This is a "featured" topic! — From here you can jump to the « previous or next » featured topic.
New topic Printable
I wonder if Prince had other business investments. Just like the fitness club that owned the private plane Prince was on from Atlanta.
You are correct, the Parent company is from Norway. If Tidal is incorporated in the US, which I do not know, then would Tidal not be under the jurisdiction of US law? According to Bloomberg, ROC Nation is a LLC and a subsidiary of Live Nation Entertainment. That makes me believe, regardless of their parent, they are responsible to US federal court jurisdiction.
Tidal Music is a subsidary of Norwegian based Aspiro. Again, I believe that Tidal is within jurisdiction. If the estate does not name Aspiro in the lawsuit, then Tidal, regardless of the parent's location, will have to respond and defend themselves in the lawsuit. I am sure Tidal and ROC can have financial documents sealed during the court proceedings.
| |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
nelcp777 said:
I wonder if Prince had other business investments. Just like the fitness club that owned the private plane Prince was on from Atlanta.
You are correct, the Parent company is from Norway. If Tidal is incorporated in the US, which I do not know, then would Tidal not be under the jurisdiction of US law? According to Bloomberg, ROC Nation is a LLC and a subsidiary of Live Nation Entertainment. That makes me believe, regardless of their parent, they are responsible to US federal court jurisdiction.
Tidal Music is a subsidary of Norwegian based Aspiro. Again, I believe that Tidal is within jurisdiction. If the estate does not name Aspiro in the lawsuit, then Tidal, regardless of the parent's location, will have to respond and defend themselves in the lawsuit. I am sure Tidal and ROC can have financial documents sealed during the court proceedings.
/-/I am sure he had other investments as Breamer at one point referred to the estate as a vast entertainment/ business empire. The jurisdiction of the court over the subsidiary dependent on how the parent/subsidiary relationship is structured it does not matter because U.S courts have had success working with foreign governments to stop copyright infringement. I still find it weird that most of the catalog is still up on the site you would think an injunction would have forced it all to come down since all parties agree to the 90 day exclusivity clause. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
I agree with you about the injunction and material still being on the site. This is a mess. From trying to do a brief research on Tidal, it has had it share of litigation in recent years and the company is fairly new. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
This is my personal opinion, I don’t have any actual knowledge of the situation and I’m simply speculating like many others do on the org. . As I see it, this discussion is simple; the issue is whether or not Tidal had the legal/contractual rights to post P’s entire catalog on Tidal in June. What’s to discuss? This will all come out in court; all this speculating, liking/not liking someone and character slurs won’t change the ‘legal’ decisions at the end of the day.
. So the possibilities (that we know of): 1) There is a contractual agreement whereby Tidal will be cleared of wrongdoing. End of case. 2) No legal/contractual agreement prior to posting the files, in that Tidal did not have the specific ‘rights’ to post P’s entire catalog on Tidal -- but went ahead and did so anyway.
. Jayz isn’t a stupid man, and I’m sure Tidal has the legal recourses to advise him of the consequences of posting albums and songs without written / specific permission. . ///So, here is where my view is different. What if Tidal did not have the rights to post? They weighted the all consequences, potential fines, and ramifications (with their legal staff) and still posted the files anyway? . Maybe Jayz/Tidal are courageous and should be admired. In honoring, Prince, they made sure the world had access to the entire catalog regardless of the potential personal consequences. . Much of P’s music had never been heard before because people simply didn’t have access to it and many were unaware. Tidal changed all that! Now fans are (re)discovering many long out of print albums that simply have never seen the light of day outside a select fan base. . Contract or not, Jayz may have done more for P’s legacy than anyone else by ‘freeing’ ALL of his music for everyone to enjoy. . As for getting paid …. I really don’t care to be a watch dog of the ‘estate’, these people (siblings) will be getting millions of dollars for doing nothing, so if they get a tiny bet less money, who cares? . Don't want to upset anyone, thisi is just my opinion.
[Edited 12/28/16 19:06pm] | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Prince #MUSICIANICONLEGEND | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Wavesofbliss....
Surely you cant have missed the WHOLE Point of SLaVE ?
Prince was not crying about not making money because of Record Companies...he MADE MONEY
HIS POINT WAS..Why should the record companies make MORE than the Artists ..??? Thats what it is all about....
Thats WHY TIDAL.... | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Prince #MUSICIANICONLEGEND | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
--Thank you. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
prince still wanted to live like a kept woman and maintain ridiculous overheads and waste cash on money pits like glam slam clubs and npg dance co. all while crying about not making money bcos of the record company”
I believe those business ventures were in place before things went sour with WB and those ventures and came to an end when he was fighting with the label. Having a place to showcase you music and letting fans hang out is not a waste. In the end he just did the same thing at Paisley Park by having dance parties and events. It is all a part of being an entrepreneur and no entrepreneur all of their money into one venture. . “he could have invested in the tech of file sharing and more recently streaming tech that would have been of longterm benefit to his work and legacy and well and truly ahead of his time.” Did you miss that NPG music club he was the first artist to have a music service were fans could purchase files to listen to. He did this 15 years before streaming came along now we have no idea how much money he made off of the club but I can remember people bitching and laughing about what he was doing. I am not sure why you do not recall any of this. I think he did a great job when he went independent and I want you to name me another artist at Prince level that left a major label and was able to find a means to distribute their music on the scale that he did for as long as he did.If he missed a few opps so be it as he was doing about 90 other things.
| |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
"As I see it, this discussion is simple; the issue is whether or not Tidal had the legal/contractual rights to post P’s entire catalog on Tidal in June. What’s to discuss? This will all come out in court; all this speculating, liking/not liking someone and character slurs won’t change the ‘legal’ decisions at the end of the day." Exactly, the court will sort it out and if money is owed it will be payed. I also don't see how anyone can beat an injuction so Tidal must have some documentation and that will have to be given to a Federal court.
| |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
sorta. there were so many complaints and weirdness i decided against it. i never paid much attention to his online presence after that. i'd just click around whatever site he had up at the time- if i could get in. i don't feel that missed much, he ended up releasing most of that music anyway. i enjoyed flipping thru that online museum they had up right after his death. Prince #MUSICIANICONLEGEND | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
laurarichardson said:
"As I see it, this discussion is simple; the issue is whether or not Tidal had the legal/contractual rights to post P’s entire catalog on Tidal in June. What’s to discuss? This will all come out in court; all this speculating, liking/not liking someone and character slurs won’t change the ‘legal’ decisions at the end of the day." Exactly, the court will sort it out and if money is owed it will be payed. I also don't see how anyone can beat an injuction so Tidal must have some documentation and that will have to be given to a Federal court.
-/- The Gold Experience is back up on Tidal. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Well given the fact that you insisted that a shareholder is higher than a CEO you clearly don't know much about business and I showed the photo to prove the point that TIDAL is not a Black owned business that is operated by Black workers despite the LIE Jay Z promoted, that was the point. Its hilarious you keep going through loop holes just to defend Jay Z. Point BLANK period, Jay Z does not own TIDAL and TIDAL is not a Black owned business. This is not rocket science.
| |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
You do have dedication to Jay Z and TIDAL. For crying out loud you just argued that a shareholder was higher than a CEO just to big up Jay Z! It is clear that you have some bias towards them and feel the need to defend them even when your argument does not factually or rationally make sense. My dislike for Jay Z has nothing to do with my feelings about this matter. However, the shady and unethical things that Jay Z and TIDAL have done does support the reasons why I dislike him. However, Jay Z has showed his own ass and does not need any help from me in pointing his flaws out on this matter. I already pointed out to you why the general public is not feeling TIDAL. The whole marketing roll out of TIDAL was wrong form the get go. There marketing strategy was to use their "star power" to get people to purchase the streaming service. "Come support us because I am Jay Z, Kanye, Beyonce and because it will give us more money" there was no catching points that was geared toward how it would benefit the consumer. Consumers have a right to question any product and how it is being marketed to them. The way TIDAL was marketed was obnoxious and geared toward shareholders as the center which was wrong, CONSUMERS should always be the focal point any time a product is being marketed, that is the whole point! In business you want consumers to buy your product!
| |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
i completely agree. it is entirely possible that prince was sold a bill of goods regarding his deal with TIDAL and that TIDAL make some quick grab after his death. it wouldn't b the first time prince made a questionable business decision and it wouldn't b the first time that jz didn't some shady business. i still can't shake the feeling that they hadto have something in place or prince wouldn't have been dealing with them before his death. it could have just gone bad for prince. didn't he pull out of a concert tIDAL was sponsoring or whatever. but then again prince was known for doing things like that,too Prince #MUSICIANICONLEGEND | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Prince made a poor business move by collaborating with JayZ/TIDAL and got taken advantage of, it happens. There is no reason for some here to defend Jay Z and to come up with excuses for him or TIDAL when its evident that they are shady. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
laurarichardson said: laurarichardson said:
"As I see it, this discussion is simple; the issue is whether or not Tidal had the legal/contractual rights to post P’s entire catalog on Tidal in June. What’s to discuss? This will all come out in court; all this speculating, liking/not liking someone and character slurs won’t change the ‘legal’ decisions at the end of the day." Exactly, the court will sort it out and if money is owed it will be payed. I also don't see how anyone can beat an injuction so Tidal must have some documentation and that will have to be given to a Federal court.
-/- The Gold Experience is back up on Tidal. No sound coming from Dolphin I asked Prince what he was planning to do. He told me , I'm going to look for the ladder. I asked him what that meant. All he said was, sometimes it snows in April. - book D.M.S.R. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
mjscarousal said:
Well given the fact that you insisted that a shareholder is higher than a CEO you clearly don't know much about business and I showed the photo to prove the point that TIDAL is not a Black owned business that is operated by Black workers despite the LIE Jay Z promoted, that was the point. Its hilarious you keep going through loop holes just to defend Jay Z. Point BLANK period, Jay Z does not own TIDAL and TIDAL is not a Black owned business. This is not rocket science.
--You do know anything about business at all which is the reason you can't answer any questions that I put forth. Why is the music still up on Tidal (The Gold Experience is back ) how can Tidal beat a Federal court a order? If Prince was fooled by Jay-z why was he still sending them content right up to the week before he died? Large shareholders can have more power that the CEO of companies. If you don't know this you do not know anything about business. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Look, I'm just a non attached friend of purple, no sides, I like what Laura adds here, I think she's level headed. I found this, Prince 2015, Ebony, I copy/ paste below: EBONY: I like this album better than Hit N Run: Phase One. No disrespect. Prince: Hit N Run sounds like today. Tidal is sinking money into it, and they need it. And my heart is always on because I want them to do well. [Beyoncé and Jay Z] have taken a lot of abuse, their family has. A historic amount of abuse between the two of ’em. And when we win on this, none of us’ll gloat. He’s not the gloating type anyway. He’s slick with his. He says to brush the dirt off your shoulder. “Y’all just need to stop. Just calm down! Everybody calm down! There ya go.” | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Well Prince obviously was misinformed about Jay Z because Jay Zgloats about all his money, ventures, business deals in his songs. He even gloated about owning Prince music so this statement from Prince is showing poor judgement of character. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
yes she is....
and patient too... | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Laura is dope and I agree with her opinions on other issues. She is very passionate and I respect that she never backs down but she is being very biased on this topic. There are receipts that have been presented that shows that Jay Z and TIDAL are shady and have not been forthright in all their dealings with Prince. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Have y'all heard of Entertainment Lawyer? A gossip blogger. He does blind items and a few times a years will give answers to some of the blind items that have been posted on his website.
Welcome to "the org", Mumio…they can have you, but I'll have your love in the end | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Mumio said: Have y'all heard of Entertainment Lawyer? A gossip blogger. He does blind items and a few times a years will give answers to some of the blind items that have been posted on his website.
I thought her last two tours did well and I am not how they control their artist royalties unless some fools just turned their royalties over to them. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Mumio said: Have y'all heard of Entertainment Lawyer? A gossip blogger. He does blind items and a few times a years will give answers to some of the blind items that have been posted on his website.
[Edited 1/3/17 20:43pm] I asked Prince what he was planning to do. He told me , I'm going to look for the ladder. I asked him what that meant. All he said was, sometimes it snows in April. - book D.M.S.R. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
How long has Crystal Ball been gone from tidal? It's on the verge of being a bit shit.
Hamburger, Hot Dog, Root Beer, Pussy | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
RicoN said: How long has Crystal Ball been gone from tidal? It's on the verge of being a bit shit.
-- Things pop up and go away and then come back. If you see something buy it in the store. Gold is back up. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
I think there might be some truth to this. Beyonce and Jay Z have been touring non stop for over the last 3 years back to back and I have found this strange. There not struggling and they don't have any debts as far as we know so why are they doing all this touring back to back?? I think there is some truth to the blind item and they owe a lot of people money. Tea was already spilled that artists that do Super Bowl half times have to now pay up front OR give half of their tour gross back to NFL.
[Edited 1/5/17 10:38am] | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Supposedly, Beyonce gets $5.5 million per show. There are times when that amount does change. I remember Prince stating in a complaint about a venue during the show that he was getting $3 million for that show and he was going to perform despite the sound issues. All I can think is that her money was joined with her DH's money and much of it walked out the door ... [Edited 1/5/17 12:27pm] | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Prince, in you I found a kindred spirit...Rest In Paradise. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
This is a "featured" topic! — From here you can jump to the « previous or next » featured topic.