Her last album only sold 1.6 million copies in the US. Sort of different than the 12 Million Like A Virgin sold. Her tour made a lot of money because of the ticket prices, but posted empty seats in a lot of places. Her adoption was absolutely pathetic and the only reason she did it was so she could get a "black" baby to match the color of her black handbag. Is she over with? Lets debate like honest people.

Wasn’t this debated fairly well here?

http://prince.org/msg/8/238758

It's not over unless, she wants it to be. She's still in a great position to write her own ticket, even if they're rediculously expensive.

please let it be so

No. Her career is in great shape. BTW, she sold 10 million copies of Confessions on a Dance Floor. The US is not the ONLY market in the world.

They had a huge report on Fox News saying that she was about to be dropped by Warner Brothers. They were very upset how she stole her little "black baby" from his loving father. They were also upset about poor concert ticket sales.

musicismydrug said:

wow!! are Mariah fans that desperate?

Rodya24 said:

That's true

I think her career is over in US, but her icon status makes her sell millions outside the US

No.

No, of course not.

You have to remember that filesharing is still going on, and that actual sales figures don't really represent how 'popular' an artist is, anymore.

No. She has too many fans outside America for her to be over.

Who cares if her career is over... she is 50 years old married with kids....


NO one should expect anything from this woman.... honestly she almost old enough to be a grandma...

anything her fans get.. they should appriciate....

I never bought her new album.. but did enjoy her Hung up video...

ok WTF? you guys may be from the US, but in the rest of the world including Canada, she's still huge, and I mean huge. I couldn't get away from hearing confessions in stores for over a year, and her tour was all anyone talked about. Everyone was feeling her.

alphastreet said:

In other words, there's no chance in hell Ms. Ciccone's career is over. She's now 25 years into her career anyways. The talk about her being over is so 1985.

never

Madonna fans are almost as bad as MJ fan's when it comes to taking the bait,

As long as there's gay people, Madonna will have a career

bboy87 said:

And cockroaches...

ehuffnsd said:

yup..the lambs (does this sound stupid 2 anyone else?) r going nuts! hehehe

once again...is the Fox News who feeds U?..then sorry but...shit-eater! :p

lazycrockett said:

so true!

Not even close. And no matter how many records she sells, Mariah will never be as relevant or one 1/100th as important as Madonna.

musicismydrug said:

Stupid statement but even if it was true it has no bearing on her career.

TonyVanDam said:

tina and madonna are completely different.... Can Madonna even hold up like Tina....

TotalAlisa said:

The question isn't will she hold up for ten more years - the question is has she lost her hold on a large scale audience? Can she continue to sell tickets & cds or will she move into the legends category which means successful tours with low cd sales? Is she relevant anymore to the buying market?
These same questions were asked before Ray of Light was released
& that cd resulted in a career rejuvenation.
Can she do it again?

When will it s top being about being on top
And just be about the music?
thats my question.

EmbattledWarrior said:

Madonna has never been just about the music. When that happens, we will all know that her career is over.

Rodya24 said:

Career may be over, but something else would be just beginning

EmbattledWarrior said:

Yes. Her once abandoned acting career. I kid. I am sure that if Madonna focuses just on the music, she will produce something great -- I think.