The P-Funk all stars was the funkest band in the 70's and came along a Prince that brought a new generation of funk that change the game! Well people which will it be Revolution or P-Funk.

To each his reach and if I don't cop it ain't mine to have
But I'll be reachin' for ya, cuz I luv ya, CC.

Can y'all get to that?

But I ain't choosin' cuz I don't have to.
`
[This message was edited Tue Mar 23 0:54:18 2004 by Supernova]

Prince with any backing band, be it the Revolution or the NPG, is a force of nature. Maybe I'm running the risk of overstating things a bit, but I can live with that. While still giving Clinton and Parliament/Funkadelic the massive amount of credit they deserve, I have 2 go with Prince when it comes to prolifacy, quality, and ability.

The P-FUNK all stars were formed in the 80's .... the time that George lost credibility
Parliament - Funkadelic ... greatest band ever

The NPG is formed in the 90's ..... the time that Prince lost credibility
The Revolution ..... only Parliament - Funkadelic and the JB's are better

But ... the Revolution (Prince's good times) is better than the P-Funk all Stars (George's bad times)

P-FUNK Allstars is Parliament/Funkadelic - all the same members.

I dig what you're saying that George and co were better in the 70s but as a live show they can tear the roof off on any given day.

I've seen both live and I've got to say if I could only see one band live it'd be P-FUNK, especially if I had a time machine!

Prince is awesome too live, but P-Funk's humour would probably make me lean towards them.

Neil said:

Eddie Hazel / Bootsy Collins / Maceo Parker ?
I've seen the P-Funk Allstars quite a few times .... but never with one of those giants (indeed, won't see Eddie ever).

i know that this is a prince site, but are you out of your mind for asking such a question. prince vs THE P FUNK , nuff said. rick james maybe, but the mothership connection never! get real!

They both great acts and it's like family now. P-Funk was the big picture for most outrageous black acts Rick James, Gap Band, Prince etc.

Maceo and Greg being with Prince. And Mallia Franklin and George all from P-Funk working with Prince. And Prince working with George it's all cool. They both have their ups and downs and major comebacks.


FUNK IS HEAR TO STAY!

I am king of the P-FUNK and i am not going 2 touch this one, when they talked about Prince vs. Hendrinx that was bad enough but now this is were i will sit back and just read the board on this one. The Revolution vs. the P-funk all-stars.....come on most of the revoluton was still in diapers when the funk was ON!!

the revolution beat the p-funk allstars...

but parliament & funkadelic in it's hey-day... sorry, but the revolution (with the exception of prince) does not have any musicians who can tackle eddie hazel, kidd funkadelic, bootsy collins, maceo parker, bernie worrell, etc, etc... that's how i see it...

that said, i'd still take prince over parliament and funkadelic... but as backing bands, i think p-funk wins...

Thumparello said:[quote]They both great acts and it's like family now. P-Funk was the big picture for most outrageous black acts Rick James, Gap Band, Prince etc.

Maceo and Greg being with Prince. And Mallia Franklin and George all from P-Funk working with Prince. And Prince working with George it's all cool. They both have their ups and downs and major comebacks



and the funny part is that prince still aint funky!