independent and unofficial
Prince fan community
Welcome! Sign up or enter username and password to remember me
Forum jump
Forums > Prince: Music and More > The Greatest ALBUM... DREAM FACTORY.
« Previous topic  Next topic »
Page 1 of 2 12>
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
Author

Tweet     Share

Message
Thread started 01/09/16 3:59pm

feeluupp

The Greatest ALBUM... DREAM FACTORY.

If DREAM FACTORY was officially released as an album, do you think it would've been the all time greatest configuration of an album released by PRINCE?

ORIGINAL CONFIGURATION (from PrinceVault: http://www.princevault.co...m_Factory:)

  • Side 1:
  1. Visions 1
  2. Dream Factory (preceded by Nevaeh Ni Ecalp A, not listed as such)
  3. Train (different version than released)
  4. The Ballad Of Dorothy Parker
  5. It
  • Side 2:
  1. Strange Relationship (different version than released)
  2. Slow Love 2
  3. Starfish And Coffee 3 (omits the alarm clock intro)
  4. Interlude – Wendy 4
  5. I Could Never Take The Place Of Your Man (different version than released)
  • Side 3:
  1. Sign O' The Times (version released as edit on the single Sign O' The Times)
  2. Crystal Ball
  3. A Place In Heaven (Lisa Coleman lead vox)
  • Side 4:
  1. Last Heart
  2. Witness 4 The Prosecution
  3. Movie Star
  4. The Cross
  5. All My Dreams

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #1 posted 01/09/16 4:05pm

alexanderalm

mabye biggrin

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #2 posted 01/09/16 5:25pm

paulludvig

No. Crystal Ball is even better..

The wooh is on the one!
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #3 posted 01/09/16 6:03pm

OldFriends4Sal
e

I woiuld need In A Large Room With No Light & Power Fantastic
But yes. I think that era would have been great

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #4 posted 01/09/16 6:49pm

warning2all

June 3 1986 version is for my money the best Prince album ever. Or, tied w/ "Parade".

Would.love to see the real DF album cover.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #5 posted 01/09/16 7:58pm

controversy99

avatar

The obvious point of comparison is Sign of the Times. If you currently think Purple Rain, 1999, or Lovesexy is his best album (the other main candidates), then it's unlikely that changing Sign into Dream Factory will persuade you to change your opinion.

So my first question is which better, Sign or Dream? And is the difference so great that it'll change order with one of the other great albums.

Gone:
Play in the Sunshine
Housequake
Hot Thing
Forever in My Life
U Got the Look
If I Was Your Girlfriend
It's Gonna Be a Beautiful Night
Adore
(part of Sign of the Times)

Added:
Visions
Dream Factory
Train
(Interlude - Wendy)
A Place in Heaven
Crystal Ball
Last Heart
Witness 4 the Prosecution
Movie Star
All My Dreams

Comparisons (imo of course)

The Best Songs
Adore vs. Crystal Ball - Adore wins. Can you imagine Prince's career without Adore released in 1987? What a loss that would be. Adore is the best slow jam from one of the greatest slow jammers ever.

If I Was Your Girlfriend vs. All My Dreams - toss up

Housequake vs. Dream Factory - toss up

Middle of the pack songs
This is basically a toss up. It'd be a little sad to lose Hog Thing but nice to have Train officially released, and so on. There's really not a big impact.

Least Good Songs
It's Gonna Be a Beautiful Night vs. A Place in Heaven - Beautiful Night wins. Prince's only live song released in the 80s vs. a weak ballad. Not even close.

Movie Star vs. U Got the Look - U Got the Look wins. Movie Star is funny, but it's a bit of novelty song when released by Prince. It would be more appropriate for The Time, although the performance probably wouldn't have been better. U Got the Look is a pretty decent single, lyrics are clever, and I like the interplay between their voices.

So for me, the answer is "no", it wouldn't be his greatest album. I currently consider 1999 his greatest. Changing Sign into DF doesn't change that at all.
[Edited 1/9/16 20:06pm]
"Love & honesty, peace & harmony"
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #6 posted 01/09/16 8:20pm

PurpleMedley12
2

feeluupp said:

If DREAM FACTORY was officially released as an album, do you think it would've been the all time greatest configuration of an album released by PRINCE?



ORIGINAL CONFIGURATION:(from PrinceVault: http://www.princevault.co...m_Factory:)




  • Side 1:

  1. Visions 1

  2. Dream Factory (preceded by Nevaeh Ni Ecalp A, not listed as such)

  3. Train (different version than released)

  4. The Ballad Of Dorothy Parker

  5. It

  • Side 2:

  1. Strange Relationship (different version than released)

  2. Slow Love 2

  3. Starfish And Coffee 3 (omits the alarm clock intro)

  4. Interlude – Wendy 4

  5. I Could Never Take The Place Of Your Man (different version than released)

  • Side 3:

  1. Sign O' The Times (version released as edit on the single Sign O' The Times)

  2. Crystal Ball

  3. A Place In Heaven (Lisa Coleman lead vox)

  • Side 4:

  1. Last Heart

  2. Witness 4 The Prosecution

  3. Movie Star

  4. The Cross

  5. All My Dreams


I prefer the June 3rd configuration with less Sign O the Times tracks...
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #7 posted 01/09/16 8:21pm

ufoclub

avatar

controversy99 said:

Housequake vs. Dream Factory - toss up

WAHHHHHAAAATT?

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #8 posted 01/10/16 11:39am

controversy99

avatar

ufoclub said:



controversy99 said:


Housequake vs. Dream Factory - toss up



WAHHHHHAAAATT?


Which do you think is better?
"Love & honesty, peace & harmony"
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #9 posted 01/10/16 3:13pm

ufoclub

avatar

controversy99 said:

ufoclub said:

WAHHHHHAAAATT?

Which do you think is better?

Housequake for miles and miles. Dream Factory was cool idea, but I think the arrangement and flow of it don't do much for my ears. I'd love to see how he would remake it.

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #10 posted 01/11/16 5:00pm

214

Dream Factory is better than Housequake i love the lyrics. In A Large Room With No Lights should be in the Dream Factory project.

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #11 posted 01/11/16 6:44pm

OldFriends4Sal
e

warning2all said:

June 3 1986 version is for my money the best Prince album ever. Or, tied w/ "Parade". Would.love to see the real DF album cover.

I heard Susannah has the original artwork

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #12 posted 01/11/16 6:46pm

OldFriends4Sal
e

controversy99 said:
Gone:
Play in the Sunshine
Housequake
Hot Thing
Forever in My Life
U Got the Look
If I Was Your Girlfriend
It's Gonna Be a Beautiful Night
Adore
(part of Sign of the Times)

Added:
Visions
Dream Factory
Train
Sexual Suicide

Power Fantastic intro
Power Fantastic
(Interlude - Wendy)
A Place in Heaven

In A Large Room With No Light
Crystal Ball
Last Heart
Witness 4 the Prosecution
Old Friends 4 Sale
Movie Star
All My Dreams

Comparisons (imo of course)

The Best Songs
Adore vs. Crystal Ball - Adore wins. Can you imagine Prince's career without Adore released in 1987? What a loss that would be. Adore is the best slow jam from one of the greatest slow jammers ever.

If I Was Your Girlfriend vs. All My Dreams - toss up

Housequake vs. Dream Factory - toss up

Middle of the pack songs
This is basically a toss up. It'd be a little sad to lose Hog Thing but nice to have Train officially released, and so on. There's really not a big impact.

Least Good Songs
It's Gonna Be a Beautiful Night vs. A Place in Heaven - Beautiful Night wins. Prince's only live song released in the 80s vs. a weak ballad. Not even close.

Movie Star vs. U Got the Look - U Got the Look wins. Movie Star is funny, but it's a bit of novelty song when released by Prince. It would be more appropriate for The Time, although the performance probably wouldn't have been better. U Got the Look is a pretty decent single, lyrics are clever, and I like the interplay between their voices.

So for me, the answer is "no", it wouldn't be his greatest album. I currently consider 1999 his greatest. Changing Sign into DF doesn't change that at all.



1.) Adore and Crystal Ball are two very different types of songs/themes etc I need to be in a certain mood to listen to either. I love both of them. But One is about 'love/romance' the other is about Social Spiritual Sexual Soul issues

2.) Housequake and Dream Factory. Housequake is a fun pumped song. High energy, the message is limited. Dream Factory takes us into a different scene. Paints a picture, city nights, parties, dates, Pop Life, friends, business etc Dream Factory wins for me on this one

3.) Train and Hot Thing. Again like 2, Hot Thing fun pumped song. Energy. But it sorta stays in the same place, musically and message. In the long run Train, takes me someplace, paints a scene, very much connected to Dream Factory, after all the fun, friends leaving the Dream Factory or Uptown or Erotic City and heading out into new adventures.

4.) I agree about IGBABN and A Place in Heaven. But I would like Nevaeh ni ecalp A on the album
IGTBABN and A Place in Heaven could easily be place on a B side But better yet IGTBABN should be released somehow with the Flesh

5.) Movie Star and U Got the Look. I would prefer U Got the Look. I love both though. Movie Star could have been a nice B side too.

Add Power Fantastic (intro/Song) Sexual Suicide Old Friends 4 Sale and In A Large Room With No Light and I'm in 100% with Dream Factory

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #13 posted 01/12/16 6:42am

jasontate

avatar

ufoclub said:

controversy99 said:

ufoclub said: Which do you think is better?

Housequake for miles and miles. Dream Factory was cool idea, but I think the arrangement and flow of it don't do much for my ears. I'd love to see how he would remake it.

That's amused me. I thought you were saying no comparison, because Dream Factory was way better than HQ. Different strokes. Still love HQ too though. cool

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #14 posted 01/12/16 6:53am

paulludvig

controversy99 said:

The obvious point of comparison is Sign of the Times.

I think the obvious point of comparison is Crystal Ball. And CB is superior to DF.

  • Side 1:
  1. Rebirth Of The Flesh
  2. Play In The Sunshine
  3. Housequake
  4. The Ballad Of Dorothy Parker
  • Side 2:
  1. It
  2. Starfish And Coffee 1
  3. Slow Love 2
  4. Hot Thing
  • Side 3:
  1. Crystal Ball
  2. If I Was Your Girlfriend
  3. Rockhard In A Funky Place 3
  • Side 4:
  1. The Ball
  2. Joy In Repetition
  3. Strange Relationship
  4. I Could Never Take The Place Of Your Man
  • Side 5:
  1. Shockadelica
  2. Good Love
  3. Forever In My Life
  4. Sign O' The Times
  • Side 6:
  1. The Cross
  2. It's Gonna Be A Beautiful Night 4
  3. Adore (Until The End Of Time)

[Edited 1/12/16 6:56am]

The wooh is on the one!
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #15 posted 01/12/16 12:30pm

214

jasontate said:

ufoclub said:

Housequake for miles and miles. Dream Factory was cool idea, but I think the arrangement and flow of it don't do much for my ears. I'd love to see how he would remake it.

That's amused me. I thought you were saying no comparison, because Dream Factory was way better than HQ. Different strokes. Still love HQ too though. cool

I feel the same.

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #16 posted 01/12/16 4:55pm

controversy99

avatar

paulludvig said:



controversy99 said:



The obvious point of comparison is Sign of the Times.



I think the obvious point of comparison is Crystal Ball. And CB is superior to DF.



  • Side 1:

  1. Rebirth Of The Flesh

  2. Play In The Sunshine

  3. Housequake

  4. The Ballad Of Dorothy Parker

  • Side 2:

  1. It

  2. Starfish And Coffee 1

  3. Slow Love 2

  4. Hot Thing

  • Side 3:

  1. Crystal Ball

  2. If I Was Your Girlfriend

  3. Rockhard In A Funky Place 3

  • Side 4:

  1. The Ball

  2. Joy In Repetition

  3. Strange Relationship

  4. I Could Never Take The Place Of Your Man

  • Side 5:

  1. Shockadelica

  2. Good Love

  3. Forever In My Life

  4. Sign O' The Times

  • Side 6:

  1. The Cross

  2. It's Gonna Be A Beautiful Night 4

  3. Adore (Until The End Of Time)

[Edited 1/12/16 6:56am]


This tracklist is RIDICULOUSLY GOOD, AMAZING. I refer to SotT since it was actually released. Take that Crystal Ball tracklist, rename it Sign of the Times to give it hat bit some weight, and you have perhaps the greatest album of all time by anyone.
"Love & honesty, peace & harmony"
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #17 posted 01/12/16 5:18pm

214

controversy99 said:

paulludvig said:

I think the obvious point of comparison is Crystal Ball. And CB is superior to DF.

  • Side 1:
  1. Rebirth Of The Flesh
  2. Play In The Sunshine
  3. Housequake
  4. The Ballad Of Dorothy Parker
  • Side 2:
  1. It
  2. Starfish And Coffee 1
  3. Slow Love 2
  4. Hot Thing
  • Side 3:
  1. Crystal Ball
  2. If I Was Your Girlfriend
  3. Rockhard In A Funky Place 3
  • Side 4:
  1. The Ball
  2. Joy In Repetition
  3. Strange Relationship
  4. I Could Never Take The Place Of Your Man
  • Side 5:
  1. Shockadelica
  2. Good Love
  3. Forever In My Life
  4. Sign O' The Times
  • Side 6:
  1. The Cross
  2. It's Gonna Be A Beautiful Night 4
  3. Adore (Until The End Of Time)

[Edited 1/12/16 6:56am]

This tracklist is RIDICULOUSLY GOOD, AMAZING. I refer to SotT since it was actually released. Take that Crystal Ball tracklist, rename it Sign of the Times to give it hat bit some weight, and you have perhaps the greatest album of all time by anyone.

Add IALRWNL , Power Fantastic and let me think

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #18 posted 01/12/16 6:32pm

OldFriends4Sal
e

just reading all the posts, the conclusion is some seriously wonderful music cam out of 1986

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #19 posted 01/13/16 9:03am

databank

avatar

feeluupp said:

If DREAM FACTORY was officially released as an album, do you think it would've been the all time greatest configuration of an album released by PRINCE?

No.

One thing we need to remember is that according to our sources, the configuration you mention (the last known config, not the original one) was apparently not considered definitive yet by Prince. He was probably planning to toy with it again after the Parade tour. So we can't say for sure what the final cut of DF would have been but my take is it would have been closer to SOTT than we'd like to think.

I have a pretty good reconstruction of that last config (I'm sure you have the same) and I think it's vastly inferior to SOTT or Crystal Ball 86, because it's much more unfocused and less cohesive.

Do I love every track on it? Yes.

Do I think it works better as an ensemble? No.

I have to admit I'm biaised because I knew SOTT by heart when I first heard DF, but the same could be said about CB and I find CB even better than SOTT, so IDK if it's why I favor SOTT over that version of DF.

I also have to admit I've often read people here say they favor that version of DF over SOTT, so maybe it works better than I think, but I wonder if the holy status of DF as an unreleased "...And The Revolution" album doesn't play in its favor.

It would be great, however, if one day Prince would release digital versions of every config of DF, as well as CB and Camille, just to allow fans to study the road from the first config of DF to SOTT, it would make a fascinating documentation of the birth and growth of what ended up being his most critically acclaimed album ever.

Now, how would DF have been received if it had been released as such in early 1987? I couldn't tell, no one could, but I think there was a certain sobriety and maturity in SOTT that played in its favor with critics, and the more dreamy/poppish tonality of DF may have led some critics to see it as too much a continuation of Parade instead of something truly new. SOTT was for many critics the album that made Prince a truly adult songwriter, without the adolescent vibe of many of his earlier recordings. Maybe if we got the original tape in pristine sound, like we now have for CB, instead of a fanmade reconstruction with unequal sound quality, it'd be easier to make a fair comparison. Hopefully such a tape exists and will leak someday.

A COMPREHENSIVE PRINCE DISCOGRAPHY (work in progress ^^): https://sites.google.com/...scography/
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #20 posted 01/13/16 9:28am

sexton

avatar

OldFriends4Sale said:

Add Power Fantastic (intro/Song) Sexual Suicide Old Friends 4 Sale and In A Large Room With No Light and I'm in 100% with Dream Factory


Add "Power Fantastic" (with intro) and "In A Large Room With No Light" and I'll like it more than Sign "O" The Times or Crystal Ball.

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #21 posted 01/13/16 12:20pm

214

Old Friends 4 Sale, how did i forget about it?

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #22 posted 01/13/16 1:40pm

TrevorAyer

Well if prince ever unleashes a 6cd set of sott, THAT could easily be the best record of all time ... So many great outtakes from this period
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #23 posted 01/13/16 4:36pm

OldFriends4Sal
e

databank said:

feeluupp said:

If DREAM FACTORY was officially released as an album, do you think it would've been the all time greatest configuration of an album released by PRINCE?

No.

One thing we need to remember is that according to our sources, the configuration you mention (the last known config, not the original one) was apparently not considered definitive yet by Prince. He was probably planning to toy with it again after the Parade tour. So we can't say for sure what the final cut of DF would have been but my take is it would have been closer to SOTT than we'd like to think.

I have a pretty good reconstruction of that last config (I'm sure you have the same) and I think it's vastly inferior to SOTT or Crystal Ball 86, because it's much more unfocused and less cohesive.

Do I love every track on it? Yes.

Do I think it works better as an ensemble? No.

I have to admit I'm biaised because I knew SOTT by heart when I first heard DF, but the same could be said about CB and I find CB even better than SOTT, so IDK if it's why I favor SOTT over that version of DF.

I also have to admit I've often read people here say they favor that version of DF over SOTT, so maybe it works better than I think, but I wonder if the holy status of DF as an unreleased "...And The Revolution" album doesn't play in its favor.

It would be great, however, if one day Prince would release digital versions of every config of DF, as well as CB and Camille, just to allow fans to study the road from the first config of DF to SOTT, it would make a fascinating documentation of the birth and growth of what ended up being his most critically acclaimed album ever.

Now, how would DF have been received if it had been released as such in early 1987? I couldn't tell, no one could, but I think there was a certain sobriety and maturity in SOTT that played in its favor with critics, and the more dreamy/poppish tonality of DF may have led some critics to see it as too much a continuation of Parade instead of something truly new. SOTT was for many critics the album that made Prince a truly adult songwriter, without the adolescent vibe of many of his earlier recordings. Maybe if we got the original tape in pristine sound, like we now have for CB, instead of a fanmade reconstruction with unequal sound quality, it'd be easier to make a fair comparison. Hopefully such a tape exists and will leak someday.

SOTT for always had 2 different vibes. One had a mature ground to it, the other was more 'pop-ish'

I think Dream Factory overall had the Maturing ground. The lyrics on all the songs are very mature and meaty. SOTT when I think of the 'serioiusness' of the opening title cut didn't follow through throught the whole album. But that goes back to it seems mixed with 2 different concepts (Dream Factory & Camille) plus 2 stand off songs:IG2BABN and Slow Love

One of the big issues with the SOTT era is Prince did not tour it in the states. Which was a bad move. The other issue with the Dream Factory/SOTT change is that we last the UPTOWN scene. from 1982-1986 we had UPTOWN EROTIC CITY PAISLEY PARK ie Prince & the 'Revolution' the Time Vanity 6/Apollonia 6 Sheila E 'the Family' Mazarati. All that went away in 1987... Madhouse could not sustain itself, and Jill Jones was totally absent from what Prince was doing... and Prince was going through a major emotional/social/musical change...

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #24 posted 01/13/16 4:37pm

OldFriends4Sal
e

TrevorAyer said:

Well if prince ever unleashes a 6cd set of sott, THAT could easily be the best record of all time ... So many great outtakes from this period

Dream Factory or Sound Factory would be a perfect compilation title.


Then release all the great outtakes from 1985

WOW

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #25 posted 01/14/16 6:33am

paulludvig

Now, how would DF have been received if it had been released as such in early 1987? I couldn't tell, no one could, but I think there was a certain sobriety and maturity in SOTT that played in its favor with critics, and the more dreamy/poppish tonality of DF may have led some critics to see it as too much a continuation of Parade instead of something truly new. SOTT was for many critics the album that made Prince a truly adult songwriter, without the adolescent vibe of many of his earlier recordings. Maybe if we got the original tape in pristine sound, like we now have for CB, instead of a fanmade reconstruction with unequal sound quality, it'd be easier to make a fair comparison. Hopefully such a tape exists and will leak someday.

[/quote]

I think it's even likely that DF would have been received as a throwback to ATWIAD. 'Here Prince goes again with another psychedelic, Beatles inspirert album'. Prince kept the most forward looking tracks for CB/SOTT, leaving behind the hippie vibe that had informed his two previous albums.
The wooh is on the one!
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #26 posted 01/14/16 6:36am

OldFriends4Sal
e

paulludvig said:

Now, how would DF have been received if it had been released as such in early 1987? I couldn't tell, no one could, but I think there was a certain sobriety and maturity in SOTT that played in its favor with critics, and the more dreamy/poppish tonality of DF may have led some critics to see it as too much a continuation of Parade instead of something truly new. SOTT was for many critics the album that made Prince a truly adult songwriter, without the adolescent vibe of many of his earlier recordings. Maybe if we got the original tape in pristine sound, like we now have for CB, instead of a fanmade reconstruction with unequal sound quality, it'd be easier to make a fair comparison. Hopefully such a tape exists and will leak someday.

I think it's even likely that DF would have been received as a throwback to ATWIAD. 'Here Prince goes again with another psychedelic, Beatles inspirert album'. Prince kept the most forward looking tracks for CB/SOTT, leaving behind the hippie vibe that had informed his two previous albums.

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #27 posted 01/14/16 11:01am

Cinny

avatar

This would be one of the greatest REISSUES (cough) if he ever does them (ahem).

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #28 posted 01/14/16 11:24am

2freaky4church
1

avatar

Hell fucking no. The best thing Warners did was to wittle that shit down. Sign would not have gotten the classic reviews. It would have been seen as self indulgent.

Thank Warners.

All you others say Hell Yea!! woot!
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #29 posted 01/22/16 5:45pm

OldFriends4Sal
e

Madhouse 2 opening with the Revolution talking... sounds like an extended part from nevaeh ni ecalP or the Dream Factory opening

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Page 1 of 2 12>
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
« Previous topic  Next topic »
Forums > Prince: Music and More > The Greatest ALBUM... DREAM FACTORY.