Which one of the two versions do you love more ? One night alone version or MPLS ?

And by the way, what does " Gimme a page on my two way" means ??? Anybody ?

Thanx !

I like them both! I have always loved this song very heart pulling. I think the part about gimme a page is pretty much what it sounds like. Maybe he think the girl got his number but just won't call. Maybe the girl is like I had your number lost it and can't call you, but the next time you see me say something ya know. Only P really knows and he ain't giving us no insight...I wish he would.

ONA

ONA without doubt. New version is a big step down imo

Newer version for sure. That's not to say the ONA version is bad. I just prefer the newer if I had to listen to it.

Same goes with "The Dance". The one on 3121 is highly superior to the NPGMC version.

whenever I see the title of this song, I get it mixed up with "The 1 U Wanna See"...and then I click the thread and get mad cuz I reliaze its about a song I dont like

yankem said:

ONA hand down
and give me a page on my two way - is to blup me on the your Boost or Nextel Phone.

The ONA version, definitely. I'm not sure why he felt the need to remake it, but I wish he had suppressed the urge.

mzsadii said:

Thanx !

ernestsewell said:

Same for me

I only have the version and I like it very much.

Bohemian67 said:

What version?

ONA.

mzsadii said:

did U ever watch AquaTeenHungerForce?


WHERE U AT DAWG!

MPLSound

One Night Alone verison is sooo beautiful, one of my favourites, but MLPSound
s verison is sooo wrong on so many levels, Its soo winey... Why not just leave it alone?!?! but hey, each to their own!

I only know the recent version, and the song is beautiful.

I'd like to believe that paging love doesn't use any wires at all. Ya know..."We got a thing that's called "R.A.D.A.R Love!"

geo4you said:

Oops I was in a hurry on my way to work. The latest version MPLS.

ONA

I like them both. I heard the P&B folks whinging about him ruining the ONA version or about it being too similar. I disagree on both counts. I think they both work in their own right and are very distinct,

( If i could only have one, though, I guess I'd also take ONA )

yankem said:

Mpls version with ONA right on it's heels

BobGeorge909 said:

O N A .....



I hope he doesnt ever redo any of his slow songs again ....


just think purple rain in a upbeat tempo


....

the MPLS version is great,

ONA is boring, imo...

I love the Mpls version too, can almost hear some Clare Fisher's string in the background (ok, ok , I know it's only a synth !!!! Let me imagine it...)

ONA version easily.

TBH I think he ruined it on Mplsound. The verses are all stuttery never allowing a flow to develop. No atmosphere in the Chorus. In a word; Sterile.

ernestsewell said:

Yep.




Although I love the ONA alone version of U're Gonna C Me more than I like the older version of The Dance. Still, great tracks. All of them!

I love the ONA version most of all.. but it does suffer a little bit from what I like to call 'I can't play piano and sing at the same time' syndrome

Erik

erik319 said:

You mean the hesitant way in which the verses are delivered? Yeah, it gives the song an own special feeling I have to be in the right mood for. But when I am it's beautiful.

I absolutely love the song and I can enjoy both versions equally. It would be a hard choice because it depends on my mood.
ONA version sounds a bit sadder to me, but again so beautiful...