I TIVO this season so that I can fast forward past the boring parts.Who do you think will be the next American Idol?

Tough call. Paris and Chris are my fav's but Mcphee and Elliot are no slouches.

From the moment the show started, my picks were Paris and Elliot
but for some strange reason i think Paris might be leaving tonite.
i hope im wrong because that girl has got a great voice.

I like Taylor, but I'm sure he won't win. I guess it'll be Chris, I don't like him that much for some reason, but he still rocked last night.

i am not a huge IDOL fan , but everyone in my household watches it ... so i am sometimes forced to see some of it ...

last night i felt Elliot kicked butt ... i predict the cutsy blond or the gray haired dude will be gone tonight .... probably gray haird dude (cus K Pickle has such a following ... not sure on that cus i guess gray hair does too )

Elliot's performance surprised me ... but i think he will only last a week or 2 ... (mainly cus i think he will pick a wrong song when it is down to 2-3 )

the ROCKER dude surprised me - cus i didnt think it was THAT GOOD and all three judges gave him props...
I do think the ROCKER dude is in the top 2 .... same with :

McPhee - she was off last night .... but .... u gotta respect her for trying that W Houston song ..... Paris is REALLY GOOD .... but .... i think she will do the same thing as Elliot (pick a wrong song, etc)

This show really frustrates me. How is Kellie still in this SINGING contest? She CANNOT sing.

kelly does have to go

SnidelyWhiplash said:

bet $$ she won't though.

Graycap23 said:

Her cutesy dumb blonde act is wearing thin...she has to go !!!

Elliot deserves to win this because of his amazing voice but wont because hes not as in your face as Chris who is great in his own right.

It will come down to McPhee and Chris.

Honestly outside of Kellie (nice ass) pickler, any one of the remaining contestants can win this thing. I just wish it was based solely on their SINGING and not other factors.....

Graycap23 said:

I totally get the frustration, but U have 2 remember that it's a reality television show 1st and only. Singing is incidental.

I also fear 4 Paris 2night.

npgmaverick said:

This show reflects how America really is. Talent loses to other factors.

Can someone.....anyone please explain to me why McPhee's father is always crying? That is some non-NORMAL shit. What is that about?

newpower99 said:

That's exactly how I feel about this. Kellie needs to go but she's got a huge following. If she didn't get kicked off last week for going ahead of the music then she won't get kicked off until next week or the week after and I hope I'm wrong. I really like everyone else but like newpower99 said it'll be between McPhee and Chris and I'm rooting for Chris.

purplecam said:

oh yeah...

newpower99 said:

chris bores me to death...

newpower99 said:

purplecam said:

You knew I wasnt gonna let an AI thread go by with me posting a drool-worthy pic of the man.

When is naked singing night on AI? Never mind I just thought of Tyler.

Resume normal sane conversation ...sorry...

I think it will come down to Taylor, Chris, and Katharine. My support is with Chris, Elliott and Paris. I like Katharine at times, but I think it's time a different style of singer to win. Elliott has been a pleasant surprise, and his support is building. Unfortunately, Paris doesn't have the support, which is a shame, so I think tonight will be her night to go, altho Kellie really she be the one. She should have been the one for the past couple of weeks.

newpower99 said:

Oh baby you need to stop! I will be glued like a mofo when that night happens! Don't be too fast to dismiss Taylor. He might have some goodies in that jar!

funkyslsistah said:

Well, the blond Southern pickle just got bounced off the show. She may have been such a cute country girl and everything, but her act was starting to wear really thin. On top of that, at this stage in the game, she had to bring it to another level; yet she actually got worse as the show went along, so she needed to go.

728huey said:

Did they say whose songs they'll be singing NEXT week?????

I've been voting for Elliott Yamin since they were 12 finalists!! He'll sneak up there in the final 2 with Chris!!

purpleunderground said:

It was cut off, but I was at the studio tonight and they said Prince!!!!!

rainbowchild said:

WHAT??!!

It was kinda funny but when Kellie's name was announced my hairstylist and I pumped our fists and had huge smiles. She was threatening not to watch if Paris was eliminated. She'll prolly only be around for another show, but at least she made the top 5.