Imagine we have 2 bands: "Europe" (not the Swedish one) and "America".

Europe are:

Drums - Phil Collins
Percussion - Peter Gabriel
Bass - Sting
Keyboards - Annie Lennox
Keyboards - Kate Bush
Piano - Elton John
Guitar - Dave Stewart
Sax - David Bowie
Vocals - Björk, Sinéad O' Connor, George Michael, Bono.

America are:

Drums - Sheila E.
Percussion - Debbie Harry hahahahahahaha...
Bass - Me'shell Ndegeocello
Keyboards - Sheryl Crow
Keyboards - Prince
Piano - Tori Amos
Guitar - Bruce Springsteen
Sax - Maceo Parker
Vocals - Madonna, Tina Turner, Michael Jackson, Lenny Kravitz.

So, which band would be better?

I know it's silly but I'm just playin'...

Both groupings sound like they'd end up to be a mess. I can't see that many strong personalities working well together. But I'm always one for picking favorites so I'll choose who I like best out of all your groupings.

Drums - Sheila E.
Percussion - Debbie Harry
Bass - Me'shell Ndegeocello
Keyboards - Annie Lennox
Keyboards - Prince
Piano - Tori Amos
Guitar - Dave Stewart
Sax - David Bowie (though not necessarily for his sax)
Vocals - (in order) Bjork, Madonna, Bono, Michael Jackson

GangstaFam said:

I think so!

But I think it would be fun to see both groups playing a few gigs...