LOVED the Lovesexy Band, Loved the SOTT set up best though | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
I'm with some of the other "old timers" when I say that I barely really "noticed"...
...I became a true Prince fan AFTER Lovesexy. Once I attended the concert, I got hooked.
I ordered SOTT (on vinyl) through Columbia Music Club.
By St. Boogar and all the saints at the backside door of Purgatory! | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
I thought he was famous for quite the opposite: giving credit to others (proteges) for music entirely written and recorded by Prince alone? The wooh is on the one! | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Trevor is bad faith made flesh when it comes to this: we all know what credit Prince gave and what credit he stole. The first list is dozens of songs, probably more than a hundred, the second list is about a dozen songs at most: I could probably list these from memory I certainly wouldn't go as far as to say that the people around Prince from 78 to 86 were talentless: some released wonderful solo albums afterwards, and even the others managed to record some really decent music even if it wasn't groundbreaking. It would be unfair to deny these people's individual talents. Now I DO agree that their talent had very little to do with Prince's success and genius or even the protégé's albums' success. Prince always was the one who had the vision, the concepts, and when all is said and done, he was the one who made the music. All of this has been documented SO MUCH, we more or less know PRECISELY who did what on what and when, so whoever is saying the opposite either doesn't know what he's talking about or is just talking bad faith. Of course the protégés are always trying to make a point: The Time, fDeluxe, even Sheila: they're always trying to say "we exixt, we were important": how could they not, their own career started like that, being intrumentals. But the Revolution members, whose solo careers started afterwards and who therefore don't have so much to prove, have always been the first ones to say in interviews: "this was all Prince, we were only instrumental in his vision and he made all the creative decisions". But Trevor and the others here know better than Dr. Fink, that's for sure These people contributed and influenced, undeniably, but in the end they weren't very important in what defines Prince's genius, and of course whoever goes and claim that Prince recorded nothing but shit after 1987 has once again to be a champion of bad faith Nothing personnal, Trevor, + you ain't the only one to say that u've just been the last one ro say it in this thread A COMPREHENSIVE PRINCE DISCOGRAPHY (work in progress ^^): https://sites.google.com/...scography/ | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Byron said: Can't say I remember giving a shit, to be honest. When they disbanded the album Sign O' The Times was coming out and I LOVED that album...played it to death. The Revolution didn't play too large a part in that album so them disbanding didn't really effect me. Plus, the video for "U Got The Look" introduced his new band--with Sheila E. looking fiiiine lol --and Dr. Fink was still there...it was a cool transition. Prince is a solo act to me, anyway. Release Yourself | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Didn't care at the time - although I jumped ship around the time of Parade - insane, I know as it's my favorite album now. Didn't come back until D&P, which is oddly not one of my favorites.
So there was definitely some disappointment in the loss of what I considered the "classic" Prince sound - though in my "second life" fandom, I dug more into the earlier albums, and realized how different his starting point was.
| |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Why are you so bent out of shape over other people's opinions? | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Look at the bolded in my comment--the band was a part of the process. But they often are whether or not there's a credit (or would have been a credit, in the case of Dream Factory). The Dream Factory album would have been more of a Revolution album (with or without the credit)--but certainly Sign o the Times was affected by, influenced by, the Revolution (or at least some members of the Revolution). But he did change the project when they left, and did minimize their representation on the album (except for including the live track--which I consider one of the Revolution's low points, honestly). He probably would not have done much of what he did on Sign o the Times without the Revolution's being around--but they had been his band (and thus who would be playing his music in any live situation--thus who he's writing for) for all of his professional career (obviously core people left and were replaced, but they did it over time, allowing the "band" to have continuity). He had grown and changed organically as the band did. It's impossible to remove them from the process.
I don't think I disagree with you on that--perhaps I felt the question of what the credit would have been on the Dream Factory album was being overemphasized, or something. I don't know. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
A little from column A, a little from column B... There are plenty of examples of both.
Don't hate your neighbors. Hate the media that tells you to hate your neighbors. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
there is always some like that, who jumps in in the middle of a discussion thinking they know the opinions and viewpoints of people focusing their attitude in one post toward everyone. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Totally agree. It's always bittersweet when one chapter ends, but the new chapter can be even more exciting. However, after SOTT, the music quality declined IMO. Sad. "Are you my Caucasian?" - L.D. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Yes, but not an equal number. Far from it! As databank pointed out maybe a dozen of credits stolen and several dozens of credits given. The wooh is on the one! | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
As someone posted above, all was forgiven/forgotten when SOTT came out. It was outstanding. Only later did I find out that a lot of it was actually Revolution material. . I do remember being excited about the solo Wendy & Lisa album too though, so the split seemed to benefit everyone IN THE SHORT RUN. . Keeping Dr. Fink and including Sheila E. really helped with the transition. If you ask me, Sheila was more his muse/counterpart than Wendy & Lisa ever were.
| |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Stolen credits I can think of: - My Love Is Forever, lyrics by Chris Moon (Moon retaliated by taking P's songwriting credits off Make It Through The Storm). - Baby, strings played by Charles Veal and keyboards played by Patrice Rushen. - Partyup, songwriting by Morris Day (Morris agreed and got the job with The Time in return). - Do Me, Baby, songwriting by André Cymone. - The Bell Of St. Mark, linn drum programming by Jesse Johnson (but the song was not credited to Prince but to Sheila E.). - The Bird and Jungle Love, songwriting by Jesse Johnson (but the song wasn't credited to Prince but to Morris day and Jamie Starr, and Jesse later retaliated by taking P's arrangements credits off Do Yourself A Favor). - Kiss, lyrics by David Z and intruments by Mazarati (but the song's writing and instruments credits were credited to Prince And The revolution, not just Prince) - Power Fantastic, songwriting by Wendy & Lisa. - Well Done, songwriting by David Z and Levi Seacer Jr. - Soul Santuary and Eye'll Never Be Another Fool,songwriting by T. Hammer and Vince Reid (that's most likely because Prince didn't know they'd cowritten the songs Sandra St. Victor had sent him, since he accurately credited her). - Van Gogh, songwriting by Sandra St. Victor (the joke here is that to this day Prince hasn't ever registered the song at ASCAP, so he probably just forgot to inform the band Van Gogh that she was cowriter at the same time he forgot to copyright it ).
I'm sure there must be one or two others that I can't think of right now, plus if u REALLY wanna be picky there are probably a few other background vocals or instruments forgotten in the credits here and there, or uncredited when there was no credits at all such as with The Black Album, but basically we now have... tadada... THIRTEEN songs.
Now if someone wanna try and make a list of all the songs where Prince credited his songwriting, arrangements and/or performances under someone else's name, or a pseudonym, or his whole band, be my guest [Edited 10/29/13 10:04am] A COMPREHENSIVE PRINCE DISCOGRAPHY (work in progress ^^): https://sites.google.com/...scography/ | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
I don't think Sheila had the song writing composing chemistry Prince had with Lisa Coleman & then Wendy Melvoin. From Eric Leeds Dr Fink Alan Leeds and others they all have said it was Prince Lisa Coleman & Wendy. Sheila E benefitted from that.
. Sheila was never known for that. We(I) liked Sheila E as a frontman, I love her upfront with Prince, that's the 'counterpart' because she was basically his protege like Morris Day. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
I'm with you on that. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
oops [Edited 10/29/13 21:56pm] "Music gives a soul to the universe, wings to the mind, flight to the imagination and life to everything." --Plato
https://youtu.be/CVwv9LZMah0 | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
I remember not liking the fact that Wendy & Lisa no longer were part of the band. I was happy though to find out that Eric Leeds still was there.
The real drama for me came, when I first heard of the new band name a few years later on ....
NPG ... "new power generation" WTF ...
Totally uncool band name and generally spoken a rather infantile, poor choice.
And albeit containing the word "power" it had the opposite effect on me.
Go figure
from
The Revolution ...
to
NPG ...
To be honest I think that band name, might have been one of the the turning points in me being a Prince fan back then.
| |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
I'm of the mindset that after the Revolution, he should've just remained "Prince". Bring in new bandmembers and such, but don't change the name. "Prince" is almost a household name . . . nobody gives a damn about the NPG or who's currently in it. . On a side note: I've read/heard that Prince announced the disbanding news to the Revolution in the same California house that the Menendez brothers later murdered their parents. The band was renting the house. Anyone else remember this? | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Yea, Lisa and Wendy recalled that story during a live chat promoting their last record. It was kind of a funny story the way they told it. "That's when stars collide. When there's space for what u want, and ur heart is open wide." | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Well it makes sense when u think of it. Prince was like a father to the Revolution and he betrayed them, condemning them to the limbo of those people who've been close to being major stars but didn't make it in the end, which is worse than hell (any priest will confirm). So by doing so Prince sort of put a curse on that house, I mean it was so bad, so terrible that the house was left haunted by that terrible event and when the Menendez motherfuckers moved in that place the 2 sons were litterally possessed by the house, haunted by the curse, and eventually they went mad and murdered their folks because in their confused minds parental figures had become synonymous to evil and betrayal, all because of Prince. I'm quite surprised that this angle wasn't studied at the trial, proving that the poor kids were not responsible for their actions in the end. A COMPREHENSIVE PRINCE DISCOGRAPHY (work in progress ^^): https://sites.google.com/...scography/ | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
wow, never heard of that one
I always wondered if Prince named the Family after cult called the Family | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
lol we talked on the side ...
BrownMark was also involved in the creation of Kiss Also the many songs that Jill Jones contributed too aren't see easily recognized I still remember the story of Prince sneaking Jill in on Glamorous Life, and then passing Sheila E who went to work on the same song. But neither knew at the time...
| |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
What were the early days like? How would you compare those experiences to your times “officially” with the Revolution?
When the whole “Revolution era” started up, it opened up a lot of possibilities for Prince’s sound. How did the writing process work with him? For example, how did you got about writing a song like “Computer Blue”? | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Prince's subsequent musicians were always talented. But arguably, they're not of the level he once had. If they don't bring any ideas, they don't challange him, they don't stimulate him. The Revolution were constantly bringing songs to his attention. They would leave rehearsal and go listen to a Duke Ellington record or a country western record. He was all ears. The more money he's had, the more he's been able to isolate himself from the real world. He handpicks his input.
-Alan Leeds SPIN Mag July 2009 pg 61 Alan, how would you equate the Revolution to the New Power Generation later on? Are they even comparable? LEEDS: For my personal taste, the most exciting Prince bands were the expanded Revolution on the European Parade tour and the band with Sheila E. on drums for the Sign ‘O’ the Times tour. Sonny Thompson and Michael Bland may have, in some ways, been Prince’s best ever rhythm section simply because they play so extremely well together. But I never felt the music recorded during the NPG era was as interesting as the 1980’s albums. Unfortunately, the format of Prince’s heavily produced tours, and even his increasingly predictable after-shows, didn’t consistently afford the band members much opportunity to display all their abilities. It was, after all, Prince’s show. But I never felt he got everything he could have out of players with such diverse vocabularies as Sheila and Eric. LEEDS: Coming from the world of James Brown where spontaneity in the studio was paramount to his genius accomplishments, I personally prefer music that embraces the rapport between an artist and his or her collaborators and accompanists. Like jazz, most R&B music had traditionally depended on this kind of musical interaction. Stevie Wonder, and then Prince became the notable exceptions. Of course without the advancements in studio technology and the development of synthesized musical instruments, none of this would have been feasible. Like Stevie, Prince uniquely combines the skill sets of writer, producer, singer and multi-instrumentalist. Unlike Stevie, Prince is actually more than good at every instrument he plays. So his recording needs simply never depended on other musicians. That he chose to record with various members of his bands said more about the flavors and individual voices that Wendy Melvoin, Lisa Coleman, Eric Leeds and Sheila E. brought to the table. The caliber of musicianship in his band grew during the Purple Rain period and I think it was simply a case of Prince recognizing the elements that these musicians could contribute to his palette. LEEDS: Wendy and Lisa particularly brought Prince a musical camaraderie he was unaccustomed to. During the course of the Purple Rain Tour, his posse of musicians swelled to include Sheila E. and horn players Eric Leeds and (Atlanta) Matt Blistan. Prince spent scores of hours jamming and recording with various combinations of these musicians—sometimes also including Levi Seacer and Matt Fink. While much of this activity was just jamming for fun, Prince was unusually open to learn from those around him. Lisa, a wonderfully talented keyboardist, brought a sophisticated arsenal of chordal ideas. Wendy brought a Joni Mitchell-inspired melodic sense. Sheila brought her rich variety of rhythms and Eric brought his background in jazz and arranging. Their frequent jams casually brought these things out. It’s also been well documented that Wendy, Lisa, and Eric were exposing Prince to musics he was unfamiliar with by regularly turning him onto albums by a wide variety of artists including Miles Davis and Duke Ellington. In short, it was probably Prince’s most curious phase of his evolution as a musician and thus he was the most open to “outside” influences. On the other hand, most of the wealth of material recorded during this phase remains officially unissued. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
.
Don't hate your neighbors. Hate the media that tells you to hate your neighbors. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Interesting insights OldFriends4Sale, thanks for the quotes
It's certain that Eric, Wendy & Lisa were very influential in exposing Prince to other kinds of music. It's also well known how he tripped on Kate Bush's Couldbusting for example. It's somewhat sad that he quit being curious musically speaking after that, from what he has shown ever since in his "radio shows" and interviews, Prince mostly listens to mainstream R&B and pop music, and he totally missed the electronic revolution of the 90t's. That was particularly obvious with Kamasutra: while P had been listening to classical music in the 80's (and, according to Fink, sampling a lot of it in GB, in such a distorted way that we can't even recognize anything), he was obviously totally unaware of the works of contemporary composers, which led him to provide quite a ridiculous piece of contemporary neo-classical music.
A COMPREHENSIVE PRINCE DISCOGRAPHY (work in progress ^^): https://sites.google.com/...scography/ | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
I would think it was reciprocal. Prince probably exposed Wendy and Lisa to a lot of funk and soul music. Wendy said Prince was her biggest influence on guitar. Maybe Prince felt he got as much as he could out of their creative relationship and it was time to end it. If the Revolution stayed on, eventually the music would have gotten stale and tired. It could be everything was getting too comfortable creatively and Prince needed to shake it up. I always respected him for taking different directions even if the results weren't always successful. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Even Prince said in 1985 they were just touching on the creativity, when we look at the unreleased catalogue of music from 1984-1986 there is no way they were close to stale. I'm talking about the whole creative energy of that whole group, the Sheila E & band, the Revolution (extended) the stuff that came with the Time, the Family, Mazarati
(just because Wendy & Lisa were not 'black') doesn't mean they weren't exposed to funk and soul music. Wendy said the first time she heard Prince was when she and Susannah went to some dance club back in the early 80s and she heard Soft n Wet. Of course they all probably shared various different artist/musicians with each other.
But the relationship shifted because of the personal level. (emotional) Prince has talked about it in a 1990 interview.
| |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
by that time everyone knew how he plays games...so it was accepted as norm | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |