"PE is a whole load of fuss about nothing. If you like it, cool. But I will pass on this one. Another one to add to my dusty collection of recent prince albums.

I think 319 (just one song) has more energy, soul, passion, class, uniqueness, raunch and funk than the PE album put together!!

Nuff proven. Nuff said."


Thats what I had to say on another post. Wondered what the reaction might be if I threw it open. Thumbs up agree, or thumbs down disagree?

Ist and..

agree with myself!!

PurpleHouse said:

Wrong thread. Lock this one please.

Jochem said:

Oh gimmie a break!

So serious..... learn to smile!

PurpleHouse said:

I was smiling...

Jochem said:

The thread is comparing 319 to PE. Its not a review of PE. Im asking a question. why should it b locked?

And if you answer that question seriously, take your hand out of your pants.

It's not out yet, and I'm withholding judgement until I get it.

PurpleHouse said:

Planet Earth - The CD - The Discussion - The Official Thread - Part III - "The Mail" Release

PurpleHouse said:

I dont see how you can compare the 2. People need to stop living in the past with Prince music and stop comparing. Like it for what it is or dont its as simple as that...nuff said!

I agree 100%.

I've never liked 319 so thats not a good comparision.

i think "lock this thread"

but my opinion is i'm loving PE but i also love 319 dancing around in my house pretended i'm one of prince's biatches!!!!! ha lol


[Edited 7/20/07 5:38am]

I could probably think of about 30 songs other than 319 that would not make this comparison laughable.

319 is one of his most forced songs. Its him trying to redo KISS. Its only topped in the "try hard" department by "Black Sweat" which is an even more forced commercial thing trying to be KISS. Sorry, bad mood have a fever.

The foundations of arrogance are often built on balsa wood, someone probably once said. This thread proves eople really should stop, look, think and listen before they shoot their congealed load of shitty genes and inherited moronity all over the internet.

Jochem said:

Are threads seriously locked because someone has an unpopular opinion? (which in the case of PE, really isn't THAT unpopular). Or is it because they are duplicative?

coltrane3 said:

Almost every other thread on the new CD and it's tracks has been locked. See thisone for example. These posts should be in the sticky's.

no shortage here of moderators in training .....

Etorres said:

Ok I was being a smart ass.
I'll leave it to the moderators.

Thumbs down, I love this album!

(oops, maybe I misunderstood what I'm supposed to be voting on. I do love 319 also, but the music is coming from different eras and I happen to like both.)
[Edited 7/20/07 12:32pm]

Serena said:

Don't you know that if you disagree with PurpleHouse's opinions it means you're deluded.

Disagreeing with some people here means being called motherfucker which ain't really civilized

Agree. I LOVE 319!

FunkJam said:

I think ppl have somewhat misread my thread. I am trying to make the point that I think that one song "taking 319 as an example" can be better than the entire PE album.

I for one, think that. I am making the point that to me, one GREAT track is better than 10 average ones... the idea of quality not quantity etc??!!

Strongly disagree.

Unfortunately I became unintersted in it as of last week.

Good album, just not my favourite kind of Prince album. Will work for some but not others.

Anyway, enough of this chaos and disorder - on to next year!

I think Planet Earth is interesting as an album.

Its existence intrigues me. I'm glad it's here. I don't think it's a masterpiece (he could have been way more mature, deep, reflective, philosophical with the whole 'earth' theme but mostly took the easy way out both in musical composition and lyrics) but I don't think it's rubbish.

I don't have any absolute fav songs on here (well maybe Somewhere HEre on Earth ...which i am really really digging right now. )
.
.
.
[Edited 7/21/07 10:29am]

Its not knocking my socks off or anything right now but I wouldn't say its a bad album. I do agree this should probably be in a sticky somewhere.

PurpleHouse said:

I think "Housequake" is better than the entire Lovesexy album. But Lovesexy is my third favorite Prince album.

I'm confused