play an instrument Madonna and then get back to me.

jthad1129 said:

Didn't she play guitar on the last album and tour? Not well...but she played.

jthad1129 said:

I take it this means you don't like Marvin Gaye, Aretha Franklin, or a million other great pop stars who, for the most part, don't play instruments?

..With all love and due respect to Maddie (cuz that's my girl from way back) she's in the media too much. Let Prince have some spotlight thrown at him for once. This could be another good year for him (hopefully).

oh yes..And Marvin Gaye played the drums, piano, and synthesizers on his LP's. And Aretha can play the hell out of the piano.

SPYZFAN1 said:

with all due respect...she's always been in the media. You make it sound like she actually "hogs" it from others. If P wants media attention he can easily get it.

newpower99 said:

I love the PSB mix and can't wait for the US maxi...I'm glad it's coming out soon! Good damn....XM gets the jump on Sirius! Siurius has been playing the shit out of the radio edit (the only difference I notice is that there is no spoken word intro).

Oh please. Why is she wearing the same girdle from the Truth or Dare tour? She looks like an over aged used to be Superhero.

PapaSmurf said:

Aretha plays piano.

jayaredee said:

Ifsixwuz9 said:

And Madonna plays guitar. Didn't she at one time also play drums in some band before she made it big as a solo performer? I may be making that up but I thought I read it or heard it in an interview.

PapaSmurf said:

Yes I know she's always been in the media, but I didn't say she was trying to "hog" the spotlight. Prince is reclusive, but it always good (and rare) to see him in the media with positive words about him as a artist and a musician. In the last couple of years, he's finally getting his props.

Not surprisingly,the "Hung Up" video was Number One on TRL yesterday.I think they're finally going to retire this video from the countdown,so it gets to retire in the Number One position.Way to go,Maddy!


now let's get ready to push the "Sorry" video to the top

SPYZFAN1 said:

Hey,Maddy can't help it if the media follows her every move.She's just doing her job (releasing music and videos,promoting her CD and planning a tour).She's a celebrity,so the media is always gonna be interested in what she does.

DavidEye said:

Cheek said:

that's all you have to say?

DavidEye said:

About Madonna???

All I have to say is "Sorry"...

Cheek said:

well,I don't wanna hear....I don't wanna know
there's more important things than hearing Cheek speak

DavidEye said:

Well, I love this song...

DavidEye said:

I dare you to name ONE...!!

MartyMcFly said:

PapaSmurf said:

this has nothing to do with any other artist. This is a Madonna thread and a Madonna comment. If she had the vocal chops of Marvin, Aretha or a few other actual singers, i would give her, her due. She is a studio girl, plain and simple. No hate, just a fact.

Cheek said:

I can't win with you huh...?

jthad1129 said:

More like opinion.

She might be your favorite pop star, you love her and no one here has any problem with that, but please stop these "Madonna plays guitar".

I mean come on, I have been playing guitar for two years and already play much better than she does...And I am not particularly gifted and have not trained particularly hard!

I thought the purpose of this thread was to discuss her new video?

instead,it's turning into yet another tired "Madonna-has-no-talent" argument


you guys are funny

VinnyM27 said:

Hmm, I just heard the PSB mix, and as a big fan of theirs, it's kind of a letdown, (though I've never been a big fan of their remixes for other artists).

Man w/a Gun remix isn't doing it for me either. For now, I'll stick with the original!

so, in the UK, when you can get so much info on a cd, Why produce CD1 (with 2 or 3 tracks) and CD2 (with 2 or 3 tracks). I just don't get it? Why not one maxi cd with 6 versions and a video, enhanced, whatever.

Why put out those mini cds?

More than 3 tracks make an EP so it wouldn't chart as a single release