independent and unofficial
Prince fan community
Welcome! Sign up or enter username and password to remember me
Forum jump
Forums > Prince: Music and More > PLANET EARTH vs. 20TEN
« Previous topic  Next topic »
Page 1 of 2 12>
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
Author

Tweet     Share

Message
Thread started 03/07/17 7:58pm

feeluupp

PLANET EARTH vs. 20TEN

1. PLANET EARTH - COMPASSION

2. GUITAR - BEGINNING ENDLESSLY

3. SOMEWHERE HERE ON EARTH - FUTURE SOUL SONG

4. THE ONE U WANNA C - STICKY LIKE GLUE

5. FUTURE BABY MAMA - ACT OF GOD

6. MR. GOODNIGHT - LAVAUX

7. ALL THE MIDNIGHTS IN THE WORLD - WALK IN SAND

8. CHELSEA RODGERS - SEA OF EVERYTHING

9. LION OF JUDAH - EVERYBODY LOVES ME

10. RESOLUTION - LAYDOWN

PLANET EARTH: 4

20TEN: 6

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #1 posted 03/07/17 8:12pm

RJOrion

1. PLANET EARTH - COMPASSION

2. GUITAR - BEGINNING ENDLESSLY

3. SOMEWHERE HERE ON EARTH - FUTURE SOUL SONG

4. THE ONE U WANNA C - STICKY LIKE GLUE

5. FUTURE BABY MAMA - ACT OF GOD

6. MR. GOODNIGHT - LAVAUX

7. ALL THE MIDNIGHTS IN THE WORLD - WALK IN SAND

8. CHELSEA RODGERS - SEA OF EVERYTHING

9. LION OF JUDAH - EVERYBODY LOVES ME

10. RESOLUTION - LAYDOWN

20Ten : 7

Planet Earth : 3

[Edited 3/7/17 20:14pm]

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #2 posted 03/07/17 8:16pm

sexton

avatar

1. PLANET EARTH - COMPASSION

2. GUITAR - BEGINNING ENDLESSLY

3. SOMEWHERE HERE ON EARTH - FUTURE SOUL SONG

4. THE ONE U WANNA C - STICKY LIKE GLUE

5. FUTURE BABY MAMA - ACT OF GOD

6. MR. GOODNIGHT - LAVAUX

7. ALL THE MIDNIGHTS IN THE WORLD - WALK IN SAND

8. CHELSEA RODGERS - SEA OF EVERYTHING

9. LION OF JUDAH - EVERYBODY LOVES ME

10. RESOLUTION - LAYDOWN

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #3 posted 03/07/17 8:29pm

Shockedelicus

This one is interesting because they're both pretty terrible.

  1. Planet Earth
  2. Guitar
  3. Somewhere Here on Earth
  4. Sticky Like Glue
  5. Act of God
  6. Lavaux
  7. Walk in Sand *puke*
  8. Chelsea Rodgers
  9. Lion of Judah
  10. Laydown
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #4 posted 03/07/17 8:34pm

RJOrion

Shockedelicus said:

This one is interesting because they're both pretty terrible.

  1. Planet Earth
  2. Guitar
  3. Somewhere Here on Earth
  4. Sticky Like Glue
  5. Act of God
  6. Lavaux
  7. Walk in Sand *puke*
  8. Chelsea Rodgers
  9. Lion of Judah
  10. Laydown

sad ...wow... thats my 11 year old son's favorite Prince song ever....

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #5 posted 03/07/17 8:49pm

feeluupp

Planet Earth is probably my least listened to album...

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #6 posted 03/07/17 9:04pm

RJOrion

feeluupp said:

Planet Earth is probably my least listened to album...

same here...i had to re-listen to some of the songs just to complete the thread... clearly one of his weakest albums... if not THE worst of his collection...

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #7 posted 03/07/17 9:11pm

feeluupp

RJOrion said:

feeluupp said:

Planet Earth is probably my least listened to album...

same here...i had to re-listen to some of the songs just to complete the thread... clearly one of his weakest albums... if not THE worst of his collection...

Agree. Sometimes I can't believe Planet Earth comes from the same artist that made Purple Rain and SOTT lol

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #8 posted 03/07/17 9:17pm

gandorb

feeluupp said:

RJOrion said:

same here...i had to re-listen to some of the songs just to complete the thread... clearly one of his weakest albums... if not THE worst of his collection...

Agree. Sometimes I can't believe Planet Earth comes from the same artist that made Purple Rain and SOTT lol

It was the last album I bought by Prince for a long while, as it seemed so bland. I think I only listened to it twice before he died. I have played it several times since, and I rather like the first half of it. Still, I am glad it's relative blandness was an exception for Prince.

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #9 posted 03/07/17 9:52pm

Adorecream

1. Planet Earth - COMPASSION - Close

2. GUITAR - BEGINNING ENDLESSLY - No contest, good vs best

3. SOMEWHERE HERE ON EARTH - FUTURE SOUL SONG - landslide victory

4. THE ONE U WANNA C - STICKY LIKE GLUE - close

5. FUTURE BABY MAMA - ACT OF GOD - both bad, but still close

6. MR. GOODNIGHT - LAVAUX - no contest

7. ALL THE MIDNIGHTS IN THE WORLD - WALK IN SAND - both quite lame

8. CHELSEA RODGERS - SEA OF EVERYTHING - no contest

9. LION OF JUDAH - EVERYBODY LOVES ME - landslide victory

10. RESOLUTION - LAYDOWN - no competition at all

.

Planet Earth 4 - 20 Ten 6

Both albums are pretty good and have some highlights and lowlights. 20Ten has the superb Futuresoulsong, his best post 2000s song.

Got some kind of love for you, and I don't even know your name
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #10 posted 03/07/17 9:57pm

BT11

avatar

1. PLANET EARTH - COMPASSION

2. GUITAR - BEGINNING ENDLESSLY

3. SOMEWHERE HERE ON EARTH - FUTURE SOUL SONG

4. THE ONE U WANNA C - STICKY LIKE GLUE

5. FUTURE BABY MAMA - ACT OF GOD

6. MR. GOODNIGHT - LAVAUX

7. ALL THE MIDNIGHTS IN THE WORLD - WALK IN SAND

8. CHELSEA RODGERS - SEA OF EVERYTHING

9. LION OF JUDAH - EVERYBODY LOVES ME

10. RESOLUTION - LAYDOWN

PLANET EARTH: 5

20TEN: 5

music
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #11 posted 03/07/17 11:47pm

bluegangsta

avatar

1. PLANET EARTH - COMPASSION

2. GUITAR - BEGINNING ENDLESSLY

3. SOMEWHERE HERE ON EARTH - FUTURE SOUL SONG

4. THE ONE U WANNA C - STICKY LIKE GLUE

5. FUTURE BABY MAMA - ACT OF GOD

6. MR. GOODNIGHT - LAVAUX

7. ALL THE MIDNIGHTS IN THE WORLD - WALK IN SAND

8. CHELSEA RODGERS - SEA OF EVERYTHING

9. LION OF JUDAH - EVERYBODY LOVES ME

10. RESOLUTION - LAYDOWN


PLANET EARTH: 3
20TEN: 7

Always cry 4 love, never cry 4 pain.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #12 posted 03/07/17 11:54pm

MattyJam

avatar

1. PLANET EARTH - COMPASSION

2. GUITAR - BEGINNING ENDLESSLY

3. SOMEWHERE HERE ON EARTH - FUTURE SOUL SONG

4. THE ONE U WANNA C - STICKY LIKE GLUE

5. FUTURE BABY MAMA - ACT OF GOD

6. MR. GOODNIGHT - LAVAUX

7. ALL THE MIDNIGHTS IN THE WORLD - WALK IN SAND

8. CHELSEA RODGERS - SEA OF EVERYTHING

9. LION OF JUDAH - EVERYBODY LOVES ME

10. RESOLUTION - LAYDOWN

Planet Earth - 6

20Ten - 4

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #13 posted 03/08/17 12:52am

dodger

1. PLANET EARTH - COMPASSION

2. GUITAR - BEGINNING ENDLESSLY

3. SOMEWHERE HERE ON EARTH - FUTURE SOUL SONG

4. THE ONE U WANNA C - STICKY LIKE GLUE

5. FUTURE BABY MAMA - ACT OF GOD

6. MR. GOODNIGHT - LAVAUX

7. ALL THE MIDNIGHTS IN THE WORLD - WALK IN SAND

8. CHELSEA RODGERS - SEA OF EVERYTHING

9. LION OF JUDAH - EVERYBODY LOVES ME

10. RESOLUTION - LAYDOWN

.

PLANET EARTH: 4

20TEN: 6

.


  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #14 posted 03/08/17 6:10am

FullLipsDotNos
e

avatar

1. PLANET EARTH - COMPASSION

2. GUITAR - BEGINNING ENDLESSLY

3. SOMEWHERE HERE ON EARTH - FUTURE SOUL SONG

4. THE ONE U WANNA C - STICKY LIKE GLUE

5. FUTURE BABY MAMA - ACT OF GOD

6. MR. GOODNIGHT - LAVAUX

7. ALL THE MIDNIGHTS IN THE WORLD - WALK IN SAND

8. CHELSEA RODGERS - SEA OF EVERYTHING

9. LION OF JUDAH - EVERYBODY LOVES ME

10. RESOLUTION - LAYDOWN

4:6

full lips, freckles, and upturned nose
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #15 posted 03/08/17 7:18am

CAL3

Shockedelicus said:

This one is interesting because they're both pretty terrible.

.


1. PLANET EARTH - COMPASSION - no contest!!

2. GUITAR - BEGINNING ENDLESSLY

3. SOMEWHERE HERE ON EARTH - FUTURE SOUL SONG

4. THE ONE U WANNA C - STICKY LIKE GLUE

5. FUTURE BABY MAMA - ACT OF GOD

6. MR. GOODNIGHT - LAVAUX - no contest!!

7. ALL THE MIDNIGHTS IN THE WORLD - WALK IN SAND - no contest!!

8. CHELSEA RODGERS - SEA OF EVERYTHING

9. LION OF JUDAH - EVERYBODY LOVES ME

10. RESOLUTION - LAYDOWN

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #16 posted 03/08/17 7:18am

Genesia

avatar

1. PLANET EARTH - COMPASSION

2. GUITAR - BEGINNING ENDLESSLY

3. SOMEWHERE HERE ON EARTH - FUTURE SOUL SONG

4. THE ONE U WANNA C - STICKY LIKE GLUE

5. FUTURE BABY MAMA - ACT OF GOD

6. MR. GOODNIGHT - LAVAUX

7. ALL THE MIDNIGHTS IN THE WORLD - WALK IN SAND

8. CHELSEA RODGERS - SEA OF EVERYTHING (I don't like either - this is a pity vote for 20TEN)

9. LION OF JUDAH - EVERYBODY LOVES ME

10. RESOLUTION - LAYDOWN

Planet Earth: 7 (This pains me)

20TEN: 3

[Edited 3/8/17 7:18am]

We don’t mourn artists because we knew them. We mourn them because they helped us know ourselves.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #17 posted 03/08/17 7:20am

Genesia

avatar

RJOrion said:

Shockedelicus said:

This one is interesting because they're both pretty terrible.

  1. Planet Earth
  2. Guitar
  3. Somewhere Here on Earth
  4. Sticky Like Glue
  5. Act of God
  6. Lavaux
  7. Walk in Sand *puke*
  8. Chelsea Rodgers
  9. Lion of Judah
  10. Laydown

sad ...wow... thats my 11 year old son's favorite Prince song ever....


So your 11-year-old son's favorite Prince song is a maxipad commercial. (Because that's what Walk In Sand would be perfect for. All it needs is a woman in white jeans.)

We don’t mourn artists because we knew them. We mourn them because they helped us know ourselves.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #18 posted 03/08/17 7:29am

RodeoSchro

1. PLANET EARTH - COMPASSION

2. GUITAR - BEGINNING ENDLESSLY

3. SOMEWHERE HERE ON EARTH - FUTURE SOUL SONG

4. THE ONE U WANNA C - STICKY LIKE GLUE

5. FUTURE BABY MAMA - ACT OF GOD

6. MR. GOODNIGHT - LAVAUX

7. ALL THE MIDNIGHTS IN THE WORLD - WALK IN SAND

8. CHELSEA RODGERS - SEA OF EVERYTHING

9. LION OF JUDAH - EVERYBODY LOVES ME

10. RESOLUTION - LAYDOWN

PLANET EARTH: 7

20TEN: 3


  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #19 posted 03/08/17 8:19am

LonelyStarfish

Planet earth <<< compassion
Guitar <<< beginning endlessly
Somewhere here on earth <<< future soul song
The one u wanns c <<< sticky like glue
Future baby mama <<< act of god
Mr goodnight <<< lavux
All the midnights <<< walk in sand
Chelsea rogers >>> sea of everything
Lion of Judith <<< everybody loves me
Resolution <<< laydown
Planet earth 1
20ten 9
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #20 posted 03/08/17 9:27am

plasticwood

avatar

1. PLANET EARTH - COMPASSION

2. GUITAR - BEGINNING ENDLESSLY

3. SOMEWHERE HERE ON EARTH - FUTURE SOUL SONG

4. THE ONE U WANNA C - STICKY LIKE GLUE

5. FUTURE BABY MAMA - ACT OF GOD

6. MR. GOODNIGHT - LAVAUX

7. ALL THE MIDNIGHTS IN THE WORLD - WALK IN SAND

8. CHELSEA RODGERS - SEA OF EVERYTHING

9. LION OF JUDAH - EVERYBODY LOVES ME

10. RESOLUTION - LAYDOWN

Planet Earth - 8

20Ten - 2

But when I just rank the songs, the two albums are closer

THE ONE U WANNA C

LAVAUX

STICKY LIKE GLUE

ALL THE MIDNIGHTS IN THE WORLD

GUITAR

BEGINNING ENDLESSLY

RESOLUTION

SOMEWHERE HERE ON EARTH

FUTURE SOUL SONG

CHELSEA RODGERS

COMPASSION

MR. GOODNIGHT

FUTURE BABY MAMA

LAYDOWN

LION OF JUDAH

EVERYBODY LOVES ME

ACT OF GOD

WALK IN SAND

SEA OF EVERYTHING

PLANET EARTH

[Edited 3/8/17 9:30am]

I sometimes wonder whether all pleasures are not substitutes for joy.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #21 posted 03/08/17 9:35am

RodeoSchro

plasticwood said:

1. PLANET EARTH - COMPASSION

2. GUITAR - BEGINNING ENDLESSLY

3. SOMEWHERE HERE ON EARTH - FUTURE SOUL SONG

4. THE ONE U WANNA C - STICKY LIKE GLUE

5. FUTURE BABY MAMA - ACT OF GOD

6. MR. GOODNIGHT - LAVAUX

7. ALL THE MIDNIGHTS IN THE WORLD - WALK IN SAND

8. CHELSEA RODGERS - SEA OF EVERYTHING

9. LION OF JUDAH - EVERYBODY LOVES ME

10. RESOLUTION - LAYDOWN

Planet Earth - 8

20Ten - 2

But when I just rank the songs, the two albums are closer

THE ONE U WANNA C

LAVAUX

STICKY LIKE GLUE

ALL THE MIDNIGHTS IN THE WORLD

GUITAR

BEGINNING ENDLESSLY

RESOLUTION

SOMEWHERE HERE ON EARTH

FUTURE SOUL SONG

CHELSEA RODGERS

COMPASSION

MR. GOODNIGHT

FUTURE BABY MAMA

LAYDOWN

LION OF JUDAH

EVERYBODY LOVES ME

ACT OF GOD

WALK IN SAND

SEA OF EVERYTHING

PLANET EARTH

[Edited 3/8/17 9:30am]



Great point. If someone asked me which was the better album, I'd say "20Ten" but the way they were both tracked, I had way more "Planet Earth" songs in my list.

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #22 posted 03/08/17 9:36am

Romeoblu

Compassion
Beginning endlessly
Future soul song
The 1 u wanna c
Future baby mama
Lavaux
All the midnight
Sea of everything
Lion of Judah
Laydown

20ten wins 6/4
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #23 posted 03/08/17 1:30pm

MIRvmn

avatar

1. PLANET EARTH - COMPASSION
2. GUITAR - BEGINNING ENDLESSLY
3. SOMEWHERE HERE ON EARTH - FUTURE SOUL SONG
4. THE ONE U WANNA C - STICKY LIKE GLUE
5. FUTURE BABY MAMA - ACT OF GOD
6. MR. GOODNIGHT - LAVAUX
7. ALL THE MIDNIGHTS IN THE WORLD - WALK IN SAND
8. CHELSEA RODGERS - SEA OF EVERYTHING
9. LION OF JUDAH - EVERYBODY LOVES ME
10. RESOLUTION - LAYDOWN

Planet Earth 6
20Ten 4
Welcome 2 The Dawn
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #24 posted 03/08/17 1:35pm

iZsaZsa

avatar

1. PLANET EARTH - COMPASSION
2. GUITAR - BEGINNING ENDLESSLY
3. SOMEWHERE HERE ON EARTH - FUTURE SOUL SONG
4. THE ONE U WANNA C - STICKY LIKE GLUE
5. FUTURE BABY MAMA - ACT OF GOD (Yes.)
6. MR. GOODNIGHT - LAVAUX
7. ALL THE MIDNIGHTS IN THE WORLD - WALK IN SAND
8. CHELSEA RODGERS - SEA OF EVERYTHING
9. LION OF JUDAH - EVERYBODY LOVES ME
10. RESOLUTION - LAYDOWN
What?
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #25 posted 03/08/17 2:52pm

sexton

avatar

Is THE CHOCOLATE INVASION vs. THE SLAUGHTERHOUSE thread coming next?

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #26 posted 03/08/17 6:07pm

gandorb

Planet Earth - Compassion (like them both)

Guitar - Beginning Endlessly (Biggest disparity - though liked Guitar live0

Somewhere her on Earth - Future Love Song (toughest match = both excellent)

The One U Wanna C - Sticky Like Glue

Future Baby Mama - Act of God

Mr. Goodnight - Lavaux

All the Midnights in the World - Walk in Sand

Chelsea Rodgers - Sea of Everything (no apologies, I am one of the few defenders of this one)

Lion of Judah-Everybody Loves Me (the weakest duo)

Resolution - Laydown (purple yoda lyric makes me smile every time).

Planet Earth 4

2-ten 6

Both album start strong but peter out in the 2nd half.

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #27 posted 03/08/17 6:13pm

purplethunder3
121

avatar

PLANET EARTH vs. 20TEN

1. PLANET EARTH - COMPASSION

2. GUITAR - BEGINNING ENDLESSLY

3. SOMEWHERE HERE ON EARTH - FUTURE SOUL SONG

4. THE ONE U WANNA C - STICKY LIKE GLUE

5. FUTURE BABY MAMA - ACT OF GOD

6. MR. GOODNIGHT - LAVAUX

7. ALL THE MIDNIGHTS IN THE WORLD - WALK IN SAND

8. CHELSEA RODGERS - SEA OF EVERYTHING

9. LION OF JUDAH - EVERYBODY LOVES ME

10. RESOLUTION - LAYDOWN

"Music gives a soul to the universe, wings to the mind, flight to the imagination and life to everything." --Plato

https://youtu.be/CVwv9LZMah0
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #28 posted 03/08/17 7:10pm

bobgeorge77

1. PLANET EARTH - COMPASSION

2. GUITAR - BEGINNING ENDLESSLY

3. SOMEWHERE HERE ON EARTH - FUTURE SOUL SONG (this one is difficult...somewhere is my favorite track on planet earth, but future soul song is kind of a classic...)

4. THE ONE U WANNA C - STICKY LIKE GLUE

5. FUTURE BABY MAMA - ACT OF GOD

6. MR. GOODNIGHT - LAVAUX

7. ALL THE MIDNIGHTS IN THE WORLD - WALK IN SAND

8. CHELSEA RODGERS - SEA OF EVERYTHING

9. LION OF JUDAH - EVERYBODY LOVES ME (hard to pick... I will have to go back and listen to these again...neither has been in my rotation for quite a long time!)

10. RESOLUTION - LAYDOWN

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #29 posted 03/08/17 7:26pm

EddieC

Okay--tougher than Lovesexy/Batman, because I just don't know these albums as well, but here goes

Planet Earth - Compassion (PE ain't great, but Compassion is one of the few tracks I want to skip)

Guitar - Beginning Endlessly

Somewhere Here On Earth - Future Soul Song

The One U Wanna C - Sticky Like Glue

Future Baby Mama - Act of God (don't really care for either one much)

Mr. Goodnight - Lavaux

All the Midnights in the World - Walk in Sand (that was tough - I actually like them both a lot)

Chelsea Rodgers - Sea of Everything (and that was really easy! Chelsea's dull, SoE is great)

Lion of Judah - Everybody Loves Me (neither's great, but ELM is fun. I'm not all that into striking enemies down, unless it's done in a more interesting way).

Resolution - Laydown

So 20Ten wins 7-3 (and of those three, only two are because I actively like the song that won. Compassion would have lost to everything on Planet Earth, and that album has quite a few songs that made very little impression on me).

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Page 1 of 2 12>
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
« Previous topic  Next topic »
Forums > Prince: Music and More > PLANET EARTH vs. 20TEN