Yeah, sorry about the cheesy topic title

Suppose you were in a melancholy mood and wanted to listen to a collection of sad P songs, what would your list look like? And I'm talking 'real sad', not 'oh no, purple & gold! sad'

Here's what I've come up with so far...

Condition of the heart

If I was your girlfriend

Anna Stesia

I hate U

Billy Jack Bitch

There is lonely

5 women

Empty room

Wasted kisses

Had U

17 days

How come you don't call me anymore?

Don't play me

Old friends for sale

Papa

Anotherloverholenyohead

The beautiful ones

Any suggestions?

Great additions!

I also thought of '4 the tears in your eyes'. And 'I can't make u love me', but of course that's just a cover song.

Nothinbutjoy said:

Solo Count the Days

I know thats right about Solo.

Imagine listening to Solo in the dark, I can barely listen to that in the Daytime when its full of Sunshine.

Also "Dark" could be on this list.

Avalanche is one of his most beautifully sad songs in my opinion. Especially the second part of the song,

"Hear the joyous sound of freedom
The Harlem Renaissance
Hear Duke Ellington and his band
kick another jungle jam
Ooh, do u wanna dance?
Who's that lurking in the shadows?
Mr. John Hammond with his pen in hand...
sayin' "Sign ur kingdom over 2 me
and b known throughout the land!"
But, u ain't got no money, U ain't got no cash,
So u sign yo name and he claims innocence
just like every snowflake in an avalanche...

CHORUS
Like the snow comin' down the mountain
that landed on Wounded Knee
nobody wants 2 take the weight-
the responsability"

These song were mentioned above already but...

How Come You Dont Call Me Anymore doesnt make me sad, its a good song. But its kinda of a generic sadness, like u know your supposed to be sad. However Old Friends 4 Sale will have my face wet with tears.

I guess Something In The Water (Does not compute) Could go on the list

ItsGonnaBLonely said:

These song were mentioned above already but...

How Come You Dont Call Me Anymore doesnt make me sad, its a good song. But its kinda of a generic sadness, like u know your supposed to be sad. However Old Friends 4 Sale will have my face wet with tears.

I guess Something In The Water (Does not compute) Could go on the list

Can't believe I forgot about that one. Definitely a keeper!

the WHOLE of NEW POWER SOUL

that shit broke my heart...............

jonylawson said:

the WHOLE of NEW POWER SOUL

that shit broke my heart...............

Even by looking at the cover art you could tell it'd be sh--, and that's saying something in P's case. I liked 'The One' & 'Wasted Kisses', though. Yeah, I'm sentimental like that

Still Waiting

It's Gonna Be Lonely

Gotta Broken Heart Again

Something In The Water (does not compute)

Purple Rain

Condition of the heart

Someties it snows in april

Still Would Stand All Time

Sweet Baby

Solo

Papa

I Hate U

Had U

Wasted Kisses

Goodbye

There Is Lonely

Eye Love U but I don't Trust

Last December

On The Couch

Notice a lot of these sad songs start with the letter SSSSSSSssssSSSSsssssSSSSS for Sad.

Nothing compares 2 U.

Not Prince or associates version but Sinead's!

SPOOKYGAS said:

Nothing compares 2 U.

Not Prince or associates version but Sinead's!

Good choice!

my ex used to joke with me about this. poor poor Prince all those sad songs while he bangs model and makes millions. WAAAAAAAAAAAA!!!!! Some of his best songs.

I think 'Sometimes It Snows In April' is his saddest song.

Also..

It's Gonna Be Lonely

The Beautiful Ones

Purple Rain

The Arms Of Orion

Sweet Baby

Dark

Into The Light/I Will

Soul Sanctuary

The Love We Make (more uplifting than sad, but it's good for when you want to bring yourself out of the bad mood)

The Dance (either version, TCI version is more emotional/sadder, I think)

Here

... though Prince usually isn't who I listen to when I'm depressed, if I had to, those are some of the songs I'd pick.

Also, though neiter album is sad, I listen to One Nite Alone... and Xpectation a lot when I'm upset.. the songs aren't really sad, though. But for me, they fit the mood.

[Edited 2/21/12 9:37am]

1995-2005..

Gotta Broken Heart Again

Somebody's Somebody

Crazy You

So Blue

Still Waiting

It's Gonna be Lonely

Comeback

Tears go Here!

^ I agree with all of your picks. I was going to list the first two, but I never really loved "Curious Child", and I wasn't really sure if "A Case Of U" classified as a 'sad' song, though I usually listen to it when I'm in a bad mood.

CrabalockerFishwife said:

OTHERS HERE WITH US ! ! !

Let's Have a Baby is the saddest song ever, IMO.

SuperFurryAnimal said:

my ex used to joke with me about this. poor poor Prince all those sad songs while he bangs model and makes millions. WAAAAAAAAAAAA!!!!! Some of his best songs.

Hilarious!

RodeoSchro said:

Let's Have a Baby is the saddest song ever, IMO.

Knowing what we know now, it probably is...

Don't Talk 2 Strangers.

Gigolos Get Lonely 2 (the Time)

I Guess It's All Over (Mazarati)

Next Time Wipe the Lipstick Off Your Collar (Sheila E)

Nothing Compares 2 U (the Family)

Computer Blue & Something In the Water Does Not Compute

mightycow said:

RodeoSchro said:

Let's Have a Baby is the saddest song ever, IMO.

Knowing what we know now, it probably is...

Yeah, that's why it's the saddest song he's ever done - if you know the backstory. I can't listen to it, it's just too hard.