If you will, so will I | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
This is what I meant to say earlier (what I bolded below). If you look at his output objectively, I do think you could pare it down to a really wonderful album every 3-4 years that probably, most of the time, rivals what he did in the 80s or any other artist at the top of their game at any time. Bono was right.
I love the way you just listened to the songs without being tied to the memories of him in the 80s...and of us, actually, as we lived life. It's a different window into his work.
Comeback is just beautiful. And devastating. Truly.
[Edited 12/20/16 16:17pm] | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
June was a derivative snooze; a throwaway that he gave to Josh for some engineering practice, I'd guess. I'm glad that some people enjoyed it however, because that's the idea after all--I just don't get with that particular soft lob. Of that brand of tune, I prefer "Reflections" from Musicology. that'll be my meta-criticism of the hour. Both of those could go together on a post-symbol compilation.
I agree with you that a collection of music from the 90s would seem contrived when you're creating a load of great songs and end up playing a tug-of-war with a record company to determine which songs will go on an album and at what time any of it will be presented to the public. In that regard, the stuff in the given context could be deemed "contrived," but your statement of "90s throwaways being cornball" is so generalized as to be ambivalent to me, meant merely to can an era of the guy's work because you don't like it! That is simple enough, but it doesn't mean that the stuff is totally unlikeable! That darn Prince was just so audacious to want to battle the businessmen and mess with the moneymakers. It was a brilliant period throughout. If you never heard much of the brilliant part of that phase of his productivity you just didn't want to hear it, in my lil' ole opinion; you may have just been into the other sounds of the Nineties. Put some of Prince's works of that era on a compilation, though, and one could be amazed at how it hits the tastemakers. [Edited 12/20/16 19:39pm] | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Germanegro said:
June was a derivative snooze; a throwaway that he gave to Josh for some engineering practice, I'd guess. I'm glad that some people enjoyed it however, because that's the idea after all--I just don't get with that particular soft lob. Of that brand of tune, I prefer "Reflections" from Musicology. that'll be my meta-criticism of the hour. Both of those could go together on a post-symbol compilation.
I agree with you that a collection of music from the 90s would seem contrived when you're creating a load of great songs and end up playing a tug-of-war with a record company to determine which songs will go on an album and at what time any of it will be presented to the public. In that regard, the stuff in the given context could be deemed "contrived," but your statement of "90s throwaways being cornball" is so generalized as to be ambivalent to me, meant merely to can an era of the guy's work because you don't like it! That is simple enough, but it doesn't mean that the stuff is totally unlikeable! That darn Prince was just so audacious to want to battle the businessmen and mess with the moneymakers. It was a brilliant period throughout. If you never heard much of the brilliant part of that phase of his productivity you just didn't want to hear it, in my lil' ole opinion; you may have just been into the other sounds of the Nineties. Put some of Prince's works of that era on a compilation, though, and one could be amazed at how it hits the tastemakers. [Edited 12/20/16 19:39pm] I've gone back and revisited the 90's many times. And like I've said there are gems in there, but you have to have the patience to sift through it all. But so cheesy. It's a real chore to go through so much music that just so cornball and seemingly second guessing what he thinks people will like. As if he dumbed his sound down to the lowest common denominator to see if he could get "kids" to listen to his music as a businessmen, a stressed out businessman instead of just an artist for the sake of art. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
I've much enjoyed the 90s Prince and plenty of the post-symbol stuff--same difference is that I actually enjoy more of that stuff. You can call it cheese until the cows come home--I don't feel the need to do a lot of sifting. But sift away if you must! A compilation of such tunes would do that for you and bring attention to this music that some haven't checked out due to their younger age, or were too discouraged toward due Prince's pissy behavior, pandering, or whatever distractions one can claim. > When you feel you've nothing to prove to anyone per your capabilities besides getting the music out that you want to get out there, you have the freedom to stretch in any direction you like as a artist--for the sake of a whim and to earn enough change to do it again! Start the compiliations ASAP. I'd be happy enough to see a straight reissue of those albums, actually, and certainly any collection among the plethora of live gems that everybody is just drooling to have in good quality. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Germanegro said:
I've much enjoyed the 90s Prince and plenty of the post-symbol stuff--same difference is that I actually enjoy more of that stuff. You can call it cheese until the cows come home--I don't feel the need to do a lot of sifting. But sift away if you must! A compilation of such tunes would do that for you and bring attention to this music that some haven't checked out due to their younger age, or were too discouraged toward due Prince's pissy behavior, pandering, or whatever distractions one can claim. > When you feel you've nothing to prove to anyone per your capabilities besides getting the music out that you want to get out there, you have the freedom to stretch in any direction you like as a artist--for the sake of a whim and to earn enough change to do it again! Start the compiliations ASAP. I'd be happy enough to see a straight reissue of those albums, actually, and certainly any collection among the plethora of live gems that everybody is just drooling to have in good quality. Well It's cheesy and what it is. Well most of the 90's stuff. There is no other word to describe it. It is what it is. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Such a critic! I'm blown away--not! You're the king of claiming what you don't like in broad, generic terms, I'll give you that. > It'll be interesting to see what kind of compilations these companies can dream up to present to new consumers. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Germanegro said: Such a critic! I'm blown away--not! You're the king of claiming what you don't like in broad, generic terms, I'll give you that. > Damn right! Me and everyone else that skipped his 90's output. I'm just with the majority of people with ears. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
The public skipping his 90's work is only because of the sounds he was conjuring? It wasn't partly because he was not a kid anymore, stopped using WB's support for promotion and distribution and alienated people by changing his name to an unpronouncable symbol? That had nothing to do with it all? You probably should not ignore all the variables.
| |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
purplerabbithole said: The public skipping his 90's work is only because of the sounds he was conjuring? It wasn't partly because he was not a kid anymore, stopped using WB's support for promotion and distribution and alienated people by changing his name to an unpronouncable symbol? That had nothing to do with it all? You probably should not ignore all the variables.
The only variable that mattered to people was that it was cheesy. It's not like he was an unknown indie act that needed massive promotion. Every new album received reviews and mention from every outlet. Ultimately the work always speaks for itself. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Prince was cheesy in the 80's too. And we loved him for it. But of course, he did it with a wink in his eye so maybe that helped.
I do agree that songs like "My Name is Prince" are cheesy but in the same album there are "Damn You" and "God Created Woman" so I am unable to be dismissive of all of his output because he had his head up his ass at times..
BTW, "My Name is Prince" (a song I absolutely detest) I realized for the first time was meant to be ironic and humorous (after all, he wasn't using his name anymore when he did that song on an album in which the love symbol signified the title of both himself and the album) but boy did he not release that song like he was dead serious.
Also, I keep in mind that the environment while recording these songs wasn't necessarily the same vibe he was giving off publically. Yes, I know his control freak reputation during those years was at all time high but he was still surrounded by extremely capable musicans and he still liked to jam for long hours.
| |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Some people *cough--Ingela--cough* would rather attempt to make a name for themselves as a critic than enjoy the music and let others identify for themselves what they like. This effort toward a critique of the 90s--post-symbol era of Prince's career gets a failing grade by me! > All it takes to make a review is a pen, paper, keyboard, and an opinion. > Let the music do the talking and put it on a compilation, already. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
A lot of the 90's R&B just has a dated sound and subject matter, which makes it hard to be accessible to the new listener. "Now" is fun, but it's hard for someone new to get into - especially if they've heard the Fresh Prince's "Boom Shake The Room" from the year before. "Emale" and "My Computer" are catchy, but SOOOO dated.
Come was interesting, but not very friendly to the uninitiated as a body of work.
The Gold Experience has great songs on it, but the segues kill it for every single person i have played it for.
Emancipation just has soooo much to wade through. For every "The Holy River" on it, there's a "White Mansion." Which isn't a bad tune, it just isn't anywhere near his best work.
Newpower Soul is nice to chill to, but mostly as BGM. There's not a high energy track that pops.
Rave Un2 The Joy Fantastic should have done better, but WB killed it's moment with The Vault and with The Very Best of.
The albums also weren't as strong front to back as they were pre-.
Listen2Prince !!
U can listen to a different Prince project every week for a year! Sometimes U might have to double (or triple) up on related albums to make it fit, tho. https://listen2prince.blogspot.com/ | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
NO arguments (especially your statement about the inconsistent nature of his 90's albums)
But what about these songs? Strolling Willing and Able Blue Light Damn U Shhh Endorphmachine MOney don't matter tonight The entirety of the Truth album ANd God Created Women I hate U Same December Shy Dolphin Days of Wild (dated? I don't know but I also don't care.) Radical Man 2045 7 (yes, I love 7) Chaos and Disorder The Ride Dinner with Delores Rippopgodazippa I love you but I don't trust you anymore the greatest Romance that has ever been sold In this bed we scream Holy River The Love we Make Empty Room (later version) 1000 hugs and kisses (early version) Calhoun Square There is lonely Get off's use of flute impressed Sexy MF's use of funky horns impressed me as well. Sarah Dark
All--highly enjoyable songs.
| |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Thanks for your comment, InwardJim! I'm inspired to share my take on some of these collections. I've heard others say that Gold is a dated album to a degree and the segues can distract, but omit those and I think that some of those songs could be known as Prince classics, some that could be called "cheesy" too, like "P-Control" and "Dolphin." "Shh" is a nice, powerful jam. "Shy" is a concise narrative on LA gang life with a tender ending that's kind of endearing--I think of it often. "I Hate U" is a pretty wild lil' tune. > Emancipation, IMO is a big treasure chest, but some just don't like its expansiveness, the production values of the thing, or its R&B focus. "Style" is classic cool, laid-back P-R-I-N-C-E! I feel that Prince' s singing on this collection overall is as on-point as ever. > NewPowerSoul is a minor effort I'll concede, but it jams in a funky way that he's rarely achieved otherwise, IMO, and I like it for that! "Mad Sex" is pretty punchy and rollicking; "Come On" leaves an impression that folks like to tune in to over again, and "I Like Funky Music" has a nice kick, to it. The love ballads" Untill Ure In My Arms Again" and "I Am the One" are just as saccharine and syrupy as you want to have them. > Come, well, I think the title informs the content. just explore it and ride the pleasure wave through all the aural slap-and-tickling that it delivers. You might be dissappointed in spots, but not all the way through--LOL! | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
I agree with all of those (except The Truth album could've done without Animal Kingdom and Man In A Uniform, which are the two low points IMHO but the rest is so good!).
When Emancipation came out, my first thought was this needs to be pared down to at least a double album. There's just too much for the casual fam.
It was the same with the post- years as well. 2004: Musicology / Chocolate Invasion / Slaughterhouse, 2009: LotusFlow3r / MPLsOUND, 2014: Plectrumelectrum / Art Official Age. If they had been combined to form truly knockout punch albums or at least had their releases staggered more (and in the case of Chocolate and Slaughter done to the public), they might be better known for their gems.
Prince would have benefitted from having a true producer post-Emancipation to help focus his output (not censor it). I love a lot of those songs, but some are truly more B-Side than album cut
Listen2Prince !!
U can listen to a different Prince project every week for a year! Sometimes U might have to double (or triple) up on related albums to make it fit, tho. https://listen2prince.blogspot.com/ | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
purplerabbithole said: NO arguments (especially your statement about the inconsistent nature of his 90's albums)
But what about these songs? Shhh Endorphmachine The entirety of the Truth album I hate U Same December Days of Wild (dated? I don't know but I also don't care.) 7 (yes, I love 7) Chaos and Disorder Dinner with Delores Empty Room (later version) 1000 hugs and kisses (early version) There is lonely Get off's use of flute impressed Sexy MF's use of funky horns impressed me as well.
All--highly enjoyable songs.
For me, I edited your list a little and I would also a few more tracks from Come | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
I'm very baffled as to how medias have been able, in a few years, to reduce the word "hipster" to a single brand of people. The term exists since at least the 50's and was always meant to define anyone who's trendy, sophisticated and hip. There are many ways of being hip, and many associated lifestyles and dress codes. I cannot accept the word to be reduced like this. I been a hipster since the mid 90's and back then it had nothing to do with beards, squared shirts, organic food and vinyl records. A COMPREHENSIVE PRINCE DISCOGRAPHY (work in progress ^^): https://sites.google.com/...scography/ | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
If there was to be a 1994/2016 compilation, it should have this tracklist :
THE HITS 3 :
1. PARTYMAN (#18 US, #14 Uk, not in any other compilations) 2. LOVE THY WILL B DONE prince version ( worldwide top 10) 3. TMBGITW (#1 worldwide) 4. LET IT GO (top 40 worldwide) 5. I HATE U (#12 US, #20 uk) 6. GOLD (#10 uk) 7. GET WILD (#19 uk) 8. BETCHA BY GOLLY WOW (#11 uk, #31 US) 9. THE HOLY RIVER (#19 uk, #58 US) 10. TGRES ( #63 US, #65 UK) 11. MUSICOLOGY ( top 40 in numerous markets, 1 grammy) 12. CALL MY NAME (#75 US, 27 weeks on charts ! and 1 grammy too !!) 13. CINAMMON GIRL (#43 Uk) 14. SST (#8 US single sales) 12. TE AMO CORAZON (#2 spain, #7 italy) 13. BLACKSWEAT (#1 US single sales, #2 Canada, #43 UK)) 15. SONG OF THE HEART (won the 2007 Golden Globe Award for Best Original Song) 16. FUTURE BABY MAMA (# 39 rnb charts, 20 weeks, 1 grammy) 17. BREAKFAST CAN WAIT 18. THIS COULD B US (#13 rnb adult charts) 19. FALL IN LOVE 2NITE with Zooey Deschanell (top 50 airplay US) 20. Xs and Qs (#12 rb adult)
| |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Not a bad list, Rod, although I'd throw out Future Baby Mama and Breakfast Can Wait and replace them with Guitar and FunkNRoll to spice things up a little! | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
I agree that this tracklist is too flooded with low tempos. But Future baby mama had a grammy, BREAKFAST CAN WAIT charted in many countries, and was a moderate hit on youtube. GUITAR was a flop (#80 in UK) and FUNKNROLL never charted anywhere. But why not, because it's a uptempo track showing what Prince was able to do in 2014. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Okay, we'd lose #s 18 & 20 then and close your compilation witha bang! | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Great work and a very good list, thank u
My list still contains 45 songs and I didn't take into account any chart positions. So I am not sure if I should post it "I'm not a human, I am a dove. I'm your conscious, I am love" | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
If you will, so will I | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Loved Emancipation!!! Agree with what many have said, seems WB only wants Prince to shine while he was under them. I loved a lot of his later music and was the reason I joined NPGMC. It was like getting a present a week. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
It will take a lot to convince me otherwise. Having been an engineer, I've seen how petty execs can be first-hand. Prince calling WB slave-owners in the very public way he did certainly gained the ire of the business-decision makers. The narrative turned to Prince just being weird, crazy, and desperate in nearly any mass-publication story written at the time of that messy divorce. Prince should have been more vocal about the genesis of the name change being so that he could get around WB's ownership of the output of anything under the name "Prince." He did said it, but it wasn't the narrative that those who needed to remain on good terms with WB picked up on. They absolutely were controlling the narrative that anything the amazing "Prince" did was done under WB, anything after he left them was generally not worth notice - hence "The Very Best Of." Rolling Stone, Mtv, and Vh1 certainly didn't need to cow to WB, but in the 90's they WERE the exceptions.
By the time Ultimate came out, just about everything post- was largely ignored by the masses so it made sense what was on that package. The Very Best Of should have contained at least TMBGITW (and if it could have been worked out: Betcha By Golly Wow, The Holy River, The One, Come On and maybe Face Down).
In this age of exceptional indie artists appearing all the time, it's hard for the new generation to realize how hard it actually was to do that in the 90's. Even more so in the early 2000's (when my three bands met their fates). Garageband really was the game changer, not because of its quality (there was none) but it's inspiration to be able to do it without needing the label. Prince's successful break from WB scared the industry. His career being largely ignored was commercially until the R&R Hall Of Fame induction and Musicology in 2004 was damage control. He still made waves and was the ground-breaking innovator he always was, it just didn't get the attention it deserved.
We know what he did, because we are the Purple Fams. No one needed to tell us that he pioneered internet music, or that he was still putting gems out. The casual listener, who is where marketing and advertising direct their efforts, is who missed out. Listen2Prince !!
U can listen to a different Prince project every week for a year! Sometimes U might have to double (or triple) up on related albums to make it fit, tho. https://listen2prince.blogspot.com/ | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Amen. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |