Below is a link to a "so-so" review of Musicology in The Chicago Sun Times. The reviewer states "The result wasn't THE record, but it was the closest he'd come since "Diamonds and Pearls."

I am willing to bet that a number of people would debate that thought. For myself, the first debate that came to mind was The Gold Experience. Read for yourself.....

www.suntimes.com/output/r...ins25.html

Soulflyer said:

when i read this review in my Sunday paper i said "this is the worst 3 star review i have ever seen"! if you didnt look at the 3 star rating and just read the review i would have said "he's giving it 1 star"

Jim Derogotis of The Sun Times is a joke. If its not by a band no one has heard of or something by Billy Corgan, Courtney Love, or some other alternative band he gives it a bad review. He has a show with Greg Kot from The Chicago Tribune on the PBS station here in Chicago...and he is proving my point without a doubt every time I watch it. Onething he said last show "I am not giving Steven Tyler any more of my money" after panning Aerosmiths latest CD. He was giving it a bad review because he feels there was no other reason for that band to make a new album except for the $$. I never heard once if the music on it was good or bad...it was as if he had a personal hatred for Tyler.