FlyOnTheWall, You have a point, but how many successful singles did he have after the Symbol album? The Most Beautiful Girl in the World and ...? He may have won Grammys, but he failed to have much success with new material on radio after 1994. Also, popularity is not the most important criterion for most of the Grammy awards. Billboard tends to be more of a "popularity contest" whereas the Grammys are more about the artistry (as they should be). -- Also, I totally understand and respect Prince's position about not wanting any of his material on YouTube. However, the downside of him having nothing on YouTube (until after his death) is that I believe younger fans had a hard time accessing his music. So prior to his death, he was not reaching a lot of teenagers and 20-something fans. However, other older artists are reaching these fans. For example, 4 years ago, I was working at a summer program with elementary-school age kids and these kids had exposure to Michael Jackson's music because of the Wii game Michael Jackson: The Experience. (I'm sure many of them also had exposure to MJ's music in other ways as well.) Also, the game Guitar Hero has introduced younger people (including myself) to rock music that is "before their time." -- Outside of the Super Bowl and some award show appearances, Prince really did not have a consistent presence in the music world to the GENERAL PUBLIC for the last 15 to 20 years in terms of radio, TV, and YouTube among others. Michael Jackson had Invincible and his 30th anniversary concert in 2001. His videos are on YouTube (although I don't know how many were there before he died.) Madonna had Ray of Light in the late 1990s and Music in 2001 -- both of which were very commercially successful and garnered a lot of airply on radio and TV. She also had the hit song with Justin Timberlake in 2008 or so. Janet Jackson has not had any big radio hits on Top 40 since the All For You album, although she has received some airplay on R&B stations. However, Janet has been in some movies and also had the unfortunate "wardrobe malfunction" at the Super Bowl. She also has been in the public eye because of MJ, especially after his death. -- I also think that what helps some of the other superstar entertainers stay in the public eye, for better or for worse, is the fact that they have children. Having children makes celebrities more newsworthy. -- I could ramble and ramble, but having been in high school and college in the 2000s, and having paid pretty close attention to the pop culture of the 2000s, Prince was a pretty irrelevant superstar for teens and 20 somethings in the 2000s. He had some moments here and there, and we all knew who he was, but very few people my age were talking about Prince's new album/song/video in the 2000s. He just wasn't that relevant. Live 4 Love ~ Love is God, God is love, Girls and boys love God above | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Thank you. It's hard telling people here that he hasn't been relevant in decades. I think the only times my family would talk to me about Prince in the last 20 years were after the Superbowl and the RR Hall of Fame guitar solo. But it made me respect him more. I think that right about the time he did Letterman (Slave on his face) is when the public just lost interest. But it just made me more of a fan.
| |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
"7" in the USA was a huge hit. Prince being transferred by WB as an R&B artist lowered his status at the label giving him less play on pop stations and less promotion. (Starting with this album.) 99.9% of everything I say is strictly for my own entertainment | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Wrong. Since his death, TVBOP sold 560.000 ex in the US, 400.000 more outside the US. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
You americans are really self-focused...SEXY MF was a hit outside the US, reaching #2 in UK, and was one of its biggest hits ever in France. . While 7 was a flop outside the US.... . Besides PURPLE RAIN, Prince's sales were usually low. Even PURPLE RAIN sold only 6 millions outside the US in 30 years...not a great achievement. . So LOVESYMBOL's sales are no big surpise at all. Of course, he deserved better sales. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Radio promotion cost a lot. Prince reportedly paid 2 millions $ to promote TMBGITW. With the inflation, it makes at least 4 millions $. Without a big record company, you can't have a hit on the radio, because you have to pay them. As simple as that. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
That's not correct ROD.
Remember in the FIRST TWO WEEKS ALONE, TVBOP sold almost 300,000 copies, in just TWO WEEKS since his death. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
PURPLE RAIN SOLD 13 MILLION IN THE U.S. ALONE.
IT IS ESTIMATED THAT THE SALES SURPASSED 25 MILLION PLUS, SO HE SOLD AT LEAST 11 MILLION WORLD WIDE, IT'S WAY MORE THAN 6 MILLION. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Madonna, Bruce Springsteen, MJ weren't exactly topping the charts regularly after they reached their peaks either. It wasn't just Prince. That's how this industry works, the entertainment industry in general. You're hot for a while then someone else comes along and takes your place.
I think his biggest problem was oversaturation. Prince never gave the gp a chance to anticipate his next album release and tour. I wish he had taken a breather of a few years after PR to build excitement for his next album. Instead, bam, bam, bam, bam...
| |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
The singles did fine here, iirc Sexy MF and MNIP were both top 5 in the UK. All the singles were very commercial - yes, even with Sexy MF's lyrics, he was obviously going for the same shock value as Gett Off, just turned up to 11. . Continental didn't make it as single though was planned as some point and was commercially viable also, maybe even things like Blue Light, Love 2 The 9s could've also worked as singles. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
There was at least 10 potential hit singles from this album. He could have promoted it for two years. Too complex for the large audience I guess | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Also, the 7 video never seemed to be off the TV. . IIRC And God Created Woman was mentioned in the ad on the Sexy MF home video so that may have also been considered as a single. . The timing was a bit off as usual - releasing the 3 Chains O' Gold video well after the album | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Prince's commercial career (in terms of singles) ended in 1999 with the song 1999.
By 2000 reality was all the rage. You had to be real. People could relate to Jay-Z and Eminem. People couldn't relate to Prince. Nobody saw Prince on TV then went out and bought a couture blue tinfoil suit. But everybody wanted the same baseball cap as their favorite rapper. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
I have only skimmed through this thread, so this probably isn't a new thought...
but I agree while those weren't the greatest singles for "commercial" success, Prince *IN MY OPINION* began to lose commercial appeal after Lovesexy- most people (in the USA) were like WTF? I feel like as moderate Prince fan during that time (I was a teenager) with Lovesexy you were either a Prince fan living (in some degree) in Prince world, or not. Batman kept him in the public eye because the movie was immensely popular, but Graffiti Bridge was much balleyhooed. D&P brought him back with the singles, but I agree the presence of Tony M was a big "no" and precipitated his image from an innovator to an imitator with his godawful rapping.
So the *commerical* singles for Symbol were like the the finals nail in the coffin to me. I don't know very many non-Prince fans who have the album or even listened to it in its entirety when it came out. The promotion and video order at that time Sexy MF and Seven was just oddly timed.
*JUST MY OPINION* | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Sign O' The Times and Parade didn't get a lot of love either. I looked at the Billboard charts and the most popular albums of his that were selling were Purple Rain, 1999, and The Very Best of Prince. I went into the FYE in Center City Philadelphia a couple of times within the 3 weeks after his death. The second time I went, I went to buy Sing O' The Times. The store database said that there were 3 copies in stock and employees and I looked everywhere and it was nowhere to be found. What they did have was HNR 1, HNR 2, lots of Purple Rain the album, lots of Purple Rain the movie, lots of 1999, lots of Prince the album, and a few copies of Around the World in a Day. I don't know who was making the decisions about what Prince material to put on the shelves. I could not believe that the store did not have SOTT because SOTT and PR are considered his masterpeices. Live 4 Love ~ Love is God, God is love, Girls and boys love God above | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
7 was a big hit...it had to be because I remember it from when I was a little girl and my parents listened to mostly NPR at home/in the car. I didn't even realize it was a Prince song until after he died, because it's not one of his hits that is played frequently on R&B radio. But when I heard it on the radio or a radio app I was like, "WOW, I remember this! I had no idea this was Prince!" 7 is a great song! Live 4 Love ~ Love is God, God is love, Girls and boys love God above | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Really sad that one of the greatest albums of all time SOTT, really got little commercial success in USA.
It barely went Platinum in the U.S. wasn't a big seller at all, but critically was very well received. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
And there is nothing wrong with him not having any top 10 singles in the last 20 years. He was putting out music, a lot of really good music, and won 3 Grammys. He was doing what he loved, and he was still very good at it. But he just wasn't as commercially successful as he had been earlier and he wasn't very relevant for the younger generation (teenagers and 20-somethings)--this is an objective statement, not a value judgement. It's not a knock on Prince, it just is what it is. (It also makes sense that he wasn't as commercially successful from the mid 1990s onward because he wasn't a part of a label.) -- Anyone who says that he was commercially successful or widely relevant during the 2000s is wearing purple-colored glasses, because he wasn't. He had a few great moments, the performance with Beyonce at the Grammys and the Super Bowl halftime show being the most salient. These were GREAT moments, but he was nowhere near his popularity in the 1980s--which is OKAY, the world changes. That Super Bowl performance was amazing, and many consider it to be the greatest of all time. So he was still great, just not as popular...but the most popular artists are typically teens through 30-somethings, not 45 or 50 years old. Live 4 Love ~ Love is God, God is love, Girls and boys love God above | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Very interesting, thank you for sharing. Live 4 Love ~ Love is God, God is love, Girls and boys love God above | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Thank you for mentioning Lovesexy - a had a close guy friend who hated Prince when Purple Rain came out. Just because of the way he dressed, the makeup, etc. All the things that made me love him even more than I did. He came to work one morning and I had hung the complete Purple Rain poster in his office behind his desk!!!!
When the cover of Lovesexy hit stores, guys I knew hated it!!! Please, someone, help me understand the hair, the pose, the thought process???!! I still worshipped him but I admit to being puzzled. Yes, he was dressed in lace and it was see through but he was still really masculine. That nude cover pose - it still freaks me out. Mostly, the hair!!! (Still better than the elf era hair!)
| |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
I worked in a music store part time in 88 and we had to hide Lovesexy behind the counter. And I even think there was an alternate cover with just his face closeup Parade and Kiss did decently Had he kept the Revolution at 5 people and toured in summer of 86 Parade would have done even better. After that a few hits from sign and other than D & P it was over in us commercially. DollyDagger said:
Thank you for mentioning Lovesexy - a had a close guy friend who hated Prince when Purple Rain came out. Just because of the way he dressed, the makeup, etc. All the things that made me love him even more than I did. He came to work one morning and I had hung the complete Purple Rain poster in his office behind his desk!!!!
When the cover of Lovesexy hit stores, guys I knew hated it!!! Please, someone, help me understand the hair, the pose, the thought process???!! I still worshipped him but I admit to being puzzled. Yes, he was dressed in lace and it was see through but he was still really masculine. That nude cover pose - it still freaks me out. Mostly, the hair!!! (Still better than the elf era hair!)
| |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
You're all confusing two separate issues: how well individual albums/singles did in terms of sales/airplay, and the fact that once he left WBR and challenged how the music industry operates, he was blackballed. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
It was a spiritual rebirth picture. The nudity was like when your born nude. It wasn't sexual nudity. The flower in the back ground was the sexual gesture. As in Prince's music the sacred and the sin is represented on the cover. 99.9% of everything I say is strictly for my own entertainment | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
beautifulone7 said: I have only skimmed through this thread, so this probably isn't a new thought...
but I agree while those weren't the greatest singles for "commercial" success, Prince *IN MY OPINION* began to lose commercial appeal after Lovesexy- most people (in the USA) were like WTF? I feel like as moderate Prince fan during that time (I was a teenager) with Lovesexy you were either a Prince fan living (in some degree) in Prince world, or not. Batman kept him in the public eye because the movie was immensely popular, but Graffiti Bridge was much balleyhooed. D&P brought him back with the singles, but I agree the presence of Tony M was a big "no" and precipitated his image from an innovator to an imitator with his godawful rapping.
So the *commerical* singles for Symbol were like the the finals nail in the coffin to me. I don't know very many non-Prince fans who have the album or even listened to it in its entirety when it came out. The promotion and video order at that time Sexy MF and Seven was just oddly timed.
*JUST MY OPINION* Bang on, some of the newer/younger fans don't understand that he wasn't always respected like he was in more recent years, if you wasn't a fan then you just didnt get him. He just turned off a lot of average people, just by the way he looked or behaved. He could be a bit of a shit sometimes, and he come across as up his own arse. A lot of people just never gave him a chance, until he matured later and realised if he was a bit more human, people may actually like him, thats what sells records to joe public | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Self focused. Most ok artists don't feel they have made it to the us charts... Sexy MF was possibly his worst single ever. Censored or not. After SOTT it was over commercially except for a few singles and d& p
feeluupp said:
PURPLE RAIN SOLD 13 MILLION IN THE U.S. ALONE.
IT IS ESTIMATED THAT THE SALES SURPASSED 25 MILLION PLUS, SO HE SOLD AT LEAST 11 MILLION WORLD WIDE, IT'S WAY MORE THAN 6 MILLION. [Edited 7/24/16 9:57am] | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
LOL Hartford Civic Center 1988 Lovesexy tour , stood near and watched Dr Fink at Al Franklin's Music World ask the owner why the album wasn't on display since they were playing there that night - too young and afraid to say hello
| |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
is such a great album..... Prince 4Ever. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
The Symbol Album didn't kill his career. If you're looking for an album as the reason that killed his career, it should've been 'Come'. But that's just my taste. No, there weren't any albums that killed his career. His name change was suggested. No, not even that did it. There was actually nothing that killed his career. In the eighties and early nineties, Prince was larger than life. It's just impossible for any artist to keep that up for decades. When his albums sold less in a commercial way, people still were following his every move and the stadiums still were sold out where ever he was going. Prince couldn't do no wrong: a movie like Graffitti Bridge? Leaving a packed stadium with 50,000 people behind after 45 minutes because it was raining? Prince touring almost every year, releasing an album (or more) almost every year? With other artists it would have been considered overkill. No. No matter what he did, people loved it. And if you look only at album sales or even Grammy Awards as the standard for a good career, than I definitely don't agree. It's the quality of the music which is the measure. I mean, take a look at artists like Justin Bieber. That should tell us enough. 'Liberate My Mind' | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
The 2nd half of The Continental was bliss. "How Ya Wanna Be Done?" I also think The Morning Papers and God Created Woman and Damn You were all good. Did U ever feel that life was like lookin' 4 a penny in a large room with no light? | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
RodeoSchro said: You mean the guy who went on to play the Super Bowl; who had the most successful tour of 2004 despite charging half of what everyone else was charging; the guy who had a #1 debut album with "3121"; the guy who redefined what a live show is? Exactly. People kill me with this nonsense of Prince just completely falling off the Clift after 1992. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |