did u sell this album in a second hand store?

do u still have this album?

do u still play it?

do u hate it (then and now)?

did (and do) u like it?

do u think it's already dated?

do u think it still sounds current/fresh?

do u think it's her worst album ever?

which is your favorite track off the album?

etc.etc

[Edited 10/23/11 7:59am]

My opinion?

Meh.

Not a big Madge fan, but I've heard the album and think Four Minutes and She's Not Me are great. Bit too much Justin Timberlake on the album for me though. Is he really so big-headed that he can't co-produce a song without plastering his whiney vocals all over it???

time FUCKIN' flies, by the way!!!

I have not listened to it after I bought it when it was released. I don't like it very much. I prefer her House/trance influenced albums.

I still play it semi-regularly

It's still fun to listen to, although I skip increadible every time.

I sill LOVE Heartbeat!

But it's probly still my least favorite album, only behind Like a Virgin.

Oh and:

did u sell this album in a second hand store? No

do u still have this album? Yes

do u still play it? No

do u hate it (then and now)? Yes

did (and do) u like it? No

do u think it's already dated? Yes

do u think it still sounds current/fresh? No

do u think it's her worst album ever? Don't know

which is your favorite track off the album? The first single with timberlake. Don't recall the name.

[Edited 10/23/11 8:18am]

hendrikus said:

Oh and:

did u sell this album in a second hand store? No

do u still have this album? Yes

do u still play it? No

do u hate it (then and now)? Yes

did (and do) u like it? No

do u think it's already dated? Yes

do u think it still sounds current/fresh? No

do u think it's her worst album ever? Don't know

which is your favorite track off the album? The first single with timberlake. Don't recall the name.

[Edited 10/23/11 8:18am]

4 Minutes.

never bothered getting it..only liked 4minutes..and when i heard that other song..i think hard candy it was so atrocious i didnt bother getting the album

did u sell this album in a second hand store? No

do u still have this album? Yes

do u still play it? Rarely, Other than like 4 okay tracks

do u hate it (then and now)? Yes

did (and do) u like it? A Little

do u think it's already dated? Yes

do u think it still sounds current/fresh? No

do u think it's her worst album ever? Yes

which is your favorite track off the album? Miles Away

I still listen to "Miles Away" almost everyday

Love that song!

I dislike this album, idk.... it was just so boring to me. Besides Miles Away i really didn't care for the album. It's up there with Like A Virginf or my least favorite Madonna albums

this is what i think of it....

Awful album. A pop artist's attempt to go 'street'.

4 Minutes is the only diamond in the bunch. But it's more of a Timberland/Timberlake song.

On the other hand, Ray of Light and Confessions' are still as slammin as the day they came out!

Lets put it THIS way, VoicesCarry tried to warned me and I didn't listen to reason like I should have.

4 Minutes really does suck! The beats were hot for a moment three years ago. But in the long-term, that is one Madonna track that didn't aged well at all.

JoeTyler said:

did u sell this album in a second hand store?

Yes. I bought the vinyl and subsequently sold it.

do u still have this album?

No.

do u still play it?

No.

do u hate it (then and now)?

Didn't hate it (then). Don't hate it now.

did (and do) u like it?

I did like it. Just not enough to keep it in my collection. Haven't heard it in awhile.

do u think it's already dated?

Yes. Twas dated upon arrival.

do u think it still sounds current/fresh?

No. It wasn't current when released.

do u think it's her worst album ever?

Hmm.. It's on the lower end of the totem pole, but worst? No..

which is your favorite track off the album?

Without having heard any of the tracks in awhile.. "Spanish Lesson".

phoned in from beginning to end. there are some nice moments here and there, but she had very little to do with them.

Love this album, it has so many underrated album tracks. It's still unforgiveable how Beat Goes On was not released. My mom heard this song recently and can't stop playing it. It's upbeat and fresh and carefree, just what she wanted. I don't know if it's her best, though it's not awful like people make it out to be, she did a good job combining modern sounds with her early sound and for that, it deserved more sales and promotion. It got airplay in Canada and the tour was a success, so I think it's just the US that can't appreciate her the way the rest of the world does. She worked very well with Timbaland and the Neptunes though it would be redundant if she kept doing it.

My only complaints about the era are that whatever work she did on her face was a distraction (sorry, I know I sound like a hypocrite but it was sad seeing her like that) , and though it was the very first Madonna tour I attended, I had awful seats in the nosebleed section and I think she already peaked a long time ago with her performing on tour though the stage set and design were amazing, and for that, I'll go for the next tour as well.

And the album artwork is nice, I love those candy designs

[Edited 10/23/11 20:22pm]

One of her best albums. I haven't like a Madonna as much as HARD CANDY since BEDTIME STORIES.

Her 00's albums were much more solid than her 90's ones IMO though I also like them. I like Erotica and ROL, Bedtime Stories was hit and miss for me as an album, but the perfect singles were chosen.

Favorite song is Miles Away and 4 Minutes, but the rest is still forgetable.

Mine are Beat Goes On, Dance 2 Night, 4 Minutes, Give It To Me

It was my first Madonna purchase and I still love it like the day I bought it.

The only Madonna album I never bought. Before that I'd buy the latest one to top up the collection to make it complete, but I couldn't bring myself to purchase this rubbish.

Loved it then, love it now. Fun listen, which is what dance pop should be.

Ellie said:

The only Madonna album I never bought. Before that I'd buy the latest one to top up the collection to make it complete, but I couldn't bring myself to purchase this rubbish.

I got like that with Mariah's Angels album

It's a great album. Still my 5th favorite of hers. "She's Not Me" and "Beat Goes On" are still hot!

It's one of Madonna's most 'fun' albums.There are no deep messages here...it's just fun,accessible dance/pop aimed at the dancefloor.

"Miles Away","Heartbeat","She's Not Me","Beat Goes On" and "Devil Wouldn't Recognize You" are strong,solid tracks.

The only clunkers on this album are "Spanish Lesson" and "Voices".

I think Madonna should work with Pharrell again.

My opinion is simple: there are three or four very average tracks (Incredible, Heartbeat, Dance 2Nite and Voices) and the other tracks are just too "american 00s shit-hop" for me. She should have worked with Timba-Lake/Pharell AND then with Stuart Price again to give the songs a nice euro-dance shine. Why do I say this? just listen tot the S&STour arena/dance remixes, the songs sound much better than the original studio versions...

That said, I just hope she NEVER releases another pure-dance/pop/fun album again, specially at this point of her career...

the highlights are still Miles Away, She's Not Me, and Give It To Me tour version

Beat Goes On is a GREAT crossover song, kind of "Madonna meets 00s Hip-Pop" song, but not a great Madonna song, if that makes any sense...and 4 Minutes still sounds like a Timba-Lake song featuring Madonna, but not the other way around,lol, the title-track was a good show opener, but not much more...

[Edited 10/24/11 8:09am]