Author | Message |
"All I Ever Wanted...Was To Be Left Alone" - Prince's Quandry ok, deep post alert, maybe not, but contemplative yes. That line, from Way Back Home, which follows other illuminating insights about want/desires, stood out to me upon first listen and still does. A man who dated many who'd be considered "trophy wives" and married two, still longed to be "left alone" and has been stated ad nauseum perhaps, died tragically alone. Prince was most generous with people and the world through his music. interpersonally, you got snippets, a restrained version, a flighty man, with chronic wanderlust musically, and relationally. people had "expiration dates" with him. few defied that. I wonder how parenting would have changed him. it opens up one's heart to previously unknown and/or inaccessible chambers. it would've been especially curious to see the affect a daughter would've had on him IMO.
As a married man, with children, i realize that, as much as i'd prefer to, i can't be/won't be "left alone." and i don't say that in the lighthearted "that's why you need a "mancave" sense of escaping to watch sports, action flicks, or whatever fits said male, it's pondering, whether "at my core", despite of how enriched and made better I am by my family, if i'm well suited for life as a husband and father. the "marrying kind" IS a thing. or one can just find themselves there (of course not "just", but...) i can hear the rebuttals, too late now, you better GET ready.... but I posit, (speculatively of course) that because of the frenetic nature of his life, absorbed by music, his relationships, seemingly failed to push him towards the type of growth where things didn't have to always be on HIS terms. Him engaging the world and people when HE wanted to (his perogative of course). But what if that "transactional" framework stunted him? Like the 3AM calls to a Van Jones, or whomever, which he could get away with because he was Prince, but what if he could "take it" like he "dished it." His opinion always had more weight because again, he was Prince, but beyond the "music examples", whom did he keep close who "pushed back" with him regularly? The Kirky J example is dubious.
Some people NEED people more than others in a general, more interconnected kind of way, others NEED them when they do, for a specific thing. They aren't trying to diminish others, the "transactional" frame is just their default. I'm such a person, (and not a Gemini for u amatuer astrologists on here). I know now, how childhood trauma shaped me and I have had to learn to be fully present with people and not fear making a genuine connection, beyond a shared interest or topic, just human to human. I've stated elsewhere on here how I know the real Wally Safford. He calls Prince a friend, one whom he had responsibilities to and for, and he too attests that Prince loved people best THROUGH his music and in ACTUAL human relationships, that's not enough. A song with his name on it flatters him, but I offer that conversations and mutual sharing, not just "venting" (or whatever version of the song says what) would've made our dearly departed an even BETTER artist. The growth WAS occurring, but the collective dynamics in place in his social circle at the time were a recipe for what happened. Sometimes alone is what you WANT but not NEED. His own words from the mouths of others might've helped, "left to our own devices, whatever will be will be" (Beginning Endlessly). [Edited 12/1/20 20:28pm] | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
- I think he wanted to be left alone from all sides and on all levels, more from a point of regret and loss. Like business wise or even on a musical level, as well as by the media and so on. But... he choose the wrong profession for that. It sounds like too little too late imho. - I dare to believe he suffered the most from never taking the time to reflect upon all that moved around him in his life, especially his own being and and the life he had lived. Like whether life has lived up to his expectations. I dare to say he chose to flee from ahead, and prefered to by guided by his superstitions & believes. Most aroudn him always said he comunicated through his music and lyrics... Which I personally considder often more riddled and questioned. More than quite unclear. But it's all guessing. - I'm more intrigued by these lyrics in the same song : "So many reasons why, ...as if he was ready to die, or even chose to die to flee from it all... We'll never know for sure. - And what you write her, I absolutely agree. - "The whole problem with the world is that fools and fanatics are always so certain of themselves. And wiser people so full of doubts" (Bertrand Russell 1872-1972) | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
THIS. EXACTLY ALL THIS. This OP and first comment. [Edited 12/2/20 6:06am] | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
He was rich and entitled.
This enabled an uneven balance in his relationships A balance that he, from what I've heard, quite relished This is also a guy who I think, didnt even do xmas He worked to avoid a lot of unpleasant things Bring controlling is one thing, being allowed to be that controlling is never healthy He couldnt Express his feelings, and not having to try, didn't help I think it crippled him in fact Wpuldnt be surprised if in that final year, the death of vanity made him reach for his pain killers even more to block those feelings [Edited 12/2/20 6:29am] | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
[Edited 12/2/20 17:37pm] | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
IMO wanted to be Left alone, he didn't want the fame. Too many people who want his attention for their personal gain. Fleshy people, non spiritual. He didn't want that typical life (or fake life) that people desire (you know fame, and trophy wives). See my bed's made up at night 'Cause in my dreams I roam. Just trying to find, trying to find My way back, back home the fame and his part in that type of life hurt or disturbed him, He realizes he made a mistake because he was disillusioned by that life he strived for. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
| |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
The song is about his son. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
thanks for the thoughtful responses to this thread. it felt a bit indulgent and I imagined when people SAW it, they were like, oh hell naw... LOL (can someone teach me how to INDENT on here). Rednblue, first of all quit apologizing for your posts. they are welcome, valid and on subject. and yes, i am the same orger who met Wally at my gym, though we were members of the same church for YEARS and never knew each other. I had to take him to lunch and vomit Prince on each other for hours....
but i digress, Vannormal, you are SO right, those lyrics you highlighted are profound also, they ALL are. i do think he felt like he didn't belong for a number of reasons. i try not to be dogmatic about most things that leave much to be speculated about but i think the song was about a lot of things, including possibly his son, which i'd never considered before.
the thoughtful people on this site is what keep me coming back when i thought post 2016, what's the point. he BECAME rich and entitled (but to stop there is an oversimplification) and it did affect him and he exploited it when and how he wanted, but, i don't think his aim was ever to use fame create a chasm between him and others. his absorption with mastering his craft left his actual people skills under developed and he hoped the music would be sufficient. and for superfically distant relationships rooted in the star/fan; bandleader/member, rockstar playboy/ingenue muse dynamic, it was. hell, this is a guy who prohibited EYE CONTACT, talk about fear of (or inability or disinterest) in real connection! SMH. Nonetheless, a he left a treasure trove of art chronicling his longings, and learning from his "selective engagement" with other humans for us to continue to explore and gain glimpses. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
This is an internal struggle many performers and creative people face. (Been there, done that ... like ... a million times.) We tend to be introverted (you can't create successfully without being introspective), yet we are lost without an audience. When we're alone, we want to be performing. When we're performing, we want to be alone. We're never at peace. [Edited 12/2/20 12:15pm] We don’t mourn artists because we knew them. We mourn them because they helped us know ourselves. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
i will have to revisit The Breakdown from that lens instead of his gazillonth "break up song."
I'm so glad you decided it WAS indeed worth going on.
As a creative, how then do you think about "self-sabotage", is unintentional self-sabotage an example of the poor relational skills at play? or is it an inentional 'pushing away" when the relationship is at a place of "explaining" what it is or will be for those involved? | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
I've always had a different interpretation of the song (and entire album). Welcome to "the org", laytonian… come bathe with me. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
We don’t mourn artists because we knew them. We mourn them because they helped us know ourselves. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Great insight. Time keeps on slipping into the future...
This moment is all there is... | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Genesia said:
so glad u found someone who GETS u Genesia. u made me wonder abt Jill Jones & P and if SAIMH is indicative how and why she was able to "stick around" and endure him, and his appetite for the ladies. on another note, u should write your story. for some reason I think a play abt how u overcame a very difficult period would resonate with ppl. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
He once said in interview "There aren't many very nice americans." By that I think he meant irrespective of fame, adulation and respect from peers and fans, he didn't believe they would bring him any more close friendships than he would've got as a non famous average joe. If I'm being a harsh outsider, non-fan, I would argue 'See money doesn't get you happiness'. But Prince got plenty happy from making music, playing music live and making his fans happy. The world's problems like climate change can only be solved through strategic long-term thinking, not expediency. In other words all the govts. need sacking!
If you can add value to someone's life then why not. Especially if it colors their days... | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
I think that Prince needed time and space to create and dream. After reading his memoir it seemed to me he spent much of his childhood in this space dreaming and visualizing his life- to- be. Some of this was childhood loneliness, though. Sometimes I think Prince saw people as actors to play a role in his musical or film creations...not as fully fleshed-out people. (He got better) He seemed to have ambivalence re: people. Some say it was childhood trauma, some say it was an artist's need for time alone to create, some say mild autism. He did seem to need to be unencumbered by people, expectations, genres etc. But, too much of this and loneliness ensues.
| |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
I think trust was a factor. He didnt trust people and felt it was either control them or be controlled. The mild autism theory seems reasonable. Obsessing and pacing back and forth, yeah I see it. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
[Edited 12/3/20 0:03am] | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
fortuneandserendipity said: He once said in interview "There aren't many very nice americans." By that I think he meant irrespective of fame, adulation and respect from peers and fans, he didn't believe they would bring him any more close friendships than he would've got as a non famous average joe. If I'm being a harsh outsider, non-fan, I would argue 'See money doesn't get you happiness'. But Prince got plenty happy from making music, playing music live and making his fans happy. I think he lived, in part, a kind of studied version of the lonely rockstar lifestyle. He didn't have to be that cloistered. He didn't have to be that extravagant. He wanted to live the rock star fantasy. Yes he had struggles with getting close to people, but he also just enjoyed being a tyrant. And fucking other women rather than settling down with one. Maybe that was bad modelling in his childhood. But I dont know if he would have had it any other way. Prince was not someone who wanted to change. If he did, he could have sought help. He did not want anyone to give him home truths as he gott older. His ego was too delicate. He wanted people to do as he wanted. He could have lived a slightly more normal life as he got older. But he wanted to keep up the appearance of a millionaire rockstar forever. Normal would have been a crushing blow for him. He was not interested in that. He wanted to be someone who had people to do everything for him which is not good for anyone. [Edited 12/3/20 1:42am] | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
To say he died tragically alone is just an opinion. We all die one day, alone or with other people watching us die. It's about the experience you have while alive that matters. He was able to do what he wanted to do for the most part - and make enough money to continue doing it. I consider that lucky.
To say that being a parent would have changed him is also another opinion. I know some parents who are unprepared and it wrecks their life in many ways to have kids. I know other parents who brag about having kids as if they need that to feel normal.
I remember when I saw him perform The Breakdown in Las Vegas. 2/3 of the crowd were talking and hardly even noticed since he chose to open with it. I felt a bit sad for him then since I knew he wanted people to enjoy his music. It was the only time I felt sorry for him though. He wasn't the greatest human being in the world. But he was an amazing musician. I think he died happy. We just don't know it yet. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
I had to laugh at the idea he enjoyed being a tyrant and having everything done for him. Wouldn't that be fun for awile? (not the tyrant part). It seems that even most older rock stars eventually settle down with one person and live as wealthy but but kind of average people. In his later years, though, he did give up the extravagant clothing, hair, girlfriends, etc. He was shedding some of the rock star accoutrements. What was left was playing and performing for as long as he could. I think it was like breathing and was vital to him.
| |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
"had to laugh at the idea he enjoyed being a tyrant and having everything done for him".
Glad to have given you a giggle. However he enjoyed, if not being a despot, then certainly being a minor dictator. Control, etc Ppl make a big deal that he never left mpls but did you see prince at the barbers? Doing food shopping? I doubt it. Lol [Edited 12/3/20 8:36am] | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
[Edited 12/3/20 11:32am] | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
We don’t mourn artists because we knew them. We mourn them because they helped us know ourselves. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
- True. But it is never easy to say exactly from Prince's point of view what he actually meant, or wanted us to really understand. He could easily build in double standards. He often deliberately built in layering in order not to make his views too clear, perhaps even to deal with ambiguities. Best example is the creation of Camile (at least to me), as if he needed an extra outlet (again imho). I believe it was primarily a form of communication strategy directed towards himself in the first place. He absolutely prefered to create unclear surprises and riddles for sure. That's why we love him, and why he is so interesting at the same time. -
"The whole problem with the world is that fools and fanatics are always so certain of themselves. And wiser people so full of doubts" (Bertrand Russell 1872-1972) | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
- I agree with your last sentece. But not with"he didn't want fame.'' Because, oh yes! he wanted fame. WHen he found out when he was very young what his skills and talent got get him, he got so hungry for stardom. Don't forget where he came from, his entire childhood background for example. Feeling not always justified that he was loved which caused him to be torn between other parties and families. Only, he did not know what becoming a star would bring along. Like so many young artists with no guidance. Plus, he deliberately did not accepted any form of guidance on top of that, lacking to develop trust in others. The fact that he made it all by himself was kind of a serius gamble, based on his tremendous skills and talent. He just was lucky to have met those people who believed in him. But those same people strugled to guide him or tried to advise him once he was famous. Which he famously rejected. Remember what The Revolution members said when they all of a sudden werre confronted with bodyguards and seperate treatments while on the road etc... For me it's obvious that he really really wanted to be a star, feeling recognised, appreciated and accepted. ''Baby I'm A Star'', ''My Name Is Prince'' ? I don't see many other artists write thesekind of songs, except some self declared rappers late on. lol - The lyrics you're refer too, are written by a man around his fifties, very typical imho. He clearly was in a momentary reflective mood. Only, it didn't last that long. He chose to flee ahead, again. -
"The whole problem with the world is that fools and fanatics are always so certain of themselves. And wiser people so full of doubts" (Bertrand Russell 1872-1972) | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
I think he wanted fame too. He seemed to be comfortable with it immediately and I bet it was very validating as he lived with many "no's" while growing up. I sense, though, in his last few years, that fame, wealth etc., was less satisfying for a number of reasons. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
the idea he didnt want fame is dumbfounding. ofc he did. he was hungry for it might not have liked everything that came with it and found so many people after him scary but he def craved it after 84, he had a brief period of thinking that it was going to just be about music and art, prob as he assumed that the PR era would return again, but once he saw it wasnt, he started to hanker after it. he needed to feel loved, to know people were into him. in 95, he could have done smaller clubs for all that new material, but he loved playing to big audiences. playing to smaller crowds after PR was a serious come down. why dyou think he pulled the SOTT tour in the US and then too the 88 tour to europe first? he was scared of playing to smaller audiences in the US. it was embarassing for him. (not mentioning the money issues and that motivation as thats a diff thread)
i kinda imagine for someone like prince whose way of dealing with people was often music (regardless of after a certain period, his lyrics started to be riddles), not having that communication, or communion, an audience to receive it, means something is missing. thats prob a reason he never stopped releasing and recording. he needed to feel there were people there waiting to hear from him.
| |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
[Edited 12/4/20 6:11am] | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |