mimi07 said:

If anything, Lady GaGa was the best. She gave me everything. What was the purpose of the guns? It looks like a revamped "Check On It" video.

ViintageJunkiie said:

yeah i was like what's up with all the guns. beyonce is always good but she hasn't brought anything new to the table. gaga didn't give me anything. i like her better when she has her costumes and she's attempting to be creative

overall is was whatever, nothing special like they hype made it seem
[Edited 11/16/09 18:12pm]

mimi07 said:

basically. The video was hyped up for no reason. sadly we might be seeing another video collabo for GaGa's "Telephone" but i know GaGa's vision will over shadow Beys...as usual

i like the fact that Lady GaGa is showing her face. i think she's gorgeous.

i'm shocked Beyoncé let someone stand in FRONT of her in a video.

the 'dancing' is predictable.

what's the point of the guns?

she worked that Bettie Page look though.

apart from the pretty colours, it wasn't impressive enough to have previews.
[Edited 11/16/09 18:24pm]

Lady Gaga dances like Mary Catherine Gallagher though

CHIC0 said:

agreed

Cinnie said:

even though it's been leaked i'm still gonna wait til 12 to watch it :stupidfornoreason:

InsatiableCream said:

wtf

InsatiableCream said:

I'ma wait ten decades and then watch it

Alej said:

so i changed my mind and watched it.

god damn that was fucking terrible

I liked GaGa's part but man

talk about a let down. the colors, the guns (wtf was that shit?), beyonce's stupid ass outfits.... lawdy

Protege said:

I'm so scared of watching

Alej said:

it's so shitty

InsatiableCream said:

InsatiableCream said:

Cinnie said:

wtf

Man, that was just horrible.

Maybe that's an unofficial rough cut. If not, that was WACK. Here I am, defending Beyonce's voice and stage talent, and she releases ANOTHER banal music video like this. "If I Were A Boy" was a great video, but yet she regresses back to this type of tired imagery, again. And what's the purpose of Gaga being there anyway? She didn't add anything interesting to this production.

InsatiableCream said:

Is it intense, though?

WaterInYourBath said:

Video Phone was a wack song to begin with. That's what you get for writing a song while the tape is running, just to say you finished it in a week.

Lady Gaga made the experience livable.

Cinnie said:

WaterInYourBath said:

Even IF it is a rough copy, the video still sucks. they made us wait for THAT? Beys videos are never groundbreaking

it's very strange seeing GaGa make Bad Romance (which is incredible) and then lower herself to this

InsatiableCream said:

It's the idea of the collaboration that makes it special though... sorta like Madonna + Prince "Love Song" [1989]

Cinnie said:

!!

Alej said:

GaGa makes it intense

however everything else makes it lame

Cinnie said:

it should have stayed just that

I like the use of the colors throughout and I'm kinda glad B is dropping the J Set dances a bit too. That shit was starting to get tired for real...

InsatiableCream said:

i didn't like the song much to begin with, so i'm thinking that's part of the reason the video (why was it hyped so much??? it has to be their names ) is striking me as incredibly boring. that and i hate the random flashy effect. it annoys me for some reason.