middle finger.

Broadcaster NBC later apologised for the "inappropriate" and "spontaneous gesture".
'True professional'

Meanwhile, Entertainment Weekly's Ken Tucker cited interviews with Madonna last week stating she had no plans to incite controversy.

"But instead of resulting in a cautious, tedious performance, Madonna gave a joyous, unironic, open-hearted one," he added.
"Now the carping will begin in living rooms and throughout the internet: Was she lip-syncing? Did she make a few wobbly moves? Was M.I.A. being a naughty girl?

"Me, I don't care - I was happy to see Madonna smiling so much, giving it her all".

Sarah Fitzmaurice, of the the UK's Daily Mail, said Madonna had previously declared she had to put on "the greatest show on earth, during the greatest show on Earth".

The paper added that she "certainly didn't disappoint".

It said that, under "immense" and greatly-felt" pressure, she had only suffered "one small slip-up throughout the show".

"As she was strutting her way across the bleachers to Music, the second song in her set, she was unable to step up onto one of them and had to repeat the dance move to hoist herself up," it said.

"But Madonna proved a true professional and laughed the error off throwing herself into the next sequence of the set."

The star's mis-step came after she revealed she had pulled a hamstring during rehearsals, requiring "a lot of warm-ups, taping and ultrasound".
Posted Image
The half-time show marks the start of the campaign for Madonna's 12th studio album, MDNA - her first for new record label Interscope

The New York Times' Jon Pareles noted that Madonna was no longer "the indefatigable trouper of years past".

"The bad girl is a grown-up now, like it or not," he added.

"It's impossible to guess what the Madonna of decades past, fascinated with lust, power, religion and transgression, might have done with this platform."

It said that, while the star was "still lithe, she measured her moves, letting her supporting cast offer distractions".

USA Today's Elysa Gardner, meanwhile, described Madonna as "stylish but hardly provocative in tailored tops and skirts that showed off her yoga-toned gams" saying she had delivered flourishes "with a winking sense of humour".

And she suggested that, if the singer "moved a little less nimbly than usual, it might have had to do with a reported pulled hamstring - or gravity-defying heels".

She added that, in Give Me All Your Luvin' - featuring M.I.A and Nicky Minaj - Madonna had "wisely" chosen "not to join the younger stars or an accompanying ensemble in donning cheerleader outfits".

The Chicago Tribune's Greg Kot complained the song, released on Friday "fell flat".

"Rhyming 'ya wanna' with 'Madonna', recasting herself as a cheerleader for a sport that she's barely noticed in decades past - it was the Material Girl who couldn't deliver the goods," he said.

Referring to the lip-syncing, he said Madonna had "never really been about 'live' performance - her concerts are essentially theatrical exhibitions accompanied by piped in music".
Posted Image

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #401 posted 02/06/12 8:47am

Milty

avatar

KCOOLMUZIQ said:

Milty said:

i think the left one was riding down. it looked wonky.

And what happened with Prince and Sheila E? there's beef?

[Edited 2/6/12 8:34am]

Yes! Sheila tweeted last year that "she will no longer per4rm with Prince again"....Now her making these praise remarks 4 Madonna's superbowl show. Puts the nail in the carpet.

Why'd she say that?

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #402 posted 02/06/12 8:48am

SoulAlive

Madonna performs during the Super Bowl XLVI Halftime Show.
Enlarge Ezra Shaw/Getty Images

Madonna performs during the Super Bowl XLVI Halftime Show.

Madonna is just about the only thing I remember about the Super Bowl last night, and interestingly, it made me think about the fact that she's just about the only thing I remember about Live Aid, which was more than 25 years ago.

Madonna performs for a sold out crowd at the Live Aid concert at JFK Stadium in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, July 13, 1985.
Frank Micelotta/Getty Images

Madonna performs for a sold out crowd at the Live Aid concert at JFK Stadium in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, July 13, 1985.

Notwithstanding the specific images that would come to define her — Marilyn Madonna, dominatrix Madonna, Evita Madonna — this was just a young, magnetic singer, clearly not lip-synching, dancing in her heavy, shoulder-padded jacket in front of a crowd that was drenched in sweat. This was July 1985, after "Like A Virgin" colonized MTV, after the underwear-as-outerwear, right before she married Sean Penn. She was already a capital-T Thing, but this was really just singing and dancing, and anyone who comes to think of her as purely an imagined concoction, all elaborate hat and no cattle, someone who never existed outside of videos, is misremembering.

All the other business, from the erotic photography book to the kiss with Britney Spears to the Super Bowl halftime show — that's all what she decided to do with being Madonna after she'd already done it, but it's not how she got to be Madonna, not originally. She got to be Madonna making enormously danceable music and being great to watch. The first video of hers that made an impression on me is surprisingly free of affectation; it's largely a cornball soap opera, just like most of the other videos of the time.

If you'd been able to put down money that day in July 1985 on whether she would be playing the Super Bowl halftime show more than 26 years later, and if you'd actually done it, you'd probably be rich now. Her chances for longevity were widely regarded as so slim as to be an available joke. My favorite TV show then was Moonlighting, and I remember an episode they did somewhere around this time about recovering a lost Rolodex full of famous names. In negotiating for its return, David Addison (Bruce Willis) asked for just a few of the cards back if he couldn't have the whole thing. Maybe he could just have the M section, he suggested. Or maybe just Madonna. "Nobody's going to want her number next year anyway," he said.

But here she is, 53 years old, it's four presidents later, and she's still a headliner. Granted, she's a headliner at the halftime show, an event that's shifted more and more toward legacy artists like The Who, Bruce Springsteen, and Tom Petty. It's tempting to attribute the nasty Twitter commentary about how she allegedly looked old and haggard — really? — to unreasonable expectations placed upon women around aging, but honestly, Mick Jagger gets the same thing. The Who got it, Bob Dylan gets it, Tom Petty gets it. It's part and parcel of aging in front of the people who once bounced your work off of their youth to discern its shape and now aren't interested in seeing whatever may be reflected in your not looking exactly like you used to.

What's curious, given how much "ewww, she's too old" stuff went around on Twitter, is that everything she did Sunday night is exactly what it should mean to age gracefully. She did what she loves and what she's always been good at: infectiously danceable pop in high-energy production numbers, assisted by lots of dancers. She looked happy. She embraced younger performers including Nicki Minaj and M.I.A., both of whom share her penchant for self-invention and both of whom are on her new single. She even made judicious choices when picking hits to perform. "Like A Virgin" might be the go-to song when Ricky Gervais wants to make a joke about her at the Golden Globes, but she's right to have relegated it to the background these days in favor of better stuff like "Vogue," which remains an irresistible confection.


Certainly the halftime show, as everyone knew it would, delivered a certain amount of over-the-top nonsense, as has been required of Super Bowl halftime shows stretching back to the days when they used to feature Up With People. (Those shirtless dudes hauling Madonna with ropes may have been silly, but they are no sillier than Indiana Jones And The Vin...rdi Trophy.) And having the words "WORLD PEACE" appear in lights at the end was probably the only thing she could do that would be sillier than all that had come before.

It's not that Madonna is the embodiment of grace for anyone else. She's done some ridiculous things, and she's picked up such hilarious affectations along the way that you can refer to a vague British accent of unknown origin as "doing a Madonna" and you can expect to be understood. But this version of Madonna, I think, is grace for her.

There was always going to be a Madonna At 53, alongside those Marilyn and Evita Madonnas. And really, what could it have looked like, other than this? What was she supposed to be at this point? Invisible? Was she supposed to abandon the dance pop to which she so palpably loved shaking her shoulders in a stadium in Philadelphia in 1985 and start singing standards? Would that not have invited a different kind of criticism, that she had gone all cruise-ship on us?

It's awfully hard to endure in public, particularly if your image tends to be big rather than little. It's hard to avoid a series of unwinnable arguments — you've changed too much; you haven't changed enough. You look old; you're trying too hard to look young. You won't accept that you're older; you've lost all the charm of your youth. But more than a quarter-century after she stubbornly danced in that ridiculously heavy jacket in all that jangly jewelry, Madonna seems to have figured out, if nothing else, how not to worry about it.

Comments

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #403 posted 02/06/12 8:50am

SoulAlive

KCOOLMUZIQ said:

Milty said:

i think the left one was riding down. it looked wonky.

And what happened with Prince and Sheila E? there's beef?

[Edited 2/6/12 8:34am]

Yes! Sheila tweeted last year that "she will no longer per4rm with Prince again"....Now her making these praise remarks 4 Madonna's superbowl show. Puts the nail in the carpet.

So because Sheila enjoyed Madonna's show,you now wanna sell your copy of "The Glamorous Life" and erase her from your memory? evillol How dare she like another artist besides your King!

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #404 posted 02/06/12 8:56am

PurpleChi

avatar

KCOOLMUZIQ said:

Milty said:

i think the left one was riding down. it looked wonky.

And what happened with Prince and Sheila E? there's beef?

[Edited 2/6/12 8:34am]

Yes! Sheila tweeted last year that "she will no longer per4rm with Prince again"....Now her making these praise remarks 4 Madonna's superbowl show. Puts the nail in the carpet.

I don't think Prince cares if Sheila thinks Madonna outdid everyone. I think Sheila was definitely trying to send a message though. The sad part is that Sheila's message hurt no one but herself. She is entitled to her opinion, but everybody knows that real musicians appreciate real music above all else. It is okay to say the Madonna's performance was entertaining and that the visuals were dope. But to say that she outdid everyone who has ever performed Superbowl halftime? That just shows her heart on her sleeve. Even she can't possibly beleive that BS.

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #405 posted 02/06/12 8:59am

SoulAlive

for the record,Sheila has been a Madonna fan from Day One.She even appears briefly in Madonna's concert documentary 'Truth Or Dare'.

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #406 posted 02/06/12 9:00am

NaughtyKitty

avatar

SoulAlive said:

It's tempting to attribute the nasty Twitter commentary about how she allegedly looked old and haggard — really? — to unreasonable expectations placed upon women around aging, but honestly, Mick Jagger gets the same thing. The Who got it, Bob Dylan gets it, Tom Petty gets it. It's part and parcel of aging in front of the people who once bounced your work off of their youth to discern its shape and now aren't interested in seeing whatever may be reflected in your not looking exactly like you used to.

What's curious, given how much "ewww, she's too old" stuff went around on Twitter, is that everything she did Sunday night is exactly what it should mean to age gracefully. She did what she loves and what she's always been good at: infectiously danceable pop in high-energy production numbers, assisted by lots of dancers. She looked happy.

Comments

Agree with this.

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #407 posted 02/06/12 9:10am

lazycrockett

avatar

M.I.A got some good press out of that middle finger, thats all any of the news outlets are talking bout.

The Most Important Thing In Life Is Sincerity....Once You Can Fake That, You Can Fake Anything.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #408 posted 02/06/12 9:11am

PurpleChi

avatar

SoulAlive said:

for the record,Sheila has been a Madonna fan from Day One.She even appears briefly in Madonna's concert documentary 'Truth Or Dare'.

I don't think anyone is criticizing Sheila for being a Madonna fan--or even for liking her Superbowl performance. I think what no one can believe is that Sheila really thinks that Madonna gave the best Superbowl perfomance ever. In interviews Sheila has always been a proponent of real musicianship. Yes, Madonna's visuals were very good--they should have been given all of the components (gladiators, marching band, Cirque de Soleil, gospel choir, elaborate staging, hot new artists, etc.). But she was singing to a recording. No real musician can really think such a performance is the best ever.

Someone I follow on Twitter said it best. "Prince sang, danced & played guitar in the pouring rain. Madonna never even turned her mic on."

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #409 posted 02/06/12 9:35am

sosgemini

avatar

lazycrockett said:

M.I.A got some good press out of that middle finger, thats all any of the news outlets are talking bout.

nod

lol

Space for sale...
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #410 posted 02/06/12 9:36am

GustavoRibas

avatar

xLiberiangirl said:

Compare in terms of talent?????

MJ has other talents than Madonna, but both are entertainers mostly to me. Madonna can do things MJ can't do, and MJ can do stuff Madonna can't do.. don't think MJ is more talented than Madonna, or Madonna more talented than MJ.

- Michael kicks Madonna´s butt when it comes to dancing, singing and songwriting (ok, he wasnt a prolific songwriter but wrote some classics all by himself). Madonna only could rival him as an entertainer/pop icon (and I still think MJ was one step ahead).

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #411 posted 02/06/12 9:38am

GustavoRibas

avatar

go2theMax said:

GustavoRibas said:

- Yes, it´s true. MJ lip synched, but let´s not compare MJ and Madonna in terms of talent...hehehehe

I agree that Madonna´s performance was better, but let´s keep in mind that MJ´s concert was during daylight, so he couldnt take advantage of all those stage lights. After watching This is It DVD, I keep on guessing how a MJ Halftime show would have been today...

no need 4 guessing here...it would be the smae coreographies and gimmicks as usual since Dangerous tour...the only new thing would probably be 3D effects

- yeah, that´s what I meant. MJ didnt change the choreographies much with the times, but was thinking about these special effects. If he did a Halftime today, it would certainly be a lot better than what he did in 93..

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #412 posted 02/06/12 9:43am

EyeJester7

SoulAlive said:

I agree with the person who said that Madonna had the most awesome stage love it's breathtaking.She should use this stage and the visuals for her tour....Posted ImagePosted Image

AHH!!! faint THE STAGE WAS ABSOLUTELY AWESOME WASN'T IT? IT IS PERFECT!!!! smile SHE REALLY SHOULD USE THIS FOR HER TOUR! It added genius to the whole thang! lol

It's Button Therapy, Baby!
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #413 posted 02/06/12 9:45am

EyeJester7

SoulAlive said:

http://www.madonnarama.com/artworks/posts/20120206-pictures-madonna-super-bowl-half-time-show-performance-88.jpg

THIS WAS epiK!!!!!!! I loved their outfits and harmony! I watched it again this morning, and she really did add energy and Z E A L! smile

It's Button Therapy, Baby!
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #414 posted 02/06/12 9:46am

WaterInYourBat
h

avatar

The visual effects during the Gordy offspring segment were impressive, but in terms of movement, Madonna looked, well, old. I thought she would be the type who wouldn't be caught flailing around like that after she turned 50.

"You put water into a cup, it becomes the cup...Now water can flow or it can crash. Be water, my friend." - Bruce Lee
"Water can nourish me, but water can also carry me. Water has magic laws." - JCVD
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #415 posted 02/06/12 9:48am

EyeJester7

V10LETBLUES said:

I like Madonna for a lot of reasons, her music has never been at the top top of my list list.

I like her for her hard work and passion in her performances.

For her sharp media savvy.

For having such a great eye and pulse on contemporary culture.

For her ability of perfectly blending commercialism and art.

Music aside, people like me could never argue with the quality of her videos or her sharp persona. The new video and Superbowl performance are sloppy and by the numbers, and maybe even out of touch and cheesy in a non clever or ironic manner. Maybe it comes with age, but this is unlike her.

Madonna has begun to just go through the motions. It's one thing to be the cool grandma, like Betty White, but it's another to be the out of touch midlife crisis grandma. She is this close to start becoming a parody of herself. She is starting to resemble something we would see while flipping through the channels on Telemundo or Siempre in Domingo.

[Edited 2/6/12 5:36am]

nod I first I never really cared to pay attention to her genius details, but that is what makes her great! smile She's awesome..As far as what you said after that.....WELL.. Eye guess we can se it many ways from the mirrors and windows!

It's Button Therapy, Baby!
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #416 posted 02/06/12 9:51am

go2theMax

avatar

GustavoRibas said:

go2theMax said:

no need 4 guessing here...it would be the smae coreographies and gimmicks as usual since Dangerous tour...the only new thing would probably be 3D effects

- yeah, that´s what I meant. MJ didnt change the choreographies much with the times, but was thinking about these special effects. If he did a Halftime today, it would certainly be a lot better than what he did in 93..

u could even expect him 2 have a double 4 some of the coreographies

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #417 posted 02/06/12 10:18am

728huey

avatar

Just as I figured it would go, Madonna's Super Bowl halftime performance wasn't that radically different from the Black Eyed Peas last year, yet all of the headlines in the mainstream media are about how awesome she was. rolleyes sigh disbelief I'm not saying it was horrible; it was entertaining, and the stage setup was awesome, but I think a lot of people are looking at this performance thru beer goggles.

typing

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #418 posted 02/06/12 10:24am

wonder505

PurpleChi said:

SoulAlive said:

for the record,Sheila has been a Madonna fan from Day One.She even appears briefly in Madonna's concert documentary 'Truth Or Dare'.

I don't think anyone is criticizing Sheila for being a Madonna fan--or even for liking her Superbowl performance. I think what no one can believe is that Sheila really thinks that Madonna gave the best Superbowl perfomance ever. In interviews Sheila has always been a proponent of real musicianship. Yes, Madonna's visuals were very good--they should have been given all of the components (gladiators, marching band, Cirque de Soleil, gospel choir, elaborate staging, hot new artists, etc.). But she was singing to a recording. No real musician can really think such a performance is the best ever.

Someone I follow on Twitter said it best. "Prince sang, danced & played guitar in the pouring rain. Madonna never even turned her mic on."

I agree with this statement. The show was visually stunning. Probably the best I've ever seen, but as far as muscianship and substance it was lacking. The sound from the mic was low and the fact that it was lip synching on top of that. Nothing like bad lip synching.

Once again, Nikki Minaj, MIA and Ceelo adding nothing to the performance. Ceelo can sing but what was that????

I don't know. She could have done better, but in NO WAY is it better than Prince's show.

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #419 posted 02/06/12 10:36am

JoeTyler

wonder505 said:

PurpleChi said:

I don't think anyone is criticizing Sheila for being a Madonna fan--or even for liking her Superbowl performance. I think what no one can believe is that Sheila really thinks that Madonna gave the best Superbowl perfomance ever. In interviews Sheila has always been a proponent of real musicianship. Yes, Madonna's visuals were very good--they should have been given all of the components (gladiators, marching band, Cirque de Soleil, gospel choir, elaborate staging, hot new artists, etc.). But she was singing to a recording. No real musician can really think such a performance is the best ever.

Someone I follow on Twitter said it best. "Prince sang, danced & played guitar in the pouring rain. Madonna never even turned her mic on."

I agree with this statement. The show was visually stunning. Probably the best I've ever seen, but as far as muscianship and substance it was lacking. The sound from the mic was low and the fact that it was lip synching on top of that. Nothing like bad lip synching.

Once again, Nikki Minaj, MIA and Ceelo adding nothing to the performance. Ceelo can sing but what was that????

I don't know. She could have done better, but in NO WAY is it better than Prince's show.

and nobody says otherwise (only a small, very small minority, lol), but I still say that Madonna's performance was the BEST of the pop/dance/slick/mainstream performances. People comparing M to BYE are just...bitter, lol

tinkerbell
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Page 14 of 28 « First<101112131415161718>Last »
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
« Previous topic  Next topic »
Forums > Music: Non-Prince > Madonna's Superbowl Performance?!