I actually didn't care much for the song at first listen but that Deluxe Edition got me into liking the song. Now if only I could learn that Spanish version...

alphastreet said:

beyonce may have had ideas, but the lyrics are structured in the way Shakira does most of her English Lyrics.

and Beyonce can't play instruments so i doubt she anything other than arbaic and spanish flavor

FOR ONCE in her long-legged life Beyonce is actually dancing and not looking like she's being electrocuted.


Oh Shit!!!!! That's just dead wrong...accurate on the visual....You have more heart than me!!!!!

I want to have sex with that video

NDRU said:

When I first saw the video I didn't care too much for the song. But now it's growing on me. (no pun intended)

That's a fuckin' awesome video!
Especially with the sound turned all the way down.

Illustrator said:

Hot mess...

I just watched this on YouTube and my reaction is

These are two og most alluring women in the music business right now (allegedly) and this is what they came up with ... christ.on.a.cracker.

Btw way is it just me or is the song just a chorus and a hook sung over and over or what? Again...

Damn I'm glad I came up in the 70's and 80's.

CalhounSq said:

heyyyyy.....I just got my puter back!!


heyhey chocolate

Shakira has the most annoying voice in the world. Autotuned to fuck as well.

Mong said:

That honor goes to Britney "nasal" Spears.
...and dont' forget Yoko "screech-like-a-banshee" Ono.

CalhounSq said:

I like the parts only with Shakira in it. Beyonce

BlaqueKnight said:

I totally forgot she had a doll. I'm surprised she doesn't have one out now now that she is permanently solo...

this thread..... beyonce is popping too much. but I like the song it is rather catchy.some of the threads on here are funny to read

I'm mesmerized by this song video
Those two are just messing with my emotions

"..Shakira, Shakira!.."

I Shakira!

and the song is good IMO

they look alike in this video, i don't really like the song but i like the video

ABeautifulOne said:

i love how all the black barbies are just white barbies painted brown

PurpleJedi said:

S H A K I R A


oh yeah, i like this song. it's the reason i bought the BDAY album. and Alejandro Sanz does a duet with Beyoncé too.



hips don't lie edit
[Edited 4/19/07 19:58pm]

CHIC0 said:

What does THAT sound like...?

PurpleJedi said:

it's pretty decent i have to admit. it's titled "AMOR GITANO". spanish guitar ballad type of love song. basically think Alejandro Sanz with guest vocals by Beyoncé.
she gets a little annoying in a part or two. but still good. Alejandro makes the song though.


on disc 2

amor gitano w? Alejandro
listen (oye)
irreplaceable (irreemplazable)
beautiful liar (bello embustero)
beautiful liar (remix)
beautiful liar spanglish featuring SASHA a.k.a Beyoncé
irreplaceable (irreemplazable) norteña remix




sasha

she needs to quit with that "sasha" shit. trying to make a nick name for herself. J.Lo, Madge, Brit, etc... were given by fans.

i LOVE this song, great video too.

love the end of it. it's all woman.

the song is garbage you'd think they could have found a better song to record together

muse87 said:

Brown? Seriously, I thought that was Christina Aguilera. Love the blond doll-weave.