and the single reason why it should

I can't help it but I like him!!! hahahha!!

I love the other guy...the one with the salt and pepper hair. He's just soooo weird!!!

shausler said:

Eh, I don't like her
[Edited 3/15/06 8:34am]

CarrieLee said:

once you here my song sista

you will change that there tune

luv4u said:

good grief

Umm, are these people 12

I'm not watching this year, no clue who these people are

shausler said:

He looks exactly like one of my wife's 2 year-old daycare kids. Glasses and all.

CarrieLee said:

Me either...she is too staged/planned/contrived...
that nerd kid belongs on Broadway...he can belt out a song, but he is just too wooden and stiff for this competition....

im lovin her

shausler said:

I watch this show because my two neices love it. It's hard to take it too seriously though, but they love it so I try.

This is only your opinion Shausler. I happen to think Katharine and Mandisa are the best singers out of the women.

He looks like that gay geek than won...

CalhounSq said:

co-

CinisterCee said:

co-co-

The joys of living on the other side of the Atlantic

I have never watched this show. It's appeal is lost on me.

MikeMatronik said:

that gay geek did not win.

sosgemini said:

I was stunned at how ignorant some of the people where. The bald rocker guy who's dead from the waste down (the dude has zero charisma) said he didn't even know Higher Ground was a Stevie Wonder song. He was relieved when he found out otherwise because he didn't think anything in Stevie's catalogue fit him. A couple of the others wasn't real interested in Stevie beforehand (and probably afterhand) either. Now that's okay but the issue comes up if they where to win and forced to release an album. The album will be pretty shallow if they're not well versed in all music> It's AMerican Idol, supposedly the best undiscovered talent in America (I'm serious, that's what it's supposed to be). If you're not capable of atleast having a knowledge of different styles of music how can you make the claim that you're the best discovered talent in America?

Oh, yeah Paula Abdul is tone deaf I think. And that Joe Cocker wannabe dude with the grey hair was definitely exposed as having a weak voice when he sung that first verse of Living for the city.... now I think about it the show is a joke, but I'm still gonna watch it.

kdj997 said:

agreed..i thought they were all pretty horrible with the exception of the last dude who totally killed any good will i'd had for him by showing little care for the legacy that is Wonder.

and why the hell was i watching this show anyways?

Chicken little is cute but Gideon should have made it and not him

Lovin McPhee & Paris Love Mandisa as well. These are my faves

CarrieLee said:

Anxiety!

CinisterCee said:

I love Anxiety too!

sextonseven said:

Amen. I refuse to support anyone who comes off of that glorified karaoke contest.

newpower99 said:

Love Elliot's voice and Chris is just the hotness

SupaFunkyOrgangrinderSexy said:

I agree but it really doesn't matter. the competetion will NOT began until all are gone but: Paris, Mandisa, Salt and pepper head, Mcphee, the baldheaded dude and the soulful cat with a face built for radio.

I am really perplexed as to how someone could have NEVER listened to a Stevie Wonder song. WFT?

Graycap23 said:

Are you really that shocked that people who grow up listenin to garth brooks and the dixie chicks are not exposed to soulful geniuses?

SupaFunkyOrgangrinderSexy said:

amen, brother!

shausler said:

Geek boy or the other nerd from N.C should be gone tonight. I can't wait for the big mouth country girl to be gone also. She makes my head hurt every time she opens her mouth. Who in the hell her age has never had salmon to eat? Give that country bumpkin crap a rest already.

Graycap23 said:

I grew up in the city and never had lobster till I was 30