Jimmy Jam and Terry Lewis Classic powered by Janet Jackson or a Stock Atiken Waterman classic powered by Kylie Minogue.

Wage your bets and get ready for a fight.


Which one would you rather have?

Oi, that's not fair. At least start from Kylie's first good album 'Rhythm Of Love' (1990). But still 'Rhythm Nation' beats that. However, I'd say everything from 'Kylie Minogue' (1994) beats all Janet's equivalent releases from their time periods.

Get real Ellie

Well it's TRUE!

Impossible Princess is better than TVR - better videos too Janet could only dream of having something as truly sexy and non-desperate as "Breathe".

Fever is better than All For You, but Fever is crap anyway, Light Years is much better, but Kylie releases albums more often so they can't all perfectly match up

Body Language is better than Damita Jo.

ehuffnsd said:

I'm a great fan of both of these ladies. But this is a mismatch for album match-up.

BTW, Control wins in Round 1!!!

Ellie said:

1. Body Language is better than Damita Jo. And Kylie's vocals is a perfect fit with nu electro-pop.

2. Fever is NOT crap. It's a masterpiece. But to be fair, Love At First Sight (U.S. Video Mix) is a better version than the album version.

I'm just not fond at all of any of the album tracks on Fever. Love At First Sight is perfection, but there aren't that many great songs on the album. Light Years however doesn't have a weak track.
[Edited 8/4/05 13:36pm]

so, after we've compared all of Kylie's and Janet's albums, all that we'll know is who is better at sleeping through their own career.

I agree that besides the singles, 'Fever' is guite poor.

Fever is flawless.

Control wins easily for this round. I will say that from 1994 onward, Kylie would win every matchup imaginable.

Heck, after 1998, Kylie would trump Madonna too.

Ellie said:

Bittersweet Goodbye?
Loveboat?

Fever is flawless throughout.

Moonbeam said:

Damn Right!!!

TonyVanDam said:

At being a mindless bimbo tart!

I LOVE Loveboat. That 2000 Live In Sydney DVD really makes a lot of the album tracks come alive.

Kylie wins in the concert area too, although I've heard that both she and Madonna use a heck of a lot of autotune. Still, Kylie hasn't lip synced a song fully in concert since the 80s.

Ellie said:

Just 80% of each song, right?

GangstaFam said:

Unlike Madonna, Kylie didn't need to make a f***ing "sex book" to sell record.

TonyVanDam said:

quite right. Kylie's never had enough class to confine it to a book. she just walks around that way

anyone else think she looks like one of Roxy Music's slutty mannequins?


[Edited 8/4/05 23:18pm]

Tessa said:

She's certainly got the bone structure. Or angular plastic contours.

TonyVanDam said:

I'll take the hilarious and cool Sex book over one of Kylie's pointless and tacky calendars anydamnday!

TRON said:

I'll take both.

Moonbeam said:

How do you get full use out of that calendar? Isn't it tough to flip the pages? Have you made it past January?

We've got that calender in our office

Tessa said:

Here's something that Madonna would never do because of her own selfish ego: SHARING THE SPOTLIGHT with your baby sister.




[Edited 8/5/05 21:03pm]

Kylie Minougue sucks !!!!! Control is far better album than anything kylie has or evr will do

TonyVanDam said:

if Madonna's little sister had her sights set on being the biggest entertainer in the world, i'm sure Madonna would help her. since she doesn't have one with her same ambitions, then what's your point?

Tessa said:

She does share the spotlight with her Brother Christopher. also she has shared the spotlight with her sister Pamela's husband, Joe Henry

Tessa said:

...just like Madonna could have help her first husband on the road to success by sharing HER spotlight with him?

PLEASE!!!! Madonna's ego is just too damn big to try to help anyone (siblings or otherwise) besides herself That's my point!
[Edited 8/6/05 23:51pm]
[Edited 8/6/05 23:52pm]

ehuffnsd said:

But where are they now? And who in the hell is Christopher? And did he ever release an album?

Tessa said: