errant said:

Right....

It humors me that ONCE AGAIN the Jackson fans are bickering like old ladies.

Timmy84 said:

What's new? They do it all of the time around here.

Graycap23 said:

They could have pulled out MJ's "What More Can I Give?" and updated it a tad, and let THAT be the Haiti single. It never was released, IIRC.

ernestsewell said:

It was released online. You could purchase the mp3 for $1 (or so) a year after the originally planed release. I have it somewhere.


[Edited 2/2/10 12:03pm]

come to think of it, I didn't play the original when i bought the album..I played 4 The Tears

daPrettyman said:

I know but it's like it's becoming an episodic thing lol Episode #1542 Midiscover and seeing voices go back over who had the best lacefront, MJ or Janet?

banks said:

I didn't either. I remember liking the Huey Lewis song, Pointer Sisters, and Prince. THere may be one more that I can't recall.

I need to dust off that cd and listen to it.

Timmy84 said:

Awe! Can't wait!

I think this is a good part of Janet's healing process + making up for not being a part of the the orginal '85 line up.

This is going to be one big ass pop culture cheeseball.

Timmy84 said:

Me and seeing voices weren't arguing

midiscover said:

I wasn't saying you were. But y'all were going back and forth.

trueiopian said:

Just like the original

Except that line up had talent, besides a few unneeded faces.

Timmy84 said:

I think you're mistaking me for ernestsewell.

midiscover said:

Well I apologize but still I don't know why anyone would bicker over something I wish wasn't re-recorded.

Lammastide said:

Did Madonna nicely told Quincy "no" already?!?

TonyVanDam said:

Either her or Gaga lol

ernestsewell said:

michael wrote like 90% of this song, they should leave some of michael's vocals in. i don't mind them redoing it since it's for a good cause i just hope they don't butcher it and if they're gonna change the lyrics they might as well make a different song.but if anyone is gonna do some of michael's parts i'd rather it be janet

Well, whoever has a lot to live up to. I always find the last 2 minutes of this astonishing.



[Edited 2/2/10 14:18pm]

Timmy84 said:

What? LOL

I posted my opinion on here and as always, I was insulted and personally attacked, and notice that I didn't insult anyone or any artist., Janet wasn’t even in my mind and I didn’t compare her to Mj, I posted my opinion because that’s why these forums created for, to share opinions and have a healthy respectful debate , something that this forum truly lacks, I was even criticized for my English , like they expect every single member on this board is a native American …re-read the posts

They shouldn't remake it PERIOD but i'm fine with janet on it.

seeingvoices12 said:

seeingvoices12 said:

I know you were attacked. I was making a mockery of how folks argue. Not going to any of y'all. Believe me you got my back.

babybugz said:

Timmy84 said:

I know

Unless Janet is singing the first chorus and "When you're down and out, and there seems no hope at all", She really isn't replacing Michael at all.

Just saying, and this is for a good cause, grow up y'all.

It's less of a good cause then it is about greed. Haiti needs more than music right now so I don't like that gesture lol but that's just me. Not being a snob just expressing myself here.

Timmy84 said:

Sure it does, but a dollar or two from someone who might buy this and not contribute otherwise helps. Times that by a couple of million... It was worth it for Ethiopia, and worth it for Haiti.