I like Adele, but I LOVE Amy, in all her crackhead glory. Can't wait for some new stuff from her.

NO contest

AMY !

Amy, please. I like Adele for what she is, which is fine. But Amy's voice is another level.

Adele.

Amy Winehouse.

I don't like Adele but I loved Amy.

Amy easily. I find Adele boring.

Adele can sing. Amy sounds like she's on smack and being kicked in the cunt most of the time.

Adele is okay.

Amy is a naturally gifted singer and songwriter with soul.

I'll get slayed for this, but I'll take Duffy over both of them.

Duffy sounds like an overheated chipmunk and I don't think she is a natural soul singer in the least.

Trueiopian, just out of curiousity-do you not think Adele is naturally gifted as singer and songwriter?

scriptgirl said:

Duffy sounds like an overheated chipmunk and I don't think she is a natural soul singer in the least.

Trueiopian, just out of curiousity-do you not think Adele is naturally gifted as singer and songwriter?

Maybe, but her songs are a lot more fun and interesting than Adele's.

I've been meaning to listen to some Adele, so I can't say yea or ney on her yet. But I DO LOVE me some Amy big time! I wish she'd get her shit together and put a new album out soon.

Amy by a winehouse.

She's a real soul child.

Adele is super-talented, love her.

But, when she's together and on.... AMY has a rare gift of days gone by.

At the moment, I can't stop listening to Adele! but I do love Amy as well, wish there was something new from her.

Gabriella Cilmi.

I also love it how she sold out her Amy Winehouse-ish image to become Kylie Lite.

scriptgirl said:

Duffy sounds like an overheated chipmunk and I don't think she is a natural soul singer in the least.

Trueiopian, just out of curiousity-do you not think Adele is naturally gifted as singer and songwriter?

I agree with the bolded

Adele is a great talent with a very nice voice but I wouldn't say she's a natural. Amy is a rare talent that doesn't come around too often in the industry.

If I can just listen to Back In Black, Amy. If I had to see a live show, well, Adele is the one who can still get through a verse without gasping for breath.

novabrkr said:

Gabriella Cilmi.

I also love it how she sold out her Amy Winehouse-ish image to become Kylie Lite.

"On a Mission" was a big flop, but I love it!

Before "21" is was Amy all the way, not sure now...i really like the "21" album, Adele's voice is very strong

slighty off topic = does Amy still have a career?? anyone?

i cant stand amy,adele or duffy they shout too much,give me judy collins any day.

robertlove said:

Before "21" is was Amy all the way, not sure now...i really like the "21" album, Adele's voice is very strong

I can't get it till the 22nd.

BOTH!!!!! I mean i love Amy a little bit more, but i absolutely adore both of them.

scriptgirl said:

Duffy sounds like an overheated chipmunk and I don't think she is a natural soul singer in the least.

Trueiopian, just out of curiousity-do you not think Adele is naturally gifted as singer and songwriter?

scriptgirl said:

Duffy sounds like an overheated chipmunk and I don't think she is a natural soul singer in the least.

Trueiopian, just out of curiousity-do you not think Adele is naturally gifted as singer and songwriter?

Her voice does get a tad bit annoying sometimes.

I didn't much like Adele's first album, but I admit I didn't give it much of a try. I did like "Chasing Pavements" though. So I picked up 21 cuz "Rolling in the Deep" is my jam and this song right here blew me away.

It's hard to say if either is "better" than the other as their voices are so different from each other, on top of being so different from typical stuff you hear.

21 is a really awesome album, though. I hope Amy can pull it together to make a third one.

Adele all the way. I love that girl's voice and her songwriting.

Amy completely lost me when I saw the video of her singing that racist football song. She could literally fall off a cliff and I could care less now, which is sad because before that I did have a lot of her music and enjoyed her as an artist. However, I will NEVER condone that level of ignorance, bigotry and disrespect from an artist, especially one who wouldn't have a career if it wasn't for many of those blacks, Pakis, and gays she insulted with that bs.