independent and unofficial
Prince fan community
Welcome! Sign up or enter username and password to remember me
Forum jump
Forums > Prince: Music and More > The day it all went wrong
« Previous topic  Next topic »
Page 2 of 2 <12
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
Reply #30 posted 02/20/03 7:47am

chickengrease

Handclapsfingasnapz said:

chickengrease said:

MiaBocca said:

jaypotton said:

For *me* the day it all went wrong was when Prince started managing himself (ie sacked Fargnoli, recruited then parted ways with Magnoli)

As soon as Prince started concerning himself withthe business aspect of his career and therefore focusing less on the music (his art) things dropped off.


I agree - which is what just after Lovesexy?


nod

definitely...lovesexy is my cut-off album: anything released after that i listen 2 with extreme caution...eek


hug That's why I luvs yoo!
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #31 posted 02/20/03 7:50am

Handclapsfinga
snapz

chickengrease said:

Handclapsfingasnapz said:

chickengrease said:

MiaBocca said:

jaypotton said:

For *me* the day it all went wrong was when Prince started managing himself (ie sacked Fargnoli, recruited then parted ways with Magnoli)

As soon as Prince started concerning himself withthe business aspect of his career and therefore focusing less on the music (his art) things dropped off.


I agree - which is what just after Lovesexy?


nod

definitely...lovesexy is my cut-off album: anything released after that i listen 2 with extreme caution...eek


hug That's why I luvs yoo!

aww...hug
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #32 posted 02/20/03 9:37am

giotto

avatar

Actually, it all began with The Game Boyz


.
"You don't frighten us, English pig dogs. Go and boil your bottoms, sons of a silly person."
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #33 posted 02/20/03 12:31pm

tackam

August 4, 1998, around 6:35 in the morning. His toaster wouldn't work, there were grounds in his coffee, and he was just like:

(stomps high-heeled fuzzy slipper on the floor)
"Gawd mutherfucking dammit all to fuck! I canNOT take this ANY MORE! I am goin' to find Jesus and write fucking music about that shit for the rest of fucking eternity, because I have had ABOUT ENOUGH of gawddamn REALITY!"
(stomp stomp stomp over to Kingdom Hall. . .)
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #34 posted 02/21/03 8:28pm

fairmoan

chickengrease said:

For all the people who long for the Prince's days of gritty funk, rock and dance. Pinpoint the moment in time where it went wrong. I believe it was the The Black Album.

Sure its original intentions were just party music for Sheila E. but it became something else when he was criticised of not being funky enough. From a collector's point of view, The Black Album was great. But, in retrospect, there was nothing really worthy of the legend of the LP except Superfunkycalifragasexy, Rock Hard In A Funky Place, and 2 Nigs United 4 West Compton...just my opinion. Other than those, it was throw-away funk and jabs at the rap industry.


This was the first point in his career when he started giving a damn about what others thought about him musically and the experimentation stopped. Now he did follow up the withdrawal of the Black Album with the classic Lovesexy (the last classic for a while) Everything post-Lovesexy has a dated sound (except TGE and portions of Exodus) which to the non-die hard can't be traced to a particular year.

Fast forward through Batman and we have Prince incorporating rap into his music and the club scene...T.C. Ellis & the Game Boyz, Glam Slams here, there and beyond. Which just... doesn't fit well in his niche. Meanwhile, he's still kicking ass live.

Fast forward to 1994. We receive the Most Beautiful Girl in the World. A great song that sounds great remixed during his performance on Soul Train. However, with the release of The Beautiful Experience, this begins Prince's lame attempts at remixes and keeping his name in the clubs.

Despite stellar tracks on albums in between 1994-1998. Prince sounds like he's competing with the likes of R.Kelly, Babyface and Dr. Dre and has lost his sound.

This tradition is continued until 1999 and the releases of Rave Un2, Rave In2. Thank God there weren't any remixes for the Rainbow Children, the one entire album that sounds like he believes in himself again.


[color=red:e15c6b732c:c57aa279f9:820b4869d5]DISCLAIMER

Now before you "fams" start clowning and throwing Watchtowers at me, please note that this thread is for those who are willing to discuss Prince's music from an unbiased perspective.


I really don't think the seeds of Prince's 90s trough were evident in The Black Album. At times I think it's his best album- crazily inventive, infectious, just brimming with ideas. Only SOTT and Lovesexy rival its wonderful, colourful genius. Prince takes those songs to the upper limits, exhausting every little tangent imaginable in bringing them to fruition.

That's all fairly intangible, though. You say that The Black Album is the start of Prince as trend follower instead of trend setter. Perhaps it was a touch self-conscious to the extent that the whole marketing strategy was built around surreptitiously proving that he could still move the hardcore funk crowd. But on the music alone I don't think you can say it is derivative in the slightest. This is Prince in the purest sense- only he could have produced an album like that. And as for 'Dead, On It', I've always said this is simply another case of Prince's ingenious genre fusion. The funk of that track hits so hard, harder than peers of his doing straight hip-hop. The rapping is needlessly criticised on this site, too- Prince brings a sense of harmony to rap that in my eyes (and this is without doubt a minority view) introduces another dimension to the genre. In this respect his point in the song is well-made- when real talent grapples with hip-hop, you are left with a new beast, and a far more imaginative one.

When was Prince's downfall? It's a rough question in the first instance, because his output in the 90s- even at its worst- is still beyond the reach of most others. But, if anywhere, I would locate the seeds of his decline with Lovesexy. It's a great album, don't get me wrong. One of my favourites. But it's also the first time Prince's arrangements lose that magical touch. Once again, we're entering dangerous territory here, and after what Brendan has said I am reluctant to use the word dated. But in patches on Lovesexy I think we get a glimpse of all that was wrong with Prince's sonic experimentation in the 90s. Something grates that didn't on SOTT and The Black Album. Fifteen or so years down the track, there is something tacky or cutesy about Lovesexy in parts. It's ever so slight, and I should repeat that I rank Lovesexy among his top five albums.

No artist in the history of popular music has been able to sustain the originality and brilliance of their peak forever. Prince is no exception. There is no shame in this. An album like SOTT or The Black Album or 1999 is so rare that we should not expect him to be able to emulate it again and again. Perhaps he lost that creative verve at the turn of the 90s. But there is a lot of gold amongst his output since, and plenty amongst his latest releases. I couldn't say TRC (or One Nite Alone, for that matter) is on par with his 80s peaks, but it's damn close, and it is some consistently excellent music. Perhaps he is ready to shock us again with a work of utter genius.
[This message was edited Fri Feb 21 20:32:32 PST 2003 by fairmoan]
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #35 posted 02/21/03 8:54pm

chickengrease

fairmoan said:

That's all fairly intangible, though. You say that The Black Album is the start of Prince as trend follower instead of trend setter. Perhaps it was a touch self-conscious to the extent that the whole marketing strategy was built around surreptitiously proving that he could still move the hardcore funk crowd. But on the music alone I don't think you can say it is derivative in the slightest. This is Prince in the purest sense- only he could have produced an album like that. And as for 'Dead, On It', I've always said this is simply another case of Prince's ingenious genre fusion. The funk of that track hits so hard,


But the Black Album was the first sign of Prince beginning to repeat himself. Maybe he thought he had done all that he could do with the Linn Drum but what was actually fresh and innovative about the Black Album? The mystique of the album was wonderful. There were signs of brilliance but for me this was the first LP, where I heard 'throwaway' tracks. Tracks that probably couldn't have been reworked to make them appeal to me as a listener.

The funk of Dead On It doesn't hit nearly as hard as Superfunkycalifragisexy, an homage to the P-Funk if I ever did hear one. The bass heavy beats of hip-hop were becoming the staple of music at this point and Prince sounded like he was trying to capture that on Dead On It. The only beat driven song that Prince came close to capturing the essence of hip-hop at the time was Housequake.
Prince wasn't blind, he knew that rap was going to take over. Little did he know that eventually some would disregard 808 drums machines and pick up some instruments and incorporate a "real" melody. Dead On It, as humorous as it may have been, was the sound of pure plastic. Much like the 90s sound of his releases without a band.



When was Prince's downfall? It's a rough question in the first instance, because his output in the 90s- even at its worst- is still beyond the reach of most others.


But somewhere during the Black Album/Lovesexy sessions. The only listeners left were his die-hard fans and the critics.


No artist in the history of popular music has been able to sustain the originality and brilliance of their peak forever. Prince is no exception.


Of course, I know Prince isn't any different. This post was really just for shits and giggles; For those who have followed the man's music since the beginning, I was just wondering when they felt that "magic" wasn't there anymore.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #36 posted 02/21/03 10:53pm

origmnd

Did ya eva stop and think maybe "the magic" didn't leave HIM but left U...
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #37 posted 02/21/03 11:05pm

rdhull

avatar

origmnd said:

Did ya eva stop and think maybe "the magic" didn't leave HIM but left U...

Oh coem on now...you now he was coasting sometimes and on some boolshit with some stuff from NPS, Emancipation, D&P, etc. He doesnt shit a gold brick every bowel movement nor should he be expected to.
"Climb in my fur."
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #38 posted 02/22/03 12:19am

sawatdiikhrap

Tom said:




With a title like "The Black Album" I would expect something as significant as the Beatles' "White Album". He should have left it titled "Funk Bible" or something like that. I think the hype over it being pulled, not to mention the pretentious title and album cover caused people to expect more of it than what it really was.

Still, I get the impression that the black album is some very raw and honest Prince. He just lets loose and looses his mind on those tracks and spews out the insanity and frustrations and kink.



Wouldn't "funk bible" build up expectations too? confuse

Besides, there's already a funk bible: Headhunters.

(p.s. jazz-funk, but even so, it is).
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #39 posted 02/22/03 7:49am

CAMILLE4U

avatar

Hmmm…. I guess it all depends on whether you like the music he’s made in the 90s and is making today. The 80s music was allot more addictive but it was songs like My name is Prince, Sexy MF, Loose, Let it go, Pheromones, Pussy control, TMBGITW, Gold, Jam of the year and Baby know (Just a few to name) That made me start collecting Prince. I bought most of the 90’s album before touched one from the 80s albums. So I can’t say he ‘lost it’.

chickengrease said:


This was the first point in his career when he started giving a damn about what others thought about him musically.


That I do agree with, and that was very significant to what he made after. He really wanted everything he did after that to be successful. But I don't think he ever gave in to mainstream.

Lovesexy?
The Truth?
The undertaker?
One nite alone (piano album)
Rainbow childen?

These were art, not created to sell millions of record but simply to be great music. He did however want people to like it.
NOTE: THIS ACCOUNT IS NOW CLOSED. PLEASE CONTACT “K A M eye L L E
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #40 posted 02/22/03 8:54am

tricky99

avatar

i know i'm one of the rare breed but for me prince has never lost the plot or the magic. Just like life music changes and musicians change with the times. They influence the culture and also are influenced by the culture. Prince delved into rap because he "had too". He could not ignore this shift in music. His talent, ego, and imagination are to great for him to have done otherwise. So many of u seem to project your limitations of the possible on to what prince has done or should have done.

I don't expect prince to produce another "1999" or "lovesexy". If anything it is the everchanging nature of Prince that keeps it fresh. I also have favorite albums and cuts but that doesn't lead me to label other things as "shit" or commercial trash because i personnally dont' get into them as deeply as others. People the magic is in the journey.

For me there is something positive to be said for almost everything prince has done musically. So much of what u all dismiss i'm glad he recorded.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #41 posted 02/22/03 9:24am

WildheartXXX

avatar

The day the Batman album was released. That whole 1989-1992 period was really really bad artistically.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #42 posted 04/27/03 9:48am

NinoSasgakagra
chi

avatar

WildheartXXX said:

The day the Batman album was released. That whole 1989-1992 period was really really bad artistically.




He got paid phat though!
*~* +*+ *?*


fatalbert If your Thirsty, I can be Friday, we can go out Saturday for a Sunday. cartman
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #43 posted 04/27/03 9:52am

LaMont

avatar

My simple conclusion: Its all good and its all funky
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #44 posted 04/27/03 4:45pm

STOP

Brendan said:

I see Prince's career as a series of ups and downs, and right now he’s very much in an upswing, while a few years ago he was at his lowest downswing.



Yes and no.lol


To me the problem with some of his 90s material in general is just that he appeared less focused from an album perspective... I think what he’s been doing since “TRC” is cohesive and has that focus.


Yes and no. TRC sounds more like desperation than inspiration.lol


The higher the quality and the more universal the themes, the more timeless the art.


Execllent point. I totally agree.lol

What makes something “dated” to me is something that is of poor quality that has some or nearly all of the stereotypical characteristics of a given era.


Agree totally.lol
**************************************************

"You can catch the Devil, but you can't hold him long..."--Rod Serling
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #45 posted 04/27/03 5:27pm

Muziqmkr

chickengrease said:

For all the people who long for the Prince's days of gritty funk, rock and dance. Pinpoint the moment in time where it went wrong. I believe it was the The Black Album.

Sure its original intentions were just party music for Sheila E. but it became something else when he was criticised of not being funky enough. From a collector's point of view, The Black Album was great. But, in retrospect, there was nothing really worthy of the legend of the LP except Superfunkycalifragasexy, Rock Hard In A Funky Place, and 2 Nigs United 4 West Compton...just my opinion. Other than those, it was throw-away funk and jabs at the rap industry.


This was the first point in his career when he started giving a damn about what others thought about him musically and the experimentation stopped. Now he did follow up the withdrawal of the Black Album with the classic Lovesexy (the last classic for a while) Everything post-Lovesexy has a dated sound (except TGE and portions of Exodus) which to the non-die hard can't be traced to a particular year.

Fast forward through Batman and we have Prince incorporating rap into his music and the club scene...T.C. Ellis & the Game Boyz, Glam Slams here, there and beyond. Which just... doesn't fit well in his niche. Meanwhile, he's still kicking ass live.

Fast forward to 1994. We receive the Most Beautiful Girl in the World. A great song that sounds great remixed during his performance on Soul Train. However, with the release of The Beautiful Experience, this begins Prince's lame attempts at remixes and keeping his name in the clubs.

Despite stellar tracks on albums in between 1994-1998. Prince sounds like he's competing with the likes of R.Kelly, Babyface and Dr. Dre and has lost his sound.

This tradition is continued until 1999 and the releases of Rave Un2, Rave In2. Thank God there weren't any remixes for the Rainbow Children, the one entire album that sounds like he believes in himself again.


[color=red:e15c6b732c:f5b7b67f87]DISCLAIMER

Now before you "fams" start clowning and throwing Watchtowers at me, please note that this thread is for those who are willing to discuss Prince's music from an unbiased perspective.
I think you have made very good observation. I have come to realize that Prince's sound was not just his sound but a sound that was developed through working with different musicians. I like the times when Dez and Andre were in the band. Even after Andre left Prince always was on the newer side of music. One of the changes that I see in Prince's music today is that he like so many others sound the same live. The musicians that he uses are excellent players but they don't seem to have any stage presence or personality. I'm not saying that they are boring but they sound like any other live band that plays behind and artist today such as Alicia Keys, Erika Badu,Musiq, etc. When Prince use to play "Do it all Night" live for instance, no one then sounded like that. Even today no one sounds like that. They always had you wanting more. He didn't really compete with other artist in the sense of trying to do what they did. He (they) innovated not duplicated. When I see an artist come on Jay Leno or Letterman, it seem like it's alway the artist out front and the band in the back and thats how Prince is today. The group thing is gone and the funky rock thing left with Dez and Andre. Sure he tried it with Mike Bland and Sonny but it seemed more contrived than natural. I think the music industry has lowered the bar a long time ago and it did have an effect on Prince's music and attitude towards the so called competition.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Page 2 of 2 <12
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
« Previous topic  Next topic »
Forums > Prince: Music and More > The day it all went wrong